Printer Friendly

Illinois Appellate Court Upholds Lower Court's Denial of Forum Non Conveniens Motion Arising out of the 2005 TANS Peru Plane Crash.

CHICAGO, June 15 /PRNewswire/ -- Today the Appellate Court of Illinois, First District affirmed a September 5, 2008 Order issued by Judge William D. Maddux which denied defendants' motions to dismiss cases on the grounds of forum non conveniens.

The original lawsuits were filed by Nolan Law Group in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois, on behalf of certain passenger's estates who have filed wrongful death and survival actions against The Boeing Company and United Technologies Corporation as a result of the August 23, 2005 crash where a Boeing 737-200 operated by Transportes Aereos Nacional de Selva (TANS) crashed in the jungle about 5.5 km south of Pucallpa Airport.

The aircraft was carrying 98 passengers, of which 40 were killed and many others were seriously injured, making it one of the worst aviation disasters in Peruvian history.

On May 29, 2009 in response to the defendants' appeal of Judge Maddux's ruling, Nolan Law Group presented written and oral arguments to the appellate court which outlined the defendants' failure to provide adequate support for their contention that the Illinois Court is an inconvenient forum.

During the proceedings, Nolan Law Group attorneys took the position that defendants failed to demonstrate exceptional circumstances favoring the transfer or dismissal of the cases and that since the decision to grant or deny a motion to dismiss based on forum non conveniens lies within the discretion of the trial court, a reviewing court would have to uphold the trial court's decision unless abuse of discretion was demonstrated.

"Without an abuse of discretion, a disagreement between judges' opinions is not tantamount to showing exceptional circumstances," said Nolan Law Group attorney Donald J. Nolan.

Nolan Law Group argued that the trial court's balance of private and public interest factors to deny defendants' motion to dismiss was correct and that there was no abuse of discretion. Nolan Law Group also reiterated its argument that the products liability context of the case guided consideration of all aspects of defendants' forum non conveniens motion.

Additionally, Nolan Law Group demonstrated why Peru is not an "available" forum for re-filing the cases, citing that certain existing jurisdictional principals in South American countries are in direct conflict with American forum non conveniens jurisprudence, including Peru's steadfast application of the Bustamente code.

Currently, Nolan Law Group represents clients who have filed wrongful death and survival actions against Boeing and United Technologies Corporation stemming from the August 23, 2005 accident. This favorable ruling allows Nolan Law Group to proceed with its cases against Boeing and United Technologies in the Circuit Court of Cook County, Illinois.

CONTACT: Tom Ellis, Director of Litigation of Nolan Law Group, Office, +1-312-630-4000, Cell, +1-312-493-3349

Web Site: http://www.nolan-law.com/
COPYRIGHT 2009 PR Newswire Association LLC
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:PR Newswire
Date:Jun 15, 2009
Words:450
Previous Article:Announcing TEDx: Encouraging Local, Independently Organized TED Events.
Next Article:Sun River Energy Engages Europa Securities to Fund Up to $7 Million to Further Evaluate and Commence a Drilling Program on Sun River's New Mexico...
Topics:


Related Articles
Foreign rollover cases can stay in U.S. court, judge rule.
US law firm says judge has conducted initial conference in GOL case.
The uncertainty factor in Canadian private international law.
Towards global convenience, fairness, and judicial economy: an argument in support of conditional forum non conveniens dismissals before determining...

Terms of use | Copyright © 2017 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters