Printer Friendly

GASB proposal on grants too narrow, says AICPA committee.

In comments to the Governmental Accounting Standards Board, the American Institute of CPAS government accounting and auditing committee (GAAC) took issue with what it termed "piecemeal standard setting" in the GASB exposure draft Accounting and Reporting for Certain Grants and Other Financial Assistance (see "GASB Proposal on Accounting for Grants," Jofa, Mar.94, page 16).

The comment letter, signed by GAAC chairman George A. Scott, noted that the original discussion memorandum issued in 1992 included all grants and financial assistance. The ED, on the other hand, "carved out three of the less significant topics covered in the discussion memorandum" for standard setting: pass-through grants, food stamps and on-behalf payments.

"The committee discourages the GASB from issuing standards in such a piecemeal manner and supports the alternative view that the board has missed an opportunity to establish a sound foundation for reporting all grants and other financial assistance transactions," wrote Scott.

The committee asked GASB to return to the broader issues of measurement focus, basis of accounting and the financial reporting model of government and business-type activities before taking on limited-scope projects. "Until the broader issues are resolved by the GASB, limited-scope projects such as this ED serve only as interim guidance and may change, potentially causing unnecessary cost and confusion," the letter said.

Other concerns. If guidance on noncash financial assistance is to be relevant, GAAC asserted, the proposal should not be limited to food stamps. Instead, the GASB also should include guidance on other significant types of noncash programs, including commodities and vouchers, in the scope of the final standard.

Moreover, the final standard should not limit the guidance regarding on-behalf payments to salaries and fringe benefits. Guidance on liabilities associated with other on-behalf payments and how they should be reported also should be included in the final standards, GAAC recommended.

The ED, which is subject to revision, is the first in an expected series of proposed standards addressing government grants. Copies may be purchased from the GASB order department by calling (203) 847-0700, ext. 10.
COPYRIGHT 1994 American Institute of CPA's
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1994, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Government Accounting Standards Board
Publication:Journal of Accountancy
Article Type:Brief Article
Date:May 1, 1994
Previous Article:New factoring directory for small business financing.
Next Article:GASB issues pension EDs.

Related Articles
GASB after the five-year structure review.
GASB proposal on accounting for grants.
GASB's financial reporting model - a decade in the making.
GASB is graded by its constituents.
Which GAAP should NPOs apply?
GASB proposes change from cost-based accounting.
Despite opposition, GASB will issue reporting model ED.
GASB issues reporting model proposal.
New accounting proposals.
GASB overhauls reporting model.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters