From boom to bust: the crash of '29: in the roaring '20s, Americans thought that the good times would last forever. Then came Black Thursday.
Pierce had lost the equivalent of $1.8 million in 2004 dollars. That she viewed her losses as reason for a party reflected the widespread belief that a new era had dawned in which the booming American economy ensured ever-rising stock prices and never-ending prosperity.
But that belief turned out to be a fantasy. Over the next several days, stock prices continued to dive, and investors lost billions in what became known as the Crash of '29--75 years ago next month. The Great Depression soon followed.
Before the Crash, in the Roaring '20s, the U.S. economy soared, fueled by enthusiasm for the wonders of the age, like the new medium of radio, and mass-produced consumer products like Henry Ford's Model T. But stock prices rose far faster than corporate profits, meaning that stocks' value on paper (what investors paid to buy shares) far exceeded what companies were actually worth.
Less than a quarter of Americans actually owned stocks in 1929, and the vast majority of them had made small investments they could afford. But that statistic belies the extent to which getting rich in stocks had become a national obsession, at least among the middle class. Frederick Lewis Allen, in his classic 1931 book Only Yesterday, recalled that an American in 1929 "could spin wonderful dreams of a romantic day when he would sell his Westinghouse [stock] at a fabulous price and live in a great house and have a fleet of shining cars."
While the immediate cause of the Crash was speculation that had sent prices too high, signs of a weakening economy, like a steep drop in farm prices, had been apparent earlier, but were overlooked or ignored.
In reporting on the first day of the Crash, known as Black Thursday, The New York Times called it "the most disastrous decline in the biggest and broadest stock market of history." The initial drop was widely viewed as having been caused by a spiral of panicky selling by amateur investors after stock prices had begun slipping.
But optimists who expected a rebound were mistaken. On Oct. 28 and 29, the market lost a quarter of its value. In its Oct. 30 edition, The Times reported: "Wall Street was a street of vanished hopes.... Men and women crowded the brokerage offices, even those who have been long since wiped out, and followed the figures on the tape. Little groups gathered here and there to discuss the falling prices in hushed and awed tones."
President Herbert Hoover and corporate leaders tried to reassure the nation that even though Wall Street was suffering, the economy was healthy, while in reality, the economy's decline was about to accelerate.
In the aftermath of the Crash, there were reports of distraught investors committing suicide. A St. Louis broker, John F. Betts, swallowed poison at home, The Times reported, after losing $500,000 ($5.3 million in 2004 dollars). "He was unable to sleep and would often spend the night walking up and down in his room," Betts's son told the paper. In fact, historical data on suicides show only a small increase after the Crash, but that did not stop the image of investors ending their lives from taking hold.
NO LAUGHING MATTER
Actor and comedian Eddie Cantor joked that during the Crash he had tried to check into a New York hotel, asking for a room on the 19th floor. "What for? Sleeping or jumping?" was the clerk's reply.
The jokes soon faded. Many of the millions who owned no stock at first took pleasure in seeing the rich suffer. But soon, businesses began laying off workers, and those who were laid off--at a time when there was no unemployment insurance--were forced to cut back on spending. Reduced consumer spending led other companies to cut production, and to lay off more workers.
Banks also were faltering. Declining farm prices had already forced some banks to close when farmers defaulted on their loans. Other banks failed when investors who had borrowed money to buy stocks--known as buying on margin--lost everything in the market and couldn't repay their loans.
Economists still differ on whether the Crash caused the Depression, but Americans at the time thought it had. Many decided that the stock market was a risky gambling den to be avoided, and stayed out of the market for years, if they returned at all. Economists generally agree, however, that better economic policies, such as quicker government action to stimulate the economy after the Crash, could have prevented the Depression.
Three years later, in 1932, with the Depression still deepening, Hoover, a Republican, lost his bid for re-election to Democrat Franklin D. Roosevelt, the Governor of New York. FDR's New Deal included many government programs aimed at boosting the economy and insulating it against future depressions: price supports for farmers; deposit insurance for bank accounts; Social Security; unemployment insurance; and a Securities and Exchange Commission to better regulate the stock market. Congress also passed legislation that allowed the Federal Reserve to set limits on how much money investors could borrow to buy stock.
A LONG CLIMB BACK
But even with massive government intervention, the economy did not fully recover for many years. In fact, many economists give the stimulus of World War II as much credit for ending the Depression as the New Deal.
Not until 1952, 20 years after Hoover's loss to FDR, would another Republican be elected President. And not until 1954 would the Dow Jones Industrial Average, the most widely quoted barometer of stock prices, close higher than the 381.17 it had recorded on Sept. 3, 1929.
To help students understand the 1929 stock-market crash and the economic disaster known as the Great Depression.
BEFORE READING: Draw four concentric circles on the board and label them "The Ripple Effect." Tell students that (1) faith that stock prices would always rise led to a stock collapse; (2) seemingly unrelated economic events rippled out to disrupt the lives of those far away.
CRITICAL THINKING/DISCUSSION: Stop at the following points to discuss how each development rippled out to affect other dements in the economy.
* Ripple 1: How did a drop in farm prices affect the economy? (Many banks had loaned to farmers and didn't get their money back. Industries that sold to farmers saw their sales fall.)
* Ripple 2: How did "the wonders of the age" influence the stock of companies that produced those wonders? (Best-sellers like radios and Model T's lured hopeful investor.) How did demand for those stocks affect their price? (The price of any product increases as demand for it rises.)
* Ripple 3: Why did businesses lay off workers? (In the aftermath of the Crash, consumers and companies, fearing an uncertain economic future, cut their purchases of all kinds of goods, causing layoffs in all kinds of industries.)
* Ripple Rebound: Note the "stimulus of World War II," on page 24. Ask why the war stimulated the economy.
(Demand for military goods forced the hiring of millions of workers to build those goods. These workers then used their income to buy goods they had been unable to afford. That boosted hiring in other industries, thus driving the ripple of economic recovery.)
* What does this article suggest about the need for government intervention in and regulation of the economy?
* Describe Americans' faith that the stock market would grow in value.
WEB WATCH: www.english.uiuc.edu/maps/depression/photoessay.htm provides dozens of black-and-white Depression-era photos from various places around the U.S.
The Crash of '29
1. About how many Americans owned stock at the time of the stock-market crash of 1929?
a Almost everyone.
b Very few.
c About half.
d Less than a quarter.
2. The economy was weakening before Black Thursday. One of the major reasons for this weakening was
a a steep drop in farm prices.
b an increase in cheap imports.
c a wave of strikes in key industries.
d competition from industrial giants like Germany, Japan, and Britain.
3. Unlike many workers who are laid off today, those who lost their jobs after the stock-market crash
a faced higher prices for basics like food.
b could not rely on family members for help.
c had no unemployment insurance.
d often had to settle for lower-paying jobs.
4. The practice of using borrowed money to purchase stocks is called buying
b on edge.
c inflated equities.
d on margin.
5. The Securities and Exchange Commission was created during the administration of President Franklin D. Roosevelt to
a insure the value of stocks.
b warn investors of poorly run companies.
c regulate the stock market.
d monitor rates of exchange between U.S. and foreign currency.
6. Suggest a reason why President Franklin D. Roosevelt's economic programs were called the New Deal.
Upfront Quiz 4 * page TE6
1. (d) less than a quarter.
2. (a) a steep drop in farm prices.
3. (c) had no unemployment insurance.
4. (d) on margin.
5. (c) regulate the stock market.
6. Answers will vary, but could include the fact that Roosevelt's policies set a new direction for the American economy.
Floyd Norris covers business for The Times.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||Time Past|
|Publication:||New York Times Upfront|
|Date:||Sep 20, 2004|
|Previous Article:||What's next for the Supreme Court? When the Justices return from their summer recess, they will consider the constitutionality of the death penalty...|
|Next Article:||Off the sidelines: cheerleading is now a varsity sport at the University of Maryland, but not everyone's cheering.|
|From Boom to Bust.|
|The old crowd: minke whales have long thrived in Antarctic seas.|