For in his days the earth was divided: classic Jewish sources for a physical division of the earth.
On the other hand, a far different perspective on the meaning of niflega has been offered: Many non-Jewish "Creationist" websites relate niflega to catastrophic plate tectonics (see below); a cataclysmic event that literally severed what had been a single land mass into separate continents.
The Tosafot Yom Tov, a commentary on the Mishna, indicates that if there no difference with regard to Jewish law between the explanation of a verse as given in the Talmud and one's own interpretation, then it is permissible to interpret biblical text according to one's understanding (Mishna Nazir 5:5). (1) I was curious to learn whether classic Jewish sources had ever dealt with this phenomenon. I now suggest that there is support in Jewish tradition for interpreting niflega as a physical division of the earth. This view is remarkable, for modern scientific evidence for this has been discovered only within the past 35 years.
CATASTROPHIC PLATE TECTONICS
Catastrophic plate tectonics, the idea that the continents have drifted apart, was first suggested in 1859 after a geologist noticed a jigsaw fit between the western coastline of Africa and the eastern coastline of South America. The theory that these continents had once been joined but had split and moved apart was recognized by the scientific community after the findings of the German meteorologist Alfred Wegener were published in 1915. Most scientists at that time felt this phenomenon took place over millions of years. However, many physical observations have been found to be incompatible with the idea of slow-and-gradual plate tectonics. A recent theory of catastrophic plate tectonics with extremely rapid formation of new ocean crust and magnetic reversals has been proposed and demonstrated in the past three decades.
What is relevant to our study of the biblical text is that a concomitant of the continental drift is the enormous flooding that occurs as the ocean floor warms during the melting of hot mantle rock on the ocean floor, as the rock expands, displacing sea water and forcing a dramatic rise in sea level.
CLASSIC JEWISH SOURCES FOR NIFLEGA AS A PHYSICAL EVENT
To begin with, when referring to nations (people), the Torah normally uses the term nifredu [branched out] (Gen. 10:5) or vayifatz [scattered] (11:8). But there is evidence in traditional Jewish sources that the term niflega refers to a geological phenomenon. Rashi, in his commentary on the Talmud (Shabbat 10b, d"h she'yeshivata), specifically indicates nitpalgu ha'aratzot [the land masses were split]. The Torah Temimah quoting the Seder Olam also uses the terminology nitpalgu ha'aratzot, as does the Rekanati on Deuteronomy 32:5. Indeed, both Targum Onkelos and Ibn Ezra translate niflega as "hatzi [divided in half']." Seforno indicates that the life span of people during Peleg's generation was halved as a result of a "change of air"; that is, something physical. Similarly, Rashi, in his commentary on I Chronicles 1:19, explains niflega as the life-span being halved, and Derashot R. Ibn Shuaib (Parashat Toldot Noah) explains niflega as "shenitpazru bshinui avir [they were dispersed by a change of air]."
JEWISH SOURCES ON A CATASTROPHIC FLOOD DURING THE GENERATION OF PELEG
As indicated above, catastrophic plate tectonics posits that massive flooding would have occurred as a result of the melting of hot mantle rock on the ocean floor. There are many classic Jewish sources for a massive flood during the time of Peleg. Among them are: Talmud Yerushalmi Shekalim 26a; Midrash Tanchuma Deuteronomy 32:8; Vayikra Rabbah Parasha 23; Yalkut Shimoni; Bereshit; Remez 5; Yalkut Shimoni, Amos, Remez 543 ("she'hefitz ha'yam et ha'olam"); Midrash Tanchuma Chayei Sarah Siman 6; Yalkut Shimoni, Iyov, Remez 924 ("she'alah ha'yam vheyfitz ha'olam"--literally, "the sea arose and moved the earth") with the Atlantic Ocean flooding what is now the Mediterranean Sea (Responsa B'tzel ha'Choma II Siman 12). Indeed, Bereshit Rabbah 38 referring to Genesis 11:8 (vayifatz otam--and they were scattered) writes: "ein 'vayifatz' ela 'vayetzaf' [scattered means flooded]."
There is ample evidence from classic Jewish sources, dating hundreds and even thousands of years before modern science conceived of catastrophic plate tectonics, that a geological event including a physical split of land masses may have occurred during the generation of Peleg and that this defines the term niflega.
(1.) See: Moshe Sokolow, "Authority and validity: Why Tanakh requires interpretation, and what makes an interpretation legitimate?" Meorot 6:2 (2007) pp. 2-14.
Dr. Joshua Backon teaches at the Hebrew University Faculty of Medicine and is the Program Administrator of the college program of the Jewish Bible Association
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||Jewish Bible Quarterly|
|Date:||Apr 1, 2009|
|Previous Article:||Letter to the editor.|
|Next Article:||Biblical onomastics: what's in a name?|