Flower visitation by adult shore flies at an inland site in Florida (Diptera: Ephydridae).
The Archbold Biological Station (ABS), located in Highlands County, is near the south end of the Lake Wales Ridge, a distinctive sandy upland. During the rainy season (Jun-Oct) low areas on the Ridge accumulate water in extensive shallow ponds, more than 150 of which occur on the ABS. These ponds usually dry up in winter and spring. Their drying shores become zones of biological hyperactivity as oxygen becomes more available for plants and animals, stranded aquatic organisms die, algae become concentrated, and nutrients are released. Such edges are ideal for a variety of shore flies. Drying ditches and a permanent lake also produce ephydrids. About 45 species of ephydrids are known from the ABS, but there are probably many additional species. Only a small number of species are known to visit flowers at the ABS.
Specimens were collected with nets and aspirators from open flowers over a period of about 20 years. Over 150 species of plants were examined, of which only a small proportion attracted ephydrids. Only 1 or 2 representative specimens of each species were mounted from flowers of a single species of plant on a single day. These specimens are in the collection of the Archbold Biological Station. Most specimens were identified by the senior author, using taxonomic guides and ABS reference specimens identified by Willis Wirth, Wayne Mathis, and J. R. Vockeroth, all of whom examined the ABS ephydrid collection. Plants were identified by the senior author.
Annotated List of Flower-visiting Ephydridae at the ABS
Genus Allotrichoma. Some species of Allotrichoma, including the species listed below, were originally placed in the genus Pseudohecamede (Wirth et al. 1987). In a study of ephydrids of muddy shores, Thier & Foote (1980) found Allotrichoma sp. breeding in muskrat dung and dead snails. They suggest that larvae of this genus are scavengers.
Allotrichoma abdominalis (Williston). Many adults were seen on a scat or pellet of insect fragments in a wet flatwoods at the ABS; this species is probably a scavenger like the species studied by Thier & Foote (1980). If this species breeds in the corpses of stranded aquatic organisms, the seasonal ponds at the ABS are excellent habitats, as these ponds are on sandy substrates and often dry up rapidly at the end of the rainy season. Allotrichoma abdominalis belongs to a species group characterized by an elongate, pointed proboscis (Cresson 1942) that might be an adaptation for nectar feeding. The proboscis is superficially similar to that of 0lcella species (Chloropidae), which often occur on flowers together with A. abdominalis. Most flower records are from plants near wet areas, but a few are from sites 0.5 km or more from wet areas. ABS records: Feb-Mar, May-Jun., Aug-Dec. General distribution: Atlantic and Gulf States, California, Neotropics (Wirth 1965).
Genus Ceropsilopa. The biology of Ceropsilopa species is apparently unknown. Two species occur in salt marshes in Florida (Rey & McCoy 1986).
Ceropsilopa adjuncta Cresson. This species has been collected at the ABS in the vicinity of ditches and also in dry scrub some distance from water. It visits a variety of flowers as well as the extra-floral nectaries of Crotalaria pallida Ait. ABS records: Feb-May, Aug, Oct-Nov. General distribution: Florida, Puerto Rico (Wirth 1965).
Ceropsilopa coquilletti Cresson. ABS records: Apr, Aug. General distribution: southern U.S., Neotropics (Wirth 1965).
Genus Discocerina. Members of this genus, like many other ephydrids, are usually found on muddy shores, where they feed on accumulations of microorganisms and finely particulate debris (Foote 1995).
Discocerina obscura Williston. At the ABS adults were collected from the muddy shore of a seasonal pond. ABS records: Jan, Mar-Apr, Nov. General distribution: New York through Florida, west into Texas, south through the Neotropics (Wirth 1965).
Discocerina obscurella (Fallen). At the ABS common along muddy shores of seasonal ponds; also found around rotten oranges on a wet lawn. Elsewhere, this widespread species occurs in a great variety of habitats, including dry, sandy areas, grassy depressions, and various types of muddy shore habitats (Deonier 2002). ABS records: Jan-Apr, Aug-Dec. General distribution: Europe, North America, Neotropics (Wirth 1965).
Genus Hydrochasma. Members of this genus are associated with both inland and coastal marshes; H. leucoproctum (Loew) occurs in freshwater habitats (Thier & Foote 1980; Deonier 2002), and H. buccatum (Cresson) occurs along beaches and coastal marshes (Deonier 2002).
Hydrochasma incisum (Coquillett). At the ABS collected on flowers in the vicinity of ditches and seasonal ponds. ABS records: Feb-Mar, Sep-Oct. General distribution: Florida, Puerto Rico, Neo-tropics (Wirth 1965).
Genus Hydrellia. Members of this large genus are phytophagous (usually leaf miners) as larvae and predators on smaller arthropods as adults (Deonier 1971). We have not been able to identify to species ABS specimens of this taxonomically challenging genus.
Hydrellia sp. Most flower-visiting specimens were found near seasonal ponds or ditches, but a few were collected in upland sites at least 0.5 km from water. It is not known whether members of this genus visit flowers to consume nectar, or to prey on smaller arthropods, such as Ceratopogonidae, that also occur on flowers.
Genus Mimapsilopa. This is a largely tropical genus with one species in Florida (Mathis & Zatwarnicki 1998).
Mimapsilopa cressoni Lizarralde de Grosso. At the ABS this species has been found on flowers, usually near seasonal ponds. ABS records: Feb-Mar, Jun, Oct-Nov. General distribution: Florida, the West Indies, Guyana and Ecuador (Mathis & Zatwarnicki1998).
Genus Nostima. Species of this genus of tiny flies are sometimes swept from grassy areas (Foote 1995).
Nostima niueiuenosa (Cresson). At the ABS this species was swept from Aristida beyrichiana Trin. & Rupr. in dry flatwoods habitats, and collected on flowers near moist or disturbed habitats. ABS records: Apr, Oct-Nov. General distribution: Florida and Neotropics (Wirth 1965).
Genus Ochthera. The raptorial forelegs of members of this genus are used to capture small arthropods (Clausen 1977). Two species are common at the ABS, one of which, O. tuberculatus Loew, has never been found on flowers, while the other, O. exsculpta Loew, occurs regularly on flowers. It seems probable that O. exsculpta is exploiting flowers as bait stations that attract insect prey.
Ochthera exsculpta Loew. At the ABS this species is usually found around permanent water. ABS records: Feb-Aug. General distribution: North Carolina through Florida, Mexico, Central America, and the Caribbean (Clausen 1977).
Genus Psilopa. Larvae of Psilopa species are leaf miners (Foote 1995). Adult feeding behavior is apparently unknown.
Psilopa dupla Cresson. This species can be swept from lawn grass at the ABS, but also occurs in dry natural areas. Elsewhere, this species is known from wet meadows (Deonier 2002). At the ABS specimens were found feeding on honeydew on Carya floridana Sarg., as well as on flowers. ABS records: Aug-Mar, May. General distribution: New Jersey south through Florida, west to Illinois and Texas; The Bahamas (Wirth 1965).
Genus Ptilomyia. Members of this genus are associated with algal mats and muddy shores of ponds and seacoasts (Deonier 2002).
Ptilomyia mabelae (Cresson). At the ABS this species is associated with both seasonal and permanent ponds. Individuals may be found on flowers 0.5 km or more from wet areas. This is one of a number of ephydrids that seems equally at home on tidal mud flats and the muddy margins of inland bodies of water (Deonier 2002). ABS records: Jan.-Nov. General distribution: Pennsylvania south through Florida, west to Texas, and Ecuador (Wirth 1965).
Genus Scatella. Species in this large and widespread genus are usually associated with muddy freshwater shores or tidal flats, or both (Sturtevant & Wheeler 1954). Some species are known to visit flowers (Sturtevant & Wheeler 1954).
Scatella stagnalis (Fallen). At the ABS this species usually occurs around the edges of seasonal or permanent ponds. Like some other ABS ephydrids, specimens sometimes appear at lights. This suggests that some species disperse to seasonal ponds at night. This widespread species occurs in both marine coastal and inland habitats (Deonier 2002), where its larvae feed on algae and decaying detritus (Thier & Foote 1980). There is a single ABS flower record for this species, and it seems probable that this species rarely visits flowers. ABS records: Oct-Mar, May-Jun. This species appears to be cosmopolitan (Wirth 1965).
Genus Tylopsilopa. Two Florida species, T. atra (Loew) and T. antennalis (Wirth), are virtually indistinguishable without dissecting and preparing the male genitalia (Wirth 1968). We have not attempted to identify ABS species, which appear to represent one or both of these similar species. Adult Typopsilopa species occur in marshes and wet meadows, and around piles of dead marsh plants (Deonier 2002). Larvae feed on decaying vegetation, and can be reared on cultures of yeasts and bacteria (Foote 1995).
Typopsilopa atra (Loew) or antennalis Wirth. Specimens were found at the edges of seasonal and permanent bodies of water. ABS records: Mar-Apr, Jun, Nov.
Floral Host Records for Ephydridae at the ABS
Baccharis halimifolia L. (Asteraceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Hydrellia sp., Hydrochasma incisum, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Psilopa dupla
Balduina angustifolia (Pursh) Robins (Asteraceae): Hydrellia sp.
Dalea feayi (Chapman) Barneby (Fabaceae): Psilopa dupla
Eriocaulon decangulare L. (Eriocaulaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis
Eryngium cuneifolium Small (Apiaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Hydrochasma incisum
Eupatorium capillifolium (Lamarck) Small (Asteraceae): Hydrochasma incisum
Euthamia caroliniana (L.) Greene ex Porter & Britton (Asteraceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Ptilomyia mabelae
Garberia heterophylla (Bartram) (Asteraceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Ceropsilopa adjuncta, Hydrochasma incisum, Nostima niueiuenosa
Ilex cassine L. (Aquifoliaceae): Discocerina obscura, D. obscurella, Hydrellia sp., Hydrochasma incisum, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Psilopa dupla
Iresine diffusa Humb. & Bonpl.ex Willd. (Amaranthaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Hydrochasma incisum Mikania cordifolia (L.f) Willd. (Asteraceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Psilopa dupla
Paronychia americana (Nuttall) Fenzl ex Walp. (Caryophyllaceae):Allotrichoma abdominalis
Paronychia chartacea Fern. (Caryophyllaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Ceropsilopa adjuncta
Phoradendron serotinum (Raf) M. C. Johnst. (Viscaceae): Ceropsilopa adjuncta, Discocerina obscurella, Psilopa dupla
Polygonella gracilis (Nuttall) Meisn. (Polygonaceae): Scatella stagnalis
Polygonella myriophylla (Small) Horton (Polygonaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis
Polygonella polygama (Vent.) Engelm. & Gray (Polygonaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Hydrellia sp., Hydrochasma incisum, Psilopa dupla, Ptilomyia mabelae
Polygonella robusta (Small) Horton (Polygonaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Hydrellia sp., Ptilomyia mabelae
Prunus angustifolia Marsh. (Rosaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Psilopa dupla
Rhus copallina L. (Anacardiaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Discocerina obscurella, Ochthera exsculpta
Sabal etonia Swingle ex Nash (Palmaceae):Allotrichoma abdominalis, Hydrellia sp., Mimapsilopa cressoni, Ptilomyia mabelae, Typopsilopa sp.
Salix caroliniana Michaux (Salicaceae): Ceropsilopa adjuncta, Discocerina obscurella, Hydrochasma incisum, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Psilopa dupla
Serenoa repens (Bartram) Small (Palmaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Ceropsilopa adjuncta, Discocerina obscurella, Ochthera exsculpta, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Psilopa dupla, Ptilomyia mabelae, Typopsilopa sp.
Solidago fistulosa Ait. (Asteraceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Ceropsilopa adjuncta, Discocerina obscurella, Psilopa dupla, Mimapsilopa cressoni, Nostima niueiuenosa
Solidago odora Ait. (Asteraceae): Ceropsilopa adjuncta, C. coquilletti, Ptilomyia mabelae
Syngonanthus flauidulus (Michaux) Ruhl. (Eriocaulaceae): Allotrichoma abdominalis, Ptilomyia mabelae
Among the flower-visiting ephydrids at the ABS, 9 of the 14 species are in the subfamily Psilopinae, 3 in the Notiphilinae, and 2 in the Parydrinae. It seems probable that flower-visiting is most frequently associated with species that colonize ephemeral aquatic habitats that require that the adult flies persist in or disperse through dry habitats. Many Psilopinae at the ABS seem to belong to this group of colonizers. Unfortunately, there are no other studies to provide comparisons of faunal composition of flower-visiting ephydrids.
The motivations of flower-visiting ephydrids at the ABS remain somewhat unclear. Species with an elongate, pointed labellum, such as Allotrichoma abdominalis, are probably specialized nectar feeders. The labellum of such species is superficially similar to that of flower-visiting Chloropidae of the genus Olcella and Milichiidae of the genus Paramyia, which often co-occur on flowers with ephydrids at the ABS. Species associated with honeydew at the ABS (Psylopa dupla) or extrafloral nectaries (Ceropsylopa adjuncta) are evidently attracted to sugars and probably nectivorous when found on flowers. Strongly predaceous species, however, such as Ochthera exsculpta, might be using flowers as bait stations that attract insect prey. Various other predatory insects at the ABS patrol flowers for prey, for example, Sphecidae of the genus Oxybelus (specializes on flies) and Philanthus (bee specialists) and the asilid Mallophorina clausicella (Macquart). Ephydrids on flowers at the ABS always occur together with a variety of other insects, some of which, such as Ceratopogonidae and Thysanoptera, could serve as prey for even the smallest ephydrids. We have not recorded ephydrids consuming pollen, but it is possible that they do so. We have no records from flowers that produce pollen only, such as species of Hypericum, and members of the Commelinaceae. Many insects at the ABS also visit flowers in search of mates; this is especially frequent among the Hymenoptera. We have no observations that suggest ABS ephydrids use flowers as mate-hunting sites.
The flowers visited by ephydrids at the ABS are distributed among 13 families of plants. Most ephydrid species visited flowers belonging to several genera and families. The floral hosts have compound inflorescenses or numerous small flowers that are tightly grouped. All flowers produce nectar available to short-tongued flies, and the ephydrids are almost always accompanied by chloropids and milichiids, as well as other insects with longer tongues. Although ephydrids are sometimes common on flowers at the ABS, their effectiveness as pollinators remains dubious. Most of the plants visited by ephydrids are also visited by many other insects, some of which, such as bees, vespid wasps, syrphid and bombyliid flies, are probably much more effective pollinators. Saw palmetto (Serenoa repens), for example, is visited by several species of ephydrids at the ABS, but also by more than 100 species of larger insects that are more likely to be moving from flower to flower and plant to plant as they seek nectar or pollen. An ephydrid such as Allotrichoma abdominalis could probably get all the nectar it could consume from a single flower on a single spike of a saw palmetto inflorescence. Mistletoe (Phoradendron serotinum) might be an exception, as its small flowers are visited primarily by tiny flies such as ephydrids, chloropids, and milichiids. Elsewhere, ephydrids are known as major pollinators of aquatic plants such as Cabomba caroliniana Gray (Osborn et al. 1991) and Nuphar species (Lippok & Renner 1997; Nagasaki 2007). Ephydrids occasionally appear in lists of flower visitors on particular plants, such as dwarf mistletoe (Gregor et al. 1974).
We are especially grateful to the late dipterist Willis Wirth, frequent visitor to the ABS, who identified many species in the ABS collection and inspired our interest in the shore flies. We miss him. The collection also was reviewed by J. R. Vockeroth, and several additional species were recently identified by Wayne Mathis, who was most generous with his time during a short visit to the ABS. This study was supported by the Archbold Biological Station.
At an inland Florida site 14 species of Ephydridae are reported from flowers of 26 species of plants, representing 84 ephydrid-plant relationships, none of which had been reported previously. Most flower visitors belong to the subfamily Psilopinae. While some species appear to imbibe nectar, it is possible that ephydrids may visit flowers to prey on smaller visitors, especially other flies. There is no evidence that flowers are aggregation sites. It is unlikely that any of the 26 recorded host plants are dependent on ephydrids for pollination. This appears to be the first general survey of flower-visiting ephydrids at a site.
CLAUSEN, P. J. 1977. A revision of the Nearctic, Neotropical, and Palearctic species of the genus Ochthera, including one Ethiopian species, and one new species from India. Trans. American Entomol. Soc. 103: 451-530.
CRESSON, E. T. 1942. Synopses of North American Ephydridae (Diptera). I. The subfamily Psilopinae, with descriptions of new species. Trans. American Entomol. Soc. 68: 101-128.
DEONIER, D. L. 1971. A systematic and ecological study of Nearctic Hydrellia (Diptera: Ephydridae). Smithson. Contrib. Zool. 68: 1-147.
DEONIER, D. L. 2002. North American ephydrid habitat types and probable ephydrid inhabitants (Diptera: Ephydridae) revised. Contrib. Entomol. Internat. 5: 33-48.
FOOTE, B. A. 1995. Biology of shore flies. Annu. Rev. Entomol. 40: 417-442.
GREGOR, S., D. WIENS, R. E. STEVENS, AND F. G. HAWK-SWORTH 1974. Pollination studies of Arceuthobium americanum in Utah and Colorado. Southwestern Natur. 19:65-73.
LIPPOK, B., AND S. S. RENNER 1997. Pollination of Nuphar (Nymphaeaceae) in Europe: flies and beetles rather than Donacia beetles. Plant Syst. Evol. 207: 273-283.
MATHIS, W. N., AND T. ZATWARNICKI. 1998. A review of the West Indian species of Mimapsilopa Cresson (Diptera: Ephydridae). Proc. Entomol. Soc. Washington 100: 7-24.
NAGASAKI, O. 2007. Pollination of the yellow water lily Nuphar subintegerrima (Nymphaeaceae) by the shore fly Notiphila (Notiphila) maritima (Diptera: Ephydridae). Plant Spp. Biol. 22: 227-230.
OSBORN, J. M., T. N. TAYLOR, AND E. L. SCHNEIDER 1991. Pollen morphology and ultrastructure of the Cabombaceae: correlations with pollination biology. American J. Bot. 78:1367-1378.
STURTEVANT, A. H., AND M. R. WHEELER 1954. Synopses of Nearctic Ephydridae (Diptera). Trans. American Entomol. Soc. 79: 151-261.
REY, J. R., AND E. D. McCoy. 1986. Terrestrial arthropods of northwest Florida salt marshes: Diptera (Insecta). Florida Entomol. 69: 197-205.
TRIER, R. W., AND B. A. FOOTE. 1980. Biology of mudshore Ephydridae (Diptera). Proc. Entomol. Soc. Washington 84:517-535.
WIRTH, W. W. 1965. Family Ephydridae, pp. 734-759 In A. Stone, C. W Sabrosky, W. W Wirth, R. H. Foote, and J. R. Coulson [eds.], A Catalog of the Diptera of America North of Mexico. U.S. Dept. Agric. Hand-book 276. 1696 pp.
WIRTH, W. W. 1968. The genus Typopsilopa Cresson in the Western Hemisphere (Diptera: Ephydridae). Proc. Entomol. Soc. Wash. 70:225-237.
WIRTH, W. W., W. N. MATHIS AND J. R. VOCKEROTH.1987. Ephydridae, pp. 1027-1047 In J. F McAlpine, B. V Peterson, G. E. Shewell, H. J. Teskey, J. R. Vockeroth and D. M. Wood [eds.], Manual of Nearctic Diptera. Vol. 2. Agriculture Canada Monograph 28:675-1332.
Mark Deyrup (1) AND Leif Deyrup (2)
(1) Archbold Biological Station, P.O. Box 2057, Lake Placid, FL 33862 E-Mail: email@example.com
(2) P.O. Box 55, Wayne, ME 04284
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Deyrup, Mark; Deyrup, Leif|
|Date:||Sep 1, 2008|
|Previous Article:||First record of Asphondylia websteri (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae) infesting Hass avocados.|
|Next Article:||Fjellberg, A. 2007. The Collembola of Fennoscandia and Denmark (Fauna Entomologica Scandinavica volumes 35 and 42), volume 42 part II:...|
|Biology and natural history of Anastrepha interrupta (Diptera: Tephritidae).|