Evaluation of results of bridge plating in comminuted fractures of long bones.
Clinical experience has shown that early AO/ASIF method of plating in comminuted fractures of long bones to ensure absolute stability and primary bone union has been associated with high risk of non-union. Recent experiences suggest that leaving the fragment untouched preserve their blood supply and accelerate union. Biological percutaneous plating provides relative stability, preserve vascularity around the fractures and it also allows controlled micromotion, resulting in rapid and more abundant callus formation, as observed in intramedullary nailing or in non operative fracture treatment. Thus bridge plating with minimum invasive technique has occupied the dominant position in recent advancement of treatment of comminuted fractures (3,4,5,6).
The present study was undertaken in prospective basis to evaluate the efficacy of bridge plating in comminuted fracture of femur and tibia.
Materials and Methods
Between 2008 and 2011 we treated 25 patients of whom 10 had femoral fracture and 15 had tibial fractures. An inclusion criterion was adult patient with closed comminuted diaphyseal fractures of femur and tibia. Cases with simple fracture, pathological fracture and periprosthetic fracture were excluded.
Initial treatment considers skeletal traction for femoral fracture and plaster slab for tibial fracture. Patients were operated under general or spinal anaesthesia and tourniquet were applied whenever possible. A fracture table and traction were used for the femur fractures. An image intensifier was used to assess fracture alignment and progress of fixation. Fixation was accomplished using standard instrumentation and narrow and broad dynamic compression plate (DCP) implants instead of locking plate only because of cost effectiveness keeping in mind the difficultness to introduce the DCP beyond fracture site particularly in femoral fractures. After the fracture was manipulated and satisfactory alignment was achieved, through proximal and distal small incisions a tunnel was made submuscularly in femur and subcutaneous in tibia (fig. 1). A DCP implants were placed in the proximal and distal to fracture site. The plate was fixed with screws on either side with a purchase of minimum six cortices both above and below the fracture, under image guidance. Intermediate fragments were left undisturbed. The wound was closed in layers. All patients received prophylactic antibiotic for 7 days. An isometric quadriceps program was initiated from 3rd post operative day and the patients were mobilized with the help of crutches on 7th post operative day. Partial weight bearing was allowed when callus was observed at the fracture site in a single plane radiographic images and full weight bearing was started on observation of callus in two planes radiographic images. Patients were followed up at 4 weeks interval clinically and radiologically.
RESULTS AND ANALYSIS: Total no. Of patients was 25(22 male and 3 female) of whom 10 had femoral fracture and 15 had tibial fracture. Average age was 34years(most common group being 20-30 years). Road traffic accident was the major causes of these fractures. Most of the fractures were fixed internally within first 7 days of injury. Partial weight bearing was started with the help of crutches between 8-13 weeks. Patients were followed up for a period of 12-48 months (average 24 months). Average time of radiological union was 20.12 weeks. In this study only one case of superficial infection and one case of skin necrosis was observed. Only one cases of nonunion was observed. Results of internal fixation were assessed according to criteria laid down by S.J. Lam (1964).
Excellent: Range of movement of adjacent joints 80-100% of normal. No pain in performing daily activities.
Good: Range of movement of adjacent joints 60-80% of normal. Pain not enough to cause any modification of patient daily routine.
Fair: Range of movement of adjacent joints 30-60% of normal. Pain enough to cause restriction of patient's daily activities.
Poor: Range of movement of adjacent joints less than 30% of normal. Pain enough to cause severe disability or non-union.
DISCUSSION: The development of modern nailing techniques has improved the overall outcome and set new standards for operative treatment of fracture of long bones. Along with the evolution of nailing technique, there has been a similar evolution of plating technique. Clinical thinking has shifted from the mechanical concept of absolute stability to a more biological concept of indirect reduction with limited or no approach at the fracture zone and epiperiosteal plate application (7).
Radiological union (callus in two planes of radiographs) and clinical signs namely absence of pain and tenderness, were taken as criteria to allow full weight bearing. The average time of union was 20.12weeks. Several cases of fracture tibia (15 cases) complained of ankle and knee stiffness initially but after 3 weeks, restricted movement was seen only 3 cases. Overall incidence of ankle was 27%, while in one patient (9%) movement was 10 degree less than normal. Complication rate was very low in the present series of study. There was no evidence of deep infection. Only one case of non-union was observed. The excellent success rate was achieved due to the indirect reduction of fractures with axial and torsional alignment rather than perfect anatomical reduction (7,8,9).
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION: Present series consisted of 25 cases of comminuted diaphyseal fractures of tibia and femur. Among 25 patients, 15 had tibial fracture and 10 had femoral fracture. All were fixed with bridge plating with minimum incision without exposing the fracture site. The average age of the patients was 34 years with male preponderance and road traffic accident being the major cause of these high energy fractures as 28% of patients had associated fractures. Average time of radiological union in this series was 20.12 weeks ranging from 16 to 30 weeks.
The highlights of the present series are that there were only very few complications with no cases of deep infection and delayed union; overall excellent and good result were seen in 92% cases. This achievement could be attributed only to biological internal fixation of fracture with minimum handling of soft tissue along with relatively stable internal fixation.
From the present study we conclude that biological internal fixation of comminuted fractures of long bones by bridge plating has overcome the previous disadvantages of rigid and more invasive internal fixation techniques by plates or vascular damage caused by intramedullary nails. Biological fixation of complex fractures gives stable as well as optimal internal fixation and complete recovery of limb function at an early stage than by fixation by other methods with minimal risk of complications.
(1.) Gustilo RB; Nelson GE: The effect of intramedullary nailing on the blood supply of diaphysis of long bones in mature dogs. J.B.J.S. 46-A: 1362-1363, 1964
(2.) Rhinelander WF; The normal microcirculation of diaphyseal cortex and its response to fracture. J.B.J.S.55A: 895-899, 1968.
(3.) Gerber C; Mast JW: Biological internal fixation of fractures. J. Orth. Trauma. 109:295-303, 1990.
(4.) Baumgaertel F. Bridge plating, In; Ruedi TP, Murphy WM, eds AO Principles of fracture management. New York, NY: Thieme; 2000; 221-231.
(5.) Krettek C. Concepts of minimally invasive. Injury, 1997; 28(suppl)1-6.
(6.) Mohammad Javdan, Ali Andalib, Biological plating of comminuted fracture of femur and tibia, Journal and Research in medical Science, July and August 2007; Vol 12, No. 4; 186-189.
(7.) Baumgaertel F, Buhl M, Rahn BA. Fracture healing in biological plate osteosynthesis. Injury 1998; 29(suppl); C3-C6
(8.) Sturmer KM. Elastic plate osteosynthesis, its biomechanics, indication and technique compared with rigid internal fixation. Unfallchirurg. 1996; 99; 816-819.
(9.) Costas Papakostidis, MD; Martin R.W. Grotz, MD-Femoral biologic plate fixation. Clinical Orthopaedics and Related Research. No-450, September 2006
Prasanta Kr. Mandal, Fagu Ram Majhi, Dibakar Ray, Mrinal Kanti Roy, M. Bhattacharyya, Amalendu Bikas Chatterjee
[1.] Associate Professor. Department of Orthopedics, Bankura Sammilani Medical College
[2.] Assistant Professor. Department of Orthopedics, Bankura Sammilani Medical College.
[3.] Assistant Professor. Department of Orthopedics, Bankura Sammilani Medical College.
[4.] Assistant Professor. Department of Orthopedics, Bankura Sammilani Medical College.
[5.] Professor. Department of Orthopedics, Bankura Sammilani Medical College.
[6.] Associate Professor. Department of Anaesthesia, Bankura Sammilani Medical College.
Prasanta Kr. Mandal
Lokepur, P. O. Kenduadihi, Dist. Bankura, Pin--722102.
Ph: 0091 94341173124.
Table-1 Showing functional results of the study Criteria No. Of patients Percentage (%) Excellent 18 72 Good 5 20 Fair 2 8 Poor -- -- Total 25 100
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||ORIGINAL ARTICLE|
|Author:||Mandal, Prasanta Kr.; Majhi, Fagu Ram; Ray, Dibakar; Roy, Mrinal Kanti; Bhattacharyya, M.; Chatterje|
|Publication:||Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences|
|Article Type:||Clinical report|
|Date:||Mar 11, 2013|
|Previous Article:||A case of recurrence of MPNST in NF 1 with intracranial and hepatic metastases.|
|Next Article:||Combination of silymarin and choline bitartrate in pregnancy induced pruritus.|