Epidemiological profile of snake-bite cases from Andhra Pradesh using immunoanalytical approach.
Methods: Data from 1379 snake-bite cases were collected from case reports for a 5 yr period (1999-2003) that included age and sex of the victim, district, month of incidence, time of incident, death of a victim and the time point of analysis. On the basis of the forensic data, specimens were collected from forensic medicine department, during rainy season and were analysed for the venom antigens (cobra and krait) by ELISA method.
Results: The peak number of snake-bite cases were seen during June-September. Majority of the cases were observed in the age group 21-50 yr (71%). Higher incidence of snake-bite was recorded in males (76%). Of the 22 cases analysed by the ELISA, 6 tested positive for cobra venom, while 8 cases tested positive for krait venom, the remaining specimens tested negative for both cobra and krait venom.
Interpretation & conclusion: Evaluation of forensic specimens (autopsy & biopsy) of human snakebite victims based on specific molecular epidemiological tool like ELISA gives a true estimate of the incidence supplementing clinical and circumstantial evidence.
Key words Enzyme immunoassays--epidemiological profile--snake-bite incidences
Snake-bite is an important and serious medicolegal problem in many parts of the world, especially in South Asian countries. It has been estimated that 5 million snake-bite cases occur worldwide every year, causing about 100,000 deaths (1). On an average, nearly 2,00,000 persons fall prey to snake-bite per year in India and 35,000-50,000 of them die every year (2). But data on the morbidity and mortality of snake-bite are unreliable due to improper reporting system; 80 per cent of individuals bitten by snakes in Africa first consult traditional practitioners before visiting a medical centre (3,4).
The snakes most commonly associated with human mortality in India are cobra (Naja naja naja), krait (Bungarus caeruleus), Russell's viper (Vipera russelli) and saw scaled viper (Echis carinatus) (5). Snake-bite incidences vary from region to region and depend upon (i) the natural habitat of particular species of snake in the region; and (ii) probability of human being coming in contact.
Based on an epidemiological survey conducted by Hati et al in 1992 (6) in 26 villages of Burdwan district, West Bengal, nearly 0.16 per cent/yr of an annual incidence and mortality rate of 0.016 per cent/ yr were observed. In Maharashtra highest incidences of snake-bites have been reported (70 bites per 100,000 population and mortality of 2.4 per 100,000/ yr) (7). The other States which show high incidences include Tamil Nadu, Uttar Pradesh and Kerala (8). However, there have been no epidemiological studies related to snake-bite incidence from the State of Andhra Pradesh.
In view of the monetary benefits given by the Government of Andhra Pradesh, India, under the scheme Apathbandhu to the dependants of those who die due to snake-bite, several false cases of snake-bite have also been reported for claiming the compensation (9). Hence, it is of immense importance for the forensic experts to detect or quantitate the snake venom residue in autopsy specimens of snake-bite victims so as to ascertain the exact cause of death and to prevent false claims.
Though several immunological methods have been reported for the detection of snake venom across the world (10-13), detection of snake venom in forensic specimens is more tedious for the forensic experts to know the exact cause of death of the victim. The reasons may be due to (i) improper preservation of the sample; (ii) non availability of species-specific antibodies; and (iii) non availability of an immunoanalytical method specific for forensic analysis.
We report retrospective epidemiological data of snake-bite incidence in Andhra Pradesh; and prospective assessment of the snake venom antigens in forensic specimens collected from snake-bite victims through immunoanalytical approach.
Material & Methods
The data of snake-bite cases from January 1999 to December 2003 were obtained from the records of the Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory (APFSL), Hyderabad. The AP State Forensic Science Laboratory is a referral government laboratory, where snake-bite cases come in from different parts of the State, to ascertain the exact cause of death.
Lyophilized crude Indian cobra (Naja naja naja) and krait (Bungarus caeruleus) venom were procured from Haffkine's Institute, Mumbai, India. Goat anti-rabbit immunoglobulin G (IgG) (whole molecule) peroxidase conjugate, Fish gelatin, 3' ,3' ,5' ,5'-tetramethylbenzidine (TMB), [beta]- cyclodextrin, urea hydrogen peroxide (Urea-[H.sub.2][O.sub.2]), bovine serum albumin (BSA), phenylmethylsulphonyl fluoride (PMSF), methylbenzethonium hydroxide were purchased from Sigma-Aldrich chemical company (St Louis, MO, USA). All the other reagents were of analytical grade unless otherwise stated.
Polystyrene ELISA plates (Microlon 600, 8x12 wells) were purchased from Greiner, Nurtingen, Germany. SLT-Spectra II microplate reader (Grodig, Salzburg, Austria) was used for experimental investigation. Sigma plot 5.0 (SPSS, Richmond, CA, USA) software was used for linear regression analysis.
Data collection: The case data documentation of snake-bite cases recorded during the period 1999 to 2003 were obtained from the Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory to collect the information on age, sex, seasonal and district distribution, time of incident, death of a victim and the time point of analysis. In addition, number of specimens received for each case and the most frequently received specimens by the forensic laboratories were also recorded.
Sample collection and preservation: Forensic specimens (skin/skin scrapings, blood/serum) were collected from 22 human snake-bite victims (diagnosed, based on the clinical symptoms and fang marks), who were admitted to the Forensic Medicine Department, Osmania General Hospital, Afzalgunj, Hyderabad, Andhra Pradesh, during 2004 (June-September, rainy season), after obtaining institutional ethical clearance. Skin/skin scrapings were preserved in cocktail containing 70 per cent ethanol, 2 per cent glycerol, 28 per cent 0.02 M phosphate buffer saline (PBS), pH 7.4 containing 0.05 per cent thimerosal, and were stored at -20[degrees]C until further use. Post-mortem blood samples were centrifuged at 10,000 x g, at 4[degrees]C for 30 min and the clear supernatant was used for the analysis. Otherwise, blood samples allowed to clot for 30 min, serum was separated, lyophilized after the addition of 0.001 M PMSF with 0.05 per cent thimerosal and stored at -20[degrees]C. The tissues were weighed and homogenized in 0.025 M PBS, pH 7.4 with 0.01 M methylbenzethonium hydroxide using a mechanical homogenizer. The homogenized samples were centrifuged at 10,000 x g, at 4[degrees]C for 30 min and the clear supernatant was analyzed for the presence of venom antigens.
Enzyme immunoassay methods (EIA): Egg yolk antibody (IgY) based sandwich ELISA (14) for the cobra venom and indirect-competitive inhibition ELISA (15) for the krait venom were used for analyzing venom antigens in the forensic specimens. Briefly, sandwich ELISA is based on the principle that the cobra venom is sandwiched between immobilized chick IgY and rabbit IgG antibodies raised against cobra venom. The detection system was based on labeled antibody (against rabbit IgG raised in goat).
Indirect-competitive inhibition ELISA is based on the principle that affinity purified rabbit IgG raised against krait venom were incubated with a known amount of the antigen (reference standard: krait venom) or test sample (unknown). The amount of free antigen (krait venom) present in the standard or test sample competes with the immobilized antigen (krait venom) for the binding sites on the antibody. The detection system was based on labeled antibody (against rabbit IgG raised in goat).
The concentration of venom in the test sample was quantitated from the calibration curve using linear regression equation (cobra venom: y = 0.2581x + 0.4375 (14); krait venom: y = 72.85 - 12.29x(15)).
A total of 1379 cases of snake-bite were recorded during the period 1999 to 2003 (Table). Rainy season (June to September) accounted for 50 per cent (n=689) of the cases reported (Fig. 1). Very few cases were recorded in the month of December, January and February. Majority of the snake-bite cases were in the age group of 21-50 yr (71%; n=980), followed by the age group of 51-60 yr (11%, n=156) and 11-20 yr (10%, n=135) (Fig 2). Interestingly, it was observed that there was a preponderant male dominance in all age groups. Also, out of 1379 snake-bite cases, 76 per cent (n=1042) of the cases were males and male to female ratio was found to be 3:1. With respect to females, more number of cases were observed in the age group of 21-30 yr (n=91)
followed by 31-40 yr (n=74) and 41-50 yr (n=68). Highest incidence (17%, n=236) of snake-bite cases were recorded from the district of Mahbubnagar, while Srikakulam district had lowest incidence (0.2%, n=3), (Fig 3). The time lapse between date of death of snake-bite victim and the time point of analysis was observed to be in the range of 20-70 days, with a mean value of 35 days. Forensic specimens received by the referral laboratory included skin, blood, liver, kidneys, viscera, heart, lungs, bladder, spleen, brain, ear, bone and finger.
[FIGURE 1 OMITTED]
[FIGURE 2 OMITTED]
Immunoanalysis of specimens (skin/skin scrapings, blood/serum) collected from 22 human snake-bite victims during rainy season revealed cobra venom in 6 specimens (2 males, 4 females), while krait venom was detected in 8 (5 males, 3 females); the remaining samples were negative for both cobra and krait venom. Cobra venom was detected in the range of 4.22-11 ng/100 mg (wet weight) tissue (skin or skin scrapings) and 6.4-13.48 ng/ml blood or serum by sandwich ELISA. Similarly, krait venom was detected in the range of 4.11-172 ng/100 mg (wet weight) tissue (skin or skin scrapings) and 58-460 ng/ml blood or serum by an indirect-competitive inhibition ELISA.
Envenomation to human may occur through unintentional interactions or more commonly due to intentional encounters with snakes (while handling and milking venom). It was reported earlier, that the majority of the snake-bites (82%) occur among the rural population (16), who are bitten in agricultural fields while working and also during sleeping outdoors. Most patients are unable to identify the snake species either because of ignorance or poor visibility during darkness.
[FIGURE 3 OMITTED]
Highest number of bites recorded during June to September in the present study is similar to that recorded earlier from Pondichery (17). The possible reason for majority of the snake-bites in rainy season may be attributed to the flooding of rain water in the dwelling places of snakes, thus causing their dislodgment. Consequently, human population becomes accidental victim to the snake-bite. Further, the situation is aggravated by the propinquity of rodents near the human habitat, thus increasing the risk of snake-bite.
In the present investigation, snake-bite cases were observed in almost all age groups (except 81-90 yr), the majority being in males aged 21-50 yr, while the male to female ratio was 3:1. In the previous studies reported from Ambajogai (Maharashtra) (18) and Karnataka (19), the male to female ratio was found to be 3.2:1 and 2:1, respectively. Studies from other countries also indicate male victim preponderance; male: Female ratio was reported as 1.9:1 in Thailand (20) and 1.3:1 in Pakistan (21). The predominance of male victims suggests a special risk of outdoor activity. The commonly affected age groups were observed to be 10-40 yr in Nepal (20), 15-44 yr in Pakistan (21) and 6-40 yr in Zimbabwe (22). A study reported an incidence of 7-15 per cent in children less than 10 yr (23). The sex ratio seems to be almost uniform in all the earlier reports with males being affected twice or thrice as commonly as females (23).
Analysis of district-wise distribution of the snake-bite incidences in the state of Andhra Pradesh showed the highest number of cases from the Mahbubnagar district and least number from Srikakulam district. The low incidence in Srikakulam district may be attributed to the presence of tribal population and a forest area covering 15.6 per cent of the total district area (24), wherein the snake-bite victims prefer to go in for traditional method of treatment rather than approaching the Government hospitals.
One of the important aspects of assessing the cause of death in snake-bite victim is by detection of the snake venom antigens in the specimens collected from the victim. Most frequently, specimens which are sent to the Forensic Laboratory for analysis include kidneys, liver, viscera, blood, skin, lungs, heart, brain, spleen, bladder, bone and ear. Previous reports have established that the order of distribution of snake venom in different organs of the body as, site of injection or skin >heart/liver > kidneys > lungs > spleen > brain (10). Post-mortem cardiac blood has been suggested to be the most suitable specimen for venom detection (25). Thus, skin (tissue at the bite area) and blood are the suitable source of biological specimen for the analysis of snake venom.
It should be noted that the venom detection in the tissue samples depends to a greater extent on the time lapse between the bite and death of a victim, which could allow the venom for extensive absorption, redistribution and excretion (26).
Normally, forensic specimens were preserved in brine solution, until further use. In order to avoid the interference of high salt concentration, an alternate preservant was used in the present study in place of brine solution. Earlier reports also indicate that the preservation of autopsy specimens is an important factor, which determines the exact quantitation of the venom (10). This study also suggested that the autopsy specimens should be collected soon after death and stored at -20[degrees]C. The immunoassay results indicated 6 of the 22 cases positive for cobra venom while 8 for krait venom and remaining 8 cases showed neither cobra or krait venom. Clinical symptoms, fang marks and circumstantial evidences substantiated these results. However, it is also pertinent to note that, psychological shock itself can kill a person even at sub-lethal doses of venom in the envenomated victims, the detection of which is limited by the sensitivity and specificity of the methods employed.
In conclusion, establishment of the snake-bite incidences based on the specific immunoanalytical tool afforded a true estimate of the specific snake-bite along with clinical and circumstantial evidence. Enzyme immunoassay may be considered a useful molecular epidemiological tool in determining the incidence of snake-bite deaths.
The authors thank Dr C.R. Ram Reddy, Professor of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology, Osmania General Hospital, Hyderabad, for providing the forensic specimens, and Dr K.P.S. Gandhi, Director. Andhra Pradesh Forensic Science Laboratory (APFSL), Hyderabad for giving permission to collect forensic data on the snake-bite cases. The authors also thank Miss M. Santhoshi kumari, APFSL-Project Assistant, for her help in the collection of forensic data. The first author (GB) acknowledge the Directorate of Forensic Science (DFS), New Delhi, for providing the research fellowship (SRF) at Central Forensic Science Laboratory (CFSL), Hyderabad.
Received July 11, 2006
(1.) Mathew JL, Gera T. Ophitoxaemia (venomous snake bite). Available at: http://www.priory.com/med/ophitoxaemia.htm (accessed on November 18, 2004).
(2.) David AW. Guidelines for the clinical management of snake-bites in the south-east Asia region. World Health Organization, Regional Office for South East Asia, New Delhi; 2005 p. 1-67.
(3.) Chippaux JP. Snake bite epidemiology in Benin (West Africa). Toxicon 1988; 27 : 37.
(4.) Snow RW. The prevalence and morbidity of snake bite and treatment seeking behaviour among a rural Kenyan population. Ann Trop Med Parasitol 1994; 88 : 665-71.
(5.) Whittaker R. Common Indian snakes: A field guide. New Delhi: McMillan India Limited; 2001.
(6.) Hati AK, Mandal M, De MK, Mukherjee H, Hati RN. Epidemiology of snake bite in the district of Burdwan, West Bengal. J Indian Med Assoc 1992; 90 : 145-7.
(7.) Gaitonde BB, Bhattacharya S. An epidemiological survey of snake bite cases in India. Snake 1980; 12 : 129-33.
(8.) Bhatia BD. Scorpion sting and snake bite. In : Sachdev HPS, Puri RK, Bagga A, Choudhury P, editors. Principles of pediatric and neonatal emergencies. New Delhi : Jaypee Brother Medical Publishers (P) Ltd., 1994 p. 257-64.
(9.) URL: http://220.127.116.11/Apath.htm, accessed on November 10, 2004.
(10.) Selvanayagam ZE, Gnanavendhan SG, Ganesh KA, Rajagopal D, Subba Rao PV. ELISA for the detection of venoms from four medically important snakes of India. Toxicon 1999; 37 : 757-70.
(11.) Cox JC, Moisidis AV, Shepherd JM, Drane DP, Jones SL. A novel format for a rapid sandwich EIA and its application of the identification of snake venoms. J Immunol Method 1992; 146 : 213-8.
(12.) Huang YP, Yu YJ, Hung DZ. Sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for Taiwan cobra venom. Vet Hum Toxicol 2002; 44 : 200-4.
(13.) Dong LV, Quyen LK, Eng KH, Gopalakrishnakone P. Immunogenicity of venoms from four common snakes in the South of Vietnam and development ELISA kit for venom detection. J Immunol Method 2003; 282 : 13-31.
(14.) Brunda G, Sashidhar RB, Sarin RK. Use of egg yolk antibody (IgY) as an immunoanalytical tool in the detection of Indian cobra (Naja naja naja) venom in biological samples of Forensic origin. Toxicon 2006: 48 : 183-94.
(15.) Brunda G, Sashidhar RB, Sarin RK. Quantitation of Indian krait (Bungarus caeruleus) venom in human specimens of forensic origin by indirect-competitive inhibition enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay. J AOAC Int 2006; 89 : 1360-6.
(16.) Sharma N, Chauhan S. Faruqi S, Bhat P, Varma S. Snake envenomation in a north Indian hospital. Emerg Med d 2005; 22 : 118-20.
(17.) Srihari PLD, Rotti SB, Danabalan M, Akshay K. Epidemiological profile of snake bite cases admitted in JIPMER hospital. Indian .I Community Med 2001; 26 : 36-8.
(18.) Mulay DV, Kulkarni VA, Kulkarni SG, Kulkarni ND, Jaju RB. Clinical profile of snake bites at SRTR Medical College Hospital, Ambajogai (Maharastra). Indian Med Gazette 1986; 131 : 363-6.
(19.) Kulakarni ML, Anees S. Snake venom poisoning: experience with 633 cases. Indian Pediatr 1994; 31 : 1239-43.
(20.) Buranasin P. Snake bites at Maharat Nakhon Ratchasima Regional Hospital. Southeast Asian J Trop Med Public Health 1993; 24 : 186-92.
(21.) Rano M. A study of snake bite cases. J Pak Med Assoc 1994; 44 : 289.
(22.) Nhachi CF. Kasilo OM. Snake poisoning in rural Zimbabwe: A prospective study. J Appl Toxicol 1994; 14 : 192-3.
(23.) Paul VK, Chawla D, Jatana V. Animal and insect bites, 4th ed. In : Singh M, editor. Medical emergencies in children. New Delhi: Sagar Publications, 2007 p. 624-83
(24.) URL:http://www.whereincity.com/india/andhra-pradesh, accessed on April 24, 2006.
(25.) Sutherland SK, Coulter AR, Broad AJ, Hilton JMN, Lane LHD. Human snake bite victims; the successful detection of circulating snake venom by radioimmunoassay. Med J Aust 1975; 1 : 27-9.
(26.) Sutherland SK, Coulter AR. Three instructive cases of tiger snake (Notechis scutatus) envenomation and how a radioimmunoassay proved the diagnosis. Med J Aust 1977; 2 : 177-80.
Reprint requests: Dr R.B. Sashidhar, Department of Biochemistry, University College of Science Osmania University, Hyderabad 500007, India e-mail: firstname.lastname@example.org
Ganneru Brunda & R.B. Sashidhar
Department of Biochemistry, University College of Science, Osmania University, Hydrebad, India
Table. Annual frequency of snake-bite incidences and sex distribution in cases (1999-2003) No. of snake- Sex Year bite cases Male Female 1999 255 190 65 2000 229 184 45 2001 331 249 82 2002 333 240 93 2003 231 179 52 Total 1379 1042 337
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Brunda, Ganneru; Sashidhar, R.B.|
|Publication:||Indian Journal of Medical Research|
|Date:||May 1, 2007|
|Previous Article:||Copper/zinc superoxide dismutase activity in newborns & young people in Spain.|
|Next Article:||Radiological manifestations of splenic tuberculosis: a 23-patient case series from India.|