Printer Friendly

Effect of Butylated Hydroxytoluene on Post-thawed Semen Quality of Beetal Goat Buck Capra hircus.

Byline: Z. Iqbal A. Ijaz M. Aleem A. H. Shahzad M.U. Sohail D. Nak Y. Nak and S. Abbas


Present study was conducted to evaluate the effect butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) on post-thawed semen quality of Beetal goat buck semen. Semen was obtained from six bucks using artificial vagina and cryopreserved in tris egg yolk extender and semen quality was assessed on the basis of post-thaw sperm motility viability plasma membrane integrity and acrosomal membrane status. Ejaculates were pooled and extended to the concentration of 2 A- 109 spermatozoa per mL in tris egg yolk extender (300 mOsmol/L). Tris egg yolk extender containing various concentrations of BHT (0.0 2.0 and 5.0 mM) was prepared. French straws (0.5 mL) were manually filled with semen gradually cooled from 39oC to 4oC and finally cryopreserved in liquid nitrogen at -196oC.

Five straws from each treatment [BHT (0.0 2.0 and 5.0 mM)] were thawed and evaluated under phase-contrast microscope (40 A-) for sperm motility whereas sperm viability plasma membrane integrity and acrosomal integrity were assessed by the supravital staining hypo-osmotic swelling test (HOST) and normal acrosomal reaction respectively. The results showed that only acrosomal integrity was improved (P less than 0.05) by the addition of BHT in semen extender. Motility was suppressed (P less than 0.05) by increasing BHT concentration. The maximum motility of sperm was achieved with 0.0 mM BHT. The HOST response and viability of spermatozoa were increased by addition of 2 and 5 mM BHT but this increment was not statistically significant. In conclusion the addition of BHT to semen extender can partially improve semen quality of Beetal goat.

Keywords: Semen butylated hydroxytoluene goat buck cryopreservation semen quality


Goats are very hardy and cope with harsh conditions of temperature and humidity (Gall 1981). Less input easy management adaptability and above all ability to survive and produce on minimal fodder availability makes them as animals of choice in tropical and subtropical parts of the world. Due to this reason perhaps 60% of total world's goat population is raised in Asia especially in developing countries (FAO 2007). Beetal breed is dual purpose mainly raised in tropical areas of Pakistan. Economic survey of Pakistan does prove that in the last two decades growth rate of goat population is 61% (37 to 59.7 millions heads) which is the highest among all domesticated livestock like cattle buffalo and sheep. In this way caprines are considered to play an important role in uplifting of socio-economic standards of common and poor income communities.

Currently artificial insemination (AI) is getting more importance in all domestic animals. Genetically superior males can be used to improve genetic potential of the breed through intensive AI programs. Large scale AI program is essential in goat farming to meet ever increasing demand of milk hair and meat. Artificial Insemination has been proved to be very useful in optimizing selection response and in spreading the genes of superior bucks and has been used particularly in intensive production systems. Success in caprine AI is limited as conception rate depend on the proper collection and preservation of semen (Leboeuf et al. 2000) and influenced by cryopreservation induced lipid peroxidation (Bailey et al. 2000; Khalifa et al. 2008).

Spermatozoa have only a short survival time outside the reproductive tract at ambient temperatures; however for a large-scale AI program it is desired to preserve spermatozoa for an extended time. Fortunately this could be achieved by the development and introduction of cryopreservation technique.

Post-thaw quality of cryopreserved semen is generally lower than fresh caprine semen (Ritar and Salamon 1983) and requires eight times more spermatozoa number to achieve equivalent fertilization rate compared with fresh Bovine semen (Shannon and Vishwanath 1995). It has been previously indicated that cryopreservation procedure may lead to some changes in morphology and biochemistry of spermatozoa such as reducing head size and altering membrane architecture and lipid composition (Halliwell and Gutterridge 1984; Gravance et al. 1998).

One of the most important factors resulting in decreased fertility in AI with cryopreserved semen is oxidative damage of spermatozoa during freeze and thaw processes. It is well known that reactive oxygen species (ROS) including hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) superoxide anion (O2-) and hydroxyl radical (OH-) are physiologically produced in living cells during metabolism (Alvarez and Storey 1992; Lasso et al. 1994). Moreover it is well documented that cryopreservation of semen produces ROS which are detrimental to spermatozoa (Watson 2000) due to the induction of lipid peroxidation (Chatterjee and Gagnon 2000). The spermatozoa possess weak anti-oxidants and the process of cryopreservation increases the susceptibility to lipid peroxidation (Foote et al. 2002). The free radicals are known to be involved in lipid peroxidation as well as DNA and sperm membrane damages that may lead to decreased sperm motility or cell death (Uysal et al. 2007).

However it has been reported that cryopreservation reduces bull sperm glutathione and superoxide dismutase activity (Aitken 1994; Bailey et al. 2000). Hydrogen peroxide and lipid peroxyl radicals are the lethal oxygen species that have ability to cross the plasma membranes freely inhibit enzymatic activities and cellular functions consequently decrease the antioxidant defenses of the spermatozoa (Aitken 1994).

It has been clearly demonstrated that excess amount of ROS in semen arrests sperm motility inhibits sperm-egg fusion and causes sperm DNA damage (Kessopoulou et al. 1995). Therefore if an antioxidant system is involved in preservation process an increasing semen quality would be expected after the addition of such antioxidant agents. Moreover it has been stated that depicting use of antioxidant agents such as vitamins catalase taurine hypotaurine dimethylsulphoxide N- acetylcysteine and butylated hydroxytoluene (BHT) in human (Alvarez and Storey 1992) bovine (Bilodeau et al. 2001) rabbit (Abd-El-Salaam 2002) and stallion (Ball et al. 2001) semen revealed some controversial efficacies and successes.

Besides the beneficial effect of BHT for the preservation of frozen sperm in ram (Watson and Anderson 1983) boar (Roca et al. 2004) goat (Khalifa et al. 2008) cattle (Shoae and Zamiri 2008) buffalo bull (Ijaz et al. 2009) and dog (Neagu et al. 2010) the elucidating effect of BHT a synthetic analogue of vitamin E which checks the auto-oxidation reaction by converting peroxy radicals to hydroperoxides on goat buck spermatozoa is still a debate. In this study it was hypothesized that addition of BHT might have improved the oxidative defense system of sperm and therefore this study was designed to elucidate the defensive role of BHT in goat semen cryopreservation extender.


Preparation of extender

All chemicals were analytical graded and purchased from Sigma-Aldrich Co. Deisenhofen Germany. Tris egg yolk extender (100 mL; 300 mOsmol/L) was prepared which was composed of Tris (hydroxymethyl) amino methane (312.63 mM) fructose (34.69 mM) citric acid (103.36 mM) egg yolk (2.50 ml) glycerol (7 ml; 950.11 mM) benzyl penicillin (50000 IU) streptomycin sulphate (0.1 g) and distilled water. The appropriate amount of BHT (0 2.0 and 5.0 mM) was first dissolved in ethanol. The ethanol was allowed to evaporate so that a thin crystallized layer of BHT was deposited on the inner surface of the tubes and extender was added. Subsequently semen was added and incubated to allow uptake of BHT by spermatozoa.

Semen collection and processing

Six beetal goat bucks were selected for semen collection using artificial vagina and adopting all hygienic measures. During the course of collection 2 bucks were replaced on the basis of post collection semen evaluation. Immediately after collection semen was transferred to a water bath at 39oC. Ejaculates from each buck were subjected to the gross (volume color) and microscopic evaluation (motility percentage sperm cell concentration with haemocytometer) to discard the ejaculates having mass motility below 60 %. When the minimum standards of motility morphology and concentration were achieved (Ijaz et al. 2009) ejaculates from all bucks were pooled and extended to concentration of 2A-109 spermatozoa per mL. Extended semen contained 0.0 2.0 or 5.0 mM BHT. French straws (0.5 mL) were manually filled with semen which contained increasing amounts of BHT [0 (control) 2.0 and 5.0 mM] gradually cooled from 39oC to 4oC subjected to LN vapors and finally cryopreserved in liquid nitrogen at 196oC.

Post-thaw semen evaluation

At the time of analysis five straws of semen from each treatment were thawed at 39oC for 30 s and pooled to perform the following semen quality parameters. Eight replicates were used in each treatment.

Sperm motility

One drop of semen was placed on a pre- warmed glass slide and a cover slip was mounted over it. Percentage motility was observed under phase-contrast microscope (40 A-). The mean of three observations was considered as a single data point.

Acrosomal integrity

A 100 L semen sample was fixed in 10 L of 1 % formaldehyde citrate in tri-sodium citrate dehydrate solution (2.9% w/v). Two hundred spermatozoa were counted under a phase-contrast microscope (100 A-) for acrosomal integrity which was indexed as percentage of normal ruffled swollen or absent acrosomes (Ijaz et al. 2009).

Plasma membrane integrity

Hypo-osmotic swelling test (HOST) was performed to assess plasma membrane integrity. A hypo-osmotic solution (190 mOsm/L) was prepared by dissolving 0.735 g of tri-sodium citrate dihydrate and 1.351 g fructose in 100 L of distilled water.

A 50 L semen sample was incubated with 500 L of hypo-osmotic solution for 45 min at 39oC. One drop of the incubated semen was placed on a pre-warmed glass slide and examined under phase-contrast microscope (40A-). Two hundred spermatozoa were counted and the percentage of spermatozoa exhibiting tail curling was determined (Ijaz et al. 2009).

Sperm viability

One drop of semen was placed on a glass slide and mixed with a drop of iso molar supravital stain [eosin (1 % w/v) nigrosin (5 % w/v) in 3 % tri-sodium citrate dihydrate solution] to prepare a uniform air dried thin smear and was observed under phase-contrast microscope (100 A-). Totally two hundred spermatozoa either live (unstained heads) or dead (stained heads) were counted to find percentage viability (Ijaz et al. 2009).

Statistical analysis

Data were presented as mean SD. The data were subjected to ANOVA using SPSS-13.0 a statistical package (SPSS Inc. Chicago IL USA). Statistical differences among means (P less than 0.05) were identified using Duncan's multiple range test (DMRT).


Data regarding post-thaw semen quality indices in response to various concentrations of BHT on Tris-based extender are presented in Table I. BHT inclusions negatively affect (Pless than 0.05) sperm motility. The maximum motility of spermatozoa was achieved with 0.0 mM BHT treatment. Nevertheless this difference in post-thaw progressive motility was not significant statistically. Other two parameters used in this investigation were HOST-response and post-thawed sperm viability. Positive HOST response was noted in treated groups as in 2.0 mM (42.303.74) and 5.0 mM (42.802.78) addition of BHT as compared to control group (39.503.68). Similarly viability response was also observed. Viability of spermatozoa containing 2.0 and 5.0 mM concentration of BHT was 59.003.74 and 59.902.78 respectively as compared to control

Table I.- Effect of BHT addition on post-thawed buck semen quality cryopreserved in a Tris egg yolk based extender.

BHT (mM)###Characteristics of spermatozoa (%)

###Motility###Acrosomal integrity###HOST positive###Viability




roup having 54.403.68 viability. Although little improvement was observed in BHT treated groups overall means of treated groups were improved. Moreover neither HOST response nor viability of spermatozoa was significantly influenced by the inclusion of BHT.

Acrosomal integrity was improved (P less than 0.05) by the addition of BHT (0.0 2.0 and 5.0 mM) in Tris-based semen extender. This improvement in acrosomal integrity was gradual and was improved (Pless than 0.05) by the addition of increasing concentrations of both 2.0 (27.000.47) and 5.0 (27.701.76) mM BHT in Tris-based semen extender as compared to control (20.301.05).


The ruminant sperm cell plasma membrane is particularly rich in poly unsaturated fatty acids (PUFA). This predominance of PUFAs renders spermatozoa highly susceptible to peroxidation because of the excessive production of ROS. ROS including H2O2 O2- and OH- are strong oxidants that are physiologically produced in living cells during respiration (Alvarez and Storey 1992; Bamba and Cran 1992). Spermatozoa are vulnerable to ROS damage due to their high polyunsaturated fatty acid content. It is well documented that cryopreservation of semen produces ROS which are detrimental to spermatozoa (Watson 2000) due to the induction of lipid peroxidation (Chatterjee and Gagnon 2001). Further lipid peroxidation levels were found to have negative correlation with fertility. The spermatozoa possess weak anti-oxidants and the process of cryopreservation increases the susceptibility to lipid peroxidation (Foote et al. 2002).

The free radicals are known to be involved in lipid peroxidation as well as DNA and sperm membrane damages that may lead to decreased sperm motility or cell death (Uysal et al. 2007). Besides during semen cryopreservation the antioxidant system of seminal plasma and spermatozoa is challenged by excessive ROS production (Leboeuf et al. 2000). Therefore the addition of synthetic antioxidants in semen extender is generally practiced for semen cryopreservation to inhibit the peroxidation of spermatozoon phospholipids particularly of polyunsaturated fatty acids.

Present study revealed that the inclusion of 5 mM BHT in semen extender could significantly improve acrosomal integrity only with mild improvement in viability and plasma membrane integrity. Proper acrosomal integrity is essential for the acrosome reaction a prerequisite for successful fertilization and subsequent fertility. During acrosome reaction outer acrosomal membrane fuses with the plasma membrane of the spermatozoon resulting in hybrid membrane vesicle formation (Smith 2001). During the process of freeze and thaw production of ROS occurs due to inducing of acrosome damage subsequently resulting in premature capacitation and acrosome reaction (Uysal et al. 2007). A proposed mechanism for BHT induced improvement in the integrity of acrosome and plasma membrane is that BHT is incorporated into the cell membrane resulting in increased fluidity of the membranes and limited lipid peroxidation reactions (Shoae and Zamiri 2008).

Conversely Aitken and Clarkson (1988) proposed that BHT may convert lipid peroxyl radicals into hydro peroxides which may reduce spermatozoa damage. Our finding is in general agreement with previous reports (Anderson et al. 1994; Shoae and Zamiri 2008; Ijaz et al. 2009). Concomitantly added BHT negatively affected sperm motility. ROS produced during cryopreservation may suppress sperm motility and fertility (Khalifa and El-Saidy 2006).

Our finding is in contrast to the most of the previous published findings (Killian et al. 1989; Anderson et al. 1994; Khalifa et al. 2008; Shoae and Zamiri 2008; Ijaz et al. 2009). It is difficult to argue poor motility rates in BHT treated groups as several factors may be responsible like dose rate breed differences spermatozoa number per dose application methods thawing time and temperature composition of extender and above all extent of cryo-damage itself. One major possible reason behind this is justifiable in the sense of protective effect of BHT in extender as it minimizes the production of ROS. Production of ROS may increase the motility and it might possible that this factor is responsible for decrease in motility. It is important to note that BHT is lipid soluble and possibility did exist that more BHT remained associated with egg yolk lipids leaving a little concentration of free BHT molecules to penetrate spermatozoa membrane (Killian et al. 1989; Ijaz et al. 2009).

In a previous study (Graham and Hammerstedt 1992) it was reported that inclusion of BHT analogues reduced the motility of the spermatozoa extended in extenders with no egg yolk and vice versa. This shows that BHT or its analogues may have a synergistic effect with egg yolk in protecting spermatozoa from cryo injury. This fact is further supported by Khalifa et al. (2008) who state that optimal goat semen cryopreservation was achieved at 5.0 mM BHT concentration in egg yolk based semen diluents and 0.3 mM BHT concentration in egg yolk-free diluents. In the current study different concentrations of BHT (05.0 mM) were studied. It seems that optimal concentration of BHT depends upon animal species. For instance the optimal concentration of BHT was 0.052.0 mM (Bamba and Cran 1992) and 0.2 1.6 mM for boar (Roca et al. 2004) and 0.51.0 mM for cattle bull (Shoae and Zamiri 2008) and 2.0 mM for Nili Ravi buffalo bull (Ijaz et al. 2009).

These results advocate that significant difficulties still exist with regard to species differences and technical abilities when using BHT to conserve sperm motility and viability.

Indeed as reported elsewhere for BHT our study concluded that addition of BHT in semen extender can partially improve semen quality of beetal goat buck. Still further studies are required to obtain more accurate dose rate and to identify molecular interactions between BHT extender components and sperm membrane.


ABD EL-SALAAM A.M. 2002. Studies on freezing rabbit semen. M.Sc. thesis Fac. Agric. Zagazig Univ. Zagazig Egypt.

AITKEN R.J. AND CLARKSON J.S. 1988. Significance of reactive oxygen species and antioxidants in defining the efficacy of spermatozoa preparation techniques. J. Androl. 9:367-376.

AITKEN R.J. 1994. A free-radical theory of male-infertility. Reprod. Fertil. Dev. 6:19-24.

ALVAREZ J.G. AND STOREY B.T. 1992. Evidence for increased lipid peroxidative damage and loss of superoxide dismutase activity as a mode of sublethal cryodamage to human sperm during cryopreservation. J. Androl. 13:232-241.

ANDERSON S. HARKNESS W. AKIN Y. KAPROTH M. AND KILLIAN G. 1994. Categorical data analysis of the effect on bull fertility of butylated hydroxytoluene addition to semen extenders prior to freezing. Dairy Sci. 77:2302-2307.

BALL B.A. MEDINA V. GRAVANCE C.G. AND BUMBER J. 2001. Effect of antioxidants on preservation of motility viability and acrosomal integrity of equine spermatozoa during storage at 5C. Theriogenology 56:577589

BAILEY J.L. BILODEAU J.F. AND CORMIER N. 2000. Semen cryopreservation in domestic animals: A damaging and capacitating phenomenon. J. Androl. 21:1-7.

BILODEAU J.F. CHATTERJEE S. SIRARD M.A. AND GAGNON C. 2000. Levels of antioxidant defenses are decreased in bovine spermatozoa after a cycle of freezing and thawing. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 55: 282288.

BAMBA K. AND CRAN D.G. 1992. Effect of treatment with butylated hydroxytoluene on the susceptibility of boar spermatozoa to cold stress and dilution. J. Reprod. Fertil. 95:69-77.

CHATTERJEE S. AND GAGNON C. 2001. Production of reactive oxygen species by spermatozoa undergoing cooling freezing and thawing. Mol. Reprod. Dev. 59:451-458.

FOOTE R.H. BROCKETT C.C. AND KAPROTH M. T.2002. Motility and fertility of bull sperm in whole milk extender containing antioxidants. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 71:1323.

FAO 2007. In: The state of world's animal genetic resources for food and agriculture (eds. B. Richkowsky and D. Pilling). FAO Rome.

GALL C. 1981. Goat production. Academic press Inc. London England.

GRAHAM J.K. AND HAMMERSTEDT R.H. 1992. Differential effects of butylated hydroxytoluene analogs on bull sperm subjected to cold-induced membrane stress. Cryobiology 29:106117.

GRAVANCE C.G. VISHWANATH R. PITT C. GARNER D.L. AND CASEY P.J. 1998. Effects of cryopreservation on bull sperm head morphometry. J. Androl. 19:704-709.

HALLIWELL B. AND GUTTERRIDGE J. 1984. Lipid peroxidation oxygen radicals cell damage and antioxidant therapy. Lancet 1:1396-1398.

IJAZ A. HUSSAIN A. ALEEM M. YOUSAF M.S. AND REHMAN H. 2009. Butylated hydroxytoluene inclusion in semen extender improves the post-thawed semen quality of Nili-Ravi buffalo (Bubalus bubalis). Theriogenology 71:1326-1329.

KESSOPOULOU E. POWERS H.J. SHARMA K.K. PEARSON M.J. RUSSELL J.M. COOKE I.D. AND BARRATT C.L. 1995. A double-blind randomized placebo crossover controlled trial using the antioxidant vitamin E to treat reactive oxygen species associated male infertility. Fertil. Steril. 64:825-831.

KHALIFA T.A.A. LYMBEROPOULOS A.G. AND EL- SAIDY B.E. 2008. Testing usability of butylated hydroxytoluene in conservation of goat semen. Repro. Domest. Anim. 43:525530

KHALIFA T.A.A. AND EL-SAIDY B.E. 2006. Pellet- freezing of Damascus goat semen in a chemically defined extender. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 93:303-315.

KILLIAN G. HONADEL T. MCNUTT T. HENAULT M. WEGNER C. AND DUNLAP D. 1989. Evaluation of butylated hydroxytoluene as a cryopreservative added to whole or skim milk diluent for bull semen. J. Dairy Sci. 72:1291-1295.

LASSO J.L. NOILES E.E. ALVAREZ J.G. AND STOREY B.T. 1994. Mechanism of superoxide dismutase loss from human sperm cells during cryopreservation. J. Androl. 15:255-265.

LEBOEUF B. RESTALL B. AND SALAMON S. 2000. Production and storage of goat semen for artificial insemination. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 62:113-141.

NEAGU V.R. GARCAA B. SANDOVAL M. RODRAGUEZ C.S. FERRUSOLA A.M. FERNANDEZ C.O. TAPIA L.G. AND PEAA F.J. 2010. Freezing dog semen in presence of the antioxidant butylated hydroxytoluene improves post- thaw sperm membrane integrity. Theriogenology 73:645-650.

RITAR A.J. AND SALAMON S.1983. Fertility of fresh and frozen-thawed semen of the Angora goat. Australian J. biol. Sci. 36:49-59.

ROCA J. GIL M.A. HERNANDEZ M. PARRILLA I. VAZQUEZ J.M. AND MARTINEZ E.A. 2004. Survival and fertility of boar spermatozoa after freeze thawing in extender supplemented with butylated hydroxytoluene. J. Androl. 25:397-405.

SHANNON P. AND VISHWANATH R. 1995. The effect of optimal and suboptimal concentrations of sperm on the fertility of fresh and frozen bovine semen and a theoretical model to explain the fertility differences. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 39:1-10.

SHOAE A. AND ZAMIRI M.J. 2008. Effect of butylated hydroxytoluene on bull spermatozoa frozen in egg yolk- citrate extender. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 104:414-418.

SMITH G.D. 2001. In vitro maturation of oocytes. Curr Womens Health. Rep. 1:143-151.

UYSAL O. BUCK M.N. YAVAS I. AND VARISLI O. 2007. Effect of various antioxidants on the quality of frozen thawed bull semen. J. Anim. Vet. Adv. 6:1362 1366.

WATSON P.F. AND ANDERSON W.J. 1983. Influence of butylated hydroxytoluene BHT on the viability of ram spermatozoa undergoing cold shock. J. Reprod. Fertil. 69:229-235.

WATSON P.F. 2000. The causes of reduced fertility with cryopreserved semen. Anim. Reprod. Sci. 60-61: 481-492.
COPYRIGHT 2015 Asianet-Pakistan
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2015 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:Pakistan Journal of Zoology
Article Type:Report
Date:Feb 28, 2015
Previous Article:Effects of Phytosterols on Growth Performance and Fat Metabolism in Broilers.
Next Article:Taphonomic Signatures on Some Intertidal Molluscan Shells from Tarut Bay (Arabian Gulf Saudi Arabia).

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters