The two articles featured in this issue are papers I doubt one would find in other journals. Since most academic journals require an ever narrower focus, it is rare to read pieces such as these that bring together a wide range of ideas, history, and disciplines to connect and integrate disparate paths of knowledge.
In "The Postmodern Critique of Liberal Education," Stephen R. C. Hicks of Rockford University integrates centuries of philosophic arguments about the nature and purpose of education. Hicks examines the long history of attacks on liberal education to demonstrate the philosophic roots of both pre- and postmodern criticisms. Hicks then identifies, clarifies, and challenges the postmodern critique of liberal education. Lastly, he looks to the future of liberal education.
Jason Kuznicki of the Cato Institute looks deep into human history to discover the roots of how we think about politics. Pulling from genetics, anthropology, ancient epic poetry, and the Bible, Kuznicki argues in "Politics as an Extension of the Harem" that gendered oppression, namely the subjugation of women and low-status men, is central to understanding the origins and development of political governance up through the contemporary era. This understanding, along with the increased inclusion of previously excluded groups, provides fuel for Kuznicki's speculations about the future of political governance.
The issues closes with a review essay of Erin Kelly's The Limits of Blame: Rethinking Punishment and Responsibility (Harvard University Press, 2018). This work takes on the justifications for harsh criminal punishments and mass incarceration. At the core of Kelly's argument is a challenge to the alignment of legal guilt and moral blameworthiness that she sees as central to retributivist's justifications. Alexandre Abitbol's review essay agrees with Kelly's call for a philosophical and humanistic reform of the criminal justice system. However, it is critical of Kelly's diagnosis that removes moral blame from the system.
Thanks for reading Reason Papers.
Shawn E. Klein
Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Klein, Shawn E.|
|Date:||Jun 22, 2019|
|Previous Article:||Sommers, Tamler. Why Honor Matters.|
|Next Article:||Symposium: Vicente Medina's Terrorism Unjustified: The Use and Misuse of Political Violence: Comments on Vicente Medina's Terrorism Unjustified.|