Printer Friendly

Commemorative okay?

Was wondering if any of you had ever actually fired a commemorative gun? Might they be dangerous, unreliable, inaccurate and short-lived? Would a pistol range allow you to shoot one? I've searched the Internet several ways and was unable to find any info. One guy on a forum said he was going to shoot one, but no result was posted. Maybe he can't write anymore?

I know about the resultant loss of value, don't need any words about that. In a last ditch situation could one of these pricey guns actually save your life? Could they fire a magazine full if you needed 'em to? I am kinda looking for a real world answer from somebody who actually tried it.

David Mehaffey

Via e-mail

Well, I can tell you the ones I've shot did fine. I don't have any safe queens, and everything I own gets fired if I can find ammo for it. I've had a couple of Colt 1911 commemoratives, a single action one, a Winchester Model 94 and a pair of Ruger Super Single Sixes (Colorado commemoratives?), and they all worked just fine. I wouldn't hesitate to shoot any of them. They are offered as real firearms so the quality needs to be there.

The biggest thing about the factory made "commemoratives " is they usually make too many of them to have any real value much beyond a standard model of the same gun, even though the initial selling price might be inflated a bit. The moral of the story is, if you like what you see, buy it, shoot it and enjoy it because you'll almost always NOT end up with a collector gun "sure to increase in value. " I'd venture to say if you check out a neighborhood gun shop chances are good you'll see various commemoratives gathering dust, with prices above a standard model. Once prices are lowered, they usually sell. But even then, it's a crapshoot. After all, you have to find someone who really likes the phony "engraving" you often find, cheap "genuine gold" (or chrome!) plating, shiny spray stock finishes and other do-dads that um ... uh ... sometimes remind me of a pimp-mobile.

Having said that, genuine, limited runs or editions, with high quality engraving, ivory or custom grips and obvious high quality often do, indeed, offer increased value. Shop www.gunbroker.com and/or use a value guide like the Blue Book of Gun Values and you'll see both ends of the spectrum. RH

COPYRIGHT 2010 Publishers' Development Corporation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2010 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:SPEAKOUT: YOUR FORUM TO PONTIFICATE, PONDER AND PROBE
Author:Mehaffey, David
Publication:American Handgunner
Article Type:Letter to the editor
Date:Jul 1, 2010
Words:413
Previous Article:Rat patrol.
Next Article:.44 special stuff.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters