Printer Friendly


Massenet's Manon, with which Lyric Opera of Chicago opened its 2008/09 season Sept. 27, is the Frenchest of French Operas. It is not a Greek tragedy, nor is it a theatrical exercise in the manner of Bertolt Brecht. Yet these elements more than intruded on the music in David McVicar's staging. Choristers, arranged in stadium-style tiers, commented on the action with multitudes of oohs, aahs and ha-has. In the most intimate scenes, involving only a few characters, extraneous supers peered around corners and fiddled with props for the principals, along the anti-illsionist lines of Brecht. McVicar's depiction of the Hotel de Transylvanie gambling scene as Hogarth's Bedlam was an interesting idea, but Lyri's printed program made an error in running a drawing that revealed that establishment to be extremely elegant.

As is customary with Lyric, musical matters were on a high plane. Natalie Dessay was in glorious form as Manon. Her voice was crystalline in tone and astonishingly accurate in execution in the past, but here a warmth and richness was newly added. Another improvement over past performing habits was dropping an excess of characterization for dramatic interest. Jonas Kaufmann's dark tenor is not a regulation des Grieux voice. His labored delivery on opening night may have been due to a lingering effect of the illness that prevented him from appearing are a pro-season Lyric concert. Raymond Aceto was impressive as the elder des Grieux, but Christopher Feigum's Cousin Lescaut was mostly small-toned. An outstanding supporting performance was from David Cangelosi, who avoided overdoing Guillot, singing well instead of cackling, convincing as both a foolish old man and a dangerous villain. Among the trio of courtesans, Andriana Chuchman carried the top line beautifully in a role that was among the first successes of another Canadian soprano, the young Teresa Stratas. Chuchman sounds as though she, too, is on the way to a bright career. Conductor Emmanuel Villaume paced the long score magnificently, drawing sumptuous sounds from Lyric's orchestra.
COPYRIGHT 2008 Opera Canada Publications
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2008 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Covello, Richard
Publication:Opera Canada
Date:Dec 1, 2008
Previous Article:War and Peace.
Next Article:Cooperstown.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters