Printer Friendly

Bullies in cyberspace: administrators may be reluctant to address this latest social problem--yet they may have no choice.

It began as a typical teenage scuffle: someone said something about someone's girlfriend, whose friends felt compelled to retaliate.

Overnight, administrators at the Hawaii Department of Education had a bigger problem than many thought possible from such an insignificant seed. Using Internet social sites like and cell phone text messaging, students blasted insults at each other from cyberspace and this sideline soap opera drama that soon enfolded students from both the Oahu and Big Island high schools cut into their ability to concentrate on classroom lessons and academic assignments the next day.

Officials turned to mediation from a private counseling group to refocus students back toward education. They then formed an ad hoc school board committee led by a lawyer to study what comes next.

"It clearly has an effect on the overall sense of safety at the school when there's this influence that creates anxiety and sometimes leads to actual physical confrontations," says Greg Knudsen, communications director for the Hawaii Department of Education.

The Definition

Other educators explain the phenomenon as cyberbullying. But it doesn't mean they have any better handle on what to do, or even how to pinpoint it. From Judy Bowers' perspective as head of guidance and counseling for the Tucson Unified School District 1 and past-president of the American School Counselor Association, cyberbullying is an ongoing intention to pick on someone using electronic means, as opposed to snide remarks.

The Center for Safe and Responsible Internet Use in Eugene, Ore., broadens the definition to include sending mean, vulgar or threatening messages or images; posting sensitive, private information about another person; pretending to be someone else to make that person look bad; and intentionally excluding someone from an online group. It goes on in e-mails, cell phone texts, Web pages, blogs and chat rooms, although students say using IM (Instant Message over e-mail) is the most popular method.

Alarmingly, 18 percent of students in grades 6 through 8 say they have been bullied in cyber space at least once in the last couple of months, points out Nancy Willard, executive director of CSRIU. In fact, 19 percent of regular Internet users between ages 10 percent and 17 report being involved in online aggression--15 percent were the bullies and 7 percent were targets. Three percent admitted they'd played both sides of the field. Girls were almost twice as likely as boys to be victims and perpetrators.

Justin W. Patchin, the assistant professor of criminal justice at the University of Wisconsin-Eau Claire's Department of Political Science, began studying online harassment in 2002. "We basically found that the more proficient a student is in computers, the more likely he will be a victim or offender of cyberbullying," he notes.

"It's absolutely going on in this school," says Robyn Jackson, a former assistant principal (now administrator on leave) at Thomas W. Pyle Middle School in Montgomery County Public Schools in Bethesda, Md. "I don't think we realize how much because it's taking place offsite." Yet she still deals with spillover hostility in classrooms and hallways regardless of where it started.

"It's not something we can monitor in schools. I can stop a kid from passing a note. I can't stop kids from IMing each other at 2 a.m. Yet the school is still seen as the authority," she describes. "So we've had to question when it becomes necessary for us to get involved and where to draw the line to say this is a home matter. And that's a really thin, fine line.

"It's very hard to tell where, and what, actually is our responsibility to do," Jackson confesses.

Legal Weigh-In

The legal standard for school intervention in off-campus speech is that there must be a substantial and material disruption--or threat of one--at school, according to Willard. The problem is that the standard has never been applied in a legal discussion involving harmful student-vs.-student off-campus speech, which leaves a gray area administrators fear. Federal court decisions like the 1998 ruling that determined a student's rights were violated after Westlake School District administrators in Cleveland suspended him for creating a Web site mocking a teacher don't help. It cost that district $30,000 in a court settlement and an apology to the student.

The American Civil Liberties Union defended a Pennsylvania high school student who created a similar work about his principal. And the district ended up paying lawyer fees.

Law enforcement isn't in a position to rescue districts, unless it's a clear and severe threat. Even then, the police are ill equipped to deal with cyber-crime--all but the largest of metropolitan forces usually lack the proper investigative tools and training, Patchin says. "Often times the police are inundated dealing with cyber-stalking and identity theft," he explains.

Washington and Florida legislators are trying to cook up some laws that give current harassment statutes more teeth to include cyberbullying, but the wheels are turning slowly.

"The cases I'm familiar with resulted in civil lawsuits by the victims' parents and most are resolved prior to trial," Patchin says. But while laws would be nice, he puts little faith in them to address the real problem. "It won't deter these kids--it will persuade administrators to develop a policy that takes cyberbullying into consideration," he adds. The real answer, he advocates, lies in schools stepping up to teach kids right from wrong online, not because they're legally on the hook, "The biggest problem is that nobody is willing to take ownership," he explains. "Parents don't know what's going on and aren't familiar with the technology. Administrators are nervous about lawsuits. So it's slipping through the cracks."

Social Skills

Meanwhile, cyber attacks have the potential to cause more harm than the in-your-face version, Willard contends. According to Bowers, acceptance is still the name of the game: bullies and their cohorts get sucked in because they don't feel good about themselves and want to impress cop leagues. They are detached from staring down the opponent, making the slings more vicious as technology spreads the poison farther.

"When you're physically bullied, you're safe at home. Online bullying goes on 24/7," she notes.

And anonymity means many students can't identify their attacker, leaving them distrustful of everyone.

The process certainly has matured since the mid-'80s when ninth-grader Mark Franek once used his dad's Apple computer to create an endless-loop printout of crass statements about a classmate in York, Penn. But he had to physically distribute the fliers along school halls. He was caught and suspended. Franek is now dean of students at the private, prestigious William Penn Charter School in Philadelphia, where he is on a mission to nip cyberbullying in the bud.

William Penn has an explicit academic use policy stating the consequences of violating Internet use rules on property or at home, "but to be honest with you, it hasn't been tested yet in the courts," he admits. Administrators here are relying on the Supreme Court case ruling that says a principal can edit a school newspaper without violating free speech rights if the material is deemed to be disruptive to school.

But they put their trust in communication. Administrators mention rules in large assemblies and remind parents in letters and memos. Technology classes include role-playing and group discussions to explore how actions impact emotions.

In Tucson Unified School Systems, the 173 school counselors Bowers supervises teach students the consequences of cyber-bullying. Ron Teixeira, the executive director of the Washington, D.C.-based National Cyber Security Alliance, wants educators to wrap cyber ethics, safety and security lessons into one.

Pyle Middle School in Maryland uses guidance counselors to train students in how to deal with bullies as a victim and bystander. Jackson uses the school television show for skits and announcements on the topic, and schedule outside experts to speak with students. She enlists parents to help write the curriculum for cyberbullying lessons. "By the time a child is bullied and brings it to school, we're in triage and repair-and often the damage is almost irreparable," she says.

"But we still have to deal with IT on the other end," she adds. When cyber-bullying is found, if the incident hasn't disrupted school, they call in parents of the alleged bully to suggest family resources and skip disciplinary action. However, if students can't focus on work because they're too engrossed chatting about the latest on, for instance, offenders face detention or suspension with counseling.

"So they're not just sitting in detention hall, but spending that time reading law surrounding what can and can't be posted on the Internet," Jackson explains. "Or coming up with alternatives to the behaviors" when they were IMing.

Hawaii's cyber-bullying committee has gingerly begun exploring its options, emphasizing how to beef up language in its regulations to expand bullying to cover technology's tentacles. Knudsen can't predict the result. "As far as writing more rules, I'm not sure they need to do that," he says. "It's legitimate to raise the issue of: Are we fully enforcing what we already have?"

What they can't do, colleagues agree, is hide their heads in the sand. "I don't think it's peaked," says Franek. "We've only begun to see the ramification and misuse of technology. We used to drag the phones in a closet to get away from Mom and Dad. Now kids can connect to the world any time and there's no going back. It's a dynamic all schools in the country will have to deal with every year.",

Proving Your Mettle

Experts like Ron Teixeira, executive director of the National Cyber Security Alliance, say it's crucial school officials teach students to seek adult help if they become entangled in cyberbullying.

If only it were that simple. "The worst example I saw was a child who videotaped herself engaged in self-gratifying sexual activities. She sent it to a guy seeking to entice him into a relationship, and he turned around and showed it to all his friends. So how do you got to your mother and say, 'I have this problem,'" asks Nancy Willard, author of Cyberbullying and Cyberthreats: Responding to the Challenge of Online Social Curelty, Threats and Distress.

With such personal issues on the line, children must believe the school has the power to stop cyber-bullying before they risk speaking up. Willard suggests these steps:

* Filters are mandatory, but never trust them

School should block student's access to chat rooms and inappropriate cyber hangouts from school computers. But today's students can bypass filters and run circles around barriers using cell phones and Blackberries.

* Make friends with Web service providers

Most sites have terms of use agreements that prohibit posting derogatory material, but they depend on complaints rather than a review process. School officials with direct relationships with companies garner faster cooperation in deleting offensive comments.

* Collect solid evidence

When someone complains, administrators need to gather the right information. Online communications leave a telltale trail. which IT staff and Internet service providers can help secure. but interviewing students peripherally involved is key.

* Get Mom on the phone

Willard encourages schools to notify parents in hopes they will better monitor their children's Internet use.

* Lower the boom

If policies indicate consequences for cyberbullying, enforce them.

Julie Sturgeon is a contributing editor.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Professional Media Group LLC
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:SCHOOL SECURITY
Author:Sturgeon, Julie
Publication:District Administration
Date:Sep 1, 2006
Previous Article:Roaming charges: wireless VoIP handsets are more expensive than their analog counterparts, but some districts find they're worth the cost.
Next Article:Scared straight: financial mismanaging, misspending, over budgeting, squandering, embezzling--by any verb, school districts are losing money they...

Related Articles
Bullying Alert!
Bullying among children.
Monster hype: how a few isolated tragedies-and their supposed causes-were turned into a national "epidemic". (Feature).
Camp: a perfect place to address bullying.
Pick on someone your own size! From the school yard to the boardroom, bullying never seems to go out of style. Luckily the antics of some...
Identification of school bullies by survey methods.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters