Brodalumab approval recommended, despite possible suicide signal.
A Food and Drug Administration advisory committee has unanimously supported approval of the monoclonal antibody brodalumab for the treatment of moderate to severe plaque psoriasis, with the majority recommending risk management options beyond labeling to address concerns about the six completed suicides among patients treated with brodalumab in clinical trials.
Though no members of the FDA's Dermatologic and Ophthalmic Drugs Advisory Committee disputed the drug's efficacy for plaque psoriasis, the possibility of a signal for suicidal ideation and behavior (SIB) among the brodalumab group prompted the committee's chair, Michael Bigby, MD, to remark, "The big problem is that you have six completed suicides.... I would say it's a fairly big number for a randomized controlled trial. Patients and clinicians need to be aware of this as a fact."
Dr. Bigby, professor of dermatology at FTarvard Medical School, Boston, headed the 18-member panel, which included dermatologists, psychiatrists, and cardiologists. Fourteen members voted in favor of approval with risk management measures beyond labeling; four members voted for approval with labeling alone.
Brodalumab targets interleukin-17 receptors, inhibiting IL-17 uptake and thus blocking the pathway responsible for the cutaneous and systemic signs and symptoms of psoriasis. The pivotal phase III brodalumab studies, AMAGINE-1, -2, and -3, enrolled a total of 4,373 patients with moderate to severe plaque psoriasis. AMAGINE-1 enrolled 661 patients in a 1:1:1 ratio to a randomized, double-blind placebo-controlled study that included two doses of brodalumab: 210 mg and 140 mg. The placebo-controlled phase of the study ran for 12 weeks, followed by a withdrawal and retreatment phase, and after 52 weeks, by an open label long-term extension phase.
AMAGINE-2 (1,831 patients) and AMAGINE-3 (1,881 patients) were identically designed studies that pitted both doses of brodalumab against an active comparator, ustekinumab (Stelara), as well as placebo, in a 2:2:1:1 ratio. This double-blind phase of the study also lasted 12 weeks. During weeks 12-52, patients on the brodalumab arms continued, with an exploration of wider-dose intervals for the 140-mg dose. Patients also continued with ustekinumab, with a rescue option to transition to brodalumab 210 mg. The placebo group could continue on brodalumab 210 mg as well. These two studies also had an open label long-term extension phase.
At the 12-week mark in AMAGINE-1, 41.9% of patients achieved the coprimary endpoint of 100% reduction in the Psoriasis Area and Severity Index (PASI 100) score, compared with 0.5% of those on placebo (P less than .001). AMAGINE-2 and -3 saw 44.4% and 36.7% of the brodalumab 210-mg arms achieving PASI 100 at the 12-week mark, respectively. These figures were significantly higher than the 21.7% and 18.5% reaching PASI 100 on ustekinumab (P less than .001), as well as significantly higher than the less than 1% of patients in the placebo arm who reached that endpoint.
At the end of 52 weeks, 51% of those on brodalumab 210 mg had completely clear skin, compared with 28.1% of the patients receiving ustekinumab (P less than .001).
The safety analysis for brodalumab showed that the most common adverse events were nasopharyngitis, upper respiratory tract infection, headache, and arthralgia; of these, the last two were considered adverse drug reactions. At 52 weeks, those on brodalumab had a slightly greater risk of having nonserious fungal infections than did those on ustekinumab. Overall, however, there was no difference between the brodalumab and ustekinumab arms at week 52 for treatment-emergent adverse events or for serious adverse events.
A cluster of SIB events occurred in 2013 and 2014 during the clinical trials, and the sponsor consulted the FDA. Additional monitoring for suicidal ideation and depression via the Columbia Suicide Severity Rating Scale (C-SSRS) and the Patient Health Questionnaire were implemented at a point where 84% of trial patients were already in the uncontrolled open label extension stage of the trial; in addition, a retrospective data review searched for suicidal ideation and attempts before the implementation of these two tools.
A total of six brodalumab patients completed suicide in all clinical trials, including those for psoriatic arthritis and RA. Suicides included two during the 12--to 52-week follow-up and four during the long-term follow-up phase. Another 29 patients attempted suicide, had intentional self-injury, or had suicidal ideation during these phases of the study, for a total of 35 SIB events. (SIB includes completed suicide, suicide attempt, suicide behavior, and suicide ideation.)
The significance of the number of completed suicides was difficult to ascertain, given the increased baseline prevalence of depression and related illnesses among patients with psoriasis. Compared with the general population, individuals with psoriasis have hazard ratios of 1.39, 1.31, and 1.44 for depression, anxiety, and suicidality, according to a cohort study cited by Robert Levin, MD, director of the division of pharmacovigilance 1 at the FDA's Center for Drug Evaluation and Research.
In addition, monitoring for suicidal ideation and attempts was stepped up during the course of the clinical trials. Brodalumab's sponsor, Valeant Pharmaceuticals, noted that the rates of suicidal ideation and attempts increased after implementation of the C-SSRS, while other neuropsychiatric symptoms remained stable or declined during the course of the studies. "This makes us think this is ascertainment bias," said Valeant consultant Lauren Marangell, MD, a psychiatrist and president of Brain Health Consultants.
Dr. Marangell also reported that, after stratification for preexisting psychiatric comorbidities and risk factors, "there is no question that the rate of SIB is higher in both arms with patients with baseline risk factors." The FDA's data analysis showed an 18-fold increase in the rate of SIB for brodalumab arm participants with a prior history of suicidality.
During its presentation, Valeant also pointed out that patients with histories of drug and alcohol abuse, depression, and suicidality were not specifically excluded from the clinical trials. This differentiates the brodalumab program from other biologic studies, "making the studies more characteristic of the real world," said R.K. Pillai, PhD, Valeant vice president.
Dr. Levin's analysis, one of several independent analyses conducted by different FDA divisions, found that the data were inconclusive. "We currently can't conclude whether or not these are drug-related risks," he said. Considering the critical severity of suicide as an outcome, "we must consider the application and regulatory actions carefully."
Jean Kim, MD, medical officer in CDER's division of psychiatry products (DPP), noted that the number of suicides seen in the brodalumab trials "is higher than typically seen in DPP's large psychiatric drug trials, which involve populations with higher psychiatric morbidity than patients with psoriasis."
Patients with psoriasis are also known to have a baseline elevated risk of cardiovascular disease, and no committee member felt the brodalumab data showed any additional signal for major adverse cardiovascular events (MACE) beyond what would be suspected in this population. "I don't right now see a safety signal for MACE," said panelist Michael Blaha, MD, a cardiologist and director of clinical research at Johns Hopkins Ciccarone
Center for Prevention of Heart Disease, Baltimore. He noted, however, that research is ongoing to elucidate the relationship between cytokine levels and MACE. "This question about whether cytokines raise or reduce rates for [cardiovascular] events is an open one."
One of the dermatologists on the committee, Lynn Drake, MD, said that her decision-making was influenced by the disease burden psoriasis inflicts on the patients she sees in her daily practice. "These patients are ill. People tend to think it's just skin disease. It is not just skin disease.... I'd hate to see our patients deprived of a drug that might help alleviate their symptoms," said Dr. Drake.
Though committee members voiced some disagreement about whether a patient registry should be established, and if it should be voluntary, they were in agreement that patients and prescribers both be aware of the potential risks of brodalumab, without making any risk management strategy so burdensome that appropriate patients would be deterred from considering the medication. Psoriasis, Dr. Drake said, "is a devastating disease. We need this in our armamentarium."
The proposed dosing for brodalumab is 210 mg injected subcutaneously weekly for 3 weeks, followed by 210 mg every 2 weeks thereafter.
The FDA usually follows the recommendations of its advisory committees. The panelists had no relevant financial disclosures.
Commentary by Dr. Kerdel:
In the clinical studies, brodalumab proved to be a high-end drug, with highly significant responses in treated patients. The problem obviously was with suicide and suicidal ideation, which was higher among treated patients than in control groups.
We have to understand that patients with psoriasis, like many patients with chronic illnesses, have a high prevalence of suicidal ideation, and indeed, even suicide. And if we are going to prescribe brodalumab, which will likely get approved, this should be considered--excluding patients who may be at greater risk of suicide.
Whether what we see here is suicide within the general scope of a chronic illness, versus an actual effect of the drug, remains to be seen.
But based on the currently available data, what will likely happen when brodalumab is approved and we consider using it to treat patients, is that we will be asked to ascertain whether the patient has had any suicidal thoughts or suicidal ideation in the past, or attempted suicide, and for such patients, we may not use this particular agent.
On Twitter @karioakes
Caption: DR. BIGBY
Please note: Illustration(s) are not available due to copyright restrictions.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Date:||Nov 1, 2016|
|Previous Article:||Secukinumab shows sustained high efficacy in SCULPTURE through 3 years.|
|Next Article:||Benefits, challenges emerge in evolution of rheumatology-dermatology clinics.|