Printer Friendly

Bio-active constituents of rotenoids resin extracted from Derris elliptica roots: comparison between local plant extract and SAPHYR (France) cube resin.


Derris elliptica or 'Tuba' as it is known locally is an insecticidal plant in Malaysia that has been used for the purpose of bio-pesticide production. 'Tuba' plant is a kind of woody creeper plant and climber. It needs at least 75% soil moisture content and the surround temperature should be in between 25 to 30[degrees]C to obtain high content of the rotenone during its development. A calm area with low acidity soil content will enhance the production of rotenone [1]. 'Tuba' is a member of the Leguminosae and Fabaceae family which comprises 200 genera and 68 species including 21 species of Tephrosia, 12 of Derris, 12 of Lonchocarpus, 10 of Millettia and several of Mundula [2]. Three species are found in Malaysia, which are Derris elliptica, Derris malaccensis and Derris uliginosa. Derris is a climbing plant in Southeast Asia and its roots contain rotenone, a strong insecticide [3]. Derris elliptica and Derris malaccensis contain approximately 4 to 5% (w/w) rotenone while Lonchocarpus utilis and Lonchocarpus urucu contain 8 to 10% (w/w) rotenone in dry roots [4]. Rotenone has been found to be used in many applications besides as insecticide. In addition to its effectiveness for both piercing-sucking insects, such as aphids and red bugs and chewing insects, especially caterpillars upon plants, it makes excellent dusts for external parasites of animals such as fleas and lice. The side effect of rotenone to aquatic animals is minimal [5]. The toxic principles all deteriorate rapidly into dihydrorotenone (non-toxic substance) and water when exposed to sunlight and air; spray and dusts usually lose their effectiveness within a week after application [6]. The outstanding advantages of this group of poisons are that they are harmless to plants (phyto-toxic), relatively non-toxic to man and act as both contact and stomach poisons to insects [2]. Even though it has several outstanding properties, there is one problem has not yet been resolved up to now. A variety of its active ingredients with respect to different kinds of species have been a major problem ever since. In this paper our goal is to examine the rotenone content in the extract of local Derris species and to compare it with the commercially available rotenone resin cube extracted from the Amazonian Derris species. The aim of this work is to also to produce a standard bio-active constituent profile of rotenone extract from Derris plant species available in Malaysia.


Plant collection:

Derris elliptica roots were collected in the state of Johor; Kota Johor Lama, Malaysia.

Raw material preparation:

An important aspect of the phytochemical processing is the pre-processing of the herbal material prior to extraction. The treatment of the herbal material affects the viability of the phytochemical as well as the extraction yield. The freshly procured Derris roots had to immediately undergo the cleaning process to remove dirt and soil. The roots were kept and dried in an oven overnight at 30 [+ or -] 2[degrees]C and sorted to collect only the roots and stems. The roots and stems were cut into small pieces using knife mill prior to grinding.

Rotenoids cube resin:

The commercial grade of dried rotenoids cube resin was obtained from SAPHYR (France) with the purity of 50% (w/w). The sample was believed to be extracted from the Amazonian native species of Lonchocarpus nicou and Lonchocarpus urucu dried roots. The cube resin was later dissolved in acetonitrile to a concentration of 0.22 mg/ml prior to the analysis. The molecular structure of essential bio-active constituents available in the extract and SAPHYR (France) cube resin are shown in Figure 1.

Extraction process:

The extraction was carried out by soaking 30 g of dried roots and stems in 300 ml of solvent; acetone, 95% (v/v) for 24 hrs at 30 [+ or -] 2[degrees]C. The liquid crude extract (LCE) was then filtered using Whatman filter paper No. 4 with the aid of Altech filter GAST laboratory diaphragm vacuum pump at 300 mbar.

Analysis of liquid crude extract and rotenoidscube resin:

The liquid crude extract and SAPHYR (France) rotenoids cube resin were subjected to a quantitative analysis using reverse-phase high performance liquid chromatography (RP-HPLC) to determine the yield of rotenone and other toxic constituents. The ultra violet (UV) photodiode array (PDA) detection was used at a wavelength of 294 nm. The analysis of the extract solutions was carried out using an internal standard method (curcumin, analytical grade, 97% (w/w)--SIGMA-Aldrich[TM] as an internal standard solution) [9]. The operational parameters are shown in Table 1. A C-18 Waters[TM] Corp. liquid chromatography stainless steel column with particle size of 10 [micro]m (3.9 mm internal diameter x 150 mm length), analytical grade of rotenone standard with known purity (PESTANAL[R], analytical grade, 96.2% (w/w); SIGMA-Aldrich[TM]), analytical grade of acetonitrile; 99.9% (v/v) and deionized water (DOW) were utilized in the analysis. The mobile phase system was prepared by diluting 3000 ml of acetonitrile into 2000 ml of deionized water (60:40) and filtered through a cellulose nitrate membrane filter (0.45 [micro]m pore size filter) to remove impurities and fine dirt [7].

Preparations of standard solutions:

To prepare an internal standard solution, about 0.035 [+ or -] 0.01 g of curcumin standard was dissolved in acetonitrile, making up to a volume of 50 ml of glass-stoppered conical flask. As for rotenone standard solution, about 0.0137 [+ or -] 0.01 g of rotenone standard was dissolved in acetonitrile, making up to a volume of 50 ml of glass-stoppered conical flask. Rotenone calibration solution: 10 ml of internal standard solution was added into 10 ml of rotenone standard solution using pipette. The mixture was homogenized using a laboratory shaker to produce a well dissolved solution.

Sample solution preparation and analysis:

To prepare a sample stock solution, 2 ml of the liquid crude extract (LCE) containing unknown rotenone concentration was transferred into a 50 ml glass-stoppered conical flask. By using the same pipette used for the calibration solution, 2 ml of the internal standard solution was mixed and diluted to 100 ml in other volumetric flask. Meanwhile, to start up the analysis, the prepared mobile phase which is a mixture of acetonitrile and water (60:40) was allowed to go through into the column overnight until the system is equilibrated (flat baseline). 5 [micro]l of the calibration solution and sample solution was injected into the system. Repetitive injections of both solutions were carried out to achieve stable responses that agree with 1% of the rotenone peak area (or height) to the internal standard peak area (or height) ratio. Additionally, the peak area (or height) ratio for the sample solution must not differ by more than 10% from the peak area (or height) ratio for the calibration solution. Equation 1 shows the formula of calculating the content (mg) and concentration (mg/ml) of rotenone via internal standard method.

[A.sub.x]/[[sub.x]] = F ([A.sub.IS]/[[sub.IS]]) (1)


[A.sub.x] = Peak area of analyte x; [[sub.x]] = Concentration of analyte x; F = Response factor; [A.sub.IS] = Peak area of internal standard and [[sub.IS]] = Concentration of internal standard.

Statistical analysis:

Data is presented as mean [+ or -] standard deviation (sd) of mean. Statistical comparisons were performed using Students t-test (PASW version 17.0 IBM Co.). A p < 0.05 was considered statistically significant.


Figure 2, 3 and 4 show chromatogram of SAPHYR (France) rotenoids cube resin and sample solution using an internal standard (IS) solution of curcumin. The area under the curve of each peak (chromatogram) is proportional to the concentration of each standard solution used and injected into the column. However, if the external standard is implemented, the sensitivity of the RP-HPLC detector in identifying the specific bio-active constituents (rotenone) could generally be compromised with different responses to each standard component used. For that reason, an internal standard method was carried out to determine the concentration of rotenone in the liquid crude extract of Derris elliptica and to compare the bio-active constituent profile with the commercially available rotenoids cube resin manufactured by SAPHYR (France). However, the SAPHYR's rotenoids cube resin had to be analyzed to verify the availability of rotenone and other constituents as a certificate of analysis (COA) of the given product was not included and disclosed.

Rotenone calibration solution:

The concentration of rotenone standard comprising theoretical amount of tephrosin and deguelin was prepared as follows: 0.0137 g/50 ml x 96.2% (rotenone purity) = 0.26 mg/ml rotenone, purity tephrosin [congruent to] 1.5% (w/w): (0.015 x 0.0137 g)/50 ml = 0.004 mg/ml tephrosin and purity deguelin; [congruent to] 0.5% (w/w) = (0.0005 x 0.0137 g)/50 ml = 0.00014 mg/ml (deguelin). The assumed approximate purity of tephrosin and deguelin was based on the data acquisition of the rotenone standard (Fig. 2). Meanwhile, the prepared internal standard concentration of curcumin can be calculated based on the observed prominent peak chromatogram (Fig. 2): 0.035 g/50 ml x 97% (purity) = 0.68 mg/ml curcumin. As the respective bio-active constituent concentration was determined, the response factors (F) were calculated with respect to its respective area under the curve (Fig. 2). Equation 1 was used to calculate the F value and is presented in Table 2. All respective peaks show different profiling responses (e.g., area under the curve and retention time) and can be distinguished accordingly (p < 0.05). Rotenone produced the highest peak area under the curve as compared to tephrosin (p < 0.05). However, deguelin was undetected due to its minute amount in the standard solution and low sensitivity of the detector used.

Sample solution:

To determine the unknown concentration of rotenone and tephrosin (analyte x and y), 2 ml of internal standard solution (0.68 mg/ml) was added to another 2 ml of unknown solution. The mixed solution was diluted to 100 ml in volumetric flask. As predicted, the analysis of the mixture showed in similar retention time (p > 0.05) with diverse peak area under the curves of rotenone, tephrosin and curcumin (p < 0.05). The bio-active constituent profiles of the analyzed sample solutions available inside the LCE are shown in Figure 2 and Table 3. The availability of the bio-active constituents especially rotenone was quite consistent with the findings from the previous reports [10,11]. Finally, the yield of all constituents available inside the sample solution (LCE) was calculated based on the area under the curves obtained (Table 4). The yield of rotenone in dried roots was slightly higher than the previous reported study (1.14% (w/w)) (p < 0.05) [13]. In addition, the sample solution profile was compared with the commercially available rotenoids cube resin manufactured by SAPHYR (France) (Fig. 3). Comparable peaks retention time was presented in Figure 4. Both solutions presented the same pattern and this result confirmed the existence of rotenone in the liquid crude extract [9,12].


The results showed that rotenone extracted from local plant species was comparable to the standard analytical grade purchased from SIGMA-Aldrich[TM]. It was also identical to the commercial grade rotenoids cube resin given by SAPHYR (France). Based on the chromatogram in Figure 3, besides rotenone (6), the liquid crude extract consisted of other insecticidal compounds which were tephrosin (5) and deguelin (7). These compounds are essential for the insecticidal action against the Lepidopteron insect pest of cabbage (Spodoptera litura). Furthermore, the analysis method used in this work was based on the AOAC official method. However, several parameters were adjusted in order to achieve high accuracy in identifying bio-active constituents. Moreover, the internal standard method used was considered the most reliable and accurate analysis method employed as compared to the external standard method. This method not only has all the advantages of the external standard method but it also compensates for variations in injection volume and for small changes in detector sensitivity or chromatographic changes that might have occurred. Because we do not need to inject exactly the same amount each time, this method generally has better precision than the use of an external standard. On top of that, ultra clean apparatus, equipment and chemical should also be given due consideration in order to obtain the optimum result of separation.


Article history:

Received 14 January 2014

Received in revised form 19

April 2014

Accepted 23 April 2014

Available online 5 May 2014


The authors wish to acknowledge the kind assistance of the following individual, En. Khairul Annuar Ramli from Institute of Bioproduct Development (IBD), Universiti Teknologi Malaysia (UTM). This research was supported by an IRPA grant 09-02-06-0083 EA261 under the Ministry of Science, Technology and Environment, Malaysia (MOSTE).


[1] Grinda, F. and J. Gueyne, 1986. Extraction of insecticides from plants. USPTO PATENT FULL-TEXT AND IMAGE DATABASE, SAPHYR S.A.R.L. (France) (U.S Patent: 4,698,222).

[2] John, R.A. and R.K. Ron, 1944. INSECT CONTROL. Jour. Econ. Ento. 37: 400-408.

[3] Gaby, S., 1986. Natural Crop Protection in the Tropics--DERRIS: Derris elliptica, D. Malaccensis, D. uliginosa. Margraf Publishers GmbH Scientific Books. Weikersheim.

[4] Kole, R.K., C. Satpathi, A. Chowdhury and M.R. Ghosh. 1992. Isolation of amorphalone, a potent rotenoid insecticide from Tephrosia candida. J. Agri. Food Chem. 40: 1208-1210.

[5] Dev, S. and O. Koul, 1997. Insecticides of natural origin. CRC Press, Florida.

[6] Schnick, R.A., 1974. Review of the literature on the use of rotenone in fisheries. FWS-LR-74/15, NTIS Conc. No. PB-235 454/6, Bureau of Sport Fisheries and Wildlife, La Crosse, Wis. Fish Control Lab 7423: 130.

[7] Rodney, B. and H. Alan, 1976. Determination of rotenone in pesticide formulations and the separations of six rotenoids by reversed-phase high performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Chromatography. 134: 210-215.

[8] Kidd, H. and D.R. James, 1991. The agrochemicals handbook, 3rd Edn. Royal Society of Chemistry Information Services, Cambridge, United Kingdom.

[9] Ralph, I. and L. Ronald, 1976. Separation of rotenoids by high performance liquid chromatography. Journal of Chromatography. 134: 207-209.

[10] Zubairi S.I., M.R. Sarmidi and R.A. Aziz, 2014. Identification of bio-active constituents from Derris elliptica liquid crude extract using vacuum liquid chromatography. Adv. Environ. Biol. 8 (2): 437-440.

[11] Zubairi S.I., M.R. Sarmidi and R.A. Aziz, 2014. Precipitation of rotenoids resin extracted from Derris elliptica roots by means of clarifying agents. Adv. Environ. Biol. 8 (2): 441-444.

[12] AOAC Official Method 983.06, 2000. Rotenone in Pesticide Formulations. Liquid Chromatographic Method. First Action 1983 and Final Action 1991. AOAC OFFICIAL METHOD OF ANALYSIS.

[13] Zubairi S.I., M.R. Sarmidi and R.A. Aziz, 2014. A study of rotenone from Derris roots of varies location, plant parts and types of solvent used. Adv. Environ. Biol. 8 (2): 445-449.

(1) Saiful Irwan Zubairi, (2) Mohamad Roji Sarmidi and (2) Ramlan Abdul Aziz

(1) School of Chemical Sciences and Food Technology, Faculty of Science and Technology, The National University of Malaysia, 43600 UKM Bangi, Malaysia

(2) Institute of Bioproduct Development, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia, 81310 UTM Skudai, Malaysia

Corresponding Author: Saiful Irwan Zubairi, School of Chemical Sciences & Food Technology, Faculty of Science & Technology, The National University of Malaysia, 43600 UKM Bangi, Malaysia.

Phone: +603-89215989; E-mail:

Table 1: Operational parameters of an isocratic
solvent system RP-HPLC.

Column temperature     Ambient (30 [+ or -] 2[degrees]C)

Flow rate              0.7 ml/min
Wavelength (lambda])   294 nm
Injection volume       5 [micro]l
Retention times (t):
a) Rotenone            3.55 min - 3.60 min
b) Internal standard   2.87 min - 3.00 min

Table 2: Bio-active constituent profiles of
analyzed standard solutions.

# Calibration     Concentration   Peak area
solution          (mg/ml)         (mV * s)

Rotenone          0.26            8445.57 [+ or -] 230 ([PSI])
Tephrosin         0.004           1111.83 [+ or -] 120
Deguelin          0.00014         Undetectable
Internal          0.68            10583.18 [+ or -] 173
  standard (IS)

# Calibration     Response
solution          factor (F)

Rotenone          2.08 [+ or -] 0.52
Tephrosin         17.86 [+ or -] 1.22
Deguelin          Not determined
Internal          Not applicable
  standard (IS)

# Results shown are means ([+ or -] sd) of 3 injection/sample
(n = 3). ([PSI]) p < 0.05 compared to the other compounds.

Table 3: Bio-active constituent profiles of
analyzed sample solutions.

# Sample          * Concentration      Peak area (mV * s)
solution          (mg/ml)

Rotenone (x)      (a) 1.95 [+ or -]    9174.95 [+ or -]
                    0.52 ([PSI])         112 ([PSI])
Tephrosin (y)     0.03 [+ or -] 0.01   622.95 [+ or -] 233
Internal          (b) 0.014            1553.47 [+ or -] 120
  standard (IS)

(a) Rotenone concentration (based on Equation 1): 9174.95/[[sub.x]]
= 2.08 (1553.47/0.0136); [[sub.x]] = 0.039 mg/ml. Thus, the corrected
rotenone concentration using dilution factor: 0.039 mg/ml x
(100 ml/2 ml) = 1.95 ml. (b) Concentration of (IS) in the unknown
solution is therefore: C (IS) = 1.36 mg/100 ml = 0.0136 mg/ml.
# Results shown are means ([+ or -] sd) of 3 injection/sample (n = 3).
([PSI]) p < 0.05 compared to the other compounds.

Table 4: Yield of bio-active constituents available
inside Derris liquid crude extract.

Sample           (a) Yield (mg)        (b) % Yield (w/w)

Rotenone         140.4 [+ or -] 0.02   1.40 [+ or -] 0.02
Tephrosin        1.44 [+ or -] 0.01    0.014 [+ or -] 0.01
(c) Rotenoids    2,070 [+ or -] 0.05   20.70 [+ or -] 0.04
(d) Other        7,780 [+ or -] 0.03   77.84 [+ or -] 0.05

(a) Yield of rotenone (mg) = C (sample) x volume of liquid crude
extract (ml). (b) Yield of rotenone in dried roots (%) = Yield of
rotenone (mg)/weight of dried roots x 100%. Density of LCE:
0.98 [+ or -] 0.02 g/ml. Acetone density: 0.791 g/ml. Density of
rotenoids resin: 0.82 - 0.791 = 0.03 g/ml. Total volume of
LCE: 70.56 [+ or -] 0.5 ml. 'Theoretical rotenoids resin
available inside the LCE = 0.03 x 70.56 ml = 2.07 g. (d) 10 g
of dried roots consist of dried bark, stem, lipid and wax
(exclude active ingredients and resin).

Fig. 2: Chromatogram of sample solution [rotenone
crude extract (x) + internal and standard  (IS)]
calibration solution [rotenone standard solution
+ internal standard solution (IS)].

Number of peak      Name of analyte

3                       Acetone
4                Internal Standard (IS)
5                      Tephrosin
6                       Rotenone
7                      Denguelin

Note: Table made from line graph.

Fig. 3: Chromatogram of SAPHYR (France) rotenoids cube resin
([C.sub.cube] = 0.22 mg/ml).

Number of peak      Name of analyte

3                      Tephrosin
4                       Rotenone
5                      Denguelin

Note: Table made from line graph.

Fig. 4: Comparison between SAPHYR (France) rotenoids cube resin
and sample solution.

Number of peak      Name of analyte

3                       Acetone
4                Internal Standard (IS)
5                      Tephrosin
6                       Rotenone
7                      Denguelin

Note: Table made from line graph.
COPYRIGHT 2014 American-Eurasian Network for Scientific Information
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2014 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Zubairi, Saiful Irwan; Sarmidi, Mohamad Roji; Aziz, Ramlan Abdul
Publication:Advances in Environmental Biology
Article Type:Author abstract
Geographic Code:4EUFR
Date:Feb 14, 2014
Previous Article:Biological properties of Algerian Cyclamen africanum extracts.
Next Article:A preliminary study of rotenone exhaustive extraction kinetic from Derris elliptica dried roots using normal soaking extraction (NSE) method.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2020 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters