I was glad to see the article ("Microbe swaps arsenic for key ingredient of life," SN.. 1/1/11, p. 5) on arsenic incorporation by microbes. The news media implied that the arsenic incorporation was natural.
In the 1970s, Richard L. Raymond Sr. started an industry using bacteria present well below the ground surface (where there's an absence of light) to degrade hydrocarbon contamination. The hydrocarbons are the electron donors and energy source for the microbes. Over the years, we have learned to use chlorinated solvents as the electron acceptors. Oxygen, nitrate and sulfate all play roles in the process. The use of microbes for soil and groundwater remediation is now a large industry.
Bob Norris, Longmont, Colo.
When tales of the arsenic-consuming bacteria from Mono Lake first appeared in the news, it was indeed a big deal, oversetting all our experience with biochemistry. I was just itching to know how the organism GFAJ-1 managed to do the metabolism. But no such luck; the news coverage just degenerated into shrill accusations, devoid of scientific details. Thank you for reporting the science behind the discovery. You have kept alive my faith in Science News.
Tom Kimmel, Tucson, Ariz.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Norris, Bob; Kimmel, Tom|
|Article Type:||Letter to the editor|
|Date:||Apr 9, 2011|
|Previous Article:||Water at the start, and later.|
|Next Article:||Japan crisis may have little effect on U.S. energy policy.|