Printer Friendly

Are increasing student loan debt levels burdening graduates?

1. Introduction

Student loan debt is problematic to eliminate in bankruptcy. While most student loan debt was issued (Popescu and Ciurlau, 2017) or is insured by the federal government, a substantial portion is as private student loans. Pricing on them is reminiscent of credit cards. For undergraduate students particularly, such loans frequently necessitate a co-borrower who is legally constrained to reimburse if the student borrower does not. (Alexandrov and Jimenez, 2017)

2. The Student Loan Debt Crisis

Bankruptcy Abuse Prevention and Consumer Protection Act (BAPCPA) did not impact considerably the cost of loans for the lowest credit score persons in relation to ones with superior credit scores: students became incapable to discharge their loans in bankruptcy (Nica et al., 2016), without undergoing an adjusting drop in price. There is no rise in loan volumes or alteration in prices. The cost elasticity of request for student loans is not notably distinct from zero. The modification in originations cannot be attributed to a price effect. BAPCPA was not quite beneficial to students, as the latter lost the capacity to discharge their private student loans, without getting any discount in return. (Alexandrov and Jimenez, 2017)

Most students aim to pursue instruction completely, but should obtain loans or try to find other subsidization to cover schooling, fees, and living costs. Student loans denote that knowledge has its price: nondischargeable student debt. Individuals utilize grants, work-study opportunities, financial aids, tax advantages, and household or personal money to assist in financing college expenses (Lazaroiu, 2015a, b, c), but loans commonly constitute a considerable share of university funding. Student loans are either federal/public student ones or private student ones made by private third party (e.g. a bank or university). The law penalizes students by hampering them from pursuing a college degree and financing their future. Regarding student debt as nonconsumer one for particular unlucky and trustworthy postgraduate debtors may enable the bankruptcy system to stabilize the concern of the prospects of the students (Radulescu, 2013) with possible misapplications in the system. (Johnson, 2016)

University loans are the most fashionable approach for individuals to meet the expense of their college degrees, but debtors persist in endeavoring to have their student loan debt (Lazaroiu, 2013, 2017) discharged in bankruptcy. Besides its non-dischargeability, student loan debt may inflict various hindrances on borrowers, contingent upon whether the debt contract (Pera, 2014a, b, c, d) is for federally or privately financed student loans. Although neither federal nor private student loan debt (Popescu, 2015) is dischargeable in bankruptcy, their long-term consequences on debtors may be distinct. Debtors remain absolutely doubtful and vulnerable for what may be subsequent (Mihaila, 2017) to their unpaid student loan debt in bankruptcy. Federal student loans should persist non-dischargeable in bankruptcy as a result of their condition as public debts, as they belong to the section of government resources, and since the U.S. Department of Education has designed numerous substitute manners for borrowers to reimburse their loans. (Keller, 2017)

3. Students as Permanent Debtors

Private Student Loan (PSL) issuers may cost differentiate among individuals as concerns diverse aspects (e.g. credit score and school), and have no grounds to cross-finance a priori risky individuals by imposing a priori safer students higher rates. BAPCPA should not have had any consequence for the a priori safer individuals with low likelihoods of resulting in bankruptcy before reimbursing their student loans (Nica, 2016): the loan issuers should have envisaged that such borrowers presented practically no bankruptcy risk (Popescu et al., 2016) even before BAPCPA became operable. Risky individuals received almost no savings from the decrease in bankruptcy barriers that BAPCPA generated. The latter was unsuccessful in diminishing prices (Nica, 2017a, b, c) and admitting it had, it is questionable that more individuals would have decided on attending higher education. (Alexandrov and Jimenez, 2017)

The sharp increase in student loans highlights the demand for admitting student loans to be categorized as nonconsumer debt in particular cases. While some institutions of higher education have been raising expenses, numerous jurisdictions have been substantially reducing their financing of higher education lately, compelling many colleges to compensate lost earnings by boosting prices. A forward-looking demand for college instruction (Mircica, 2011a, b) has brought about escalating prices, influencing students to obtain more loans. The student loan rise may also be associated with access to credit. Private loans are advertised via many banks and universities, frequently with superior interest rates (Popescu, 2017a, b, c) than public loans where public choices are not achievable or reach the limit. (Johnson, 2016)

There are some federal student loan repayment proposals and deferral choices that enable the government to cooperate with each separate borrower and supply a scheme or system of reimbursement that they may pay for monthly. Making private loans dischargeable may motivate private lenders to be more rigorous regarding their qualification demands (Mihaila et al., 2016) and should significantly diminish the quantity of loans private lenders may grant, learning that their loans are dischargeable. While the quantity of prominent student loan debt has been noticeably boosting lately, the undeniable issue numerous debtors confront (Pera, 2015 a, b) in attempting to reimburse their student loan debt is the accumulation of interest (Nica and Mirica (Dumitrescu), 2017) at high rates. (Keller, 2017)

4. Student Loans' Presumptive Non-Dischargeability in Bankruptcy

As the BAPCPA applied subsequently to PSLs that were initiated before the law became operative but had not yet been entirely reimbursed, the law also generated a payout for holders of prominent PSLs initiated before BAPCPA, and a comparable deficit to the borrowers who unexpectedly lost the opportunity of discharging the loans. The latter, initiated at a moment when PSLs were certainly dischargeable in bankruptcy, apparently comprised within their cost a superior risk premium (Nica and Potcovaru, 2015) to reimburse lenders for the unrestricted convenience of the bankruptcy discharge. Pre-BAPCPA, borrowers most probably had to cover the cost of this premium. After bankruptcy reform became operative, all PSLs became similarly problematic to discharge in bankruptcy. After BAPCPA, a default on a student loan debt may not have the same consequence as a default on other kinds of debts. The student loan debt is more outstanding as the receiver is incapable to discharge it in bankruptcy. (Alexandrov and Jimenez, 2017)

The employment of skewed facts-and-circumstances assessments in detecting excessive difficulties (Mihaila, 2016a, b) generates dissimilar outcomes for debtors endeavoring to circumvent their oppressive debts in bankruptcy. Congress's addition of student loan debt as a non-dischargeable one entails a disbelief of students collectively. Congress should supply more explicit and neutral criteria by which debtors participating in the surprising changes of bankruptcy filings may require some kind of coherence regarding discharge and treatment. (Keller, 2017) (Figures 1 and 2)

5. Conclusions

Bankruptcy reform did not bring about low credit-score individuals at four-year colleges reimbursing less for PSLs, although such loans were seemingly nondischargeable. BAPCPA was a pay supplement concerning PSLs initiated before it was established, as the borrowers were assessed for creditworthiness (Popescu Ljungholm, 2016a, b) and received their loans when they apparently comprised a supplementary expense being dischargeable in bankruptcy. The pay supplement might have wound down there if individuals had obtained some of the advantage (Mircica, 2012, 2014) of the law modification in reduced prices. Losing the capacity to discharge loans in bankruptcy constituted a clear loss for individuals, even after considering market reaction by the lenders. (Alexandrov and Jimenez, 2017)

doi: 10.22381/JSME5220175


Alexandrov, Alexei, and Dalie Jimenez (2017). "Lessons from Bankruptcy Reform in the Private Student Loan Market," Harvard Law & Policy Review 11: 176-233.

Johnson, Matthew R. (2016). "Punishing Our Professionals: Why Student Loans Should Be Non-Consumer Debt," Transactions: The Tennessee Journal of Business Law 18: 235-271.

Keller, Rebekah (2017). "The 'Undue Hardship' Test: The Dangers of a Subjective Test in Determining the Dischargeability of Student Loan Debt in Bankruptcy," Missouri Law Review 82(1): 211-239.

Lazaroiu, George (2013). "Besley on Foucault's Discourse of Education," Educational Philosophy and Theory 45(8): 821-832.

Lazaroiu, George (2015a). "Employee Motivation and Job Performance," Linguistic and Philosophical Investigations 14: 97-102.

Lazaroiu, George (2015b). "Work Motivation and Organizational Behavior," Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice 7(2): 66-75.

Lazaroiu, George (2015 c). "The Role of the Management Consultancy Industry in the Knowledge Economy," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 3(2): 71-76.

Lazaroiu, George (2017). "The Routine Fabric of Understandable and Contemptible Lies," Educational Philosophy and Theory 49(6): 573-574.

Mihaila, Ramona (2016a). "Is the Decrease in the Gender Wage Gap the Principal Driver of the Sustained Rise in Female Labor Market Participation?," Journal of Research in Gender Studies 6(2): 146-152.

Mihaila, Ramona (2016b). "Female Labor Force Participation and Gender Wage Discrimination," Journal of Research in Gender Studies 6(1): 262-268.

Mihaila, Ramona, Gheorghe H. Popescu, and Elvira Nica (2016). "Educational Conservatism and Democractic Citizenship in Hannah Arendt," Educational Philosophy and Theory 48(9): 915-927.

Mihaila, Ramona (2017). "The Lying Epidemic," Educational Philosophy and Theory 49(6): 580-581.

Mircica, Nela (2011a). "Husserl on the Relationship between Intentionality and Knowledge," Review of Contemporary Philosophy 10: 184-189.

Mircica, Nela (2011b). "Scheler's Phenomenology of Values," Review of Contemporary Philosophy 10: 240-245.

Mircica, Nela (2012). "Sartre's Anthropology of Freedom," Linguistic and Philosophical Investigations 11: 141-146.

Mircica, Nela (2014). "Constructive Communication in Effective Negotiation," Analysis and Metaphysics 13: 64-72.

Nica, Elvira, and Ana-Madalina Potcovaru (2015). "Gender-typical Responses to Stress and Illness," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 3(2): 65-70.

Nica, Elvira, Cristina Manole, and Roxana Briscariu (2016). "The Detrimental Consequences of Perceived Job Insecurity on Health and Psychological Well-being," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 4(1): 175-181.

Nica, Elvira (2016). "Will Technological Unemployment and Workplace Automation Generate Greater Capital-Labor Income Imbalances?," Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 11(4): 68-74.

Nica, Elvira (2017a). "Techno-Pedagogy Knowledge in Smart Learning Environments," Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 12(1): 75-81.

Nica, Elvira (2017b). "Foucault on Managerial Governmentality and Biopolitical Neoliberalism," Journal of Self-Governance and Management Economics 5(1): 80-86.

Nica, Elvira (2017c). "Political Mendacity and Social Trust," Educational Philosophy and Theory 49(6): 571-572.

Nica, Elvira, and Catalina-Oana Mirica (Dumitrescu) (2017). "Is Higher Education Still a Wise Investment? Evidence on Rising Student Loan Debt in the U.S.," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 5(1): 235-241.

Pera, Aurel (2014a). "Neural Mechanisms Underlying School-Based Learning," Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice 6(1): 7-12.

Pera, Aurel (2014b). "The Integration of Cognitive Neuroscience in Educational Practice," Contemporary Readings in Law and Social Justice 6(1): 70-75.

Pera, Aurel (2014c). "The Use of Educational Psychology to Explain Economic Behavior," Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 9(1): 112-117.

Pera, Aurel (2014d). "The Interface between Personality Psychology and Education Economics," Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 9(1): 160-165.

Pera, Aurel (2015a). "Heuristic Reasoning in the Psychology of Mathematics Education," Review of Contemporary Philosophy 14: 132-137.

Pera, Aurel (2015b). "Cognitive Psychology, Mathematical Reasoning, and Organizational Creativity," Review of Contemporary Philosophy 14: 156-161.

Popescu, Gheorghe H. (2015). "The Dynamics of Social Innovation Networks," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 3(2): 77-82.

Popescu, Gheorghe H., Mihaela Comanescu, and Oana Matilda Sabie (2016). "The Role of Human Capital in the Knowledge-networked Economy," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 4(1): 168-174.

Popescu, Gheorghe H. (2017a). "Is Lying Acceptable Conduct in International Politics?," Educational Philosophy and Theory 49(6): 575-576.

Popescu, Gheorghe H. (2017b). "Organizational E-learning and Knowledge Management in Higher Education," Journal of Self-Governance and Management Economics 5(1): 87-93.

Popescu, Gheorghe H. (2017c). "The Economics of E-learning Production," Economics, Management, and Financial Markets 12(1): 68-74.

Popescu, Gheorghe H., and Florin Cristian Ciurlau (2017). "The Skyrocketing Costs of U.S. Higher Education and the Student Debt Crisis," Psychosociological Issues in Human Resource Management 5(1): 242-248.

Popescu Ljungholm, Doina (2016a). "The Role of Work Organizations in the Social Construction of Gender," Journal of Research in Gender Studies 6(1): 269-275.

Popescu Ljungholm, Doina (2016b). "Organizational Social Capital and Performance Management," Linguistic and Philosophical Investigations 15: 108-114.

Radulescu, Adina (2013). "Aspects of Metalinguistic Awareness in Solution-focused Therapy," Linguistic and Philosophical Investigations 12: 150-155.


Center for Human Resources and Labor Studies at AAER, New York; Bucharest University of Economic Studies


Bucharest University of Economic Studies

Received 27 October 2016 * Received in revised form 10 February 2017

Accepted 11 February 2017 * Available online 20 February 2017

Caption: Figure 1 Total education debt of students and parents per graduating class (in billions)

Caption: Figure 2 Number of Americans whose Social Security checks were garnished due to unpaid federal student loan debt
COPYRIGHT 2017 Addleton Academic Publishers
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2017 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Nica, Elvira; Mirica, Catalina-Oana, "Dumitrescu"
Publication:Journal of Self-Governance and Management Economics
Article Type:Report
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Apr 1, 2017
Previous Article:The IMF's role in the resolution of the European sovereign debt crisis: a reassessment.
Next Article:Citizenship, human rights and identity: prospects of a liberal cosmopolitan order.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2018 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters