Are dietary supplements safe? An analysis of the Iowa Women's Health Study.
Comment; One potentially big problem with this study is that the researchers did not report the actual mortality rates. Instead they compared "adjusted" mortality rates between supplement users and nonusers. This was done by adjusting for a wide range of factors including weight, intake of calories, cigarette smoking, blood pressure, educational level, diabetes, use of hormone-replacement therapy, physical exercise, and fruit and vegetable intake. For each of these factors, those who took supplements were in the categories that would be considered healthier; for example, less diabetes, less obesity, more physically active, less smoking, and more fruits and vegetables in their diet. These healthier people would be expected to have lower death rates than those individuals who did not take vitamins. What this does statistically is that the mortality rate of the supplement users would then be adjusted upward compared with the mortality rate of non-supplement users. It is very possible that the researchers "overadjusted" the collection of data, skewing the death rate among supplement users to look higher than it really was. This conclusion is supported by the fact that when the researchers adjusted the data based only on age and intake of calories, there was in fact no statistically significant difference in mortality rate between supplement users and nonusers.
Studies that are observational, as this one was, are always weaker than randomized controlled trials. You can never prove cause and effect with observational studies, and it would be a mistake to make meaningful conclusions from this study due to its observational nature and possible overadjustment of the data. Another issue to ponder is that the individuals taking supplements were likely not more healthy, but perhaps less healthy. In other words, we might wonder, why they were taking supplements to begin with? Perhaps they had a chronic health problem or a family health history that the researchers did not use as an identifier. What if they had a family history of heart disease for example, and that is why they were taking supplements? These individuals could then easily have an increased mortality rate due to their family history.
The scientific literature is robust with randomized clinical trials demonstrating the diverse range of benefits of taking vitamins and minerals. It is always important to recognize the potential benefit and risk of any intervention whether it be over-the-counter or prescription drugs, vitamins, minerals, or herbs. For now, women should not be discouraged to take vitamins and minerals, but individual assessment and need are best determined by a licensed practitioner trained in the use of these therapies. The medical degree that offers the most training in this area of medicine is a naturopathic doctor degree. Licensed graduates from the accredited naturopathic medical schools receive extensive training in nutrition and the use of vitamins and minerals for prevention and treatment.
Mursu J, Robien K, Harnack L, el al. Dietary supplements and mortality rate in older women. The lowa Women's Health Study. Arch Intern Med. 2011;171 (18):1625-16J3.
by Tori Hudson, ND firstname.lastname@example.org
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||Women's Health Update|
|Date:||Apr 1, 2012|
|Previous Article:||The complete calendar can be accessed at townsendletter.com.|
|Next Article:||Alcohol and breast cancer risk: even low levels are associated with elevated risk.|