Analysis of literature seminar Web sites.
This is a review of the use of the WWW for classroom-based literature seminars. Due to the complexity of those seminars, both teaching and learning are challenging tasks. Can dedicated Web sites help meet those challenges? What can they do beyond meeting the basic need for course management? How effective are the literature information pages, links to online full texts, Web tutorials, literature forums, online quizzes and exams, search capabilities, and digital media?
This article focuses on the pedagogical considerations of the use of the WWW for classroom-based literature seminars. It is based on an experience with the Web projects I designed to enhance those seminars. I will review the functions and limitations of various components of the Web sites. The initial need for my literature seminar Web sites was to improve seminar management. Later, I found it beneficial to maintain links to outside Web sites with related literary texts. I realized that I needed to create more valuable Web sites to meet those seminars' pedagogical requirements and started to create my own Web materials by using such Web features as hyper-linking, interactivity, and cross-platform performance (Agnew & Kellerman; Wang).
Seminar Management Pages
Like thousands of other literature Web sites around the world, my initial Web sites were to post general seminar information such as a syllabus, class schedule, attendance and grading policy, and seminar updates. The immediate results were that once objectives, grading policies, and a class schedule were made readily available online, students no longer had to worry about misplacing their hard copies. In addition, seminar information, such as class schedule and reading assignments, was directly linked to content pages on authors, works, terms, themes, background materials, and other seminar pages such as forum, tutorials, and quiz center. The direct linking gave students convenient access to content pages, management pages, and seminar activities. The Web sites became more dynamic, accessible, and user-friendly. However, these advantages did not come automatically with the Web sites. I had to verify and update seminar information and links to content pages and external pages on a regular basis to avoid confusion and to secure access.
Literature Information Pages
My first seminar Web site was dedicated to a "20th Century Literature" seminar that dealt with fast changing literary movements, authors of each movement, and works of each author around the turn of the century. This period was associated with too much literary and nonliterary background information and too many literary movements, experiments, authors, works, ideologies, events, aspects and terms to be covered all in class. However, this information was too crucial for the seminar to be treated casually. The Web turned out to be an excellent platform to present all this information because everything can be cross-referenced and hyper-linked (Harris). I linked the years and places that were relevant to the individual authors to resourceful external Web pages. Students could find from the index of authors the biographical and bibliographical information of an author, and his related works and interpretations. This cross-referencing and hyper-linking feature made literature seminar information so contextualized and meaningful that students could easily get more background information by following the links. As a result, they displayed a more in-depth understanding of the authors and works in class. The literature information pages were also linked to pages such as Class Schedule, Literature Forum, Interactive Literature Tutorial, and even Quizzes. When certain information was relevant to the understanding of particular questions, the cross-links substantially eased the students' access to literary information and helped them understand literary texts.
There was a concern about the potential for student plagiarism because literary interpretations and analyses were readily available in electronic forms, and students could be easily tempted to use them as their own contributions--piracies, which were sometimes difficult to detect. The content portion of the Web site was most tempting because it directly dealt with materials covered in the seminar. However, the real problem was not in the media but rather in the academic code of honor, the education of academic ethics, and the university's rules in preventing the academic plagiarism. Students determined to steal intellectual properties would do so in many other ways; stealing the electronic texts was just a more convenient way. Another copyright and intellectual property related concern was theft by colleagues. Therefore, some teachers were reluctant to post materials other than syllabi. To protect my intellectual properties, I locked up sensitive materials in a password-protected Web directory, which could only be accessed by those who have express permission. I debated with myself on what language (English or the target language) should be used for seminar Web sites and decided to utilize the target language because it was also the language used in the seminar. An additional English version would be certainly an excellent add-on if there were students struggling with the original texts.
Links to Online Full Texts
The rapidly increasing availability and the hypertext feature are often seen as advantages of online literary texts over printed ones for reading in foreign languages (Schmidt), especially for extensive reading (Bamford; Day). Searchability can be considered another advantage. Quoting exact passages and referencing exact page numbers is crucial to a good research paper. The literature book is often too thick and the search for "hidden" passages often takes much time during the busy student's overloaded schedule. With Web-based literary texts, my students just had to run a keyword search to locate the chapters containing the wanted passages. This significantly saved them time in writing papers and strengthened their textual support of papers. However, some students preferred reading books to online texts because of the lack of tangibility in an online environment. Similar situations had been observed and documented (Grossman). Therefore, I avoided assigning long online texts for initial reading, but recommended them for research purpose. In addition, because external Web pages with literary texts were often of a transient nature, I regularly checked links to external Web pages to maintain accessibility and avoid confusion.
The Web sites of "Comparative Drama" and "20th Century German Drama" were designed both for the classroom-based seminars and for future distance-learning seminars. This means that the Web sites must also allow distance-learning students to complete the seminar requirements largely online. To reach this goal, these Web sites had to offer a classroom-like learning environment (Sala), in which a "community of learners" could not only have detailed explanations of literary works, but also participate "collaboratively" (Grigar; Holeton; Wang; Woodlief) in communication in "real time" or "on demand."
The forum of my Web sites were virtual meeting places for students to discuss questions related to literature seminars. They were organized by author and then by his or her works. The teacher and students posted questions and answered questions from other students. The forum had its own merits. First, not every student was brave enough to ask questions in class. Some chose not to ask questions in class and some preferred to raise questions anonymously. The discussion online was more provocative than that in class. The forum was separated into discussion panels. Students could easily locate and respond to messages. This convenient platform allowed me to receive more feedback from students and to incorporate questions posted in the forum into class activities. Students were more involved in the critical thinking process. Password protection was necessary to prevent intruders from interruption and allowed students to use their real names if desired. Another convenient feature of the forum was that students could include links to relevant Web resources in their messages. I encouraged those who had written excellent papers to post their papers in the forum. These activities significantly electrified students' enthusiasm and involvement in literature seminars and enriched their learning experience.
Online Quizzes and Exams
Online quizzes could be reused with some adaptation, revision, and enhancement for future classes. The initial investment of more time and energy in creating Web-based quizzes paid off. According to my survey, the students preferred online quizzes to traditional in-class quizzes because they could take them at their convenience. They also appreciated the possibility to check the answers online. However, since the Web-based quizzes depended on the network, technical problems of the quiz server and the network forced me to postpone deadlines. The "'soft" deadlines, in turn, invited students to delay the completion of their reading assignments of literary works, which again had a negative impact on class activities that relied on their reading preparation.
Another problem was that it gave the students an opportunity to find out answers by communication. Poor students sometimes "performed" much better on Web-based quizzes than in class. This "problem" caused me to reevaluate the objective set for quizzes and tests. The online tests were used as an assessment tool. Therefore, they were administered in a relatively closed, monitored physical environment to insure the reliability of testing outcomes. The purpose of quizzes was redefined as to help students learn. When students achieved better results in online quizzes through communicating with others, the intended objective was considered accomplished. When there was a doubt about some students' class preparation, smaller class assignments (pop quizzes or question sheets) were given. Because literature seminars deal with a much more complex mix, literature quizzes are often different from straightforward science and math quizzes that can be easily converted to Web-based quizzes. While literary concepts, biographical facts, and historical facts can well be contents of quizzes and be further converted to Web-based quizzes, it would be controversial to do so with literary interpretation, especially if the tests were automatically graded.
My drama seminar Web site has a vocabulary list for each work covered. Whenever available, easier German words are used to explain difficult ones. An advantage of online vocabulary lists is that words in these lists are also linked to other related Web pages and vice versa. This back and forward linking or "word webs" (Barton) allows students to reflect on the use of the words in literary texts. An alternative is the annotation of literary texts. The vocabulary lists and text annotations save students a great deal of time for reading and thus more effectively prepare them for class activities.
Another Web feature--search engine--made the literature seminar Web sites pedagogically more attractive than literature textbooks alone. Unfamiliar words or terms often obstruct students' text comprehension. In a book, it is difficult to get explanations despite the existence of indexes. The Web search engine, which is put on a separate search page and on each seminar page, allowed students to search for explanations despite the enormous amount of Web pages on a literature Web site. The search function, in conjunction with indexes of the literature Web site, saved students much time on research.
Use of the Web in Conjunction with Multimedia
Digitizing audiovisual materials has become relatively easy and inexpensive. Digitize audiovisual materials have a potential to serve as a more interactive and learner-friend learning tool than original audiovisual materials (Sammons). However, the use of vide materials for Web tutorials must be dealt with great caution because this involves mo sensitive copyright issues than that of photocopied print materials. It is high recommended to use these materials either in a face-to-face classroom setting or in password-protected Web site.
As analyzed above, dedicated Web sites can contribute to enhancing literature seminars through course management, literature information pages, links to online full texts, Web tutorial literature forums, online quizzes and exams, search capabilities, and digital media if they a designed and used in a pedagogical way. The limitations of those functions should, however, t carefully avoided.
Agnew, P. W. & Kelierman A. S. Distributed multimedia: Technologies, applications, a opportunities in the digital information industry. A guide for language learners and providers. New York ACM, 1996.
Bamford, J.; Day, D. "Extensive Reading: What Is It? Why Bother http:// langue.hyper.chubu.ac.jp/jaltlpub/tlti97/may/extensive.html.
Barton, J. "Teaching Vocabulary in the Literature Classroom http:// www.ncte.orglpdfsdsubscribers-only/ej/0904-march01/EJ0904Teaching.pdf
Grigar, D. "Collaborative Learning Tools for the Literature Classroom." SCMLA 2001 October 27, 2001. http://www.eaze.net/~dene/scmla_paper.html.
Grossman, J. "Linking the Old Ways to the New: History, Literature, and Technology in "17 Classroom Electric." http://www.mith.umd.edu/mithologies/grossmanpritu.html
Holeton, R. "The Semi-Virtual Composition Classroom: A Model for Techno-Amphibians." http:// ts.mivu.org/default.asp?show=article&id=512
Meskill, C. and Swan, K. "Roles for Multimedia in the Response-based Literature Classroom.'" Journal of Educational Computing Research, Vol. 15, No. 3, 1996, p. 217-2 http://www.albany.edu/lap/Papers/roles%20for%20multimedia.html.
Sala, N. "Web Based Learning Environment: To Follow the Instructions." World Conference on the WWW and Interact 2000(1), 973-974. http://www.aace.org/dl/index.cfrrgfuseaction/View/paperID/303
Sehmidt, Ken. "Online extensive reading opportunities for lower-level learners of EFI/ESL." http://www.kyoto-su.ac.jp/information/tesl-ej/ej13/int.html. TESL-EJ 4 (1), July 1999.
Sammons, M. "Using Computer Slide Presentations in the College Classroom http://horizon.unc.edu/projects/monograph/CD/Language_Music/Sammons.asp
Tang, Q. Instructional systems design for interactive distance education on the Internet. Ensched University of Twente, Faculty of Educational Science and Technology, 1995.
Waiters, R. Computer-mediated communications: Multimedia applications. Boston: Artech House 1995.
Wang, C. and Rosenberg, M. "Creating a Collaborative Web-based Training Virtual Team World Conference on the WWW and Internet 2000 (1), 838-83 http://www.aace.org/dl/index.cfrrdfuseaotion/View/paperID/209.
Woodlief, A. "A Community of Learners: Teaching Literature Electronically http://www.vcu.edu/engweb/home/webchap.htm
--."Changing the Paradigm: Hypertext and Interactive, Student-Centered Learning http://horizon.unc.edulprojects/monograph/CDILanguage_Music/Woodlief.asp
Peter Yang, Case Western Reserve University, OH
Jesse Hauk Shera, Case Western Reserve University, OH
Yang is Associate Professor & LRL Director (since 2002). Shera is Assistant Professor & LRC Director (1996-2002).
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Author:||Shera, Jesse Hauk|
|Publication:||Academic Exchange Quarterly|
|Date:||Jun 22, 2003|
|Previous Article:||Appropriating literature in foreign language classrooms.|
|Next Article:||Excellent teachers: exploring constructions of teaching.|