An Unusual Complication of Otitis Media: Luc's Abscess.
Otitis media is one of the most frequently diagnosed and treated childhood diseases. Although it is often self-limited, there are important complications of the disease due to its proximity to the intracranial and intratemporal compartments. Subperiosteal abscesses are extracranial and extratemporal complications of otitis media, which are termed according to location. When the infection spreads deep to the sternocleidomastoid muscle, it is called Bezold's abscess, and when located in the digastric triangle, it is called Citelli's abscess. In the case of Luc's abscess, the infection is located beneath the temporal muscle . Many clinicians have a little experience in the diagnosis and treatment of this disease due to its rare nature.
Subperiosteal abscesses of otitic origin usually occur following the spread of infection to the subperiosteal area from the cortical bone destruction often secondary to acute mastoiditis. Luc's abscess is different from the other subperiosteal abscesses in that respect. It usually occurs not through the mastoid bone but by spreading of the middle ear infection through a pre-existing pathway in the external ear canal. Therefore, the disease may not be accompanied by acute mastoiditis . A rare route of infection spreading to the temporal fossa is by the pneumatized zygomatic arch. Under this condition, subperiosteal abscesses may be observed along with acute mastoiditis . Computed tomography (CT) of the temporal bone would give very useful information under such conditions. Here, we present a case of Luc's abscess with mastoid bone involvement associated with acute otitis media, following parental approval.
An 11-year-old boy presented to the emergency department with complaints of painful swelling on the right half of the face, difficulty in opening his mouth, and high fever, which started a day before. He also presented with complaints of right ear pain and hearing loss for the past 2 days. There was no previous medical history of any ear disease or trauma. Physical examination revealed that the patient had trismus and that the swelling originating from the right temporal region extended toward the cheek and inferior palpebra. The tympanic membrane was not clearly evaluated due to severe edema in the right external ear canal, as observed on otoscopic examination.
Laboratory analysis revealed leukocytosis (26.84 K/uL), neutrophilia (%87.5), and increased C-reactive protein (CRP: 21.74 mg/dL; normal<0.5). Pure tone audiogram revealed a moderate conductive-type hearing loss in the right ear. After obtaining these findings, the patient was scheduled for CT of the paranasal sinuses and temporal bone and cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
CT examination revealed soft tissue density completely filling the right external auditory canal, middle ear, and mastoid bone along with marked edema in the right masticator and buccal space (Figure 1). There were no pathological findings in the paranasal sinuses. Cranial MRI revealed a 38x5-mm contrast enhancement of the loculated collection extending from the right external auditory canal anteriorly to the vicinity of the temporomandibular joint and edema in the right pterygoid muscles (Figure 2).
Based on these findings, the patient was hospitalized with the diagnosis of otitis media complicated by Luc's abscess. He was commenced on intravenous (IV) vancomycin and ampicillin/sulbactam treatment following recommendation from the infectious disease clinic. The patient was observed to have intubation difficulty due to trismus. As a result, no emergency surgery was scheduled. Following regression of the findings of trismus by the 5th day of medical treatment, myringotomy and a grommet insertion, cortical mastoidectomy and abscess drainage were performed, under general anesthesia after a written informed consent was obtained from the parents of the patient (Figure 3). During the surgery, no direct relationship between the temporal abscess and the mastoid bone was detected. The mastoid cavity and cavity of the middle ear were observed to be filled with hemorrhagic granulation tissue. No cholesteatoma was observed in the mastoid. Pathological examination of the material obtained from the operation was reported as chronic active inflammation. Culture of the abscess showed no growth. Following the surgical operation, IV antibiotic treatment was completed within 14 days, and the patient was discharged following recovery. The postoperative 1st month follow-up demonstrated that his ventilation tube was still in place and that his hearing completely recovered.
Subperiosteal temporal abscess relating to acute otitis media was first described in 1913 by Henri Luc . According to Luc, the disease differs from other subperiosteal abscesses in that it develops without the mastoid bone involvement and that the infection spreads through the notch of Rivinus and branches of the deep auricular arteries located between the roof of the middle ear and the external ear canal, and the subperiosteal area. Consequently, Luc suggests that in the absence of findings of mastoiditis such as retroauricular swelling and persistent otorrhea, there is no need for these patients to undergo mastoidectomy, which is a risky and dangerous surgical intervention.
A very limited number of cases of Luc's abscess have been reported in the literature, particularly following the widespread use of antibiotics. Literature cases of Luc's abscess are shown in Table 1. In the case presented by Knape et al. , a 15-year-old girl underwent mastoidectomy following the diagnosis of Luc's abscess; however, no bony involvement was observed. Consequently, they reported that temporal abscesses had a much better course than other otitic subperiosteal abscesses and that a conservative approach should be considered in its treatment management. Similarly, Weiss et al.  presented two 5-year-old boys with Luc's abscess, and no mastoid bone involvement was observed in both cases. In the case presented by Er et al. , no mastoid bone involvement was observed in the temporal CT. Therefore, only needle aspiration of the abscess and a grommet insertion were performed in this case.
Unlike these cases, patients have been reported who have Luc's abscess with mastoid bone involvement. Asha'ari et al.  and Garner et al.  presented two cases of Luc's abscess relating to acute otitis media. Upon the detection of mastoid bone defect with subperiosteal abscess on CT, cortical mastoidectomy was performed in both cases. Similarly, Scrafton et al.  presented a case in which a 6x2 cm temporal abscess with acute mastoiditis on CT was detected. Only a single case with Luc's abscess associated with congenital cholesteatoma was presented by Santhi et al. . Modified radical mastoidectomy operation was performed in this patient.
Review of the literature shows that Luc's abscess often occurs in the pediatric age group and that it develops as a complication of acute otitis media. Only one adult case has been reported in the literature , and congenital cholesteatoma has been reported only in one case . It is also noteworthy that Luc's abscess usually affects male patients. However, this has been considered to be a coincidence. Both aerobic and anaerobic bacteria have been found as the causative agents in the abscess cultures. Therefore, broad spectrum antibiotics should be used for the empirical treatment until the final aspirate culture and microbiological advice reports return.
The results of clinical and temporal CT show that Luc's abscess with concomitant mastoiditis has been reported in 3 cases of acute otitis media [3, 7, 8]. Scrafton suggested that cases in which mastoiditis was observed with temporal abscess should be considered as a different patient group, unlike described by Luc, and that temporal CT might be a guide . In our case, MRI results showed that the abscess reached the temporal region from the external ear canal. Therefore, it followed the dissemination path described by Luc. In addition, cortical mastoidectomy was added to the treatment protocol due to the accompanying mastoid involvement as seen on CT.
In addition, the limitation of jaw movement was priority complain in our patient. The presence of trismus resulted in intubation difficulty. Therefore, unlike the other Luc's abscesses described in the literature, our patient was not scheduled for an emergency surgery. The patient was only able to be taken for surgical operation due to trismus regression following IV antibiotherapy. Trismus, a finding observed in temporal abscesses, occurs as a result of the abscess draining into the mandibular fossa. The presence of an abscess near the temporomandibular joint and edema in the pterygoid muscles on MRI defined the trismus in our patient.
Luc's abscess is a rare but serious complication of otitis media. Although its prognosis is better than other subperiosteal abscesses, it may be life-threatening if the abscess reaches the mandibular fossa by causing trismus. The lack of adequate experience of the clinician may lead to delayed diagnosis and treatment. Temporal CT is a useful imaging tool in determining the spread of the disease and its treatment strategy. Furthermore, cranial MRI may clearly demonstrate the spread of the abscess. The main point in this case is to decide whether mastoidectomy will be added to treatment protocol. Surgical findings in our case support the idea that CT scan is an important factor in this critical decision.
Informed Consent: Written informed consent was obtained from the parents of the patient who participated in this study.
Peer-review: Externally peer-reviewed.
Author Contributions: Concept - E.M., F.N.A.; Design - E.M., FNA.; Supervision - E.M., F.T.; Resources - E.M., F.N.A.; Materials - E.M., E.S.; Data Collection and/or Processing - E.M., F.T., E.S.; Analysis and/or Interpretation - E.M., F.N.A.; Literature Search - E.M.; Writing Manuscript - E.M., F.T., E.S., F.N.A.; Critical Review - E.M., F.N.A.
Conflict of Interest: The authors have no conflict of interest to declare.
Financial Disclosure: The authors declared that this study has received no financial support.
[1.] Spiegel JH, Lustig LR, Lee KC, Murr AH, Schindler RA. Contemporary presentation and management of a spectrum of mastoid abscesses. Laryngoscope 1998; 108: 822-8. [CrossRef]
[2.] Luc H. Sub-periosteal temporal abscess of otic origin without intra-osseous suppuration. Laryngoscope 1913; 23: 999-1003. [CrossRef]
[3.] Garner EF, McKinnon BJ. Luc's abscess-a case report. Int J Pediatr Otorhinolaryngol Extra 2013; 8: e5-7. [CrossRef]
[4.] Knappe MV, Gregor RT. Luc's abscess--a rare complication of middle-ear infection. J Laryngol Otol 1997; 111: 461-4.
[5.] Weiss I, Marom T, Goldfarb A, Roth Y. Luc's abscess: the return of an old fellow. Otol Neurotol 2010; 31: 776-9. [CrossRef]
[6.] Er A, Erdag TK, Caglar A, Kumus O, Duman M. Luc abscess: an extraordinary complication of acute otitis media. Am J Emerg Med 2016; 34: 117. e1-3. [CrossRef]
[7.] Asha'ari ZA, Shiyuti MI, Zihni M. Luc's abscess: a reminder of potential complication of otitis media. Brunei Int Med J 2012; 8: 261-4.
[8.] Scrafton DK, Querishi A, Nogueria C, Mortimore S. Luc's abscess as an unlucky complication of mastoiditis. Ann R Coll Surg Engl 2014; 96: e28-30. [CrossRef]
[9.] Santhi K, Tang IP, Nordin A, Prepageran N. Congenital cholesteatoma presenting with Luc's abscess. J Surg Case Rep 2012; 2012: rjs026.
Erdem Mengi [iD], Funda Tumkaya [iD], Ergin Sagtas [iD], Fazil Necdet Ardic [iD]
Department of Otolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, Pamukkale University School of Medicine, Denizli, Turkey (EM, FT, FNA)
Department of Radiology, Pamukkale University School of Medicine, Denizli, Turkey (ES)
Cite this article as: Mengi E, Tumkaya F, Sagtas E, Ardic FN. An Unusual Complication of Otitis Media: Luc's Abscess. J Int Adv Otol 2018; 14(3): 497-500.
This study was presented at the 39th Turkish ENT and HNS Congress, 8-12 November 2017, Antalya, Turkey.
Corresponding Address: Erdem Mengi E-mail: email@example.com
Submitted: 05.11.2017 * Revision Received: 23.01.2018 * Accepted: 01.02.2018 * Available Online Date: 15.10.2018
Table 1. Reported cases of Luc's abscess Age/Sex Etiology Knappe et al.  1997 15-year-old female - Weiss et al.  2010 5-year-old male AOM 5-year-old male AOM Asha'ari et al.  2012 73-year-old male AOM Santhi et al.  2012 5-year-old male Congenital cholesteatoma Garner et al.  2013 5-month-old male AOM Scrafton et al.  2014 4-year-old male AOM Er et al.  2016 9-year-old male AOM This report 11-year-old male AOM Treatment Knappe et al.  1997 Mastoidectomy, IV antibiotherapy Weiss et al.  2010 Abscess drainage, tympanostomy tube insertion, IV antibiotherapy Abscess drainage, tympanostomy tube insertion, cortical mastoidectomy, IV antibiotherapy Asha'ari et al.  2012 Abscess drainage, cortical mastoidectomy IV antibiotherapy Santhi et al.  2012 Modified radical mastoidectomy Garner et al.  2013 Abscess drainage, myringotomy, cortical mastoidectomy, IV antibiotherapy Scrafton et al.  2014 Abscess drainage, tympanostomy tube insertion, cortical mastoidectomy, IV antibiotherapy Er et al.  2016 Abscess drainage, tympanostomy tube insertion, IV antibiotherapy This report Abscess drainage, tympanostomy tube insertion, cortical mastoidectomy, IV antibiotherapy Mastoiditis Culture Knappe et al.  1997 No - Weiss et al.  2010 No Streptococcus pyogenes No Fusobacterium necrophorum Asha'ari et al.  2012 Yes Klebsiella ozaenae Santhi et al.  2012 Yes - Garner et al.  2013 Yes Streptococcus constellatus Scrafton et al.  2014 Yes Streptococcus pyogenes Er et al.  2016 No No growth This report Yes No growth
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||Case Report|
|Author:||Mengi, Erdem; Tumkaya, Funda; Sagtas, Ergin; Ardic, Fazil Necdet|
|Publication:||The Journal of the International Advanced Otology|
|Article Type:||Clinical report|
|Date:||Dec 1, 2018|
|Previous Article:||Middle Ear Osteoma Causing Mixed Hearing Loss: A Case Report.|
|Next Article:||Canal Wall-Down Mastoidectomy plus Meatoplasty for Extensive Verruca Vulgaris in the Ear Canal and Mastoid Bone.|