Printer Friendly

An ESP experiment with the sequential card search task.

ABSTRACT: Sequential card search (SCS) is a variant of a forced-choice ESP task, in which participants search for 1 card symbol (target) from among a finite set in an array of concealed cards. The participants are asked to continue the search until the symbol is found or remains undiscovered on the last card. The task is appealing and well accepted even by participants who otherwise feel discouraged by experimental tasks with an overt ESP component. Also, the experiment provides a rich data structure as the probability of a chance hit varies with the number of alternatives. A simple test of the null hypothesis is based on the expected distribution of average search run length (ASRL), that is, the number of subtrials needed, on average, to find the target.

The first SCS study was conducted by Copenhagen in 2000 with 26 participants recruited from 2 subpopulations: (a) clairvoyants, participants practising ESP in their community sessions (Group C, n = 11), and (b) controls, participants not claiming any ESP abilities (Group N, n = 15). A software implementation of the SCS task (program jcards) on a portable computer was used to run the experiments at participants' homes. Five classic Zener symbols were used. Each participant completed 1 run consisting of 100 complete trials.

The ASRL statistics showed no significant departure from the mean chance expectation (MCE) in either Group C or N; the difference between the groups was also not significant. Hit rates were analyzed separately by successive subtrials, as the hit probability due to chance varies with the number of alternatives from which to choose, and numbers of subtrials naturally decrease with decreasing number of alternatives. The deviations of hit rates from hit probabilities by chance show similar profiles between Groups C and N, but the deviations, taken as a whole, are not significant.

The most remarkable feature of the data structure is an asymmetry observed at extreme ends of ASRL distributions in both Groups C and N: extremely low values (i.e., in the expected direction) deviated farther from MCE than the extreme values on the opposite wing of the distributions. Although this observation has to be taken with extreme care, the joint probability of these departures, given the null hypothesis, is rather low (p [approximately] .012). This observation is strongly suggestive of an inhomogeneity in the source population; one might hypothesize that the experimental samples were statistical mixtures of a major portion scoring on the chance level and a minor fraction using an unknown, extra-chance cognitive process.
COPYRIGHT 2001 Parapsychology Press
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2001 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:extrasensory perception
Author:Wackermann, Jiri; Benthin, Rebecca; Putz, Peter
Publication:The Journal of Parapsychology
Article Type:Brief Article
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Dec 1, 2001
Previous Article:The problem of replication and the "psi-conducive" experimenter.
Next Article:Experimenter effects and the remote facilitation of attention focusing: Two studies and the discovery of an artefact.

Related Articles
Meta-analyses of 10 experiments on perceptual defensiveness and ESP: ESP scoring patterns and experimenter and decline effects.
What makes a good psi target? Three studies of forced-choice ESP varying target emotionality and complexity.
Reliabilities and psychological correlates of guessing and scoring behavior in a forced-choice ESP task.
Perceptual defensiveness and ESP performance: Reconstructed DMT ratings and psychological correlates in the first German DMT-ESP experiment.
Children's psi and personality variables.
The phychology of the "psi-conductive" experimenter: personality, attitudes towards psi, and personal psi experience.
Perceptual defensiveness and ESP performance: reconstructed DMT ratings and psychological correlates in the first German DMT-ESP experiment.
Use of an ESP cover story facilitates reinforcement without awareness.
Complicating the conversation: rhetoric, substance, and controversy in parapsychology.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2020 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters