Printer Friendly

ATTITUDE TOWARDS PSYCHIATRY--A COMPARATIVE STUDY AMONG MEDICAL INTERNS AND UNDERGRADUATE STUDENTS OF A TERTIARY CARE HOSPITAL IN KERALA.

BACKGROUND

The stigma connected to mental disease and mentally ill is a universal phenomenon and a serious barrier to provision of mental health services. [1] Stigmatising attitudes toward mental disease does not lie solely among uninformed members of a society; they exist among health professionals, as well as medical students, which they carry onto their professional lives. [2-5] Global recruitment in psychiatry has been falling for many decades as a result of medical students and graduates are finding it consistently unattractive. [6,7] Medical students have misperceptions regarding psychiatry, even before they start graduate school. The factors that appear to deter medical students from taking over psychiatry as a future career might include: stigma, bad prognosis of psychiatric illness, lack of scientific rigour in psychiatry, psychiatrist's low status among physicians, threats of violence from patients and lack of resources. [6-11]

The potential impact of psychiatry clerkships throughout undergraduate medical training on student attitudes and career alternative has been extensively studied largely at academic establishments in developed countries. [12] Many previous studies have found that medical students undertaking psychiatric internship do develop a lot of positive attitudes toward psychiatry [13-15] though some studies have found no measurable change. [16-18] But some authors disagree and assume that undertaking psychiatric clerkship doesn't essentially change students' opinions to decide on to specialise in the subject [19,20] and that the improvement is temporary, with the proportion of potential candidates for psychiatry continue to fall up until the completion of graduate school. [21,22] When negative attitude towards psychiatric disorders have been reported to be prevalent in all sections of society, [23] it is not surprising that medical students carry with them these prejudices when they enter the medical community. [24] However, if these negative attitudes are overlooked and unchanged throughout the course of medical education, it may prove harmful in the longterm. [25]

Trend to settle on psychiatry as a career by doctors and their orientation towards management of psychological problem in physically unwell patients as general physicians and surgeons is demand of the current time. Maximum part of perspective building towards subjects takes place in medical coaching. Therefore, attitude of medical students is of paramount importance. [26] However, Psychiatry as a discipline is felt to be given a lukewarm treatment at the undergraduate level which is mirrored in the range of lectures in psychiatry and number of hours of Psychiatry clinical posting. [27] Until recently, even during the course of the internship, Psychiatry was considered to be a non-mandatory subject as compared to compulsory posting in Surgery, Medicine, Gynaecology, among other branches. [28] So as to improve psychiatric coaching within the undergraduate medical population both in terms of quantity as well as quality, the character and magnitude of shortcomings in information, perception, and attitude toward psychiatry in this cluster ought to be assessed and understood. [23,29] Previous analysis into attitude to psychiatry as a specialty and career choice appears to have produced conflicting results and most of it was conducted among medical students. [27]

Aim and Objectives

This study compared the attitude of the medical interns who had completed their psychiatry internship with that of the final year medical students who were yet to do the internship in Psychiatry. This was to determine the impact of the internship on the students' attitude to psychiatry. Additionally, study assessed medical students' attitude towards psychiatry as a profession and a choice of career after graduation.

Inclusion Criteria

1. Final year students who are yet to start internship

2. Interns who have completed their psychiatry internship

Exclusion Criteria

Students and interns who refused to participate

Methodology

This hospital-based cross-sectional study was conducted in Academy Of Medical Sciences, Pariyaram, Kerala. The duration of study period was 1 month, conducted in August 2017. At that time, all interns completed their compulsory rotatory internship in Psychiatry for 2 weeks. The final year MBBS students were yet to start their internship in Psychiatry. Questionnaires were distributed to students who gave their informed consent for participation for study.

Materials

1. Sociodemographic data sheet

2. Attitude Towards Psychiatry questionnaire (ATP-29).

The authors designed a brief demographic and career interest questionnaire, which was used in obtaining data such as age, gender, academic year and preferred career choice following graduation.

The study used Balon et al's questionnaire which consisted of 29 questions which examined the attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry and explored six main areas: 1) overall merits of psychiatry 2) efficacy 3) role definition and functioning of psychiatrists, 4) possible abuse and social criticism, 5) career and personal reward and 6) specific medical school factors. The items are scored on a Likert scale with responses expressing the degree of agreement with the sentence described in each item: "strongly agree," "moderately agree," "moderately disagree," and "strongly disagree". Results "strongly agree" and "moderately agree" responses are combined; also "strongly disagree" and "moderately disagree" included in the study.

Statistical Analysis

Data analysis done using the SPSS (version-20.0). Standard descriptive statistics (mean, median, standard deviation, percentage) were used to analyse the characteristics of participants. The differences between the final year students and interns were assessed using Chi-square test and p-value <0.05 considered significant.

Ethical Consideration

Ethical clearance was obtained from institutional ethical committee.

RESULTS

Out of total 133 students, 38 did not give consent or returned the questionnaire back. A total of 95 participants was included in final analysis of the study, out of which final year medical students and interns were 42 and 53, respectively.

DISCUSSION

Overall, majority of the students from two groups had a favourable response to the statements of the ATP-29 scale. More positive attitude towards mental illness came from interns when compared to final year students in this study. This was true for majority of statements of scale used in the study. This could be attributable to the administration of the attitude questionnaire after two weeks of internship, which included seminars, lecture classes, case presentations, daily ward rounds and residential duty. A positive impact of psychiatric clinical postings, lectures, and workshops on attitude towards psychiatry had been reported in previous studies as well. [13,16,18]

In the present study, attitude towards overall merit of psychiatry was evaluated. Results were found to be equivocal in two groups when considering that psychiatric research has made a good strides in advancing care for major mental disorders. Majority of interns and final year students disagreed that psychiatry is considered unscientific and imprecise. In some studies, undergraduate students were found to believe psychiatry to be an imprecise, unscientific branch and did not believe it to be an expanding branch. [13,30]

Regarding psychiatric consultation and recommendation to other people who are emotionally disturbed, 100% interns agreed to this statement. However, another study reported negative opinion about seeking psychiatric consultation. [30] The statement 'psychiatrists to be having the most authority and influence among mental health professionals', more than half of final year students had contrast opinion. This may be due to lack of awareness and knowledge about this specialty in Indian students. [29,31] Overall, majority agreed psychiatry was scientific and the treatment was worth recommending to family members with psychiatric problems. This opinion is in contrast to that found in some previous studies that claimed lack of scientific rigour, and non-efficacy of treatment.

Regarding psychiatrist's role and functioning, "Psychiatry is not a genuine and valid branch of medicine," 19% of the final year students disagreed with this statement compared to interns (7.6%). The confusion regarding the role of clinical psychologists and social workers in interns persisted even after internship, as they were not able to differentiate their role in psychiatry. It could be due to underexposure of students to psychology during internship and poorly planned curriculum.

Students generally disagreed on views that psychiatrists misuse their powers to lock up their patients inside hospitals. Students may be aware about the mental health act, which prevents overruling the rights of the patients while a decision on hospital admission is considered.

Majority of the final year students felt that 'psychiatry' had low prestige among general public and other medical disciplines. They believed that psychiatrists are respected less in their society, and had prejudices of those choosing psychiatry as odd, eccentric people in their personality.

Around one-fourth of participants felt uncomfortable with mentally ill persons irrespective of exposure to psychiatry. This could be due their stereotype, negative perception of mental health care even before entering medical school.

A significantly greater agreement was reported by the final year (69%) as compared to the interns (24.5%) for the statement that no effort was made to encourage them to become psychiatrists at their medical school, which is alarming. Psychiatric training in the undergraduate medical curricula appears to be falling short, as reflected by an insufficient number of allotted lectures, shortage of qualified teaching faculty as well as inadequate clinical postings, which leads to inadequate exposure of medical students to psychiatry. [29,32]

Although, in the current study, there is better outlook of interns toward psychiatry when compared to final year students in some areas, their negative attitude cannot be ignored in few aspects of psychiatry which has to explored further.

Many of the students held positive opinions towards most variables assessing their attitudes to psychiatry, despite this observation; nearly none of them chose the profession as a choice of future specialisation. The 2 weeks duration of internship in psychiatry by medical interns very likely was not enough to have steered appreciable positive interest among them towards specialising in psychiatry. Some of the negative conceptions in the beliefs of medical students about psychiatry practice like 'not in the main stream' of medicine, and involves caring for patients without good treatment outcome, may contribute to their not choosing to specialise in the profession. Other factors that effect on specialty choices are personality characteristics. [16] Around 69% final year students and 32% of interns considered psychiatry profession as low prestige and less respected among general public, despite rating the discipline as having higher intellectual challenges than others. It is not surprising that despite having a favourable attitude to psychiatry, they were not interested in becoming a psychiatrist, suggesting that variables other than attitude determine specialty choice [12] like social stigma attached to psychiatry and low prestige among mental health care professionals.

CONCLUSION

Findings suggest that both groups do not have a negative attitude towards psychiatry in the study and they have a good perception of psychiatry, though they didn't show a significant change in their intention to pursue psychiatry as a prospective career.

Limitations

The sample size was small, and study was limited to one medical college setting, so generalisation of results to other areas needs to be done with caution. Multicentric studies are required to assess the impact of current curriculum of psychiatry across various colleges.

REFERENCES

[1] Reddy JP, Tan SMK, Azmi MT, et al. The effect of a clinical posting in psychiatry on the attitudes of medical students towards psychiatry and mental illness in a Malaysian medical school. Ann Acad Med Singapore 2005;34(8):505-10.

[2] Keane MRN. Contemporary beliefs about mental illness among medical students: implications for education and practice. Acad Psychiatry 1990;14(3):172-7.

[3] Lyons M, Ziviani J. Stereotypes, stigma and mental illness: learning from fieldwork experiences. Am J Occup Ther 1995;49(10):1002-8.

[4] Mirabi M, Weinman ML, Magnetti SM, et al. Professional attitudes toward the chronic mentally ill. Hosp Commun Psychiatry 1985;36(4):404-5.

[5] Scott DJ, Phillip AE. Attitudes of psychiatric nurses to treatment and patients. Br J Med Psychol 1985;58(Pt 2):169-73.

[6] Farooq K, Lydall GJ, Malik A, et al. Why medical students choose psychiatry - a 20 country cross-sectional survey. BMC Med Educ 2014;14:12.

[7] Fazel S, Ebmeier KP. Specialty choice in UK junior doctors: Is psychiatry the least popular specialty for UK and international medical graduates? BMC Med Educ 2009;9:77.

[8] Feifel D, Moutier CY, Swerdlow NR. Attitudes toward psychiatry as a prospective career among students entering medical school. American Journal of Psychiatry 1999;156(9):1397-402.

[9] Goldacre M, Fazel S, Smith F, et al. Choice and rejection of psychiatry as a career: surveys of UK medical graduates from 1974 to 2009. Brit J Psychiat 2013;202(3):228-34.

[10] Brown T. Recruitment Strategy 2011-2016 (updated February 2012). Royal College of Psychiatrists, 2012.

[11] Mukherjee K, Maier M, Wessely S. UK crisis in recruitment into psychiatric training. DOI: 10.1192/pb.bp.112.040873 Published 3rd June 2013.

[12] Adebowale TO, Adelufosi AO, Ogunwale A, et al. The impact of a psychiatry clinical rotation on the attitude of Nigerian medical students to psychiatry. Afr J Psychiatry (Johannesbg) 2012;15(3):185-8.

[13] Bulena A, Phialhez G, Coll J, et al. Changes in the attitudes toward psychiatry among Spanish medical students during training in psychiatry. Eur J of Psychiatry 2005;19(2):79-87.

[14] Burra P, Kalin R, Leichner P, et al. The ATP 30-a scale for measuring medical students' attitudes to psychiatry. Med Educ 1982;16(1):31-8.

[15] McParland M, Noble LM, Livingston G, et al. The effect of a psychiatric attachment on students' attitudes to and intention to pursue psychiatry as a career. Medical Education 2003;37(5):447-54.

[16] Walton HJ. Personality correlates of a career interest in psychiatry. Br J of Psychiatry 1969;115(519):211-9.

[17] Yager J, Lamotte K, Nielsen A 3rd, et al. Medical students' evaluation of psychiatry: a cross-country comparison. Am J of Psychiatry 1982;139(8):1003-9.

[18] Galletly CA, Schrader GD, Chestemtan HM, et al. Medical students' attitudes to psychiatry: lack of effect of psychiatric hospital experience. Med Educ 1995;29(6):449-51.

[19] Alexander DA, Eagles JM. Attitudes of men and women medical students to psychiatry. Med Educ 1986;20(5): 449-55.

[20] Sivakumar K, Wilkinson G, Toone BK, et al. Attitudes to psychiatry in doctors at the end of their first postgraduate year: two year follow-up of a cohort of medical students. Psychol Med 1986;16(2):457-60.

[21] Brook P. Who's for psychiatry? United Kingdom medical schools and career choice of psychiatry 1961-75. Br J Psychiatry 1983;142:361-5.

[22] Reiser LW, Sledge WH, Edelson M. Four-year evaluation of a psychiatric clerkship: 1982-1986. Am J of psychiatry 1988;145(9):1122-6.

[23] Jugul K, Mukherjee R, Parashar M, et al. Beliefs and attitudes towards mental health among medical professionals in Delhi. Indian J Community Med 2007;32(3):198-200.

[24] Malhi GS, Parker GB, Parker K, et al. Attitudes toward psychiatry among students entering medical school. Acta Psychiatr Scand 2003;107(6):424-9.

[25] Aruna G, Mittal S, Yadiyal MB, et al. Perception, knowledge and attitude toward mental disorders and psychiatry among medical undergraduates in Karnataka: a cross-sectional study. Indian J Psychiatry 2016;58(1):70-6.

[26] Khan SA, Yousafzai AU, Mehir RK, et al. Attitude of medical students towards psychiatry in NWFP. J Ayub Med Coll Abbottabad 2008;20(3):44-6.

[27] Sarfraz MA, Merrony I, Atkins C. A survey of Foundation doctors' attitudes towards psychiatry before and after their first clinical working year. BJMP 2016;9(3):a923.

[28] Kallivayalil RA. The importance of psychiatry in undergraduate medical education in India. Indian J Psychiatry 2012;54(3):208-16.

[29] Chawla JM, Balhara YP, Sagar R, et al. Undergraduate medical students' attitude toward psychiatry: a cross-sectional study. Indian J Psychiatry 2012;54(1):37-40.

[30] Lingeswaran A. Psychiatric curriculum and its impact on the attitude of Indian undergraduate medical students and interns. Indian J Psychol Med 2010;32(2):119-27.

[31] Parikh NC, Sharma PS, Chaudhary PJ, et al. Study of attitude of interns toward psychiatry: a survey of a tertiary level hospital in Ahmedabad. Ind Psychiatry J 2014;23(2):143-8.

[32] Rajagopalan M, Kuruvilla K. Medical students' attitudes towards psychiatry: effect of a two week posting. Indian J Psychiatry 1994;36(4):177-82.

Sajad Mohammed (1), Yesudas Kalathara Francis (2), Binoo Divakaran (3)

(1) Junior Resident, Department of Psychiatry, ACME, Pariyaram, Kannur.

(2) Professor and HOD, Department of Psychiatry, ACME, Pariyaram, Kannur.

(3) Associate Professor, Department of Biostatistics, ACME, Pariyaram, Kannur.

'Financial or Other Competing Interest': None.

Submission 29-11-2017, Peer Review 23-12-2017, Acceptance 29-12-2017, Published 08-01-2018.

Corresponding Author:

Dr. Sajad Mohammed, Nishad Dale, Umayanalloor P.O, Kollam, Kerala-691589.

E-mail: sajadmohd@gmail.com

DOI: 10.14260/jemds/2018/36
Table 1. Descriptive Statistics of Age

       N    Minimum   Maximum   Mean    Standard
                                        Deviation

AGE   95      21        26      23.85     0.850

Table 2. Distribution of Male-Female in the Sample

         No. of Students   Percentage

Male           22             23.2
Female         73             76.8
Total          95             100

Table 3. Frequency Comparison of Interns and Final Year
Students

             No. of Students   Percentage

Interns            53             55.8
Final Year         42             44.2
Total              95             100

Table 4. Students' Attitude Toward Psychiatry

Overall 20% chose Internal Medicine followed by OBG 18.9%. 11.9% each
from final year students chose internal medicine and OBG respectively,
while 26.9% and 24.5% of the interns chose Internal Medicine and OBG
respectively as their preferred choice of specialty. Only 1.1%
students out of both groups chose Psychiatry as a preferred area of
future specialisation. 15.8% had no response and 17.9% of them were
yet to decide regarding their future career of choice.

Sl.   ATP Questions         Final Year (%)      Interns (%)     P-Value
No.                       Agree   Disagree   Agree   Disagree

1     Psychiatric          100       0       98.1      1.9       0.000
      research has made
      good strides in
      advancing care of
      the major mental
      disorders

2     Psychiatry is a     85.7      14.3     98.1      1.9       0.114
      rapidly expanding
      frontier of
      medicine

3     Psychiatry is       11.9      88.1      5.7      94.3      0.046
      unscientific and
      imprecise

4     Psychiatric         88.1      11.9      100       0        0.008
      consultation for
      an emotionally
      upset family
      member

5     Psychiatry is not    19        81       7.6      92.4      0.000
      a genuine or
      valid branch of
      medicine

6     Psychiatrists       40.5      59.5     92.5      7.5       0.000
      have the most
      authority and
      influence among
      mental health
      professionals

7     With few            26.2      73.8     58.4      41.6      0.000
      exceptions,
      clinical
      psychologists and
      social workers
      are just as
      qualified as
      psychiatrists to
      diagnose and
      treat emotionally
      disturbed persons

8     Psychiatrists        9.5      90.5      7.6      92.4      0.000
      frequently abuse
      their legal power
      to hospitalise
      patients against
      their will

9     Psychiatrists       33.3      66.7     60.4      39.6      0.001
      make as much
      money as most
      other doctors

10    Psychiatry has a     69        31      32.1      67.9      0.000
      low prestige
      among the general
      public

11    Psychiatry has a    40.5      59.5     71.7      28.3      0.018
      high status among
      other medical
      disciplines

12    Family              21.4      78.6     37.8      62.2      0.027
      discouraging from
      specialising in
      Psychiatry

13    I would feel        21.4      78.6     26.4      73.6      0.100
      uncomfortable
      with mentally ill
      persons

14    No effort was        69        31      24.5      75.5      0.000
      made to encourage
      them to become
      psychiatrists at
      their medical
      school

P-value <0.05 considered significant

Figure 1

Preferred Career Choice

                        Percentage

Undecided                  17.9

No response                15.8

Others                      4.2

Radiology                   1.1

Dermatology                 7.4

Anesthesia                  2.1

Psychiatry                  1.1

OBG                        18.9

Surgery and allied          4.2
Specialties

Pediatrics                  7.4

Internal medicine          20

Note: Table made from bar graph.
COPYRIGHT 2018 Akshantala Enterprises Private Limited
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2018 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Original Research Article
Author:Mohammed, Sajad; Francis, Yesudas Kalathara; Divakaran, Binoo
Publication:Journal of Evolution of Medical and Dental Sciences
Article Type:Report
Geographic Code:9INDI
Date:Jan 8, 2018
Words:3226
Previous Article:THORACIC EPIDURAL ANAESTHESIA FOR MODIFIED RADICAL MASTECTOMY IN CARCINOMA BREAST CASES--A RETROSPECTIVE DESCRIPTIVE STUDY.
Next Article:USE OF ECG AND OTHER CLINICAL VARIABLES FOR DETECTING PULMONARY HYPERTENSION IN COPD PATIENTS--A CROSS-SECTIONAL OBSERVATIONAL STUDY.
Topics:

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2020 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters