A nursing education era ends: Judy Kilpatrick's career has encompassed--and shaped--many changes in nursing education.
The head of the University of Auckland's (UoA) nursing school since its foundation in 1999 retires this month after a nursing career spanning close to five decades. That career began at Christchurch Hospital in January 1968. She had always intended going to university --law or teaching history appealed. But on a whim one day, after she'd left school, she wandered past the hospital, went in, asked about nursing and emerged signed up for the next intake.
There's nostalgia as she recalls her student days under the apprenticeship model of training, which was "lovely and appalling". Students were a significant part of the nursing workforce and "we bungled through, taking advice from slightly more senior nurses. The attrition rates were terrible and we were so young". But she learned to take responsibility and there were other compensations. "Living in the nursing home meant there was always someone to debrief with, to drink coffee with late into the night. I still have friends from those days."
Ironically, the woman who has been a champion of tertiary-based education for nursing and a powerful advocate for postgraduate nursing education, loved her hospital-based training. She has never regretted her on-a-whim career choice.
Rising through the ranks
After graduating, she went into accident and emergency (A&E) nursing, quickly rising through the ranks to become charge nurse at Green Lane Hospital's A&E department before becoming senior supervisor at the hospital. "I worked under Matron Margaret Taylor who allowed you to have a go. We introduced primary nursing and nurses were allowed to set their own rosters. That was unheard of; that power previously resided with charge nurses who could punish a recalcitrant nurse with a ghastly roster. It was a great place to work and Margaret Taylor was a wonderful mentor."
Her "teaching urge" remained and she started teaching Auckland and Green Lane Hospital nursing students. After a year at Wellington's School of Advanced Nursing Studies, she returned to clinical practice at Green Lane Hospital.
In 1981, she "took the plunge and joined Yvonne Shadbolt's small team at the then Auckland Technical Institute (ATI)". This new breed of nursing students, educated in tertiary institutions rather than hospitals, were still considered "weird beasts".
Shadbolt was another great mentor who encouraged Kilpatrick and gave her plenty of opportunities. She rose through the ranks at ATI, subsequently Auckland Institute of Technology and then Auckland University of Technology (AUT), from course supervisor to associate head to head of school. "I never escaped from teaching."
Kilpatrick has been a dominant and, at times, divisive figure in nursing education, unconcerned about attracting flak and passionate about university-delivered postgraduate education and advanced practice. And, as the head of the nursing school at Ara, Cathy Andrew, pointed out, able to navigate the political minefields of education and health.
There's a fearlessness about her. Head of Victoria University's graduate school of nursing and midwifery Kathy Holloway said Kilpatrick was not afraid to lead change from the front and "to strategically challenge the status quo with charm and wit".
Behind the garrulous, laughing and seemingly casual persona is a tough intellect--"I'm smart rather than intelligent" --and an entrepreneurial spirit. She also has the ability to grasp the big picture--"I'm not a details person" and see where and how nursing should best position itself.
That fearlessness and her ability to discern trends, have seen her champion advanced practice and, in her time as Nursing Council chair from 1996 to 2002, guide the development of the nurse practitioner (NP) role. She was chair of the council when the country's first NP, Deborah Harris, was registered.
A latter-day successor at AUT, current head of school Stephen Neville, says as a young nurse he was "in awe of this tall, articulate and passionate woman who was fearless in her defence and support of the development of advanced nursing practice roles".
Holloway said Kilpatrick was "a trailblazer and policy entrepreneur" who raised political awareness of the importance of advanced nursing practice. "Her voice will be missed in those conversations," she said.
Kilpatrick remains convinced that getting that "top layer of expert clinician, the NP, right," has meant other specialist clinical roles have developed. "All other roles have fallen out of that because the career pathway--from degree entry to top clinician--is in place, and where other roles fit on that pathway is clear. Nurses can choose how far they want to progress on that pathway. Not everybody wants to be an NP."
Professor of nursing at Massey University Jenny Carryer describes Kilpatrick as a "larger-than-life leader" who has used determination, humour and vision to power through many important changes for nursing. "Her contribution has been huge and long-standing," she said.
Postgraduate education was an essential component of the nursing pathway and, in her role as head of the UoA's nursing school, Kilpatrick has driven that agenda hard. As the inaugural head of a nursing school set up within an established medical school, she was criticised by some who feared a return to doctor-dominated nursing education. And that's another skill--an ability to work alongside medical colleagues--"I love the docs"--while also challenging their power and their stranglehold on funding, particularly in primary health care.
Establishing the nursing school at the UoA, now within the Faculty of Medical and Health Sciences, has enhanced inter-professional education and collaboration, strengthened nursing's scientific foundation and placed postgraduate nursing education within "the normal academic framework", she says. This semester the school has 1200 postgraduate nursing students and "a small but perfectly formed" undergraduate programme, with 100 first-year students.
Kilpatrick is adamant postgraduate nursing education should be delivered in universities--"the resources to underpin that education are available there". The exposure to other disciplines is "marvellous and brings confidence. Nursing has been too insular for too long".
Referring to funding for postgraduate education, she says "nurses sometimes forget how lucky they are. Most nursing postgraduate study is funded--course fees through Health Workforce New Zealand and study leave through DHBs. And postgraduate study means nurses are equipped to apply for more senior positions, which attract more money."
But she has "total admiration" for the time and dedication so many nurses spend on that education.
On undergraduate education, she says there's no risk of a two-tier system developing between university--or institute of technology-prepared students. "The undergraduate programme can be taught at both." She sees institutes of technology as the natural place for health care assistant and enrolled nurse programmes. She's convinced enrolled nursing is going to come back into its own. "Universities aren't going to provide those courses. That's not being elitist; it's about encouraging institutions to do the stuff they're really good at."
She thinks there are too many undergraduate nursing schools. "But in smaller centres, they give people an opportunity to get educated in their home town and give second-chance learners a way of getting a degree. And at some institutes, the nursing programme is the only course holding those places up."
She's not convinced every nurse should be guaranteed a job at the end of their degree. "What other profession--apart from doctors--expects a job at the end of their training? Most get a job within a year of finishing their education."
Speaking more generally about the profession, she bemoans the fact nursing takes itself "terribly seriously" and would dearly love it to "lighten up". She'd also dearly love nurses to be far more politically savvy. "You've got to be political if you are going to make change."
And nurses "have stayed out of the money game" to their detriment. "That unwillingness held up the development of the NP role."
She's glad chief nursing officer Jane O'Malley has gathered a team of nurses around her and sits on the Ministry of Health's executive leadership team. It's "disgraceful and unacceptable" that not all directors of nursing (DoNs) are on their district health boards' (DHBs) executive leadership teams. Kilpatrick would love all DoNs to have responsibility for nursing budgets. "Very few do and it is apparent which ones do, because they bring a different strength to the job."
She's bewildered by "the way nurses turn on themselves. What the hell is that all about?" she asks. There are lessons to be learned from doctors, whose squabbling "all happens behind closed doors". Answering her own question, she believes the "highly-stressed" health system is one reason, and also the lack of joy in that system. "When I was nursing, it was a joyous occasion when someone was discharged fully recovered. Now we send people home who are still quite sick, so the joy of seeing someone go home well is missing."
As she faces retirement and acknowledges the profession's progress, she admits funding remains a stumbling block to innovation and truly autonomous practice. "Funding models, particularly in primary care, have to change, to enable both nurses and GPs to work at the top of their scopes. Funding for nursing has been an issue as long as I can remember."
She's going to miss the education milieu "terribly. I've really loved my working life and have no regrets at all. But it's time to move on."
Neville says, in the years since he was in awe of her, "we have gotten to know each other well and I appreciate her significant contribution to our profession."
Life in retirement includes a partner, a year-old grandson in Melbourne, a lifestyle block in Kumeu, a beach house at Mangawhai and some voluntary work. But she doesn't rule out some future involvement in the profession that has been her lifeblood. "I'm not actively looking but if something comes along that I can turn my hand to, I may be interested."
By co-editor Teresa O'Connor
Caption: Judy Kilpatrick who retires this month.
Caption: Judy Kilpatrick when she began at AIT in 1981.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Publication:||Kai Tiaki: Nursing New Zealand|
|Date:||Apr 1, 2017|
|Previous Article:||From Belarus to Whangarei.|
|Next Article:||Canvassing views on assisted dying.|