# A broadband out-of-phase power divider for high power applications using through ground via (TGV).

1. INTRODUCTIONRF subsystems are composed of many components [1-4]. Among these passive and active devices, power dividers are fundamental and important ones. Thus far, the Wilkinson power divider is the most widely used kind [5-13] since it features low insertion loss, perfect isolation, all ports matching and other advanced performances. Unfortunately, they are not suitable for balanced-circuits such as balanced mixers, multi-pliers and push-pull amplifiers due to their IN-PHASE responses. To achieve the out-of-phase features, much research has been conducted and different balanced transmission lines have been investigated [14-17]. For instance, microstrip-slot lines [14] and asymmetrical coplanar striplines (ACPSs) [15] are used to design out-of-phase power dividers. Recently, the double-sided parallel-strip line (DSPSL) becomes very popular in out-of-phase power divider designs. Both single- [16] and dual-band [17] power dividers have been presented by using DSPSLs. However, the isolation resistors of these dividers are integrated in the middle of the substrate, which makes the heat-sinking difficult. This drawback limits their high-power applications. To improve the power-handling capability, the authors have developed a novel power divider with external isolation resistors in [18]. The isolation resistors are directly grounded for heat dissipation, where they can be easily mounted on the cooling systems by adding a transmission line of the same characteristic impedance. However, the frequency ratio (m) of the power divider only covers the range of 1.62 < m < 3. Meanwhile, the designed power divider is limited to achieve narrow bandwidth responses, which is the main restriction for potential industrial applications.

Therefore, in this paper, we propose a novel design of the power dividers to overcome the drawback of the limited band-width. The proposed power divider consists of a novel dual-band impedance matching network with two external isolation resistors. The resistors are grounded with a direct path for heat sinking. A through ground via (TGV), connecting both sides of the DSPSLs, is employed. The special via is realized to makes the isolation resistors shorted at full-frequency band when odd-mode is excited. Meanwhile, it can be ignored when the excitation is even-mode. This property is efficiently utilized to obtain broadband matching and isolation features. To analytically investigate the proposed power divider, a set of designed equations are derived base on the even- and odd-mode analysis method. For practical design process, design charts are also proposed by using these analytical equations. It is found that the proposed power divider can operate at two frequencies [f.sub.1] and [mf.sub.1] with a frequency ratio range at 1 < m < 1.7. By choosing the proper frequency ratio, the proposed broadband power divider can be designed. For verification, an example power divider with frequency ratio of 1.4:1 is implemented. The measured results show that a bandwidth of 630 MHz (44.3%) with better than 15 dB return loss and 18dB port isolation is obtained. Since the proposed power divider simultaneously has the advanced performances including broadband matching/isolation, out-of-phase feature and high power capability, it is a perfect candidate for balanced high-power applications.

2. INVESTIGATION OF THROUGH GROUND VIA

Figure 1(a) shows the conventional DSPSL with a mid-inserted conductor plane as common ground. A metal via connects the top and bottom sides of the DSPSL at the reference face T-T' through the mid-inserted common ground. It is named as Through Ground Via (TGV). Therefore, at the reference face T-T', the voltage on the both sides of the DSPSL is equal.

For odd-mode excitation, the mid-inserted plane can be regarded as infinite ground [18,19]. And the voltage along the DSPSL has identical amplitude but opposite phase. Thus, the voltage at the reference face T-T' must be equal to zero. The equivalent circuit is shown in Figure 1(b). This property can be used to short the isolation resistors loaded at the reference face T-T', when odd-mode is excited.

For even-mode excitation, the voltage along the DSPSL has identical amplitude and phase. Thus, the TGV has no effect on the DSPSL and the equivalent circuit is shown in Figure 1(c). Emphatically, the defect of the mid-inserted plane is ignored since its dimension is very small compared the guided wavelength.

In addition, all the analysis above is frequency independent. This point can be utilized to improve the matching and isolation bandwidth in power divider designs.

3. CONFIGURATION AND ANALYSIS OF THE PROPOSED POWER DIVIDER

Figure 2(a) shows the configuration of the proposed broadband power divider. It consists of several sections of DSPSLs, two external isolation resistors, and a mid-inserted conductor plane as well as a through ground via (TGV). As discussed in [17, 19], the conductor plane segregates the DSPSLs to back-to-back microstrip lines, where it also acts as the common ground of the two output ports. Two circuits on the top and bottom layers have identical sizes, and all transmission lines have the same electrical length ([theta]). Figure 2(b) illustrates the dimensions of the top/bottom circuits. Since the proposed power divider is symmetrical, we can use even- and odd-mode method to extract the circuit parameters from the matching/isolation conditions. For convenience, all the impedance values in this paper are normalized with respect to input/output ports impedance ([Z.sub.0] = 50 [OMEGA]).

3.1. Odd-mode Analysis

For the odd-mode analysis, the mid-inserted plane can be regarded as the infinite ground, and the impedance of port 1 is split to be half of the initial value [17-19]. Meanwhile, the voltages along the transmission lines on the top and bottom layers have the same magnitude and opposite phase. Since the TGV connects the DSPSLs together, the voltage of the DSPSLs at the plane F-F' has satisfied to be zero. In this case, the isolation resistors are shorted and the odd-mode equivalent circuit of the proposed power divider can be simplified as shown in Figure 3. Emphatically, all the impedance parameters ([z.sub.1], [z.sub.2], [z.sub.3]), in this paper, represent the values of microstrip lines.

Mathematically, the ABC D matrix of the two-port network can be calculated as [20]

[MATHEMATICAL EXPRESSION NOT REPRODUCIBLE IN ASCII] (1)

where

A = [cos.sup.2 (2a)][theta] - [[z.sub.1]/[z.sub.2]][sin.sup.2][theta] + [[z.sub.2]/[z.sub.3]][cos.sup.2][theta] + [[z.sub.1]/[z.sub.3]][cos.sup.2][theta] (1)

B = j([z.sub.1] + [z.sub.2])sin [theta] cos [theta] (2b)

C = j(1/[z.sub.1] + 1/[z.sub.2])sin [theta] cos [theta] + j[[z.sub.2]/[z.sub.1][z.sub.3]]sin [theta] cos [theta] - j[1/[z.sub.3]][[cos.sup.2] [theta]/tan [theta]] (2c)

D = -[[z.sub.2]/[z.sub.1]][sin.sup.2] [theta] + [cos.sup.2] [theta] (2d)

Subsequently, the input impedance of the circuit may thus be expressed as

[z.sub.in] = A + B/C + D (3)

Then, the matching condition at port 1 becomes

[z.sub.in] = 1/2 (4)

By combining (2)-(4), we obtain

[z.sub.2] = -b + [square root of [b.sup.2]] - 4ac]/2a (5a)

[z.sub.3] = 2([z.sub.1] + [z.sub.2])/(2[[z.sub.1]/[z.sub.2]] - [z.sub.2]/[z.sub.1])[tan.sup.2] [theta] - 1 (5b)

where

a = 4 + [tan.sup.2] [theta]/[z.sup.2.sub.1] (6a)

b = 8[z.sub.1] - 2/[z.sub.1] (6b)

c = 4[z.sup.2.sub.1] - 2 [tan.sup.2] [theta] - 1/[tan.sup.2] [theta] - 4 (6c)

To fulfill the dual-band impedance matching condition, the electrical length ([theta]) of the transmission lines at [f.sub.1] should be satisfied as [21]

[theta] = [pi]/1 + m (7)

where m is the frequency ratio of the dual-band operation.

Consequently, the impedances of [z.sub.2] and [z.sub.3] can be uniquely determined for some chosen [z.sub.1] once the designed frequency ratio is m given.

3.2. Even-mode Analysis

For the even-mode analysis, the two signals along the transmission lines on the top and bottom layers have the same magnitude and phase. Therefore, the TGV can be ignored since it has no effect on the DSPSL. Besides, there is also no current flowing through the input load and the input port can be regarded as an open circuit. In this case, the even-mode equivalent circuit of the proposed power divider can be simplified as shown in Figure 4.

Based on the transmission line theory, the input impedances can be expressed as

[z.sub.in1] = [z.sub.1]/j tan [theta] (8a)

[z.sub.in2] = [z.sub.2][[z.sub.in1] + j[z.sub.2] tan [theta]/[z.sub.2] + j[z.sub.in1] tan [theta]] (8b)

[z'.sub.in2] = [z.sub.in2]/1 + [z.sub.in2] (8c)

[z.sub.in3] = [z.sub.3][[z'.sub.in2] + j[z.sub.3] tan [theta]/[z.sub.3] + j[z'.sub.in2] tan [theta]] (8d)

The matching condition becomes

[(1/1/r + 1/j[z.sub.4] tan [theta]).sup.*] = [z.sub.in3] (9)

By separating the real and imaginary parts of Equation (9), the designed parameters of r and z4 can be achieved as

r = 1/Re([z.sup.-1.sub.in3]) (10a)

[z.sub.4] = 1/tan [theta] x Im ([z.sup.-1.sub.in3]) (10b)

3.3. Analysis of Broadband Characteristics

Combining (5)-(8) and (10), we can obtain that the circuit parameters ([z.sub.2], [z.sub.3], [z.sub.4], r) are functions of the frequency ratio m once the value of z1 is fixed. For some typical values of [z.sub.1] ([z.sub.1] = 0.75, 0.8, 0.85, 0.9), the corresponding design parameters against the frequency ratio m = [f.sub.1]/[f.sub.2] can be calculated by using MATLAB. Numerical results are achieved as shown in Figure 5, which can be used as the design charts.

Assuming that the available impedance values are in the range of 10 [OMEGA] < [Z.sub.i] < 150 [OMEGA], the normalized impedance values have the range of 0.2 < [z.sub.i] < 3. Therefore, a frequency ratio range covering 1 < m < 1.7 can be obtained from Figure 5(c). This range can be complementary with that of the power divider presented in [18].

For instance, we employ Figure 5(b), as the design chart, to investigate the broadband characteristic of the proposed power divider. The circuit parameters under different frequency ratios are calculated as shown in Table 1. The transmission and reflection coefficients of the proposed power divider can be calculated by [18, 21]

[S.sub.11] = [S.sup.o.sub.11] (11a)

[S.sub.21] = [S.sub.31] = [square root of [S.sup.o2.sub.21]] (11b)

[S.sub.22] = [S.sub.33] = [S.sup.e.sub.22] + [S.sup.o.sub.22]/2 (11c)

[S.sub.32] = [S.sup.o.sub.22] - [S.sup.e.sub.22]/2 (11d)

Therefore, the corresponding calculated results of the power divider are obtained as shown in Figure 6.

It is obvious that the proposed power divider can operate at broadband response when proper frequency ratios are adopted. In Figure 6, we can find that the maximum bandwidth with 15 dB return loss/port isolation is achieved when the frequency ratio m is nearly equal to 1.4.

3.4. Analysis of Power Dissipation

The power-handling capabilities of the power dividers mainly depend on how the isolation resistors handle the generated heat. As discussed in [18, 21-24], power dividers with external isolation resistors have high power handling advantage over those with internal isolation resistors. This is because external isolation resistors can be easily mounted on the cooling systems with good thermal conductivity by adding a transmission line of the same characteristic impedance between the resistor and heat sink.

Besides the advantage of high power handling capability in operation bands, the proposed power divider presents another advantage out of the operation band. As presented in [18,21-24], the external isolation resistors are generally shorted by transmission lines. Thus, the out-of-band signal power will be partly dissipated on the isolation resistors since the shorting condition is frequency-dependent. In this design, the isolation resistors are shorted by TGV at full-frequency band. Therefore, no power is dissipated on the isolation resistors. This property ensures the proposed power divider has a high power capacity both in and out of the operation bands.

4. SIMULATION AND MEASUREMENT

To validate the previous analysis, an experimental power divider is implemented in this section. The divider is fabricated on two sandwiched Rogers 4350 substrates with the relative dielectric constant of 3.48, a thickness of 0.76 mm, and a loss tangent of 0.004.

Typical parameters of the designed power divider are given as follows:

[Z.sub.0] = 50[OMEGA], [f.sub.1] = 1.25 GHz, [f.sub.2] = 1.75 GHz, m = 1.4

The design parameters can be obtained from Table 1 and the desired electrical length of the transmission lines is calculated to be 75[degrees] based on Equation (7). The physical dimensions of the circuit are achieved as illustrated in Table 2 by using the simulator Ansoft Designer. For the actual implementation, the component of R = 51[OMEGA] is adopted in this design.

The photograph of the fabricated power divider is shown in Figure 7. The simulation and measurement are accomplished by using Ansoft simulator HFSS and Agilent 8358E network analyzer, respectively. Figures 8(a)-(c) compare the calculated, simulated and measured results. The measured return loss ([S.sub.11], [S.sub.22]) and isolation ([S.sub.32]) are below -15dB/-18dB from 1.11GHz to 1.74GHz (FBW: 44.3%). The maximum insertion loss during the corresponding band is measured to be 3.7dB. Furthermore, the measured phase difference between the two output ports is in the range of 180[degrees] [+ or -] 6[degrees] from 1.11 GHz to 1.74 GHz as shown in Figure 9.

The proposed power divider is compared with previous out-of-phase dividers in Table 3. It can be found that the proposed divider has a wider bandwidth. Meanwhile, the isolation resistance is shorted by TGV at full-frequency band. It also means no power is dissipated on the isolation resistors at full-frequency band. This property ensures the proposed power divider has a high power capacity both in and out of the operation bands.

5. CONCLUSION

In this paper, a novel broadband out-of-phase power divider has been presented. The proposed power divider employs the external isolation resistors, which have advantages in heat sinking and largely enhance the power-handling capability. A through ground via (TGV) is investigated. And a novel dual-band impedance matching structure is developed. Besides, analytical equations have been derived and several design charts are given. In Section 4, an experimental power divider, operating a bandwidth of 630 MHz (44.3%) with better than 15 dB return loss and 18 dB port isolation is implemented. The good agreement between simulated and measured results has been achieved, validating the proposed methodology. This power divider will be very useful for the high-power balanced systems and push-pull applications.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) under Projects 61201072 and 61274110, by the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities under Projects 2011QNA5022.

REFERENCES

[1.] Kuo, J.-T., C.-Y. Fan, and S.-C. Tang, "Dual-wideband bandpass filters with extended stopband based on coupled-line and coupled three-line resonators," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 124, 1-15, 2012.

[2.] Wong, Y. S., S. Y. Zheng, and W. S. Chan, "Multifolded bandwidth branch line coupler with filtering characteristic using coupled port feeding," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 118, 17-35, 2011.

[3.] Kuo, J.-T. and C.-H. Tsai, "Generalized synthesis of rat race ring coupler and its application to circuit miniaturization," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 108, 51-64, 2010.

[4.] Wu, Y., Y. Liu, and S. Li, "An unequal dual-frequency Wilkinson power divider with optional isolation structure," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 91, 393-411, 2009.

[5.] Wilkinson, E., "An N-way hybrid power divider," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 8, No. 1, 116-118, Jan. 1960.

[6.] Deng, P.-H., J.-H. Guo, and W.-C. Kuo, "New Wilkinson power dividers based on compact stepped-impedance transmission lines and shunt open stubs," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 123, 407-426, 2012.

[7.] Wu, Y. and Y. Liu, "An unequal coupled-line Wilkinson power divider for arbitrary terminated impedances," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 117, 181-194, 2011.

[8.] Chang, L., C. Liao, L.-L. Chen, W. Lin, X. Zheng, and Y.-L. Wu, "Design of an ultra-wideband power divider via the coarse-grained parallel micro-genetic algorithm," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 124, 425-440, 2012.

[9.] Ip, W. C. and K. K. M. Cheng, "A novel unequal power divider design with dual-harmonic rejection and simple structure," IEEE. Microw. Wireless Compon. Lett., Vol. 21, No. 4, 182-184, Apr. 2011.

[10.] Li, J., Y. Wu, Y. Liu, J. Shen, S. Li, and C. Yu, "A generalized coupled-line dual-band Wilkinson power divider with extended ports," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 129, 197-214, 2012.

[11.] Wu, Y., Y. Liu, Y. Zhang, J. Gao, and H. Zhou, "A dual band unequal Wilkinson power divider without reactive components," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 57, No. 1, 216-222, Jan. 2009.

[12.] Al-Zayed, A. S. and S. F. Mahmoud, "Seven ports power divider with various power division ratios," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 114, 383-393, 2011.

[13.] Park, M. J., "Dual-band Wilkinson divider with coupled output port extensions," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 57, No. 9, 2232-2237, Sep. 2009.

[14.] Ogawa, H., T. Hirota, and M. Aikawa, "New MIC power divider using coupled microstrip-slot lines: Two-sided MIC power divider," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 33, No. 11, 1155-1164, Nov. 1985.

[15.] Fan, L. and K. Chang, "A 180[degrees] out-of-phase power divider using asymmetrical coplanar stripline," IEEE Microw. Guid. Wave Lett., Vol. 6, No. 11, 404-406, Nov. 1996.

[16.] Chen, J. X., C. H. K. Chin, K. W. Lau, and Q. Xue, "180[degrees] out-of-phase power divider based on double-sided parallel striplines," Electronics Lett., Vol. 42, No. 21, Oct. 2006.

[17.] Yang, T., J. X. Chen, X. Y. Zhang, and Q. Xue, "A dual-band out-of-phase power divider," IEEE Microw. Wireless Compon. Lett., Vol. 18, No. 3, 188-190, Mar. 2008.

[18.] Dai, G. L., X. C. Wei, E. P. Li, and M. Y. Xia, "Novel dual-band out-of-phase power divider with high power-handling capability," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 60, No. 8, 2403-2409, Aug. 2012.

[19.] Chen, J. X., C. H. K. Chin, and Q. Xue, "Double-sided parallel-strip line with an inserted conductor plane and its applications," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 55, No. 9, 1899-1904, Sep. 2007.

[20.] Pozar, D. M., Microwave Engineering, 3rd edition, 307-310, Wiley, New York, 2005.

[21.] Zhang, H., X.-W. Shi, F. Wei, and L. Xu, "Compact wideband Gysel power divider with arbitrary power division based on patch type structure," Progress In Electromagnetics Research, Vol. 119, 395-406, 2011.

[22.] Sun, Z., L. Zhang, Y. Yan, and H. Yang, "Design of unequal dual-band Gysel power divider with arbitrary termination resistance," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 59, No. 8, 1955-1962, Aug. 2011.

[23.] Oraizi, H. and A. R. Sharifi, "Optimum design of a wideband two-way Gysel power divider with source to load impedance matching," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 57, No. 9, 2238-2248, Sep. 2009.

[24.] Oraizi, H. and A. R. Sharifi, "Optimum design of asymmetrical multi-section two-way power dividers with arbitrary power division and impedance matching," IEEE Trans. Microw. Theory Tech., Vol. 59, No. 6, 1478-1490, Jun. 2011.

Yunlong Lu (1, 3), Gaole Dai (1, 2, 4), *, Xingchang Wei (1), and Erping Li (1)

(1) Department of Information Science and Electronic Engineering, Zhejiang University, Hangzhou 310027, China

(2) Ningbo Institute of Materials Technology & Engineering, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Ningbo 315201, China

(3) Hangzhou RFID Research Center, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Hangzhou 310011, China

(4) The State Key Laboratory of Millimeter Waves, Nanjing 210096, China

Received 7 January 2013, Accepted 2 February 2013, Scheduled 8 March 2013

* Corresponding author: Gaole Dai (daigaole@nimte.ac.cn).

Table 1. Normalized circuit parameters of the proposed power divider under different frequency ratios. Frequency m = 1.1 m = 1.2 m = 1.4 m = 1.6 Ratio [z.sub.1] 0.8 0.8 0.8 0.8 [z.sub.2] 1.1187 1.0866 0.9947 0.8980 [z.sub.3] 0.8224 0.8345 0.8782 0.9479 [z.sub.4] 0.3686 0.4251 0.7119 1.7792 r 0.7012 0.7944 1.2046 2.1459 Table 2. Dimensions of the experimental power divider. [W.sub.1] = 2.405 mm [W.sub.2] = 1.732 mm [W.sub.3] = 2.097 mm [W.sub.4] = 2.838 mm [L.sub.1] = 29.8 mm [L.sub.2] = 30.225 mm [L.sub.3] = 29.975 mm [L.sub.4] = 29.6 mm R = 60.23 [OMEGA] Table 3. Comparison with previous out-of-phase power dividers. Ref. Power division [14] equal [15] equal [16] equal [17] equal [18] equal This work equal Ref. Isolation resistance [14] Internal Isolation Resistance [15] Internal Isolation Resistance [16] Internal Isolation Resistance [17] Internal Isolation Resistance [18] External Isolation Resistance This work External Isolation Resistance Ref. 15-dB isolation Bandwidth [14] 11.3% [15] 9.5% [16] 58.6% [17] Dual-band (34.5%/15.5%) [18] Dual-band (10.4%/4.2%) This work 44.3% Ref. Heat sinking [14] Not Easy [15] Not Easy [16] Not Easy [17] Not Easy [18] Easy This work Easy Ref. Phase Difference [14] Out-of-Phase [15] Out-of-Phase [16] Out-of-Phase [17] Out-of-Phase [18] Out-of-Phase This work Out-of-Phase Ref. -- [14] -- [15] -- [16] -- [17] -- [18] -- This work --

Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback | |

Author: | Lu, Yunlong; Dai, Gaole; Wei, Xingchang; Li, Erping |
---|---|

Publication: | Progress In Electromagnetics Research |

Article Type: | Report |

Geographic Code: | 9CHIN |

Date: | May 1, 2013 |

Words: | 3601 |

Previous Article: | A synchronous wideband frequency-domain method for long-distance channel measurement. |

Next Article: | Modeling SAR images based on a generalized gamma distribution for texture component. |

Topics: |