A Transplant "Compromise" - Washington Post Editorial - April 19.
The organ network has fought fiercely against any change, and it has lots of allies, mainly in states that 'harvest' a lot of organs and don't want to share them. A system weighted less toward location would result in those centers shipping more of 'their' organs to large hospital centers where patients in need of immediate transplant tend to cluster.
The Senate compromise doesn't address who should get organs; rather, it would send disagreements between HHS and the organ network to an 'appeals board' picked by transplant professionals, the independent Institute of Medicine (which is on record of favoring changes) and the government. How long this process would delay any actual changes in transplant practice is anyone's guess, but it could be years-besides needlessly diluting the legal authority to set organ policy that HHS quite properly claims to have already. That raises the question of why the administration has signed on. Nor is it obvious that the Kennedy-Frist compromise can avoid further watering down; Sen. Russell Feingold of Wisconsin has blocked even this bill from quick consideration, saying he has 'misgivings' about the appeals board's makeup. Wisconsin just happens to be suing to block the HHS rule that would allow 'its' organs to be sent out of state.
That rule, which went into effect March 16, was supposed to set changers in motion, with the government and the organ network cooperating to improve distribution. The new round of machinations slows that process to a crawl. Meanwhile, patients awaiting transplants die at the rate of 10 a day. Their lives are being squandered for the purest and pettiest of self-interested and political reasons-this on an issue that you'd thing would strike at least some players, somewhere, as transcending parochial concerns."
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Date:||Apr 28, 2000|
|Previous Article:||Specter vows to block NOTA bill if changes made in conference with House.|
|Next Article:||Commentary Frist-Kennedy bill offers transplant community and the Secretary what every good fight needs--the ability to save face, declare victory,...|