Printer Friendly

A Review of Black Salve: Cancer Specificity, Cure, and Cosmesis.

1. Introduction

Complementary and alternative medicines (CAM) encompass a wide range of popular health interventions [1]. Self-reported use of CAM from surveys across North America, Europe, and Australia shows a high level of use with 35 to 69% of respondents having used CAM in the preceeding 12 months [2-4].

Patients with dermatological conditions more heavily utilize CAM than the general population, with 12-month prevalence figures of 49% versus 36% in 2002 [5] and 85% versus 38% in 2007[6]. Despite conventional therapies having high cure rates for skin malignancies, a number of patients are opting to manage their skin cancers with CAM [7]. While the extent of this practice is yet to be determined, patients are motivated by a preference for natural therapies and a perception of lower toxicity for CAM compared to orthodox treatment modalities [8].

Despite questions regarding the effectiveness of CAM therapies [9] and their general lack of systematic scientific testing [10], herbal medicines should not be dismissed without consideration. Natural products have been a vital source of anticancer pharmaceuticals, with 49% of oncology small molecules discovered since 1940 being either unaltered or direct derivatives of natural compounds [11]. Due to the molecular diversity and structural complexity of natural products compared to synthetic compound libraries, there is renewed interest in natural product drug discovery [12].

Concerns however exist about the lack of regulatory control over the natural therapy sector and how this impacts quality control and patient safety [13]. Although used as medicines, regulators in some countries treat herbal therapies as dietary supplements [14]. Unlike pharmaceutical products, manufacturers are not always required to provide safety or efficacy evidence to regulators before their product can be sold to patients [15]. To better inform clinicians and patients, this literature review seeks to assess some of the health claims made regarding black salve.

2. Black Salve as a Natural Therapy

Blacksalve was originally developed by an American surgeon, Jesse Fell, its use first reported in the 1850s [16]. Fell had heard of a plant growing on the shores of Lake Superior used by Native Americans to treat cancer (reviewed in [17]). He identified it as S. canadensis, combining it with zinc chloride to make a cancer salve known as Fells' paste [18]. Since then, other entrepreneurs have developed topical cancer therapies based on these two core ingredients, today's formulations being known as black salve [19].

Referred to as "Natures Scalpel" [20], it is important to assess the veracity of black salves' natural credentials. Consumers often believe natural therapies are safe, having the ability to heal with a low risk of toxicity [21]. Portraying black salve as a natural product appeals to this naturalness bias, which in turn may increase black salve utilization by CAM users.

Black salves usually contain bloodroot, the rhizome of Sanguinaria canadensis. Manufacturers have differing formulations that may also contain chaparral (Larrea mexicana), graviola (Annona muricata), oleander (Nerium oleander), galangal (Alpinia officinarum), ginger (Zingiber officinale), red clover (Trifolium pratense), sheep sorrel (Rumex acetosella), burdock (Arctium lappa), pokeroot (Phytolacca decandra), and turmeric (Curcuma longa) [22-25].

Apart from its botanical ingredients, black salve contains zinc chloride (Zn[Cl.sub.2]) with some formulations also containing dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO). Zn[Cl.sub.2]is a chemical usually manufactured from zinc and hydrochloric acid and does not occur naturally apart from the very rare mineral simonkolleite [Zn.sub.5][(OH).sub.8] [Cl.sub.2][H.sub.2]O [26]. Zn[Cl.sub.2] is widely used for industrial processes such as textile manufacture and metallurgical fluxes for soldering galvanized iron [27]. The Zn[Cl.sub.2] contained in black salve is a synthesized chemical and in some preparations the main ingredient by weight [28].

DMSO is added to enhance the epidermal penetration of some black salve formulations. Although trace amounts of DMSO may be naturally found in cereals, fruits, and vegetables [29], DMSO is commercially manufactured from lignin, a byproduct of paper production [30]. DMSOs' chemical synthesis utilizes lignins free methyl radicals; these are coupled to sulphur and then oxidized [31].

Patients seeking natural skin cancer therapies may not realize black salve contains significant quantities of synthetic chemicals. This knowledge may alter the treatment choices of CAM patients, a population often wanting to reduce their exposure to unnatural compounds [56].

3. Black Salve Cancer Specificity and Normal Tissue Toxicity

Black salve is promoted as a safe skin cancer therapy, able to discriminate between cancerous and healthy tissue [57]. There are concerns about the accuracy of this claim with cases of extensive tissue necrosis reported in the literature from black salve use [38, 58]. Two explanations may account for this finding. Treated cancers were more extensive than they appeared clinically, or, in addition to having a destructive effect on malignant tissue, black salve can also cause normal tissue necrosis.

As a therapeutic product containing multiple bioactive compounds, the discriminating ability of black salve can be gauged by the cytotoxic potential of its individual constituents against malignant and normal cells. S. canadensis, known as bloodroot because of the red latex of its rhizome, is an important component of blacksalve [17]. Native Americans called the plant puccoon and used it as a traditional medicine to treat a variety of conditions including cancer [18].

Bloodroot rhizomes predominantly contain a number of quaternary benzophenanthridine alkaloids (QBA) in addition to protopin alkaloids [59]. These plant defence toxins target multiple cellular pathways [60], being able to intercalate with DNA [61] and RNA [62-64], alter gene expression through the epigenetic modification of chromatin and core histones [65], inhibit microtubules needed for cell division [66], and generate oxidative stress [67].

Several studies have compared the antiproliferative and cytotoxic effects of these alkaloids against normal and malignant cells in vitro. In 2000, Ahmad et al. reported that sanguinarine had preferential, concentration dependent tumour cytotoxicity when tested against the A431 epidermoid carcinoma cell line and normal human epidermal keratinocytes derived from foreskin. At 2 [micro]M, sanguinarine induced 60% cytotoxicity in A431 cells compared to 10.8% in normal keratinocytes. However 5 [micro]M sanguinarine caused 65% cytotoxicity in A431 cells compared to 38.3% in normal keratinocytes representing a loss of discrimination [34].

Contradictory results however have shown sanguinarine to have greater cytotoxicity against normal skin fibroblasts compared to the same A431 squamous cancer cell line [32]. This suggests that sensitivity to sanguinarine cytotoxicity depends more on target cell characteristics than whether the exposed cells are malignant or benign. After 24-hour exposure to the two main bloodroot alkaloids sanguinarine and chelerythrine gingival fibroblasts have shown low [IC.sub.50] values of 1.2 [micro]M and 4.7 [micro]M, respectively [33,68] (Figure 1). Various cancer cell lines in these studies showed greater resistance to sanguinarine cytotoxicity than nonmalignant cells, further undermining the argument that sanguinarine has tumour specific cytotoxicity. Similar results from four biologically active S. canadensis minor quaternary benzophenanthridine alkaloids (minor QBAs) also frequently showed greater nonmalignant cell cytotoxicity (Figure 2).

The mechanism of sanguinarine cytotoxicity has not been fully elucidated and appears to vary for different cell types. In squamous carcinoma cells, sanguinarine induces cell death by apoptosis, while, in keratinocytes, sanguinarine induces cell death bynecrosis [34]. Several apoptotic molecular pathways have been implicated such as caspase 3 and 7 activation in PC3 prostate cancer cells, rapid GSH depletion in murine L929 fibroblasts [68], and reduced bcl-2 with increased BH3 interacting domain death agonist (Bid) and proapoptotic B cell lymphoma 2 associated X protein (Bax) levels in gingival fibroblasts [69].

As epidermal keratinocytes provide a barrier to environmental toxins, they contain antioxidant levels 200% higher than those found in fibroblasts [70]. Oxidative stress has been suggested as a key mechanism of sanguinarine action [71], with the greater resistance to sanguinarine cytotoxicity of epidermal keratinocytes ([IC.sub.50] 10 [micro]M) compared to fibroblasts ([IC.sub.50] 1.2 [micro]M) possibly due to the increased antioxidant reserve of these cells.

Zn[Cl.sub.2] also has well described cytotoxicity against L929 murine fibroblast cultures, having an [IC.sub.50] of 0.928 [micro]M, classifying it as a highly cytotoxic metal salt [36]. At high concentrations of 80 [micro]g/mL or 0.6 mM, Zn[Cl.sub.2] exposure results in 40% HLE B-3 human epithelial cell death by either apoptosis or necrosis [72]. Thus, current in vitro evidence suggests the two main ingredients of black salve, bloodroot and Zn[Cl.sub.2], are indiscriminate in their cytotoxic action at concentrations that may be present in black salve preparations.

Black salves contain additional botanical ingredients that may also have normal cell cytotoxicity (Table 1). Chaparral (Larrea tridentata) leaves contain multiple phytochemicals including nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA), a polyphenol lignin that constitutes 5-10% of leaf dry weight [73]. HaCaT immortalized human keratinocytes exposed to 150 [micro]M of NDGA undergo apoptosis indicated by a complete disappearance of poly (ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP) [37]. Some black salves contain 17% NDGA by weight [28]. Graviola (Annona muricata) leaves are a rich source of acetogenin (AGEs) long chain fatty acids. Over 100 AGEs have so far been identified in the plant, many with promising antitumour activity [74]. Cytotoxicity has been reported with an A. muricata extract against WRL-68 normal hepatic cells, with an [IC.sub.50] of 52.4 [micro]g/mL [75]. Oleander (Nerium oleander) may also be a constituent and contains antitumour cardiac glycosides [76] such as oleandrin [77]. Oleandrin at concentrations of 0.6 [micro]g/mL (1.04 [micro]M) did not have a cytotoxic effect on isolated human peripheral blood mononuclear cells or neutrophils [78] but normal cell cytotoxicity has not been assessed at higher concentrations.

As a natural product, the alkaloid composition of S. canadensis shows natural variation, being influenced by a number of environmental and genetic factors [79, 80]. Bloodroot rhizomes have been shown to have an up to fifteenfold variation in sanguinarine concentration [81]. When natural products are incorporated into therapeutic agents, it is often difficult to control the concentration and stability of the active ingredients to which patients are exposed. Even if sanguinarine has a narrow window of preferential tumour cell cytotoxicity, with the [IC.sub.50] of A431 epidermoid carcinoma cells being 0.7 [micro]g/mL and normal human epidermal keratinocytes being 3.7 [micro]g/mL [82], small variations in black salve sanguinarine concentration could result in normal cell cytotoxicity. Surprisingly the chemical analysis of black salve has only been reported once in the literature, this being from a single sample with no quantitative analysis performed [47]. Currently the black salve constituent concentration range patients may be exposed to is unknown.

With a number of black salve constituents possessing in vitro normal cell cytotoxicity at low concentrations, health claims regarding black salve tumour specificity appear false. Normal cell cytotoxicity is usually assessed with single agent or single botanical source in vitro assays. Complex herbal formulations such as black salve present a challenge for assessing their cytotoxic potential. Different compounds and botanical extracts may have antagonistic or synergistic effects of relevance to black salve therapeutic efficacy and toxicity.

3.1. In Vivo Evidence of Nonselectivity: Histology. Studies that have examined the histopathology of skin following the application of black salve are also counter to claims of a discriminating destructive action. Treated areas typically develop an eschar of dead tissue that sloughs off approximately ten days after salve application, leaving an ulcer [42]. Histologically these ulcers are surrounded by necrosis, suppurative inflammation, and limited residual viable tissue [44]. Moreover, extensive tissue necrosis has been found to develop from the epidermis to the dermis and into subcutaneous tissues [83]. Histological examination of a detached eschar following black salve administration showed it to contain both malignant and normal tissue, contradicting the claim that black salve only damages cancer cells [42].

Black salve may have other pathological implications and has been shown to induce cellular and structural atypia in tissues that can mimic malignancy [83]. In a series of sixteen black salve treated lesions, pathologists needed to perform immunohistochemistry on seven lesions (44%) due to concerning histological features such as atypical spindled cells and necrotic melanocyte containing architecture [44]. Although initially used by patients to treat skin lesions, black salve can result in collateral clinical and histological pseudomalignancies that pose diagnostic challenges.

3.2. In Vivo Evidence of Nonselectivity: Mohs Paste. In 1941, Mohs and Guyer, while investigating the reaction of cancerous and normal tissues to various irritants, observed that a 20% solution of Zn[Cl.sub.2] chemically killed both benign and malignant tissues while maintaining their microscopic structure [84]. Mohs spent four years developing and testing a fixative paste that would histologically preserve human tissue in a controlled manner. The paste functions like a reservoir that slowly releases Zn[Cl.sub.2], the depth of tissue death and fixation determined by the thickness, and surface area of paste application [85].

With standard skin cancer surgery, 1-2% of surgical margins are histologically examined [86]. Mohs believed histological examination of the entire margin for tumour involvement would improve skin cancer cure rates. The Mohs fixed tissue technique involves tumour site fixation with Mohs paste. Horizontal tissue sections are sequentially removed and histologically examined with tumour margin involvement being mapped; further tissue fixative is then applied to persisting tumour until clear margins are obtained [87]. Using the fixed tissue method, Mohs 5-year cure rate, despite a complicated case load where 20% of patients had recurrent disease, was 99.3% for BCC based on 7,257 cases and 94.4% for SCC based on 2,551 cases [88].

In contrast to black salves, where Zn[Cl.sub.2] concentration has not been reported, Mohs fixative paste contains 45.2% Zn[Cl.sub.2] by weight [84]. Small millimetre-scale changes in paste thickness resulted in significant changes to the depth of fixative penetration. To perform its function, Mohs paste fixes and kills both benign and healthy tissue. The Mohs histology slides of 1000s of patients from the past 75 years attest to the indiscriminate toxicity of salves containing Zn[Cl.sub.2] and S. canadensis.

The experience of Mohs fixed tissue technique highlights the potentially destructive power of escharotics. Mohs also used his paste to treat gangrene. Applying a thin 2 mm layer to a gangrenous toe for 24 hours fixed the entire toe, facilitating amputation [89]. In this 24-hour timeframe, tissue destruction to a depth of 2 cm can occur [90], with the rapid penetration rate for some normal tissues like cartilage rendering them more susceptible to excessive tissue damage [87].

Blacksalve has been portrayed as a therapy that selectively destroys tumour cells, enabling it to cure 98-100% of skin cancers with minimal scarring [57]. The indiscriminate in vitro cytotoxicity of both S. canadensis alkaloids and zinc chloride, the histological evidence showing normal tissue necrosis in patients that have used blacksalve, and the adverse event case studies in the medical literature all suggest black salve lacks tumour specificity.

4. Is Black Salve Effective at Curing Skin Cancer?

The literature contains 14 journal articles and abstracts that report the use of black salves derived from S. canadensis in 19 pathology confirmed skin cancers from 15 individuals (Table 2). While case studies cannot determine efficacy or assess toxicity rates, they can provide information about potential toxicities and characterise treatment failures. Black salves have been used to treat melanoma, squamous cell carcinoma (SCC), and basal cell carcinoma (BCC) with varying results as detailed below.

A number of Internet sites suggest that black salve can be used to treat melanoma effectively [91, 92]. The scientific literature does not support this claim. Of the two documented patients that have used black salve to treat melanoma, both developed metastatic disease [38, 39]. One of these patients had a superficial 0.6 mm Breslow thickness melanoma on her calf with an anticipated 12-year survival rate with conventional surgical management of 92.2% [93].

Nonmelanoma skin cancers have also been treated with black salve. Squamoproliferative lesions include two SCCs [40,42] and a keratoacanthoma (KA) [41]. While one patient showed no evidence of persisting SCC on partial biopsy of their black salve treatment site, the other two patients showed persisting malignancy. One presented with a 10 cm diameter scalp SCC with perineural invasion and regional lymph node metastases despite blacksalve application [40].

Basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) have had mixed results when treated by black salve. A total of nine out of 14 BCCs (64%) appeared to be treated successfully. However, only two of these cases had the entire salve treatment area excised and examined histologically [42, 43], with five other cases having a posttreatment biopsy that did not show BCC persistence [44,48]. Two additional cases were clinically free of recurrence at 6 months' [47] and 12 months'follow-up [49], too short a timeframe to determine if the treatment had been curative.

Blacksalve BCC treatment failures resulted in 8-stage and 10-stage Mohs surgery being required to completely remove a scalp and separate nose BCC in one patient [45]. Another patient had a nose BCC recur after apparent resolution with black salve. The tumour infiltrated the maxilla requiring partial maxillectomy; the BCC subsequently metastasized to regional lymph nodes with the patient dying of metastatic BCC despite radical neck lymphadenectomy with adjuvant radiotherapy [43].

Conventional surgical skin cancer management has been assessed in multiple clinical trials, individually involving thousands of patients. These have shown primary BCC cure rates of 95.2% for clinical margin surgery [94] and 99.5% for Mohs Micrographic Surgery [95]. Primary SCC has a 5year recurrence free rate of 94.6% with standard excision [96] and 97.4% with MMS [97]. In melanoma the prognosis varies depending on tumour thickness ranging from a 92% 10-year survival for lesions <1mm thick to a 50% 10-year survival for lesions >4 mm thick [98]. The majority of lesions are thin melanomas [99]. Despite the likely publication bias favouring the reporting of negative outcomes following black salve use in the medical literature, claims that black salve has superior or equivalent efficacy to surgery are currently not substantiated.

Clinicians are trained to assess the risk that skin lesions pose using variables such as histological subtype, lesion location, diameter, and thickness [100]. Compared to surgical excisions which have a 96% cure rate for BCC [101], the topical cream Imiquimod has a clearance rate for superficial and nodular BCC of 85% and 81%, respectively, [102] but only 56% for infiltrating or aggressive BCC subtypes [103]. For this reason the standard of care for aggressive BCC subtypes is surgical excision [104].

Currently the pharmacokinetics of black salve are not known. While surface eschar formation may be reassuring to patients, the depth of its cytotoxic effect has not been determined. Malignancy may persist under black salve scar tissue and extend subcutaneously before becoming clinically apparent [45]. Without an understanding of skin cancer biology and behaviour, unsuitable lesions can be selected by patients for black salve topical treatment, placing them at increased risk of recurrence and metastatic disease.

5. Does Black Salve Cause Less Scarring Than Surgery?

Surgery by primary closure results in healing where wound edges are in apposition. Black salve leaves an open wound that heals by secondary intention. Secondary intention healing begins with basal wound granulation and wound edge contraction followed by subsequent reepithelialization [105]. Zn[Cl.sub.2] escharotics have been used to treat venous ulcers [106] and osteomyelitis [107]. In Mohs surgery the fixative paste provides an infection resistant platform for wound healing with rapid epithelialization where defects of 8 cm diameter have healed completely in six weeks [108].

The cosmetic result for healing by secondary intention depends on the site and size of the defect. With facial wounds, concave areas of the nose, eye, ear, and temple (NEET regions) have cosmetic outcomes often superior to transposition flaps and grafts [109, 110]. Wounds on convex areas such as the nasal tip and nasal ala however heal with poor cosmetic results [111]. Smaller wounds <2cm in diameter predictably heal better than larger wounds, having greater tissue contraction, resulting in less scar tissue deposition [112]. Facial defects involving more than one cosmetic subunit usually have poor cosmetic results with second intention healing [111]. The cosmetic outcome for patients using black salve will depend to some extent on the site, size, and number of cosmetic subunits to which it has been applied. Black salve ulcers are surrounded by inflamed and necrotic tissue [44] from which regeneration tries to occur, the ulcer potentially taking up to 2 years to heal [57].

It is difficult from the available literature to assess definitively the cosmetic outcomes for patients that have used black salve. A standardized measure for cosmesis is not used by authors, with some papers not recording the cosmetic outcome or failing to identify the number of sites where black salve was applied. Within these limitations there are reports relating to a total of 36 patients that have treated 43 skin lesions with black salve. These reports include 19 confirmed malignancies and 24 lesions of either benign histology or where histology was not taken [113,114]. Of these 43 lesions, four lack a comment on cosmesis, five had a persisting tumour, and nine were in the ulcerative stage. The ulcerative stage follows sloughing of the black salve eschar; as an open wound it prevents an assessment of final cosmesis to be made.

Of the 25 lesions that have some cosmetic outcome information documented (Table 3), the cosmetic outcome for two lesions (8% of black salve assessable cases) is reported as fair to good in the literature. In one of these cases where a nasal tip BCC was treated with black salve for eight consecutive days the patient was left with a depressed, irregular scar which the dermatologist authors described as a fair cosmetic outcome [48]. In the other case, where a R nasal sidewall BCC was treated for 6 days with alternating black and yellow salves at a six-month review the patient had a good cosmetic outcome [47].

In thirteen cases (52%) scarring was noted after black salve application without grading cosmesis. These include a large neck eschar that required management with oral and topical corticosteroids [51], a biopsy proven compound naevus on a 35-year-old woman's thigh that developed into a 5 cm granulomatous plaque [52] and a 29-year-old man who developed cheek scarring that required three scar revision surgeries [42]. Two treatment areas (8%) developed keloid scarring [44] with one requiring cosmetic surgery [43], and an additional three treatment areas (12%) had pigmentation changes necessitating histological assessment [44].

The most graphic cosmetic adverse events occurred in five individuals (20%) that suffered deformity as a consequence of black salve use. All five cases involved the nose with two patients losing an ala unit [43, 46] and another suffering a through-and-through nasal alar defect requiring a hinge flap repair [53]. The most extensive destruction however occurred with two female patients having the majority of their nose destroyed by black salve [54, 55]. These individuals subsequently required a number of reconstructive surgical procedures in an attempt to repair the escharotic damage they sustained.

Although selection bias will favour the reporting of adverse events in relation to black salve, it is notable that, of 25 cases available for cosmetic assessment in the literature, only 8% report a good or fair cosmetic outcome. The number of case studies reporting scarring, keloid formation, and disfiguring deformity suggests black salve has the potential to cause significant cosmetic harm. In contrast, of 174 patients undergoing standard excision, 87% rated their cosmetic result as good [115], while 93% of228 patients reported a satisfactory or good rating following Mohs surgery [116]. While portrayed as a cosmetically superior treatment to surgery, black salve's mechanism of action and suspected indiscriminate toxicity suggest this is not the case. Black salve has not spared a number of patients from requiring surgery to correct cosmetic damage or treat persisting malignancy.

6. Discussion

An increasing number of patients are turning to the Internet to provide them with information about healthcare and treatment options [117]. As an unregulated space, there is the potential for inaccurate or misleading claims to result in choices leading to harmful health outcomes [118].

Mohs was aware of the toxicity of black salve type escharotics, where an extra millimetre of salve thickness could result in significant tissue destruction. For this reason he patented his paste [119] to prevent untrained individuals from using it as a blind chemosurgical technique [120]. Some have suggested that Mohs paste, in addition to facilitating the histological excision of skin cancers, may possess immune enhancing effects [121]. Evidence of improved five-year survival rates in Mohs treated melanoma patients compared to a historical standard excision control cohort furthers these claims [122]. This study however did not determine whether salve pharmaceutical effects or the process of microscopic tumour removal was responsible; it also relied on bias prone historical control data. Claims of an immune adjuvant Mohs paste effect are currently therefore unsubstantiated. The benefit of Mohs paste lies not in its action as a cancer killing therapy but rather in its ability to fix tissue, allowing a cancer to be microscopically mapped and removed. The equivalent cure rates of the Mohs fixed tissue technique utilizing Mohs paste, and the subsequently developed Mohs fresh tissue technique without Mohs paste, attest to this fact [123]. Mohs paste has a very limited role in contemporary clinical practice being reserved for skin tumours that invade bone [124], neoplastic pelvic bleeding [125], and palliative local cancer control [126].

A number of bold claims have been made regarding black salve. Currently the evidence does not exist to confirm or dismiss the claim that black salve has a better cure rate than surgery or that it results in a better cosmetic outcome than surgery for patients. This would require a randomized clinical trial, which has not occurred in the 150-year history of black salve use. Substituting highly effective conventional therapies with an unproven alternative such as black salve should not occur outside the framework of a clinical trial.

Regulators have been trying to protect consumers from black salve by policing the claims vendors post on their websites [127] and by making it illegal to import or sell black salve [128]. A number of loopholes however exist in the regulatory framework. Vendors may relocate their operations to countries with reduced regulatory controls [57], black salve ingredients can be legally imported from which patients can manufacture their own salve [129], and black salve veterinary products can be imported and used by humans [130]. While regulation is a valuable pillar in harm prevention, it is failing to limit escharotic salve use to treat skin cancer.

Skin cancer is the most common malignancy in the western world. The annual cost to the US health system from 2007 to 2011 was $8.1 billion, with skin cancer expenditure growing 126.2% over the 5-year period compared to a 25.1% cost increase for all other cancers [131]. In 2007 $34 billion was spent on CAM in the US [6]. With growing demand and an absence of clinical evidence assessing the benefits and risks of blacksalve, patients will continue experimenting. Observational studies and clinical trials offer a mechanism for assessing the efficacy of black salve; they may also facilitate harm minimisation by discouraging black salve use for melanomas, high risk nonmelanoma skin cancers, and obviously benign lesions.

7. Conclusion

Black salve is not a natural therapy. It contains significant concentrations of synthetic chemicals. Black salve does not appear to possess tumour specificity with in vitro and in vivo evidence indicating normal cell toxicity. Blacksalve does appear to cure some skin cancers, although the cure rate for this therapy is currently unknown. The use of black salve should be restricted to clinical research in low risk malignancies located at low risk sites until a better understanding of its efficacy and toxicity is developed. Where a therapy capable of harm is already being used by patients, it is ethically irresponsible not to study and analyse its effects. Although cautionary tales are valuable, black salve research needs to move beyond the case study and into the carefully designed clinical trial arena. Only then can patients be properly informed of its true benefits and hazards.

Competing Interests

The authors declare that they have no conflict of interests.


[1] C. Zollman and A. Vickers, "ABC of complementary medicine: what is complementary medicine?" British Medical Journal, vol. 319, no. 7211, pp. 693-696, 1999.

[2] H. A. Tindle, R. B. Davis, R. S. Phillips, and D. M. Eisenberg, "Trends in use of complementary and alternative medicine by US adults: 1997-2002," Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine, vol. 11, no. 1, pp. 42-49, 2005.

[3] B. Bucker, M. Groenewold, Y. Schoefer, and T. Schafer, "The use of complementary alternative medicine (CAM) in 1 001 German adults: results of a population-based telephone survey," Gesundheitswesen (Bundesverband der Arzte des Offentlichen Gesundheitsdienstes (Germany)), vol. 70, no. 8-9, pp. e29-e36, 2008.

[4] C. C. L. Xue, A. L. Zhang, V. Lin, C. Da Costa, and D. F. Story, "Complementary and alternative medicine use in Australia: a national population-based survey," Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 13, no. 6, pp. 643-650, 2007.

[5] P. M. Barnes, E. Powell-Griner, K. McFann, and R. L. Nahin, "Complementary and alternative medicine use among adults: United States, 2002," Advance Data, no. 343, pp. 1-19, 2002.

[6] P. M. Barnes, B. Bloom, and R. L. Nahin, "Complementary and alternative medicine use among adults and children: United States, 2007," National Health Statistics Reports, no. 12, pp. 1-23, 2008.

[7] N. Smith, D. B. Shin, J. A. Brauer, J. Mao, and J. M. Gelfand, "Use of complementary and alternative medicine among adults with skin disease: results from a national survey," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 60, no. 3, pp. 419-425, 2009.

[8] S. E. Baron, R. G. Goodwin, N. Nicolau, S. Blackford, and V. Goulden, "Use of complementary medicine among outpatients with dermatologic conditions within Yorkshire and South Wales, United Kingdom," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 52, no. 4, pp. 589-594, 2005.

[9] J. D. Berman and S. E. Straus, "Implementing a research agenda for complementary and alternative medicine," Annual Review of Medicine, vol. 55, no. 1, pp. 239-254, 2004.

[10] M. Angell and J. P. Kassirer, "Alternative medicine--the risks of untested and unregulated remedies," New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 339, no. 12, pp. 839-841, 1998.

[11] D. J. Newman and G. M. Cragg, "Natural products as sources of new drugs over the 30 years from 1981 to 2010," Journal of Natural Products, vol. 75, no. 3, pp. 311-335, 2012.

[12] J.-Y. Ortholand and A. Ganesan, "Natural products and combinatorial chemistry: back to the future," Current Opinion in Chemical Biology, vol. 8, no. 3, pp. 271-280, 2004.

[13] S. Bent, "Herbal medicine in the United States: review of efficacy, safety, and regulation--Grand Rounds at University of California, San Francisco Medical Center," Journal of General Internal Medicine, vol. 23, no. 6, pp. 854-859, 2008.

[14] X. Zhang, Regulatory Situation of Herbal Medicines a Worldwide Review, vol. 26, World Health Organization, Geneva, Switzerland, 1998.

[15] S. Board, "Botanical medicines--the need for new regulations," The New England Journal of Medicine, vol. 347, no. 25, 2002.

[16] A. D. M. C. Shaw, C. H. Moore, and M. Henry, "Editorial," Western Lancet, A Monthly Journal of Practical Medicine and Surgery, vol. 18, pp. 541-542, 1857.

[17] A. Croaker, G. King, J. Pyne, S. Anoopkumar-Dukie, and L. Liu, "Sanguinaria canadensis: traditional medicine, phytochemical composition, biological activities and current uses," International Journal of Molecular Sciences, vol. 17, no. 9, article 1414, 2016.

[18] J. W. Fell, "DR. Fell's treatment of cancer," The Lancet, vol. 70, no. 1785, p. 507, 1857.

[19] D. M. Elston, "Escharotic agents, Fred Mohs, and Harry Hoxsey," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 523-525, 2005.

[20] Natures Scalpel,

[21] F. L. Bishop, L. Yardley, and G. T. Lewith, "Why do people use different forms of complementary medicine? Multivariate associations between treatment and illness beliefs and complementary medicine use," Psychology & Health, vol. 21, no. 5, pp. 683-698, 2006.

[22] Alpha Omega Labs, salve.html?SID=713077897fa03d416e83f0408ebbe831.

[23] Best on Earth Black Salve, Black-Salve.

[24] Virxcan-X Blog,

[25] Herbal Plus Black Salve,

[26] K. Schmetzer, G. Schnorrer-Kohler, and O. Medenbach, "Wulfingite, epsilon-Zn(OH)2, and simonkolleite, Zn5(OH)8Cl2.H2O, two new minerals from Richelsdorf, Hesse, F.R.G.," Neues Jahrbuch fur Mineralogie, Monatshefte, no. 4, pp. 145-154, 1985.

[27] M. K. Jha, V Kumar, and R. J. Singh, "Review of hydrometallurgical recovery of zinc from industrial wastes," Resources, Conservation and Recycling, vol. 33, no. 1, pp. 1-22, 2001.

[28] Alpha Omega Labs, 266-cansema-black-topical-salve-22g.

[29] T. W. Pearson, H. J. Dawson, and H. B. Lackey, "Naturally occurring levels of dimethyl sulfoxide in selected fruits, vegetables, grains, and beverages," Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry, vol. 29, no. 5, pp. 1089-1091, 1981.

[30] K. Capriotti and J. A. Capriotti, "Dimethyl sulfoxide: history, chemistry, and clinical utility in dermatology," Journal of Clinical and Aesthetic Dermatology, vol. 5, no. 9, pp. 24-26, 2012.

[31] N. A. David, "The pharmacology of dimethyl sulfoxide," Annual review of pharmacology, vol. 12, pp. 353-374, 1972.

[32] I. Slaninova, Z. Slunska, J. Sinkora, M. Vlkova, and E. Taborska, "Screening of minor benzo(c.)phenanthridine alkaloids for antiproliferative and apoptotic activities," Pharmaceutical Biology, vol. 45, no. 2, pp. 131-139, 2007.

[33] J. Malikova, A. Zdarilova, A. Hlobilkova, and J. Ulrichova, "The effect of chelerythrine on cell growth, apoptosis, and cell cycle in human normal and cancer cells in comparison with sanguinarine," Cell Biology and Toxicology, vol. 22, no. 6, pp. 439-453, 2006.

[34] N. Ahmad, S. Gupta, M. M. Husain, K. M. Heiskanen, and H. Mukhtar, "Differential antiproliferative and apoptotic response of sanguinarine for cancer cells versus normal cells," Clinical Cancer Research, vol. 6, no. 4, pp. 1524-1528, 2000.

[35] Z. Slunska, E. Gelnarova, J. Hammerova, E. Taborska, and I. Slaninova, "Effect of quaternary benzo[c]phenanthridine alkaloids sanguilutine and chelilutine on normal and cancer cells," Toxicology in Vitro, vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 697-706, 2010.

[36] A. Yamamoto, R. Honma, and M. Sumita, "Cytotoxicity evaluation of 43 metal salts using murine fibroblasts and osteoblastic cells," Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, vol. 39, no. 2, pp. 331-340, 1998.

[37] J. Pachernik, A. Hampl, K. Soucek et al., "Multiple biological effects of inhibitors of arachidonic acid metabolism on human keratinocytes," Archives of Dermatological Research, vol. 293, no. 12, pp. 626-633, 2002.

[38] J. J. Cienki and L. Zaret, "An Internet misadventure: bloodroot salve toxicity," Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 16, no. 10, pp. 1125-1127, 2010.

[39] G. Sivyer and C. Rosendahl, "Application of black salve to a thin melanoma that subsequently progressed to metastatic melanoma: a case study," Dermatology Practical & Conceptual, vol. 4, no. 3, pp. 77-80, 2014.

[40] L. Ma, J. W. Dharamsi, and T. Vandergriff, "Black salve as self-treatment for cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma," Dermatitis, vol. 23, no. 5, pp. 239-240, 2012.

[41] J. M. Tan, P. Peters, N. Ong, B. Shepherd, and H. P. Soyer, "Histopathological features after topical black salve application," Australasian Journal of Dermatology, vol. 56, pp. 75-76, 2015.

[42] C. W. Brown, G. D. Goldstein, and C. S. Birkby, "," Dermatologic Surgery, vol. 27, no. 11, pp. 975-978, 2001.

[43] S. McDaniel and G. D. Goldman, "Consequences of using escharotic agents as primary treatment for nonmelanoma skin cancer," Archives of Dermatology, vol. 138, no. 12, pp. 1593-1596, 2002.

[44] T. N. Leecy, T. W. Beer, N. T. Harvey et al., "Histopathological features associated with application of black salve to cutaneous lesions: a series of 16 cases and review of the literature," Pathology, vol. 45, no. 7, pp. 670-674, 2013.

[45] N. Jellinek and M. E. Maloney, "Escharotic and other botanical agents for the treatment of skin cancer: a review," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 487-495, 2005.

[46] K. L. Eastman, L. V. Mcfarland, and G. J. Raugi, "A review of topical corrosive black salve," Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, vol. 20, no. 4, pp. 284-289, 2014.

[47] S. S. Osswald, D. M. Elston, M. F. Farley, J. G. Alberti, S. C. Cordero, and V. F. Kalasinsky, "Self-treatment of a basal cell carcinoma with 'black and yellow salve'," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 509-511, 2005.

[48] A. G. Affleck and S. Varma, "A case of do-it-yourself Mohs' surgery using bloodroot obtained from the internet," British Journal of Dermatology, vol. 157, no. 5, pp. 1078-1079, 2007.

[49] F. Saltzberg, G. Barron, and N. Fenske, "Deforming self-treatment with herbal 'black salve'," Dermatologic Surgery, vol. 35, no. 7, pp. 1152-1154, 2009.

[50] A. G. Affleck and S. Varma, "A case of do-it-yourself Mohs' surgery using bloodroot obtained from the internet [23]," British Journal of Dermatology, vol. 157, no. 5, pp. 1078-1079, 2007.

[51] M. J. Schlichte, C. P. Downing, M. Ramirez-Fort, R. Gordon, and S. Tyring, "Bloodroot associated eschar," Dermatology Online Journal, vol. 20, no. 7, 2014.

[52] J. L. Hou and J. D. Brewer, "Black salve and bloodroot extract in dermatologic conditions," Cutis, vol. 95, no. 6, pp. 309-311, 2015.

[53] K. Bickle and R. G. Bennett, "Combined hinge flap full-thickness skin graft for a through-and-through nasal defect," Dermatologic Surgery, vol. 34, no. 3, pp. 389-392, 2008.

[54] Disciplinary Action against Jerome Craft MD, in Florida Medical Board Disciplinary Action against Jerome Craft MD,

[55] The United States District Court for the Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division Case No. 1:03-CV-1183 LJMWTL, 2004.

[56] F. L. Bishop, L. Yardley, and G. T. Lewith, "A systematic review of beliefs involved in the use of complementary and alternative medicine," Journal of Health Psychology, vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 851-867, 2007.

[57] Cansema and Escharotics FAQ, faq101.htm.

[58] N. C. Ong, E. Sham, and B. M. Adams, "Use of unlicensed black salve for cutaneous malignancy," Medical Journal of Australia, vol. 200, no. 6, p. 314, 2014.

[59] J. Slavik and L. Slavikova, "Alkaloide der mohngewachse (Papaveraceae) XVII. Ua ber neue alkaloide aus Sanguinaria canadensis L.," Collection of Czechoslovak Chemical Communications, vol. 25, no. 6, pp. 1667-1675, 1960.

[60] M. Wink, T. Schmeller, and B. Latz-Briining, "Modes of action of allelochemical alkaloids: interaction with neuroreceptors, DNA, and other molecular targets," Journal of Chemical Ecology, vol. 24, no. 11, pp. 1881-1937, 1998.

[61] L.-P. Bai, Z.-Z. Zhao, Z. Cai, and Z.-H. Jiang, "DNA-binding affinities and sequence selectivity of quaternary benzophenanthridine alkaloids sanguinarine, chelerythrine, and nitidine," Bioorganic and Medicinal Chemistry, vol. 14, no. 16, pp. 5439-5445, 2006.

[62] S. R. Chowdhury, M. M. Islam, and G. S. Kumar, "Binding of the anticancer alkaloid sanguinarine to double stranded RNAs: insights into the structural and energetics aspects," Molecular BioSystems, vol 6, no. 7, pp. 1265-1276, 2010.

[63] P. Giri and G. S. Kumar, "Specific binding and self-structure induction to poly(A) by the cytotoxic plant alkaloid sanguinarine," Biochimica et Biophysica Acta--General Subjects, vol. 1770, no. 9, pp. 1419-1426, 2007.

[64] M. Hossain, A. Kabir, and G. S. Kumar, "Binding of the anticancer alkaloid sanguinarine with [tRNA.sup.phe]: spectroscopic and calorimetric studies," Journal of Biomolecular Structure and Dynamics, vol. 30, no. 2, pp. 223-234, 2012.

[65] R. Selvi B, S. K. Pradhan, J. Shandilya et al., "Sanguinarine interacts with chromatin, modulates epigenetic modifications, and transcription in the context of chromatin," Chemistry & Biology, vol. 16, no. 2, pp. 203-216, 2009.

[66] M. Lopus and D. Panda, "The benzophenanthridine alkaloid sanguinarine perturbs microtubule assembly dynamics through tubulin binding: a possible mechanism for its antiproliferative activity," FEBS Journal, vol. 273, no. 10, pp. 2139-2150, 2006.

[67] A. Burgeiro, A. C. Bento, C. Gajate, P. J. Oliveira, and F. Mollinedo, "Rapid human melanoma cell death induced by sanguinarine through oxidative stress," European Journal of Pharmacology, vol. 705, no. 1-3, pp. 109-118, 2013.

[68] E. Debiton, J.-C. Madelmont, J. Legault, and C. Barthomeuf, "Sanguinarine-induced apoptosis is associated with an early and severe cellular glutathione depletion," Cancer Chemotherapy and Pharmacology, vol. 51, no. 6, pp. 474-482, 2003.

[69] J. Malikova, A. Zdarilova, and A. Hlobilkova, "Effects of sanguinarine and chelerythrine on the cell cycle and apoptosis," Biomedical Papers of the Medical Faculty of the University Palacky, Olomouc, Czechoslovakia, vol. 150, no. 1, pp. 5-12, 2006.

[70] M.-T. Leccia, M.-J. Richard, F. Joanny-Crisci, and J.-C. Beani, "UV-A1 cytotoxicity and antioxidant defence in keratinocytes and fibroblasts," European Journal of Dermatology, vol. 8, no. 7, pp. 478-482, 1998.

[71] S. S. Matkar, L. A. Wrischnik, and U. Hellmann-Blumberg, "Production of hydrogen peroxide and redox cycling can explain how sanguinarine and chelerythrine induce rapid apoptosis," Archives of Biochemistry and Biophysics, vol. 477, no. 1, pp. 43-52, 2008.

[72] Y. Du, D. Guo, Q. Wu, D. Liu, and H. Bi, "Zinc chloride inhibits human lens epithelial cell migration and proliferation involved in TGF-[beta]1 and TNF-[alpha] signaling pathways in HLE B-3 cells," Biological Trace Element Research, vol. 159, no. 1, pp. 425-433, 2014.

[73] J.-M. Lu, J. Nurko, S. M. Weakley et al., "Molecular mechanisms and clinical applications of nordihydroguaiaretic acid (NDGA) and its derivatives: an update," Medical Science Monitor, vol. 16, no. 5, pp. Ra93-Ra100, 2010.

[74] N. H. Oberlies, C.-J. Chang, and J. L. McLaughlin, "Structure-activity relationships of diverse annonaceous acetogenins against multidrug resistant human mammary adenocarcinoma (MCF-7/Adr) cells," Journal of Medicinal Chemistry, vol. 40, no. 13, pp. 2102-2106, 1997.

[75] V. Cijo George, D. R. Naveen Kumar, V. Rajkumar, P. K. Suresh, and R. Ashok Kumar, "Quantitative assessment of the relative antineoplastic potential of the n-butanolic leaf extract of Annona Muricata Linn. in normal and immortalized human cell lines," Asian Pacific Journal of Cancer Prevention, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 699-704, 2012.

[76] S. K. Manna, N. K. Sah, R. A. Newman, A. Cisneros, and B. B. Aggarwal, "Oleandrin suppresses activation of nuclear transcription factor-[kappa]B, activator protein-1, and c-Jun NH2terminal kinase," Cancer Research, vol. 60, no. 14, pp. 3838-3847, 2000.

[77] M. S. Karawya, S. I. Balbaa, and S. E. Khayyal, "Estimation of cardenolides in Nerium oleander," Planta Medica, vol. 23, no. 1, pp. 70-73, 1973.

[78] Y. Sreenivasan, A. Sarkar, and S. K. Manna, "Oleandrin suppresses activation of nuclear transcription factor-[kappa]B and activator protein-1 and potentiates apoptosis induced by ceramide," Biochemical Pharmacology, vol. 66, no. 11, pp. 2223-2239, 2003.

[79] A. K. Salmore and M. D. Hunter, "Environmental and genotypic influences on isoquinoline alkaloid content in Sanguinaria canadensis," Journal of Chemical Ecology, vol. 27, no. 9, pp. 1729-1747, 2001.

[80] A. K. Salmore and M. D. Hunter, "Elevational trends in defense chemistry, vegetation, and reproduction in Sanguinaria canadensis," Journal of Chemical Ecology, vol. 27, no. 9, pp. 1713-1727, 2001.

[81] B. C. Bennett, C. R. Bell, and R. T. Boulware, "Geographic variation in alkaloid content of Sanguinaria canadensis (Papaveraceae)," Rhodora, vol. 92, pp. 57-69, 1990.

[82] I. Slaninova, K. PCncikova, J. Urbanova, J. Slanina, and E. Taborska, "Antitumour activities of sanguinarine and related alkaloids," Phytochemistry Reviews, vol. 13, no. 1, pp. 51-68, 2014.

[83] A. M. Moran and K. F. Helm, "Histopathologic findings and diagnostic difficulties posed with use of escharotic agents for treatment of skin lesions: a case report and review of the literature," Journal of Cutaneous Pathology, vol. 35, no. 4, pp. 404-406, 2008.

[84] F. E. Mohs and M. F. Guyer, "Pre-excisional fixation of tissues in the treatment of cancer in rats," Cancer Research, vol. 1, no. 1, pp. 49-51, 1941.

[85] F. E. Mohs, "Chemosurgery: a microscopically controlled method of cancer excision," Archives of Surgery, vol. 42, no. 2, pp. 279-295, 1941.

[86] A. Kimyai-Asadi, L. H. Goldberg, and M. H. Jih, "Accuracy of serial transverse cross-sections in detecting residual basal cell carcinoma at the surgical margins of an elliptical excision specimen," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 53, no. 3, pp. 468-473, 2005.

[87] F. E. Mohs and R. Caruso, "Chemosurgery and skin cancer," AORN journal, vol. 13, no. 2, pp. 89-97, 1971.

[88] F. E. Mohs, "Chemosurgery for the microscopically controlled excision of cutaneous cancer," Head and Neck Surgery, vol. 1, no. 2, pp. 150-166, 1978.

[89] F. E. Mohs, Chemosurgery in Cancer, Gangrene and Infections, Featuring a New Method for the Microscopically Controlled Excision of Cancer, Thomas, Springfield, Ill, USA, 1956.

[90] F. E. Mohs, "Chemosurgical amputation for gangrene," Surgery, vol. 57, no. 2, pp. 247-253, 1965.

[91] Cancer Compass Website, http://cancercompassalternateroute .com/therapies/black-salve/.

[92] Doctors Are Dangerous, articles/skincancer.htm.

[93] A. Maurichi, R. Miceli, T. Camerini et al., "Prediction of survival in patients with thin melanoma: results from a multi-institution study," Journal of Clinical Oncology, vol. 32, no. 23, pp. 2479-2485, 2014.

[94] M. K. Silverman, A. W. Kopf, R. S. Bart, C. M. Grin, and M. S. Levenstein, "Recurrence rates of treated basal cell carcinomas. Part 3: surgical excision," Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 18, no. 6, pp. 471-476, 1992.

[95] T. Wetzig, M. Woitek, K. Eichhorn, J. C. Simon, and U. Paasch, "Surgical excision of basal cell carcinoma with complete margin control: outcome at 5-year follow-up," Dermatology, vol. 220, no. 4, pp. 363-369, 2010.

[96] L. Lansbury, F. Bath-Hextall, W. Perkins, W. Stanton, and J. Leonardi-Bee, "Interventions for non-metastatic squamous cell carcinoma of the skin: systematic review and pooled analysis of observational studies," BMJ (Online), vol. 347, article f6153, 2013.

[97] I. Leibovitch, S. C. Huilgol, D. Selva, D. Hill, S. Richards, and R. Paver, "Cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma treated with Mohs micrographic surgery in Australia I. Experience over 10 years," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 53, no. 2, pp. 253-260, 2005.

[98] C. M. Balch, J. E. Gershenwald, S.-J. Soong et al., "Final version of 2009 AJCC melanoma staging and classification," Journal of Clinical Oncology, vol. 27, no. 36, pp. 6199-6206, 2009.

[99] D. C. Whiteman, P. D. Baade, and C. M. Olsen, "More people die from thin melanomas (< 1 mm) than from thick melanomas (> 4 mm) in Queensland, Australia," The Journal of Investigative Dermatology, vol. 135, no. 4, pp. 1190-1193, 2015.

[100] J.-C. Martinez and C. C. Otley, "The management of melanoma and nonmelanoma skin cancer: a review for the primary care physician," Mayo Clinic Proceedings, vol. 76, no. 12, pp. 1253-1265, 2001.

[101] K. Mosterd, G. A. Krekels, F. H. Nieman et al., "Surgical excision versus Mohs' micrographic surgery for primary and recurrent basal-cell carcinoma of the face: a prospective randomised controlled trial with 5-years' follow-up," The Lancet Oncology, vol. 9, no. 12, pp. 1149-1156, 2008.

[102] F. Bath-Hextall, M. Ozolins, S. J. Armstrong et al., "Surgical excision versus imiquimod 5% cream for nodular and superficial basal-cell carcinoma (SINS): a multicentre, non-inferiority, randomised controlled trial," The Lancet Oncology, vol. 15, no. 1, pp. 96-105, 2014.

[103] W. E. Love, J. D. Bernhard, and J. S. Bordeaux, "Topical imiquimod or fluorouracil therapy for basal and squamous cell carcinoma: a systematic review," Archives of Dermatology, vol. 145, no. 12, pp. 1431-1438, 2009.

[104] N. R. Telfer, G. B. Colver, and C. A. Morton, "Guidelines for the management of basal cell carcinoma," British Journal of Dermatology, vol. 159, no. 1, pp. 35-48, 2008.

[105] A. E. Rivera and J. M. Spencer, "Clinical aspects of full-thickness wound healing," Clinics in Dermatology, vol. 25, no. 1, pp. 39-48, 2007.

[106] V. Falanga and M. Iriondo, "Zinc chloride paste for the debridement of chronic leg ulcers," Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 16, no. 7, pp. 658-661, 1990.

[107] R. G. Bennett and M. P. Goldman, "Chemosurgical debridement of osteomyelitic bone by zinc chloride fixative," Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 13, no. 7, pp. 771-775, 1987.

[108] J. B. Moles and B. C. Ghosh, "Chemosurgery for basal cell carcinoma," The Journal of the American Medical Association, vol. 210, no. 9, pp. 1759-1761, 1969.

[109] J. A. Zitelli, "Secondary intention healing: an alternative to surgical repair," Clinics in Dermatology, vol. 2, no. 3, pp. 92-106, 1984.

[110] G. Bernstein, "Healing by secondary intention," Dermatologic Clinics, vol. 7, no. 4, pp. 645-660, 1989.

[111] F. F. Becker, "Secondary healing after Mohs chemosurgery," Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, vol. 90, no. 1, pp. 142-143, 1992.

[112] P. A. Van Der Eerden, P. J. F. M. Lohuis, A. A. M. Hart, W. C. Mulder, and H. Vuyk, "Secondary intention healing after excision of nonmelanoma skin cancer of the head and neck: statistical evaluation of prognostic values of wound characteristics and final cosmetic results," Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, vol. 122, no. 6, pp. 1747-1755, 2008.

[113] M. Kalavala and C. Mills, "Bloodroot: an ancient remedy in modern times," in British Journal of Dermatology, Blackwell, Oxford, UK, 2007.

[114] K. Krishnamurthy, C. Hoffman, and J. Del Priore, "Bloodroot necrosis," Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, vol. 60, no. 3, supplement 1, p. AB44, 2009.

[115] J. Y. Petit, M. F. Avril, A. Margulis et al., "Evaluation of cosmetic results of a randomized trial comparing surgery and radiotherapy in the treatment of basal cell carcinoma of the face," Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, vol. 105, no. 7, pp. 2544-2551, 2000.

[116] A.-M. Wennberg, O. Larko, and B. Stenquist, "Five-year results of Mohs' micrographic surgery for aggressive facial basal cell carcinoma in Sweden," Acta Dermato-Venereologica, vol. 79, no. 5, pp. 370-372, 1999.

[117] G. J. Huang and D. F. Penson, "Internet health resources and the cancer patient," Cancer Investigation, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 202-207, 2008.

[118] A. Molassiotis and M. Xu, "Quality and safety issues of web-based information about herbal medicines in the treatment of cancer," Complementary Therapies in Medicine, vol. 12, no. 4, pp. 217-227, 2004.

[119] "Composition of matter for the chemical fixation of diseased tissue preparatory for surgical removal," Google Patents, 1944.

[120] L. B. Trost and P. L. Bailin, "History of Mohs surgery," Dermatologic Clinics, vol. 29, no. 2, pp. 135-139, 2011.

[121] R. S. Kalish, J. A. Wood, D. M. Siegel, V. N. Kaye, and N. A. Brooks, "Experimental rationale for treatment of high-risk human melanoma with zinc chloride fixative paste. Increased resistance to tumor challenge in murine melanoma model," Dermatologic Surgery, vol. 24, no. 9, pp. 1021-1025, 1998.

[122] N. A. Brooks, "Fixed-tissue micrographic surgery in the treatment of cutaneous melanoma: an overlooked cancer treatment strategy," Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 18, no. 11, pp. 999-1001, 1992.

[123] F. E. Mohs, "Chemosurgery for skin cancer: fixed tissue and fresh tissue techniques," Archives of Dermatology, vol. 112, no. 2, pp. 211-215, 1976.

[124] M. Braun III, "The case of Mohs' surgery by the fixed-tissue technique," Journal of Dermatologic Surgery and Oncology, vol. 7, no. 8, pp. 634-640, 1981.

[125] S. Yanazume, H. Douzono, Y. Yanazume, K. Iio, and T. Douchi, "New hemostatic method using Mohs' paste for fatal genital bleeding in advanced cervical cancer," Gynecologic Oncology Case Reports, vol. 4, pp. 47-49, 2013.

[126] N. Nakai, Y. Okuzawa, and N. Katoh, "Clinical usefulness of Mohs' chemosurgery for palliative purposes in patients with cutaneous squamous cell carcinoma with risk factors or without indication for surgery: three case reports," The Journal of Dermatology, vol. 42, no. 4, pp. 405-407, 2015.

[127] FDA Letter TriHerba,

[128] A. Government, Black Salve, Red Salve and Cansema, Edited by Department of Health and Ageing, Therapeutic Goods Administration, 2012.

[129] "How to Make Black Salve (Cansema) for Yourself," http://www

[130] "Black Salve Use on Animals,"

[131] G. P. Guy, S. R. Machlin, D. U. Ekwueme, and K. R. Yabroff, "Prevalence and costs of skin cancer treatment in the U.S., 2002-2006 and 2007-2011," American Journal of Preventive Medicine, vol. 48, no. 2, pp. 183-187, 2015.

Andrew Croaker, (1,2) Graham J. King, (1) John H. Pyne, (3) Shailendra Anoopkumar-Dukie, (4) and Lei Liu (1)

(1) Southern Cross Plant Science, Southern Cross University, Lismore, NSW 2480, Australia

(2) Wesley Medical Research Institute, Wesley Hospital, Auchenflower, QLD 4066, Australia

(3) School of Medicine, University of Queensland, St Lucia, QLD 4072, Australia

(4) School of Pharmacy, Griffith University, Gold Coast Campus, Gold Coast, QLD 4222, Australia

Correspondence should be addressed to Andrew Croaker; and Lei Liu;

Received 23 September 2016; Accepted 28 December 2016; Published 26 January 2017

Academic Editor: Bhushan Patwardhan
Table 1: Black salve constituent normal cell cytotoxicity.

Compound         Cell type                  IC50([micro]M)    Ref

                 Skin fibroblasts KF-II            1          [32]
Sanguinarine     Gingival fibroblasts             1.2         [33]
                 Epidermal keratinocytes          10          [34]

Chelerythrine    Skin fibroblasts KF-II           1.5         [32]
                 Gingival fibroblasts             4.7         [33]

Sanguilutine     Lung fibroblasts                 1.2         [35]

Chelilutine      Lung fibroblasts                 1.7         [35]

Sanguirubine     Skin fibroblasts KF-II          0.53         [32]

Chelirubine      Skin fibroblast KF-II            0.5         [32]

Zinc chloride    Murine fibroblast               0.93         [36]

NDGA             HaCaT keratinocytes              150         [37]

Table 2: Black salve skin cancer treatment clinical outcomes.

Cancer       Number of    Outcome                             Ref
type         cases

Melanoma     2            2 metastatic melanomas              [38, 39]

                          1 metastatic SCC                    [40]
SCC          3            1 persisting SCC                    [41]
                          1 recurrence-free histologically    [42]

                          1 metastatic BCC                    [43]
BCC          14           4 persisting BCC                    [44-46]
                          3 recurrence-free clinically        [47-49]
                          6 recurrence-free histologically    [42-44]

Table 3: Black salve cosmetic results.

Cosmetic outcome                   Number of cases    Ref

Fair to good                              2           [47, 50]
Scarring                                  13          [42, 51, 52]
Keloid scarring                           2           [43, 44]
Concerning pigmentation changes           3           [44]
Deformity                                 5           [43, 46, 53-55]

Figure 1: Major QBA cytotoxicity against normal and malignant cells
24 hr incubation. Data from [34,69,71]. Cell line: GF: gingival
fibroblast; EK: epidermal keratinocyte; MDA-MB231: breast; HCT116:
bowel; OVCAR-3: ovarian; A431: SCC; Du-145: prostate; MCF-7:
breast; LNCaP: prostate.

                  Cell line

                Normal   Malignant


GF              1.2
MDA-MB231               1.6
HCT116                  1.8
OVCAR-3                 1.8
A431                    2.0
DU-145                  2.3
MCF-7                   4.4
LNCaP                   6.3
EK              10


GF              4.7
DU-145                  6.0
LNCaP                   22

Note: Table made from bar graph.

Figure 2: Minor QBA cytotoxicity against normal and malignant cells
72 hr incubation. Data from [32,35]. Cell line: LF: lung
fibroblast; SF: skin fibroblast; HL60: leukaemia; A-2780: ovarian;
HeLa: cervical; A431: SCC.

                  Cell line

                Normal   Malignant


HL-60                    0.1
A-2780                   0.2
HeLa                     1.1
LF               1.2


HL-60                    0.4
LF               1.7
A-2780                   1.7
HeLa                     2.2


HL-60                    0.3
SF               0.5
HeLA                     1.6
A431                     2.0


HL-60                    0.3
SF               0.5
A431                     0.7
HeLa                     0.9

Note: Table made from bar graph.
COPYRIGHT 2017 Hindawi Limited
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2017 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Croaker, Andrew; King, Graham J.; Pyne, John H.; Anoopkumar-Dukie, Shailendra; Liu, Lei
Publication:Evidence - Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine
Date:Jan 1, 2017
Previous Article:Modification of the Integrated Sasang Constitutional Diagnostic Model.
Next Article:Antiobesity and Anti-Inflammatory Effects of Orally Administered Bonito Extracts on Mice Fed a High-Fat Diet.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2021 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters