Printer Friendly

'Pathological bias' under consideration for DSM-V.

SAN DIEGO -- Racism, a concept absent from DSM-IV, is under consideration for inclusion in DSM-V under the rubric "pathological bias," Dr. Carl C. Bell said at the annual meeting of the National Medical Association.

In addition to racism, pathological bias might include sexism and heterosexism, and may be included in DSM-V as either a symptom or a full-blown disorder.

The decision on whether to include pathological bias in DSM-V, and, if so, in what form, is certain to be controversial.

"Some folks are very concerned about having this conversation about racism being a mental illness as medicalizing a social problem, and there's some truth to that," said Dr. Bell of the department of psychiatry and public health at the University of Illinois at Chicago.

"But at the same time there are those cases of people with paranoia or schizophrenia or mania who are engaged in racist behavior but if their [illness] is adequately treated, that racist behavior goes away."

Dr. Bell guessed that 95%-98% of racist behavior is socially, culturally, or politically determined, but that "a sliver" of racist behavior may be based on psychopathology, which argues for its inclusion in DSM-V, due out in 2012.

At present the state of research is inadequate to suggest one course or another, and the first step will be to look at pathological bias scientifically, and to determine whether it is a valid construct that can be measured reliably, said Dr. Bell, also president and chief executive officer of the Community Mental Health Council, Chicago.

Several committees are helping to define the research agenda and are spearheading the discussion.

These include committees of the American Psychiatric Association; the department of psychiatry at Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston; and the Social Sciences Research Council, an independent, nonprofit organization that is based in New York.

The research, which is likely to include neuroimaging, may help determine whether pathological bias should be considered a symptom of certain disorders (such as paranoid personality disorder or bipolar disorder), or perceived as a disorder in its own right.

Dr. Bell sees an analogy between violence and pathological bias. Some diagnoses in DSM-IV list violence as an associated feature, and some have violence as a central feature of the disorder. Likewise, pathological bias may sometimes be a feature of some disorders and in other patients may be their central psychopathology.

The issue of how to classify such a disorder must also be resolved. Dr. Bell has published articles arguing that pathological bias may be a manifestation of narcissistic personality disorder.

Others have argued that pathological bias might be perceived as a relational problem.

"You could have a situation in which two people, as a result of their values and their belief systems, have interpersonal friction, but in fact they have no real psychopathology," Dr. Bell explained.

In any case, the controversy over including pathological bias in DSM-V is likely to be heated, with arguments for and against coming from all sides of the political spectrum.

Some fear that defining pathological bias as a psychopathology may provide a convenient excuse for people being charged with engaging in racist behavior. Others suggest that medicalizing the issue will reduce the pressure to eliminate racist behavior by social and political means.

But without taking a position on the inclusion of pathological bias in DSM-V, Dr. Bell posed the question of how one should regard an individual with mania, for example, who engages in racist behavior and professes racist attitudes while in the throes of his or her illness, but who disavows the same behavior and attitudes when properly medicated.


San Francisco Bureau.
COPYRIGHT 2004 International Medical News Group
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2004 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Psychiatry; Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders
Author:Finn, Robert
Publication:Internal Medicine News
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Oct 1, 2004
Previous Article:SSRIs top agents in treating posttraumatic stress disorder.
Next Article:Doctor's orders: advise patients to stop smoking.

Terms of use | Privacy policy | Copyright © 2019 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters