Printer Friendly
The Free Library
22,728,043 articles and books

Young refugees talk about well-being: a qualitative analysis of refugee youth mental health from three states.

   The only fact of our immediate experience is what has been called
   'the specious' present, a sort of saddle-back of time with a certain
   length of its own, on which we sit perched, and from which we look
   in two directions into time. (William James, 1892)

   Within given limits, 'now' is always transcended. (Agnes Heller,

As James suggested at a psychological level and Heller at an historical level, it can be difficult to neatly separate past, present and future. Although we cannot avoid such separations, we also know at a deeper level that the past inextricably in·ex·tri·ca·ble  
a. So intricate or entangled as to make escape impossible: an inextricable maze; an inextricable web of deceit.

 reaches into our present and future. By definition, refugees hold with them a past involving persecution or fear of persecution. Yet refugees also embody hope for a brighter future. Refugees perhaps more than any other group confront the challenges of the present and future in the context of a tumultuous past. For young people from a refugee background, the desire for better futures is more poignant as they seek to establish secure futures not only in a new social, cultural and geographical space but also in a new adult space as well.

Refugees arriving in Australia face not only the stresses of migration related to sudden changes in language and culture, but they must also contend with a past that is often filled with extremely traumatic experiences. It is not surprising then, that the health literature concerning refugees tends to focus on the stress of adapting to new environments as well as the additional stress of dealing with past events. Yet in the West, mental health status is often understood in terms of acculturation acculturation, culture changes resulting from contact among various societies over time. Contact may have distinct results, such as the borrowing of certain traits by one culture from another, or the relative fusion of separate cultures.  stress and post-traumatic stress disorder. Whilst both of these areas are clearly extremely important, they can focus attention on refugees in a manner which limits our understanding of them as whole people with lives that stretch beyond the label of refugee. Our gaze can be restricted to transitions in lives rather than whole lives, to victims rather than survivors, to illness rather than health. Moreover, biomedical bi·o·med·i·cal
1. Of or relating to biomedicine.

2. Of, relating to, or involving biological, medical, and physical sciences.
 dominance tends to direct our attention toward the clinical level of treatment rather than a broader population health perspective.

Langer (1990:69) has commented that to understand the experience of refugees we must have a 'clear sense of refugee trauma as having its origins in the intersection of history, social structure and biography--an intersection that does not cease when refugees leave their homeland.' When we talk of 'refugee youth' we are creating a construct, which at times can mask the diverse ways in which a young person from a refugee background experiences the world. A young refugee might experience the world primarily as a young black person, or a young woman--issues of gender, race, discrimination, inequality, poverty could provide some of the primary prisms through which the world is experienced. Trauma emerges as the past mixes with both the painful experiences of the present and anxieties about the future. The outbreak of war again in the country of origin will often trigger experiences that link to the past--a complex nexus of individual emotion and broader social and political forces.

Wyn and White (1997:25) reminds us that the experience of young people is best understood as a 'relational concept', one that enables us to 'take into account the diverse ways in which young people are constructed through social institutions, and the ways in which they negotiate their transitions'. It is essential then, that we do not make assumptions about who refugees are and what problems they face. The only way we can achieve this is by listening to refugees themselves, and attempt to understand their issues within their frame of reference. This paper presents the voices of young people who have recently settled in Australia as refugees. We argue that rather than being fearful of the subjectivities of refugees and the scientific 'bias' this may bring we need to engage directly in the experiential ex·pe·ri·en·tial  
Relating to or derived from experience.

 world (2). We do this in order to describe mental health issues that exist not only within social contexts, but also as a means to challenging prevailing assumptions embedded within related biomedical research Biomedical research (or experimental medicine), in general simply known as medical research, is the basic research or applied research conducted to aid the body of knowledge in the field of medicine. .


Research in the area of immigrant youth mental health suggests a complex relationship between migration and health. Some studies suggest higher rates of psychiatric morbidity, some lower and some no difference when compared to the general population (Bevan, 2000). In part, this reflects the diversity of different population groups as well as the use of different measurement tools. Some authors have suggested that part of the problem with many studies of psychiatric morbidity is that they focus on only a narrow spectrum of issues, and that the range of issues spans from risk factors common to all adolescents through to very specific factors relevant to specific groups (Klimidis et al. 1994). This focus emphasizes individual pathology over broader social questions.

Yet, as Moore (1997) has suggested in her application of public health principles to youth mental health, optimal mental well-being is produced through a balance between the young person's personal characteristics and the environmental pressures she or he encounters. This can be a major challenge for refugee young people who must seek out a community to which they can belong. They may feel guilt or anxiety for 'betraying' their culture of origin, yet suffer isolation from the broader community if they do not embrace the dominant culture.


Much of the literature on acculturation stress implies a conservative understanding of change, in which the challenge for migrant mi·grant  
1. One that moves from one region to another by chance, instinct, or plan.

2. An itinerant worker who travels from one area to another in search of work.

 populations is related to adaption adaption

see adaptation.
 to new environments. However, as O'Neil (1986:250) argues, much of the distress impacting on migrant and other 'acculturating' communities has 'less to do with change per se and more to do with the political and economic structures which constrain con·strain  
tr.v. con·strained, con·strain·ing, con·strains
1. To compel by physical, moral, or circumstantial force; oblige: felt constrained to object. See Synonyms at force.

 individual and community attempts to construct meaningful and rewarding social environments'. This has important implications for how mental health status is conceptualised among migrant and refugee populations. Much of the research literature concerns itself with finding correlations between level of acculturation and mental health status, with some literature suggesting low levels of acculturation produce greater risk of psychological illness. Yet, elsewhere higher levels of acculturation are thought to produce higher levels of psychological illness (Klimidis, 1995:93). Rogler et al. (1991) suggests a bicultural bi·cul·tur·al  
Of or relating to two distinct cultures in one nation or geographic region: bicultural education.

 position is best. The overall evidence seems unclear with one review of the literature showing 12 studies supported a positive relationship, 13 negative, 3 curvilinear curvilinear

a line appearing as a curve; nonlinear.

curvilinear regression
see curvilinear regression.
, 2 either, depending on measurement variables (Klimidis, 1995:94).

Although it is clearly important that acculturation research provides a focus on the capacity of refugees to adapt to a new environment; from a broader population health perspective, we also need to understand the importance of adapting environments to suit the needs of refugees. Within this approach we need to acknowledge the broader social determinants of health Social determinants of health are the economic and social conditions under which people live which determine their health. Virtually all major diseases are primarily determined by specific exposures to these conditions.  (including mental health) (Promotion, Prevention and Early Intervention ear·ly intervention
n. Abbr. EI
A process of assessment and therapy provided to children, especially those younger than age 6, to facilitate normal cognitive and emotional development and to prevent developmental disability or delay.
 for Mental Health, 2000). Without a commitment to providing supportive environments for refugees, there is the real danger of placing both blame and burden on already compromised individuals.

Post-traumatic stress

Muecke (1992:520) has argued biomedicine biomedicine /bio·med·i·cine/ (bi?o-med´i-sin) clinical medicine based on the principles of the natural sciences (biology, biochemistry, etc.).biomed´ical

 can objectify refugees as medical phenomenon particularly through the category Post Traumatic Stress Disorder Post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD)
A disorder that occurs among survivors of severe environmental stress such as a tornado, an airplane crash, or military combat. Symptoms include anxiety, insomnia, flashbacks, and nightmares.
 (PTSD PTSD posttraumatic stress disorder.

posttraumatic stress disorder

Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) 
) which highlights only one aspect of the suffering that refugees experience, and diverts attention away from the 'stigma, isolation and rejection of being irretrievably ir·re·triev·a·ble  
Difficult or impossible to retrieve or recover: Once the ring fell down the drain, it was irretrievable.

 out of phase with the host society and its values, and with one's parents' generation and with the generation of one's children'. Similarly, Sharpe's (1998) discussion of Iraqi refugee men in Australia argues the need to understand refugee mental health circumstances beyond the 'panacea' of PTSD. Allotey's (1998) analysis of Latin American women refugees in Australia also suggests the need to describe the entire 'baggage' carried by refugee women.

These aforementioned critiques of biomedical dominance all try to locate refugees within a broader social context (see also Farias, 1991). They do not suggest that there are no substantial issues of pathology surrounding refugees, rather they show how these medical categories do not capture the full array of challenges to refugees. As Sharpe (1998) argues, early assessment of issues like PTSD are valuable if used in conjunction with models of practice and policy which empower refugees 'rather than interventions driven by pathological considerations'.

Guus van der Veer Van der Veer may refer to:
  • Jeroen van der Veer (b. 1947), a Dutch businessman
  • Kelly van der Veer, a Dutch former Big Brother contestant
See also
  • Vander Veer
 (1999:9) has suggested:
   .... there are signs that may indicate a change in paradigm, at
   least in countries outside Western Europe and North America. In
   Third World countries that suffer the after effects of armed
   conflict, a new generation of mental health workers has become
   active, and they do not seem too impressed by Western views on
   trauma counselling. These people say that rebuilding their
   shattered communities and mobilizing its resources are much more
   important and much more effective than individual treatment,
   although individual treatment may be useful in some cases.

Furthermore Guus van der Veer argues from his experience of working with trauma survivors in the Netherlands that 'traumatized refugees are often people who do not have a social network. The primary objective of professional help is therefore, by means of therapeutic contact, to help refugees to build up a social network...." (1999:51)


The data used in this paper is derived from a larger study of the social and emotional well-being of young people from culturally and linguistically diverse backgrounds (Selvamanickam et al, 2001) which involved in-depth interviews with 123 young people from Queensland, South Australia South Australia, state (1991 pop. 1,236,623), 380,070 sq mi (984,381 sq km), S central Australia. It is bounded on the S by the Indian Ocean. Kangaroo Island and many smaller islands off the south coast are included in the state.  and Western Australia Western Australia, state (1991 pop. 1,409,965), 975,920 sq mi (2,527,633 sq km), Australia, comprising the entire western part of the continent. It is bounded on the N, W, and S by the Indian Ocean. Perth is the capital.  and included 10 different ethnic communities. A purposive pur·po·sive  
1. Having or serving a purpose.

2. Purposeful: purposive behavior.

 sampling strategy was adopted in which participants aged 16-24 who identified themselves as having experienced depression, anxiety or stress were recruited by bi-lingual interviewers in each of the participating ethnic communities. Using both formal and informal networks interviewers were able to recruit participants for the study.

Of the total 123 interviews, 70 had been accepted to Australia as refugees. Those interviewed came from Somalia (17), Sudan (11), Former Yugoslavia (26), Cambodia (10), El Salvadore and Columbia (6). A further 6 Chinese young people were identified in the interviews as having met the definition for refugee status, although they had migrated under non-refugee programs.

These 76 interviews were extracted from the total data set and re-coded to ensure themes specific to refugee issues were appropriately acknowledged and analysed. The data was then analysed using standard qualitative thematic interpretation Thematic Interpretation is the practice of verbal and non verbal communication, utilizing illustrated and non illustrated techniques, used by interpretive naturalists, Natural and cultural interpretive specialists, tour guides and others to present complex and sometimes dry subject  utilising NUDIST software to organise and assist in the process.

Results and discussion

Traumatic Pasts

Most of the young people interviewed had left their home countries with their immediate families as a result of war and or other major political disturbances. The circumstances under which people were forced to leave their homes were often traumatic in the extreme. Some had personally experienced torture, rape and imprisonment Imprisonment
See also Isolation.

Alcatraz Island

former federal maximum security penitentiary, near San Francisco; “escapeproof.” [Am. Hist.: Flexner, 218]

Altmark, the

German prison ship in World War II. [Br. Hist.
. Many others lived in fear of such possibilities for several years, having lost friends and family. Some did not know the fate of loved ones, sometimes being rewarded with the sudden return of a missing family member, whilst others were to have to contend with the confirmation of their worst fears. Although each story is different the common theme is one of trauma and chaos. A young person (19) from the former Yugoslavia vividly described her own chaotic experience:
   The war was raging on, grenades were flying everywhere and the
   snipers were on every corner. Eventually I got over being scared of
   the explosions, those days it was just a normal part of life. If it
   hits you there was no way out, you just die. But the scariest part
   was when it was quiet, because when it is quiet that's when
   something big is really going on, which meant the enemy is occupying
   people's homes and killing them in cold blood. So one day without a
   shell being fired the army barged into our home and took mother,
   father and grandfather away ... I was left with my grandmother and
   we were both screaming and crying. With the guns that they pointed
   at us, they said they would blow our brains out if we don't shut up.
   So we did ... For four months I didn't know anything about my
   parents or about my grandfather and meanwhile my grandmother and I
   were moving from one home to another. We were told we had to do that
   to save our lives. After four months my parents came back but without
   my grandfather.

The journey into refugee status represented a chaotic period of life in which the young people interviewed described further trauma and insecurity. Many were forced to travel long distances, with few or no belongings, crossing borders into refugee camps, finding the administration of refugees to be often long and confusing. Sometimes both the escape journey as well as life inside camps were to contain further traumas, both physical and emotional. Many were assisted by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees Headquartered in Geneva, Switzerland, the Office of the UN High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) (established December 14, 1950) protects and supports refugees at the request of a government or the United Nations and assists in their return or resettlement.  (UNHCR UNHCR n abbr (= United Nations High Commission for Refugees) → ACNUR m

UNHCR n abbr (= United Nations High Commission for Refugees) → HCR m 
) to gain entrance to Australia. The most common reason for selecting Australia was that it was seen as peaceful. For others the decision was more pragmatic, selecting whatever country would take them at the time.

The first few months

For most of the young people, the early months after settlement in Australia were the most difficult. Many expressed a sense of emotional shock upon first arriving. A young woman (17) from the former Yugoslavia stated:
   Soon after arrival I was so stressed and I cried every single day.
   Everything was so stupid. I missed my home, house, my friends. I
   wanted to go back immediately when I realised the emotional state I
   was in........ advice was not helpful for me because they kept
   saying 'you will get used to it, do not worry!', but I was in
   terrible pain. They said there is nothing we can do about it.

Another young woman from the former Yugoslavia who had been having trouble communicating at school described the sensation as surreal sur·re·al  
1. Having qualities attributed to or associated with surrealism: "Even with most facilities shut down ...
   I had a feeling that my body and mind were separating. I was walking
   but in front of me were pictures of my town, my friends and
   relatives. Shortly I think that I am falling apart.

A young Chinese woman (17) described her first experience of Australia:
   When I came, I was 10 year old. I could not understand and speak
   English well. It was very stressful for me. No one understood me
   and I understood no one. People laughed at me.

Settling In

Having 'survived' the initial period of settlement, most of the young people described some improvement in their situation. Not surprisingly, the discovery of their own cultural community within Australia, for most proved a source of great comfort. Most reported that it was not too difficult to continue to retain their own culture within Australia. There was a genuine appreciation of cultural diversity within Australia. Indeed many young people as well as their parents cited multiculturalism along with freedom and peace as the things they liked most about Australia. Multiculturalism was almost universally praised by the young people. Though for a few it was also perplexing per·plex  
tr.v. per·plexed, per·plex·ing, per·plex·es
1. To confuse or trouble with uncertainty or doubt. See Synonyms at puzzle.

2. To make confusedly intricate; complicate.
 for them to then discern exactly what constituted 'Australian' culture. The nexus between ethnic division and war was a profound experience from which people were glad to be freed. A young man (22) from the former Yugoslavia described why he valued Australian multiculturalism:
   My main problem was living in a society, which was divided
   on ethnic/nationalistic basis. It led to terrible war later. I was
   experiencing fear and anxiety.

Young people frequently spoke of appreciating the freedom of Australian life. For some though, this freedom was not always easy to enjoy, particularly among young women. As one young Cambodian woman (16) put it:
   ... there is so much freedom. People can do whatever they want.
   Like, kids my age can go out wherever they want to whereas its
   very hard for me to do that. Because as a girl being in a Cambodian
   culture I'm not allowed to go out really. The most difficult is
   wanting to go out to movies and parties with my Australian friends
   but I'm never allowed so I sneak out.

Parents were more likely to see freedom in the Australian lifestyle as a negative. Australian families were often seen as not being as close and allowing their children too much freedom. The disjunction disjunction /dis·junc·tion/ (-junk´shun)
1. the act or state of being disjoined.

2. in genetics, the moving apart of bivalent chromosomes at the first anaphase of meiosis.
 between life in Australia and home for some caused family rifts which left young people finding themselves in a position of independence before they felt ready. A young Somali man (21) described his situation in this way:
   I wasn't feel happy at the beginning because of too much control,
   uncomfortable style of life. Then I decided to leave them [family]
   --too much restriction. That is when I started having stress and
   depression because I was new in this country and too young to handle
   a problem.

Finding a place in multicultural Australia was for some a challenging prospect involving questions about their own identity. A young woman (19) from Hong Kong Hong Kong (hŏng kŏng), Mandarin Xianggang, special administrative region of China, formerly a British crown colony (2005 est. pop. 6,899,000), land area 422 sq mi (1,092 sq km), adjacent to Guangdong prov.  described her situation:
   The problem of identity crisis, a sense of belonging. Difficult to
   tell which group I belonged to, local Australian or people from
   Chinese community. I did not feel happy ... Even international
   students, like students from Hong Kong, felt easier to identify
   themselves ... But I'm a permanent resident. I had the feeling of
   being 'left out' by either of the groups.

Despite the enjoyment of Australian multiculturalism, young people were nevertheless very aware of racism. A young Cambodian woman (20) cited racism as a major stumbling block stum·bling block
An obstacle or impediment.

stumbling block

any obstacle that prevents something from taking place or progressing

Noun 1.
 to forming relationships with Australians:
   And the most difficult to practice is when I am trying to socialise
   with the Australian people because we are not Australians and I
   don't know whether or not they are racist. Also trying to get a job
   is difficult because they look at you 'funny' because most of the
   managers or whatever are white.

Most commonly, racism was spoken about in relation to school. It included verbal and physical abuse and caused some young people to carefully monitor places they decided as safe or not safe. A young Cambodian woman (16) described racism at school as her biggest problem:
   When I'm at school there were a few who were racist towards me.
   And some place that I went or even now go to. I'm pretty hesitant of
   going by myself because of these types of people.

Racist violence was particularly catastrophic for young people and their families who had escaped violence in their past. In one incident involving a racist attack in a public place, two young people from El Salvador El Salvador (ĕl sälväthōr`), officially Republic of El Salvador, republic (2005 est. pop. 6,705,000), 8,260 sq mi (21,393 sq km), Central America.  were set upon by three adults. The emotional consequences of this attack were profound leading to depression and social withdrawal. One of the young people locked himself in his room for several weeks. The mother of the young people described the worst consequence as triggering 'memories of mistrust, where I couldn't trust my own shadow.' The mother was to later attempt suicide.

The Traumatic Continuum

Various stressors described by the young people were of an ongoing nature having been problems in their home country and not going away upon settlement in Australia. This ability for stressors to 'travel' with refugees makes the notion of 'post'-trauma problematic. Anxiety about family and friends still living in their home country amidst sometimes ongoing human rights violations caused considerable stress. As a young man (22) from Somalia put it:
   People get killed everyday. They do not have any government
   protection. Every time I call them, I wonder if they are going to
   tell me someone in the family died. There is nothing I can do for
   them as I am yet in school and do not have the necessary powers to
   better their conditions of life.

Education had often been severely disrupted in their countries of origin as a product of war or other upheavals, hence the challenges of education in Australia Education in Australia is primarily regulated by the individual state governments. Generally education in Australia follows the three-tier model which includes Primary education (Primary Schools), followed by Secondary education (Secondary Schools / High Schools) and Tertiary  were often seen as a continuance The adjournment or postponement of an action pending in a court to a later date of the same or another session of the court, granted by a court in response to a motion made by a party to a lawsuit.  of disruption rather than a new challenge in their lives. One young man (18) from Sudan had already changed education systems twice before settling in Australia:
   The depression that I had is because how I feel about the gap in my
   education. I started my schooling in English in Southern Sudan but
   due to war, I fled to Northern Sudan where I found the education
   there in Arabic language. I found it difficult to cope with that and
   it effected my educational progress. Then, I left for Cairo. I
   thought the situation would change but I found the same problem.
   Most of the government schools is in the Arabic language.

It is a well known phenomenon for young people from CALD CALD

chronic active liver disease.
 (culturally and linguistically diverse) backgrounds to find themselves in positions of great family responsibility upon settlement in a new country. For some though this was not an entirely new role and began in their country of origin. Parents suffering major reactions to traumatic events sometimes needed the support of their children as much as their children needed the parents support. Hence, some young people find themselves trying to cope with helping parents suffering from major emotional disorders. One young woman (23) from the former Yugoslavia described her situation:
   The major problem I had (and still have) is living and dealing with
   my mother's disorder [post-traumatic stress disorder] ... This makes
   it difficult to cope, because I attend school, trying to get things
   done around the house to make it easier for her. However it is not
   that easy; it is very stressful to see her almost destroy herself
   (she eats only once a day), and also trying to help her through her
   nervous episodes and her not giving us (my brother and me) any

Moreover relationship problems, family conflict and domestic violence which had their beginnings in the country of origin travelled with the family. Some relationships already stressed at home reached breaking point in Australia. Men who had abused their partners in the home country, continued to abuse in Australia. The strain of such disharmony dis·har·mo·ny  
1. Lack of harmony; discord.

2. Something not in accord; a conflict: "the disharmonies that assail the most fortunate of mortals" Peter Gay.
 was multiplied for many families who continued to stay together because they feared additional isolation on top of an already isolated existence. For others, where separations did occur, the associated grief and loss on top of other traumas often convened to crisis situations. The meaning and depth of anxiety related to family break-ups was for many young people multiplied several fold by their personal histories involving already substantial loss and grief.

Sometimes the social context of a stressor was almost as important as the stressor itself. A young woman (16) from El Salvadore described how the thing she valued most about El Salvadorean culture was family closeness and that the break-up of her mother and father was devastating dev·as·tate  
tr.v. dev·as·tat·ed, dev·as·tat·ing, dev·as·tates
1. To lay waste; destroy.

2. To overwhelm; confound; stun: was devastated by the rude remark.
 because her father returned to El Salvadore. She explained:
   It interfered with my friends because they didn't understand. A lot
   of them (Anglo-Australians) had their parents divorced and for them
   it wasn't a big deal ... I was so depressed, cried to sleep in my
   room and felt like crying all the time ...

For many young people trying to manage a bi-cultural identity was a major challenge. Most wanted Most Wanted may refer to:
  • Lists used by law enforcement agencies to alert the public, such as the FBI Ten Most Wanted Fugitives and FBI Most Wanted Terrorists
  • America's Most Wanted, a U.S.
 some of each culture, seeing positives and negatives in each. But their views about this did not always line up with their family or community's expectations. A common problem for young people was in forming relationships outside of their own cultural community. Many young refugees described a particular 'turning point' in their feelings about Australia and their country of origin. It was the point when they fully realised that they were not going back. For some this point was based on a commitment to making Australia 'home', for others it was an awareness that going home was simply not possible. Whatever the reason, there seemed a profound sense of mixed emotions for young people when they reached this point. A young woman(19) from the former Yugoslavia described her feelings:
   Migration experience--expecting to find something better here.
   Financial/educational expectations of improvement. Does it
   compensate for family and friends you left behind? Not sure if it
   was the right decision. I was really depressed when NATO bombed
   Serbia. That created a real distance between us here and people left
   behind. When that happened I knew we couldn't go back. Being
   helpless, feelings of certain guilt, you had a chance to escape and
   they didn't.

Coping and Resilience

Young refugees used a variety of strategies to deal with stress and anxiety including talking with friends, family, counsellors, medical practitioners to playing sport, listening to music, and participating in community activities. Some wanted help to deal with their problems but were not sure to whom they should talk. Others felt they should deal with problems by themselves. Many felt that they needed to be strong because others in their family were dealing with so much that they felt too guilty adding to the level of burden. This background level of high stress appeared to be very common, not only making it difficult for young people to feel comfortable about exposing their personal issues to others scrutiny, but also meant that additional stressors accumulated very quickly.

Social interaction of various kinds was by far the most commonly cited activity which young people found helpful. One young man (22) from the former Yugoslavia with severe traumatic reactions described the limitations of drug therapy he had experienced:
   Migration, leaving my country because of the war. When I arrived
   here I was highly stressed, nervous, full of anxiety, sweaty palms.
   I couldn't sleep properly, had lots of bad dreams. And felt bad all
   the time. I was taken to a doctor, he gave me 12 tablets to take a
   day. I had lots of tests and examinations to find out what was wrong
   with me. I felt numb each time I saw the doctor. For 3 months, I
   felt this way, then I made some friends and the symptoms seemed to
   reduce and then go away.

Many of the young people interviewed straggled to imagine that anyone would be suitable to talk to about their problems. A young Chinese woman (17) mapped out her options thus:
   My mum was aware of my problem, but I didn't want to show her
   too much ... I didn't want to burden her even more. One of my
   teachers noticed and asked me, but I didn't tell her. To me teacher
   is someone who teaches, and it didn't occur to me that I could speak
   to a teacher ... I didn't confide in my friend because I couldn't
   express them in English well at that time, so I didn't know how to

Although some young people did eventually find people they could talk too, many simply kept their problems to themselves. A young man from the former Yugoslavia (19) bluntly described his situation:
   I could not get any family support because of the circumstances that
   I have described earlier. I have kept my problems in me and I do
   not think that I will talk about it in details with anybody ...
   Thinking about the past and bringing back bad memories was not
   helpful at all (makes me feeling worse).

Strength in community was commonly cited by young people as an important positive in their life. For example consider the following two quotes, the first from an El Salvadorian, the second from a Bosnian:
   I feel comfortable and proud to be from El Salvadore and being
   associated with everything over there. I like to talk about it.
   I'm not sure about many things but what I feel about being from El
   Salvadore is very positive.

   The most helpful things for me were my social activities with the
   friends of mine from Bosnia. While we were together we were able
   to discuss openly about nearly everything, even intimate things. I
   have hard feelings of belongings to some group of people. I felt

This did not mean that young people did not value time with young people from the broader community. Sometimes very special friendships could emerge which were extremely valued as lines of support. For others, friendships outside of their cultural community were seen as 'escapist', providing opportunities not to have to talk about their problems.

Despite all of the challenges facing young refugees, perhaps the most inspiring part of their psychological outlook was that of their optimism for the future. Almost all of the young people interviewed spoke positively about the future. They had endured so much already, they felt sure they could make good futures for themselves. Considering that all of the young people interviewed had identified themselves as someone who had experienced significant anxiety or depression, this view of the future demonstrates enormous courage and conviction.


The data reported here suggests that the refugee experience of migration and resettlement Re`set´tle`ment   

n. 1. Act of settling again, or state of being settled again; as, the resettlement of lees s>.
The resettlement of my discomposed soul.
- Norris.
 is more complex than simply a series of discrete events. At least in terms of mental health and well-being, the refugee experience lingers well beyond the flight from chaos. In this sense, trauma and the consequent emotional instability is better conceptualised within a life continuum rather than a series of discrete events.

Young people's experience of the present is very much mediated by their past. This is not only true of present reactions to past catastrophic traumas, but also to other past traumas related to family break-down, illness, educational disruption, job losses, family and friendship disruption. The past mingles Mingles are a type of mint chocolates made by Bendicks and sold in the UK. Varieties
There are 5 different varieties of Mingles, which are packaged together in one box:
  • Red - Marbled dark and white chocolate with light mint truffle center.
 with the present too in terms of the meanings and interpretations young people give to life events as they unfurl. Sense of success or failure, notions of freedom and independence, identity and physical and emotional security may be played out in the present, but contain salient meanings generated by the past. Among the young people interviewed here, it is difficult to discern neat boundaries between a past traumatic event A traumatic event is an event that is or may be a cause of trauma. The term may refer to one of the followiong:
  • Traumatic event (physical), an event associated with a physical trauma
  • Traumatic event (psychological), an event associated with a psychological trauma
 and a state of 'post' trauma. Rather than conceptualise v. t. 1. same as conceptualize.

Verb 1. conceptualise - have the idea for; "He conceived of a robot that would help paralyzed patients"; "This library was well conceived"
conceive, conceptualize, gestate
 their lives in terms of illness boundaries, young people were far more likely to talk of their degree of connectedness within their family, their own ethnic community, their friends, and within Australian society at large. This exemplifies the importance of promoting supportive social environments within public health approaches to refugee health. Biomedical dominance tends to highlight individual dysfunction in our understanding of health. Whilst this has a place, it is essential we also attempt to look at the larger picture. Community development strategies which connect young people to communities and communities to young people are of critical importance.

Of course, past experiences impact on all people, but they have special relevance to young people due their occurrence at a time of rapid emotional development. The ability of the individual to negotiate this period of their life can have an impact on their future mental wellbeing suggesting a heightened risk of later mental illness. One of the positive things to come out of this study was the evidence of resilience amongst the participants that has perhaps been underrated in the past. Considering the difficulties that they had experienced, there was evidence of an inner strength to keep moving forward in the hope of better things to come. This strong desire to construct positive and productive futures is one we should be careful to harness not hinder.


To the young people who had the courage to share their stories for the Non-English Speaking Background Youth Mental Health Needs Assessment Project, the data from which this paper is based on, we sincerely thank. Thanks are also due to Rita Prasad-Ildes for her thoughtful direction during the initial discussion of the paper. Finally we acknowledge the support provided by the partnership between the Queensland Transcultural Mental Health Centre and the Youth Affairs Network of Queensland Inc, without whom this work could never have been undertaken.

(2) See recent paper by Sultan and O'Sullivan (2001) as well as subsequent letters to the editor by Ruddock rud·dock  
n. Chiefly British
An Old World robin (Erithacus rubecula) having olive-brown upper plumage and a conspicuous orange breast.
 (2002) and Graves (2002).


Allotey, P (1998) 'Travelling with "excess baggage excess baggage nexceso de equipaje

excess baggage excess nexcédent m de bagages

excess baggage excess n
": Health problems of refugee women in Western Australia', In L. Manderson (ed) Australian Women Health: Innovations in Social Science and Community Research, New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
, Haworth Medical Press.

Bevan, K (2000) 'Young people, culture, migration and mental health: A review of the literature', In M. Bashir & D. Bennett, (eds) Deeper Dimensions: Culture, Youth and Mental Health, Sydney, NSW NSW New South Wales

Noun 1. NSW - the agency that provides units to conduct unconventional and counter-guerilla warfare
Naval Special Warfare
 Transcultural Mental Health Centre.

Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care (2000) Promotion, Prevention and Early Intervention for Mental Health--A Monograph, Canberra, Mental Health and Special Programs Branch, Commonwealth Department of Health and Aged Care.

Farias, P (1991) 'Emotional distress and its socio-political correlates in Salvadoran refugees: Analysis of a clinical sample', Culture, Medicine and Psychiatry, 15, (167-192).

Graves, D (2002) 'Letter to the Editor', Medical Journal of Australia, 176, 86.

Heller, A (1982) A Theory of History, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.

James, W (1892) Psychology: The Briefer Course, New York, Harper Torchbooks (1961 edition edited by Gordon Allport Gordon Willard Allport (November 11 1897 - October 9 1967) was an American psychologist. He was born in Montezuma, Indiana, the youngest of four brothers. One of his older brothers, Floyd Henry Allport, was an important and influential psychologist as well. Gordon W. ).

Klimidis, S & Minas Minas may refer to:
  • Minas, Uruguay
  • Minas Avetisyan
  • Minas (bishop)
  • Minas cheese (from Minas Gerais)
  • Minas Department, Córdoba
  • Minas Department, Neuquén
  • Minas, Cuba, a municipality in Cuba
  • See also: Special:Allpages/Minas
, I (1995) 'Migration, culture and mental health in children and adolescents', In C. Guerra & R. White (eds) Ethnic Minority Youth in Australia, Hobart, National Clearinghouse for Youth Studies.

Klimidis, S., Stuart, G., Minas, I & Ata, A (1994) 'Immigrant status and gender effects in psychopathology psychopathology /psy·cho·pa·thol·o·gy/ (-pah-thol´ah-je)
1. the branch of medicine dealing with the causes and processes of mental disorders.

2. abnormal, maladaptive behavior or mental activity.
 and self-concept in adolescents: A test of the migration-morbidity hypothesis', Comprehensive Psychiatry, 35 (5), 3 93-404.

Langer, B (1990) 'The continuing trauma of refugee settlement--the experience of El Salvadoreans', In P. Hosking (ed) Hope After Horror Sydney, Uniya.

Moore, R (1997) 'Youth mental health promotion: A public health perspective' Youth Studies Australia Youth Studies Australia (ISSN 1038-2569) is a peer reviewed academic journal published by the Australian Clearinghouse for Youth Studies -- also known as ACYS -- based at the University of Tasmania. , 16(4), 27-36.

Muecke, M (1992) 'New Paradigms for Refugee Health Problems' Social Science and Medicine, 35(4), 515-523.

O'Neil, J (1986) 'Colonial stress in the Canadian Arctic: An ethnography ethnography: see anthropology; ethnology.

Descriptive study of a particular human society. Contemporary ethnography is based almost entirely on fieldwork.
 of young adults changing', In C. Janes, et al. (eds) Anthropology and Epidemiology, Dordrecht, Holland, D. Reidel.

Rogler, L., Cortes, D., & Malgady, R (1991) 'Acculturation and mental health status amongst hispanics: convergence and new directions for research' American Psychologist, 46,585-97.

Ruddock, P (2002) 'Letter to the Editor', Medical Journal of Australia, 176:85.

Selvamanickam, S., Zgryza, M. & Gorman, D (2001) Coping in a New World: The Social and Emotional Wellbeing of Young People from Culturally and Linguistically Diverse Backgrounds, Brisbane, Queensland Transcultural Mental Health Centre and Youth Affairs Network Queensland.

Sharpe, I (1998) 'Looking beyond pathology: How a group of Iraqi refugee men see their mental health' Migration Action, 20(1), 44-48.

Sultan, A and O'Sullivan K (2001) 'Psychological disturbances in asylum seekers held in long term detention: A participant-observor account', Medical Journal of Australia, 175,593-596.

van der Veer, G (2000) 'Empowerment of traumatized refugees: A developmental approach to prevention and treatment' Torture, 10(1), 8-11.

Wyn, J & White, R (1997) Rethinking Youth, St. Leonards, Allen & Unwin.

Mark Brough, Don Gorman, Elvia Ramirez and Peter Westoby (1)

(1) Dr Mark Brough, Medical Anthropologist, School of Population Health, University of Queensland The University of Queensland (UQ) is the longest-established university in the state of Queensland, Australia, a member of Australia's Group of Eight, and the Sandstone Universities. It is also a founding member of the international Universitas 21 organisation. . Mark's research interests are concerned with the social determinants of health and include particular emphasis on Indigenous health, migrant and refugee health, youth health, drug and alcohol use and social capital.

Prof Don Gorman is Associate Professor of Mental Health Nursing at the University of Southern Queensland USQ has a substantial campus in Hervey Bay (Fraser Coast Campus) to the north of Brisbane, and has recently established a new campus at Springfield in Brisbane's outer suburbs (2006). Another major campus of University of Southern Queensland has been set up in Auckland, New Zealand. . His major area of research is in cross-cultural health care and education.

Elvia Ramirez is Mental Health Promotion Coordinator at the Queensland Transcultural Mental Health Centre. Elvia is a psychologist from El Salvador who migrated to Australia under the Special Humanitarian Program. She has been working in multicultural health promotion over the last twelve years and completed a masters degree in health promotion.

Peter Westoby is Team Leader of Community Connections/Youth Team: Queensland Program of Assistance to Survivors of Torture & Trauma. Peter has spent the past 5 years working as part of the youth team at QPASTT with young people from a refugee background. He also lectures in youth work practice at Griffith University Griffith University is an Australian public university with five campuses in Queensland between Brisbane and the Gold Coast. In 2007 there were more than 33,000 enrolled students and 3,000 staff. . Prior to this he spent 4 years involved in youth worker training and national youth initiatives in South Africa South Africa, Afrikaans Suid-Afrika, officially Republic of South Africa, republic (2005 est. pop. 44,344,000), 471,442 sq mi (1,221,037 sq km), S Africa. ; and with CEDPA--an International NGO NGO
nongovernmental organization

Noun 1. NGO - an organization that is not part of the local or state or federal government
nongovernmental organization
 working on adolescent girl empowerment projects. Peter's background is in sociology, community development and peace & conflict studies.
COPYRIGHT 2003 Australian Council of Social Service
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2003 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Brough, Mark; Gorman, Don; Ramirez, Elvia; Westoby, Peter
Publication:Australian Journal of Social Issues
Date:May 1, 2003
Previous Article:Immigration policy under the Howard government.
Next Article:What it takes to be a grandparent in a new country: the lived experience and emotional well-being of Australian-Vietnamese grandparents.

Related Articles
Many refugees can't flee mental ailments.
Mental health and refugee families: "what is needed more than political ideology is to build a family-centered approach to refugee mental health."...
The "brown paper syndrome": unaccompanied minors and questions of status.
Refugees and migrant issues. .
Meeting the needs of refugee children: helping resolve the complex mental health needs of refugee children living in New Zealand is the aim of a new...
The aftermath of the Gulf War:. mental health issues among Iraqi Gulf War veteran refugees in the United States.
The costs of legal limbo for refugees in Canada: a preliminary study.
"We are sad, not mad" the role of social work in the successful resettlement of refugee families who have experienced torture and trauma.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters