Where do the United States and Canada stand vis-a-vis other countries regarding entrepreneurship?
MR. McILROY: I would like to call this meeting to order again. As you know, this is the ninth session, so we are about three quarters of the way through our program. And in case you haven't noticed, the program is "The Comparative Legal Aspects of Entrepreneurship in Canada and the United States The United States and Canada share a unique legal relationship. U.S. law looks northward with a mixture of optimism and cooperation, viewing Canada as an integral part of U.S. economic and environmental policy. ."
What I would like to do just to briefly kick off this session is to focus for a couple of moments on a couple of titles, and the first title I want to focus on is the title of this session, which is "Where Do the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. and Canada Stand vis-a-vis Other Countries Regarding Entrepreneurship?"
So in effect, what we are doing here, and what we have done for the last day and-a-half, is compare Canada, on the one hand, to the United States, on the other. We are going to go a little beyond that in this session in that Dr. Hisrich is also going to compare where Canada and the United States fit in vis-a-vis other countries around the world. So it is more of a comparative approach than we have seen thus far.
That's the title of the session; let me move to the title of our speaker: Dr. Hisrich. He is the Garvin Professor of Global Entrepreneurship and Director of the Center for Global Entrepreneurship at the Thunderbird School of Global Management Thunderbird School of Global Management is a business school in the United States, and the first and oldest graduate school specializing in international management and global business. . So you hear the word "global" there no less than three times. And, I think, just looking at his title you can tell that he is very, very qualified to speak on how Canada and the United States fit into the global order of entrepreneurship.
Now, as you may note, the Thunderbird School of Global Management is located in Arizona, and its mandate is: "We educate global leaders who create sustainable prosperity worldwide." So it is very much an institute that is in keeping with the theme of this program. And if you look at Dr. Hisrich' s background, you will see that he is eminently qualified, both from a scholarly perspective and also from a hands-on perspective.
Let me deal first with his scholarly background. Although he resides in Arizona now, Dr. Hisrich is no stranger to Ohio. He attended the University of Cincinnati The University of Cincinnati is a coeducational public research university in Cincinnati, Ohio. Ranked as one of America’s top 25 public research universities and in the top 50 of all American research universities, where he obtained two degrees, his MBA and a Ph.D. He taught here for ten years, as some of you heard yesterday, and he built a very successful business program here at Case.
Now, in addition to his strong academic foundation, Dr. Hisrich has very extensive hands-on international experience, including his work in a couple of countries where you don't really think of entrepreneurship--that is a couple of countries that came out of the demise of the Soviet empire--and that is Russia and the Ukraine.
He is also a very prolific writer but he does not reside in an ivory tower ivory tower
A place or attitude of retreat, especially preoccupation with lofty, remote, or intellectual considerations rather than practical everyday life. . He has authored or co-authored over a dozen books, many of which are very successful, and they are listed in your program.
Given his expertise and his experience, we are going to be in for a very stimulating session. So I would ask you to please join me in welcoming Dr. Robert Hisrich.
Dr. Robert Hisrich *
DR. HISRICH: Thank you, James. Thank you very much for a wonderful introduction. James forgot to tell you that one of my books is How to Lie With Your Resume.
It is really thrilling to be here for a couple of reasons; particularly, it is good to be back to Cleveland. I had ten great years here at Case Western Reserve University creating what ended up to be ranked fifth in the world, an entrepreneurship program, before I left. And I have created two companies here that are doing very well, one in the medical software field and another one in medical devices.
And so I have really enjoyed my time here in Cleveland, and it is always good to be back to this part of the world. Similarly, it is always good to have Canadians here. I love your country. Basically, it is an economic love.
When I was at MIT MIT - Massachusetts Institute of Technology , as a professor, we created a company called Polymer Technology, and we made the Boston lens, which was the first gas permeable gas permeable gas adj (lenses) → luftdurchlässig hard contact lens contact lens, thin plastic lens worn between the eye and eyelid that may be used instead of eyeglasses. Actors, models, and others wear them for appearance, and athletes use them for safety and convenience. in the world. (1) I had tremendously good patents on the lens-five patents that were almost unbreakable; we did not want to take the money to get FDA approval in the United States because we would have had to sell quite a bit of our company. So we went to Canada, and you made us a lot of money. I appreciate that a lot.
I particularly like Toronto because that's where we started. We obtained a distributor there--Boots Drugs and others distributed our solutions.
The company was later sold to Bausch & Lomb, so I am out of the lens business, but it was fun. When Henry called, two things concerned me: One, he said I want you to address this topic in 30 minutes. Of course, you know, you never say no to Henry, and never question how much time you are going to have; I thought how am I going to address global entrepreneurship in 30 minutes? Second, Henry indicated that I was on the program after lunch. I thought, "you never have a great audience after lunch, everybody is half asleep." In spite of these two negatives, it is fun to be here, and I know we are going to have a good time exploring this very important topic.
I am more eager for your questions than my talk as I talk all over the world. But I want to set the stage for looking at this topic of global entrepreneurship around the world. Let's first think together what it takes to form a company, as that's what we do as entrepreneurs.
I am going to address this topic through three lenses: one, from the academic lens because I've studied this process all over the world; two, from the entrepreneur lens, having created multiple companies both here and in Hungary and Russia and now one in China; and three, from a theoretical lens as we should understand some of the theory behind it. What does it take to form a company? Four things.
Number one, you have to have the idea. That's number one. We heard that talked about today in terms of the venture people. You need an idea that makes sense; most ideas aren't a business. when Mal was speaking, he said one out of a hundred people fail. There is a high failure rate in business start ups and about one out of a hundred ideas I see actually could be the basis of a business. You need to have the right idea.
All around the world there are innovation and ideas. While some companies are a little more innovative than others, but even in Hungary, under socialism and Soviet control, there was the Rubik's Cube Rubik's Cube (commonly misspelled rubix, rubick's or rubicscube) is a mechanical puzzle invented in 1974 by the Hungarian sculptor and professor of architecture Ernő Rubik. . When I was in Hungary in 1989 living under the Soviet days, I saw a woman retailer who had the most beautiful vegetable stand that would be an incredible merchandising tool anywhere in the world. There is some degree of creativity and innovation all over the world.
The second thing you have to have is money. I have had venture money behind two of my companies--which is a particularly interesting topic all on its own; you need money, particularly money for startup.
In the United States, we are very fortunate. It is not the venture capital industry that affects entrepreneurs in the U.S. at startup but it is what you heard yesterday: the angel market. These angels are private individuals investing in companies. (2)
We did a study of U.S. companies asking, "Outside of family and friends and your own money, where did you get your funding to start your venture?" Eighty-seven percent of those companies received their funding from private individuals. (3) That's the key to the U.S. economy. Are we entrepreneurial? Yes. Do we form more companies than anywhere else in the world? Yes. (4) But it is the angel money in the United States that is so critical to entrepreneurs. That's what I am trying to develop as a member of an advisory board in the country of Slovenia; the goal is to provide startup capital and help Slovenians understand the importance of investing in startup companies.
Private individuals investing in a startup company The creator of this article, or someone who has substantially contributed to it, may have a conflict of interest regarding its subject matter.
It may require cleanup to comply with Wikipedia's content policies, particularly neutral point of view. is not happening anywhere in Europe or other countries in the world. (5) And this money is available in every one of these countries. There is wealth in China. (6) There is wealth in Slovenia. (7) There is wealth in Croatia. (8) There is wealth in Hungary. (9) How do we get that money to work for the betterment of the country's economy, as well as the individual entrepreneur? A country needs to incentivize in·cen·tiv·ize
tr.v. in·cen·tiv·ized, in·cen·tiv·iz·ing, in·cen·tiv·iz·es
To offer incentives or an incentive to; motivate: these individuals to invest a percentage of their wealth in startup companies. I don't see this occurring anywhere else I have been outside the U.S. You need money.
The third thing you need is the entrepreneur. The entrepreneur takes the idea (either his idea or from an inventor) to the marketplace. He or she is the driver of that particular product and idea.
I have studied entrepreneurs all over the world, and the interesting thing which is really nice for entrepreneurs doing international business--is that they are more similar than different. We are "crazies" as I heard some venture people say. I am glad I am "crazy" because I love the process. I am passionate about the process. I understand the process and actually undertake the process. I meet entrepreneurs in China, Russia, Hungary or Ireland and they are very similar. We are more similar than different.
For example, in one study of entrepreneurs, we asked, "What motivated you to start your business?" The same comment was made, whether it was from a Russian or a German or an American entrepreneur: "We can't work for anyone else. We want to be independent." You heard Mal Mixon mention this the other day. Entrepreneurs want independence; they want to be their own boss.
The second reason given in terms of motivation for starting a business was that they want to make money. The third reason was that they are passionate about the idea and want the product/service on the market. They are really passionate about their ideas. These two reasons were also similar all over the world.
The only difference between men and women, in terms of these motivators across countries, was women had passion about the idea as second, and money as the third. These three reasons accounted for around 70 percent of the responses.
Entrepreneurs are also similar in two other aspects. One is the decision process in becoming an entrepreneur. We have to make a decision to go from something to something, as is indicated in Table 1.
You have to change lifestyles if you are not presently an entrepreneur because it is a different way of life. You heard Mal talk about the fluctuations in wealth and the fluctuations in security you have. That's all part of the process. The majority of people can't handle that. You need the ability to be flexible to form a new enterprise. What causes us to do this? It has to be desirable. What makes it desirable? This desirability is different for entrepreneurs in various countries.
One aspect of the country is that its culture needs to support entrepreneurship. The culture has to look at entrepreneurship as a positive element. Entrepreneurship is not looked at very positively in Austria. (10) It is looked at negatively in Russia. (11) The culture in the United States, and the culture in Canada, is pro-entrepreneurship. (12) But even in a pro-entrepreneurship culture, there will be pockets of entrepreneurship. A total culture isn't entrepreneurial; it contains pockets of entrepreneurship.
Look at the United States: we have pockets of entrepreneurship. Where are they? The major ones are: Silicon Valley, Route 128, and North Carolina North Carolina, state in the SE United States. It is bordered by the Atlantic Ocean (E), South Carolina and Georgia (S), Tennessee (W), and Virginia (N). Facts and Figures
Area, 52,586 sq mi (136,198 sq km). Pop. Triangle. (13) That's where the heaviest emphasis on entrepreneurship is; entrepreneurs like to cluster together. So it is really the subcultures
This is a list of subcultures. A
When I was in Ireland in 1984, the Irish economy was terrible. It was one of the worst economies in the European Union in 1984--high debt ratio, something like 35 percent. (14) Some homes did not have telephones. The economy was in terrible shape. (15) We started teaching entrepreneurship at the University of Limerick The university is located along the River Shannon, on a 200 acre (0.8 km²) site in the 600 acre (2.4 km²) National Technological Park at Plassey, 5 km from Limerick city centre. The university has currently in excess of 11,000 full-time undergraduate students and 1,500 part-time students. , which is on the Limerick Limerick, city, Republic of Ireland
Limerick, city (1991 pop. 56,083), seat of Co. Limerick, SW Republic of Ireland, at the head of the Shannon estuary. The city has a port with two docks. side, and in Dublin at the University College Dublin, then in Cork and in Galway.
Then a coalition between the government, the universities, and businesses was formed. Now the Irish economy, in just 20 years, is one of the strongest in Europe. (16) What a tremendous transformation. When a minister in the government said, "Let's have entrepreneurship throughout," I said, "That will not be possible. There are going to be pockets of entrepreneurship," and indeed, that is what has occurred today.
Families also make a difference. Entrepreneurial families beget be·get
tr.v. be·got , be·got·ten or be·got, be·get·ting, be·gets
1. To father; sire.
2. To cause to exist or occur; produce: Violence begets more violence. entrepreneurs. Teachers make a difference; some exciting teachers really stimulate students to become entrepreneurs. Finally, entrepreneurial role models make a difference. Entrepreneurs like to associate with entrepreneurs.
You need an environment where entrepreneurs can get together and solve each other's problems. That's what we enjoy the best. That's what makes it desirable. What makes it possible? The government. That's what I want to focus on because that's the biggest difference in various countries.
When you look at company formation in Canada, the United States, Germany, China, and Austria, it is the government and the infrastructure set up that makes the company formation process different, either easier or more difficult.
The background of the entrepreneur makes a difference, whether we are technology push or market pull. As you can tell from Mal's talk yesterday, he is a market pull entrepreneur. I knew Kenny Olson Kenny Olson is a guitarist from the suburbs of Detroit, Michigan.
As a native of the Detroit, Michigan, suburbs, guitarist Kenny Olson grew up with an affection for the indigenous traditions of his surroundings - muscle cars, classic rock and Motown music, and the classic (who founded DEC) when he and I were on a board of trustees together. Kenny Olson believed if he had the best technology, he would always win. Digital Equipment is not around today. There has to be a blend between the technology and the market to be successful.
So that's the decision process that entrepreneurs go through, whether in Canada, the United States, Germany, China, or Russia.
The second thing that is the same is the four-stage entrepreneurial process we go through in forming a company (see Table 2). In the first stage, an entrepreneur needs to identify and evaluate the opportunity. It is all about the idea. We need to have an idea that is the basis for a business. If this idea can be protected, as talked about today in a previous session, it is even better. I try to obtain market protection on my products if they are not patentable. Most entrepreneurial concepts aren't patentable.
You need to develop a business plan, particularly if you need outside capital. Venture funding--the VCs, the angels, the banks--will not seriously discuss things with you without at least a mini business plan. You have to obtain the resources. My companies never have enough money and we entrepreneurs never have enough time. These are the two biggest commodities that I wish I had more of. We just finished raising $1.3 million this week to get FDA approval for a medical device company. You need resources such as capital, management, and sources of supply and distribution.
Finally, we need to manage the enterprise. Can entrepreneurs become managers? I think some can, some can't. Sometimes entrepreneurs need to let professional managers help grow the company. The process is the same all over the world.
A country needs ideas, money, and entrepreneurs. The last part of the formula of why companies are created is the infrastructure in the country itself. I have studied this all over the world. Here is a continuum between a poor entrepreneurial culture and a strong entrepreneurial culture (see Table 3).
These are several reasons why one culture or an economy is more entrepreneurial than another. One is ease in company formation. The easier it is to form companies, the more companies are going to be formed. (17) Just look at the laws and the rules in countries regarding what entrepreneurs have to do to form companies. Let us take three situations: forming a company in Austria, in Russia, and in the United States. In the United States you can form a company over the Internet with your credit card for about $200. (18) In Austria, it requires 13 governmental agencies, 10,000 Euros in the bank, and 2,000 Euros in cost. (19) In Russia, it takes about one and a half years with significant costs. (20) Why is entrepreneurship so prevalent in the United States? It is easier to become one.
Number two is the tax rate on businesses. When I was in Norway speaking to a group of entrepreneurs and business people, the Minister of Industry was there. She was not very happy when I said, "Why would you bother to form a company in Norway? Do you know what your tax rate is?" It is extremely high because the country wants a social net.
Same with the tax rate on individuals. If you tax businesses or entrepreneurs heavily, why should they bother forming a company? If I am going to work all the hours, take the risks, I want some kind of return. I want to make some money, the second motivator. Countries need to monitor the tax rate on companies and individuals. Generally, the higher the tax rates, the less the entrepreneurial activity. (21)
Bankruptcy laws and being able to let people go make a difference in the amount of entrepreneurial activity. You know, in some countries, to fire someone takes about a year. You go through numerous problems trying to get someone off the payroll even if they haven't performed. (22) The better the bankruptcy laws and the easier it is to hire and fire people, (23) the more people are going to become entrepreneurs in a particular country.
The extent of the infrastructure--such things as incubators, government sponsored programs, government training programs, government providing seed capital, and the government providing guaranteed loan programs--can all help provide a positive infrastructure for entrepreneurship. These all affect people forming companies. When all these are available, there is a solid infrastructure for entrepreneurs to form companies.
Finally, there is the overall government attitude towards business and entrepreneurship. Is it pro or not? We have gone through ups and downs ups and downs
Alternating periods of good and bad fortune or spirits.
ups and downs
alternating periods of good and bad luck or high and low spirits of government attitude in the United States, like other countries. The entire atmosphere established by the government for entrepreneurs forming businesses varies significantly across countries.
What makes things different in one country over another is not the people. The people are very similar. They have the same motivations. They have different demographics The attributes of people in a particular geographic area. Used for marketing purposes, population, ethnic origins, religion, spoken language, income and age range are examples of demographic data. : more educated in some countries than others. Obviously, there is a difference between the sexes forming companies in various countries. However, the main differences are the atmosphere, the culture, and infrastructure of the country in forming businesses.
Basically, it is the government's responsibility to create the infrastructure to support company creation. When looking at Canada and the United States, the statistics were very interesting. In Table 4 there is information regarding new firm formation and bankrupt firms from Canadian government material. You will see that basically there has been an increasing formation rate over the last five years in firms that employ more than one individual. (24) If you add the one-person firms, this number would double or maybe triple. In firms that employ more than one individual, there was an increase from 19,500 up to 31,000 in 2005. (25) Interestingly, in Canada bankruptcy has decreased (26) down to its lowest level, 25 percent, below its high in 2001. (27) There were 787 bankrupt firms in 2005. (28) Canada is really moving in the right direction increasing formation rates and decreasing bankruptcy rates. (29) That's a very good sign.
Now, let's look at the U.S. As is indicated in Table 5, the U.S. firm formation is now rising again. (30) Venture capital is increasing. (31) The IPO (Initial Public Offering) The first time a company offers shares of stock to the public. While not a computer term per se, many founders, employees and insiders of computer companies have found this acronym more exciting than any tech term they ever heard. market is back. (32) There will probably be double the number of high-tech firms going public this year than last year, and new firms are being formed at an accelerated rate. Again, if firms employing more than one individual would be included, this number would triple. (33)
There were 671,000 firms formed in 2005. The U.S. is increasing its firm formation rate as the economy has improved. (34) Over the last three years firm closures have stayed about the same. (35) Remember, in the U.S. bankruptcy means that the firm isn't yet dead. The firm can come back out of bankruptcy as occurred with Delta and Continental and other major corporations. (36) The U.S. had 544,000 bankrupt firm closures in 2005, which stayed constant for the last three years. The number in bankruptcy was high in 2000 and 2001, as you would expect, reflecting the bubble and the dot com dot com - com problem. (37)
The interesting thing is that about the same number of firms form each year as fail. Maybe a small net gain of 30,000 to 40,000 companies a year. The failure rate is about 70 percent. (38) This is not totally accurate, as firms that form in the home and one-person companies are not tracked well. Only in Slovenia are all companies tracked well, as there are only about one-and-a-half million people in the country.
Basically, there is the same closure in terms of openings in the United States with about 70 to 80 percent of companies failing over a five-year period from startup. (39) The U.S. forms a lot more companies than Canada and will continue to do so.
The next table, Table 6, is World Bank statistics for Canada, China, the European Union, India, South Africa South Africa, Afrikaans Suid-Afrika, officially Republic of South Africa, republic (2005 est. pop. 44,344,000), 471,442 sq mi (1,221,037 sq km), S Africa. , and the United States and how they are doing in terms of entrepreneurship. First, the utility costs are very interesting. It is cheaper to run a company in the United States in terms of utilities; (40) only China, India, and Africa are cheaper. So companies in the U.S. have an advantage in terms of utility cost as well as basic construction costs. Canada has a very high cost of getting into business and operating a business because of construction and utility costs versus other countries in the world. (41)
You look at the percent in terms of contracts and how much it will cost to get started; this measure by the World Bank is a percent of debt. Another measure of the World Bank is the percent of debt. In the U.S., this is about 7.7 percent. (42) Canada has a very high debt ratio in terms of attorney cost. (43)
The tax rate is also a key issue. In the United States, the tax rate is 46 percent on average because of the progressive tax rate. (44) In Canada it is 43 percent. (45) Look at the tax rate in China, India, and Austria. These countries place a tremendous tax burden on entrepreneurs setting up and running their companies, 56 percent, 77 percent, and 81 percent, respectively. (46)
Finally, the World Bank has a very unique system of rating countries in terms of starting a business and in terms of ease of doing business in 174 countries. (47) Canada was ranked number one by the World Bank in terms of starting a business, number one out of 174 countries. (48) The U.S. was four. (49)
And in terms of doing business, Canada was four, and the U.S. was three. (50) In terms of the World Bank looking at countries being entrepreneurial, the U.S. was in the top five, and Canada was number one in the category of starting a business. (51)
As expected, it is more difficult in the European Union. Even though they call themselves a union, they are not. It is different doing business in Austria versus Germany versus Ireland. It is very different doing business there, with Austria ranked 74. (52) It is generally more difficult to start and operate businesses in countries in the European Union.
China is extremely difficult, and I can vouch for vouch for
verb 1. guarantee, back, certify, answer for, swear to, stick up for (informal) stand witness, give assurance of, asseverate, go bail for
verb 2. that personally. India is 88 (53) and South Africa 57. (54) You can see on a country-by-country comparison, it is very different in forming and starting and operating a business. What does this reflect? Mostly the infrastructure of the countries previously discussed: tax rates, ease of company formation, bankruptcy laws, government pro-business attitudes, incubators, guaranteed bank loans, or even providing equity.
These make a difference on a country basis in terms of whether it is going to be an entrepreneurial culture. In terms of entrepreneurship throughout the world, there are several things needed.
You have to have the idea. You need to have money available, particularly seed or startup capital, the most difficult capital to obtain.
You need to have entrepreneurs trained and willing and wanting to start new companies. These potential entrepreneurs need to feel it is desirable, and possible. And you need the infrastructure available to start and operate companies. When these four things are available, what happens?
One, ideas and creativity turn into businesses. While there are some differences, with some nations being more creative than others, there is creativity and ideas present in every country. The United States is very innovative and creative. One thing I monitor is the number of patents filed by U.S. versus non-U.S. citizens. Only one time in the last 20 years have more patents been filed in the United States by foreigners than by U.S. citizens. (55) As long as the U.S. continues to be innovative, I am not as worried about our competitive position. As long as Canada and the United States remain innovative, creative, and entrepreneurial, China can do what it wants to do.
Second, both countries need to have seed capital available. Again, in the United States, there is a strong angel community, and they are now getting into what is called bands of angels. I really don't know how much impact this will have because I think the real wealth will never get into a group. They like to do things individually. But we will see what happens. There are bands of angel groups operating in the United States today. (56) There are two bands in Arizona. (57) On the other hand, there is little venture capital in Arizona. The six venture capital firms Name Location Founding date Managing Partners/Directors Specialty Capital managed
5AM Ventures Menlo Park, CA; Waltham, MA 2002 John Diekman, PhD (managing partner), Scott Rocklage, PhD (managing partner), Andrew Schwab (managing partner) life sciences $200M  are all fully funded, fully vested.
Third, entrepreneurs are more similar than different. They are like Mal and myself. We are crazy and passionate. We love what we do, and we are going to do it, no matter what it is. And finally, entrepreneurship varies greatly reflecting the infrastructure, government attitudes, and culture of a country.
That's what makes the difference. You need to challenge your Canadian government. We need to challenge the U.S. government. How are you going to help build value? How are you going to stimulate and protect innovation? How are you going to support taking technology to the marketplace by entrepreneurs?
While I sent these slides in about three months ago, I did not know Mal was going to use the same closing as I am--a Robert Frost poem. What is particularly interesting in the poem are the last two stanzas. You look down the road and you come to a fork. This is how Frost sets the stage in New England New England, name applied to the region comprising six states of the NE United States—Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, and Connecticut. The region is thought to have been so named by Capt. , one of my favorite parts of the word. Frost concludes: I looked at the fork--I knew I had a choice to take one branch or the other. (58)
We have all had what I call fork-in-the-road experiences. Look at your life. There may be five, six fork decisions that radically affected your life from then on. One of mine was going to Ireland in 1984. I spent eight months living in a country helping impact its economy--an incredibly life-changing experience.
Frost ends that poem saying: "I took the one (the fork) less traveled by, and that has made all the difference." (59) That's what entrepreneurs do. It is the passion we have.
It is crazy, you know, to go through this process and finally make something of it and think, "Why would I do that again?" Yet you go back and do it again, again, and again. That's how entrepreneurs are.
Thank you very much. You have been very attentive at·ten·tive
1. Giving care or attention; watchful: attentive to detail.
2. Marked by or offering devoted and assiduous attention to the pleasure or comfort of others. . I will be glad to answer any questions.
DISCUSSION FOLLOWING THE REMARKS OF DR. ROBERT HISRICH
MR. McILROY: We are into our Q and A session now, and we have 22 minutes. The floor is open. Who is first on deck?
DR. HISRICH: I was either very stimulating or very boring, one of the two.
DR. BARBER: So far in our discussions here, we have been worrying most about helping entrepreneurs, and you have ended up with a line, which says our governments really need some help. How do you do that?
DR. HISRICH: That's very hard. Starting companies is relatively easy compared to that. I think there are several ways that we can assist government in doing that. At least, I am trying to do that in Slovenia, Hungary, and Russia.
It was said very nicely today before lunch, who contributes the net employment? Who contributes the number of new products to the marketplace? It is mostly the small business/entrepreneurial sector. I think one thing we can do is help the government understand this sector's economic development.
What can you do to change the government and the rules and laws to make people more interested in forming those companies? That is a long term process, which I am working on in Slovenia and Hungary where there is a lot of wealth to do this. (60)
How do I get wealth to invest, and how do I get the government to relax some of the rules? One thing I came up with is forming a venture fund with the government, matching each individual's investment dollar for dollar, and is giving 100 percent tax benefit for every dollar invested in this particular fund, established to invest in entrepreneurs. (61) Also, I am training people how to evaluate businesses in which to invest; they are feeling more security because they have other monies investing with them and they get a tax benefit. It is important to make the laws more positive for investing and entrepreneurial activity.
MR. McILROY: Daniel?
MR. SANDLER: One of the real difficulties in Canada and the United States is that we live in federal jurisdictions, and there is competition between states and provinces in Canada. And from a federal level, from a country level, do you just have to live with the fact there are going to be areas because we know entrepreneurs go into pockets, and that's just the way it will be, or is there enough to go around in all of the provinces and all of the states to have some piece of the body?
DR. HISRICH: That's a great question. I was asked that in Ireland in 1984 because they wanted to have a universal entrepreneurial society. I have never seen a universal entrepreneurial society. I would like to tell you we can do that but I have never seen it occur. I think what will happen is that there will be these pockets of predominance pre·dom·i·nance also pre·dom·i·nan·cy
The state or quality of being predominant; preponderance.
Noun 1. predominance - the state of being predominant over others
predomination, prepotency in Canada as in the United States, Ireland, Germany, and Austria. Austria will have one--Vienna.
And what do you do with any surplus money? We help these other areas develop through other mechanisms. I just don't think you are going to see entrepreneurship throughout any country.
MR. McILROY: Dr. King has a question.
DR. KING: What do we have to worry about from the developing world? In other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke"
put differently , who is catching up, and how can we protect our flanks?
DR. HISRICH: That's a great question, Henry. I thought you said the questions would be easy.
MR. McILROY: That's a love ball. That's about as soft a question you will get from Dr. King.
DR. HISRICH: Thank you, Henry.
Two of my books are in the Chinese language. My Entrepreneurship (62) book sold over 200,000 copies in the Chinese language. A friend of mine tells me that means it really sold 300,000. It still is not as bad as Iran where this professor e-mailed me and said, "We love your book. We are not part of the international copyright community. We are going to translate it. Would you write a letter?"
I thought, "Let me see what you are asking me. Write a letter for you to rip off my book, as I receive no royalty." I waited a few days, wrote him back saying, "I can't write the letter, but I would love a couple copies of the book when you publish it." Six months later two copies of the Iranian edition arrived.
Anyway, I am fortunate because that book and my Thirteen Biggest Problems (63) book are in Chinese. This has allowed me the opportunity to meet top government officials. I will never forget, I was in Beijing a few years ago with the president of one of the premier universities and we were at this wonderful table he hosted; he has absolute impeccable im·pec·ca·ble
1. Having no flaws; perfect. See Synonyms at perfect.
2. Incapable of sin or wrongdoing.
[Latin impecc English. For every 500,000 Chinese studying English, one American is studying Chinese. I asked, "If you let people like myself into this country you are never going to be the same."
I had just lectured to thousands of students and entrepreneurs. My book is being sold. I had been interviewed by 150 people from the media, print, radio and television. He responded, "We know that. We also know we can't compete with the West with the economic situation the way it is; and we are going to compete."
So if I look around the world and ask who, ten years from today, are going to be the economic powerhouses? China is going to be one. They are powerful today and they will continue to be powerful in the future.
So if you look at a competitive threat, Henry, it is going to be China. Some people say India but I just haven't seen that. I have tried to do things in India. India just has its ups and downs. Theoretically, they should be ahead of China, but again, it's the government, the infrastructure, and the attitudes they have there.
I don't see India becoming significant in the next few years. So it is going to be from China. As Mal said he is competing with Chinese products that are probably his design. China is here to stay.
MR. McILROY: We have a question at the back there, and then we have a question at the right.
MR. KERESTER: Is there an optimum tax rate that would not discourage entrepreneurship and still raise enough money for a business?
DR. HISRICH: Of course, zero.
MR. KERESTER: You really think that would contribute to it?
DR. HISRICH: No, not really. I am satisfied with the U.S. tax rate--but will not quoted be on that.
I think entrepreneurs are literally fair-minded people, and we need to pay to play. The problem is with a tax system that is unwieldy, when the government gets more than you get, or gets above 50 percent, that is close to the maximum.
While it bothers us to write tax checks, by the same token, we understand the needs and infrastructure, and most entrepreneurs, interestingly enough, give back. It is this giving back mentality they have, particularly in our two countries where you make money and give it back.
Look at all the foundations in the U.S. that now take care of some of the costs of the government, the museums, the art institutes, and things like what Mal is doing here in Cleveland. Entrepreneurs give back. That reminds me That Reminds Me is a series of programmes broadcast on BBC Radio 4 where someone (usually) connected with comedy talks about their life for thirty minutes in front of a live audience. , in terms of Henry' s question, Chinese entrepreneurs know how to give back.
That's very significant because that means they truly understand the entire entrepreneurial model, making money, giving it back; their entrepreneurs already have named buildings at Chinese universities. (64) Nowhere in Europe do you see that. (65) You don't see that in Japan. (66) You don't see that in Australia. (67)
China is a force to be reckoned with. Does that help? I don't know if the right tax amount is 15 percent or 20 percent, but it has to be below 50, and the lower it is the better. But a zero tax rate, I don't think that would be that beneficial.
MR. McILROY: Morris, we are just going to go to Brad Cherniak, and then you are next.
MR. CHERNIAK: With all that is going on in the world and in China and the emerging opportunities, is it becoming harder or easier to become an entrepreneur in America, say, ten years ago or 20 years ago than now?
DR. HISRICH: Do you take the hard questions?
MR. McILROY: No. I am just the moderator moderator - A person, or small group of people, who manages a moderated mailing list or Usenet newsgroup. Moderators are responsible for determining which email submissions are passed on to the list or newsgroup. .
DR. HISRICH: You set me up for this, Henry. That's a very interesting question.
I don't think it is any more difficult today than it was; it is a very hypercompetitive world, but generally entrepreneurs are very competitive creatures anyway, so that doesn't bother us. In fact, I like it because that means I have to be smarter, better, and faster than anybody else. I would much rather have a competitive environment than a noncompetitive one.
When it really gets difficult for us is when there is not money available, so the era of 2000 to 2004 was tough. I mean, entrepreneurs just couldn't find money and we need money. And, banks aren't responsible for that because they are asset based lenders.
The trouble is, as somebody said, we have no assets except for intellectual property. Some ventures had no protection. So if money is available, then we are fine; I don't think it is any harder today. Today there is more money available than ever in the history of the world. Today it is sort of fun to be an entrepreneur.
I have had less trouble raising capital, and large public equity funds have significant monies. Some people worry about them but I like them. My companies are always up for sale. As long as we agree on valuation, you can buy any of them. I think it is the same in Canada. I have never done business in Canada except for my Boston Lens business and that was 20 years ago when I was an MIT professor.
MR. McILROY: Morris?
MR. SHANKER: I want to follow up on Henry's question. You suggested ten years from now China will be a big player to be worried about, words to that effect. Are you then suggesting the general prosperity of this country will then be diminished if China becomes the big player or any other country becomes the big player?
DR. HISRICH: I am sorry I didn't respond succinctly suc·cinct
adj. suc·cinct·er, suc·cinct·est
1. Characterized by clear, precise expression in few words; concise and terse: a succinct reply; a succinct style.
2. enough because I didn't mean that. No, I think China is a dominant economic power that is going to be here for the next decade.
The United States and Canada are fine. I don't worry about China. In fact, I think it is better to have another economic power. I don't think our two economies can carry the world any more. I think the world is too big and too complicated.
So I find what they are doing--low cost manufacturing--is very beneficial. I am a manufacturer, and I don't consider that a threat. I consider that a reality that they are going to be here as an economic power. I think our prosperity is going to stay the same as long as we innovate in·no·vate
v. in·no·vat·ed, in·no·vat·ing, in·no·vates
To begin or introduce (something new) for or as if for the first time.
To begin or introduce something new. and be entrepreneurial. Our countries are in an entirely different product/market space.
With about 80 percent of the economy of the U.S. in service-based business, low cost manufacturing is not a threat. (68) I would love to say manufacturing is coming back, but I just don't think it will at least, as we now know manufacturing today. China is also a big market, too. Wait till the people start making money over there.
MR. McILROY: We have another question I think from Daniel Sandier.
MR. SANDLER: I would like to come back to the angels, and they are the key both in Canada and the United States. A number of things, there has been a huge push in both countries to introduce a federal tax credit. It was deferred by the SBA SBA
Small Business Administration
Noun 1. SBA - an independent agency of the United States government that protects the interests of small businesses and ensures that they receive a fair share of government and seems to have died in committee or is dying in committee.
Do you think, first of all, that is a good thing, an income tax credit at the federal level, and why do you think the governments are so adverse for that if you think it is a good thing?
DR. HISRICH: That's a great question. I never thought about that before. I think people, entrepreneurs, some of them angels now, have accumulated wealth through some means. I think some are going to be angels regardless of the tax credit.
Even if you raise the tax a bit, I would still be an entrepreneur. I am not sure it is going to stimulate any more investment. Maybe it would in Canada --I don't know your culture well enough. I don't think it significantly would in the United States.
Why do I think the governments of the two countries are not doing it? It is the same in every government. I am trying to convince Slovenia they should give 100 percent tax credit for these people to invest. The government doesn't like that. They want instantaneous in·stan·ta·ne·ous
1. Occurring or completed without perceptible delay: Relief was instantaneous.
2. money, not futuristic fu·tur·is·tic
1. Of or relating to the future.
a. Of, characterized by, or expressing a vision of the future: futuristic decor.
b. money. This money won't pay back anything until cash-out time, which may be seven to ten years.
I don't think governments in general are futuristic thinkers. Today it is better to have today's gratification GRATIFICATION. A reward given voluntarily for some service or benefit rendered, without being requested so to do, either expressly or by implication. rather than future gratification. However, I am not a politician. Ireland was interesting. When I was there in 1984, the Irish government tried to attract companies to manufacture there, feeling that would be the salvation of country. That was the policy for years and there are companies manufacturing there. (69) The Irish government gave huge tax incentives, (70) and that didn't really stimulate the economy. (71) I am not sure taxes are ever the main issue.
MR. McILROY: Maybe I could just follow on that topic. One figure that really struck me, Bob, in your numbers was the number of firms that were formed in 2005 in comparison between Canada and the United States. Usually in Canada, there is the ten times rule. (72) Our population has been generally one tenth of yours, so we usually expect to see a number in the U.S. to be ten times what it is in Canada.
But in 2005, 30,000 new firms in Canada roughly; (73) the United States, 672,000. (74) So in other words, it was 20 times instead of ten times, and I see that as twice as high per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. , which is a significant difference. That sort of flies in the face, I think, of the World Bank numbers where they sort of seem to say we were the same.
I, as a Canadian, think that there are far fewer entrepreneurial firms formed in Canada, and your numbers seem to hold that out. (75) The World Bank numbers, I am not so sure, and I was wondering if you could comment on that, why you see more firms formed in the United States and more of an entrepreneurial spirit?
DR. HISRICH: Good question. These numbers came right from the government numbers. Remember these numbers reflect people that form a company and have at least one employee, not a single employee firm. That would really change these numbers if we add single employee firm formations. I think it will probably change the numbers equally in both countries.
The numbers would at least double. The U.S. has always had a culture (and I don't know Canada well enough except my experience in Canada with my Boston lens) forming things, being creative, and being our own boss. And we have this angel environment that makes money available. (76)
We have taught entrepreneurship in our schools a lot longer than Canada. Remember, teachers do have an impact. (77) This started in Canada at the university level about six years later than the U.S. (78) It started rigorously in the U.S. in about 1980. (79) Germany just started teaching entrepreneurship in their schools two years ago. (80)
So educationally, we have been more prone to create entrepreneurs, and our society is probably more open and supportive of entrepreneurs. It is just the culture that the U.S. has had throughout, which perhaps hasn't been quite as strong in Canada.
By the same token, the World Bank is talking about their overall measurement, so these are their rankings. The numbers in the United States and Canada versus other countries make relative sense to me.
MR. McILROY: I understand we are down to two minutes, but Henry has just given me the you-are-out-of-time sign. So I think we are going to call this to a close.
I would like to very much thank Dr. Hisrich for traveling from Arizona to join us. I think we can all agree that he brings a unique perspective to the topic of this Conference, and I would like you to join me in thanking him for his presentation.
Session Chair--James McIlroy
Speaker--Dr. Robert Hisrich
* Dr. Robert D. Hisrich is the Garvin Professor of Global Entrepreneurship and Director of the Center for Global Entrepreneurship at Thunderbird thunderbird
In North American Indian mythology, a powerful spirit in the form of a bird that watered the earth and made vegetation grow. Lightning was believed to flash from its eyes or beak, and the beating of its wings was thought to represent rolling thunder. . In addition to his M.B.A. and Ph.D. degrees from the University of Cincinnati, Dr. Hisrich has honorary doctorates from Chuvash State University The I. N. (Il'ia Nikolaevich) Ulianov Chuvash State University is the main university of Chuvashia (or the Chuvash Republic) and is located in Cheboksary, the capital of the Republic (Population 450,000), on the Volga River northeast of Moscow. (Russia) and the University of Miskolc Location
Most of the buildings can be found in Egyetemváros ("University Town"), a part of the city of Miskolc. Its area is about 850,000 square metres. The Béla Bartók Music Institute, which became a faculty of the university in 1997, can be found in the downtown, in the (Hungary), and held Fulbright Professorships at the International Management Center in Budapest and the Foundation for Small Enterprise Economic Development. He has authored or co-authored fourteen books, including Entrepreneurship: Starting, Developing and Managing a New Enterprise in its 7th edition and Small Business Solutions: How to Fix and Prevent the 13 Biggest Problems That Derail de·rail
intr. & tr.v. de·railed, de·rail·ing, de·rails
1. To run or cause to run off the rails.
2. Business. Dr. Hisrich has served on the editorial boards of The Journal of Business Venturing, Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice, Journal of Small Business Management, and Journal of International Business and Entrepreneurship. He has instituted academic and training programs such as an entrepreneurship training program for high school teachers in Russia and college level programs at the Institute of International Entrepreneurship and Management in Russia and the Entrepreneurship Center in the Ukraine.
(1) See Poly(ethylene oxide ethylene oxide Occupational medicine A gas used to sterilize medical supplies and other materials ) coated surfaces, Patent Storm, http://www.patentstorm.us/patents/6616982-description.html (last visited Sept. 27, 2007).
(2) Clark S. Judge, The Tax That Ate the Economy, WALL ST. J., June 24, 1991, available at http://www.whwg.com/thefirm/sample.php/60/Clark_S._Judge.
(3) See generally, Stephen D. Prowse, The Economics of the Private Equity Market, ECON ECON Economics (course)
ECON Economy (minimum cost speed schedule)
ECON Centre for Economic Analysis
ECON Eastern Coalition of Nations (Star Trek) . & FIN fin, organ of locomotion characteristic of fish and consisting of thin tissue supported by cartilaginous or bony rays. In some fish, e.g., the eel, a single fin extends from the back, around the tail, and along the ventral surface. . POL'Y REV., Q III 1998, 21, available at http://ideas.repec.org/a/fip/fedder/y1998iqiiip21-34.html#download.
(4) See generally, Maria Minniti & William D. Bygrave, National Entrepreneurship Assessment United States of America UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. The name of this country. The United States, now thirty-one in number, are Alabama, Arkansas, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Louisiana, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, : 2003 Executive Report 7 2003 GLOBAL ENTREPRENEURSHIP MONITOR available at http://www.kauffman.org/pdf/gem_2003_us_report.pdf.
(5) Id. at 10.
(6) Shi Li & Renwei Zhao, Changes in the Distribution of Wealth in China, 1995-2002 19 (January 2007) (United Nations University--World Institute for Development Economics Research ed. 2007) available at http://www.wider.unu.edu/publications/rps/rps2007/rp200703.pdf.
(7) E.g., Daily Says Mirko Tus the Wealthiest Slovenian, Republic of Slovenia Government Communications Office, http://www.ukom.gov.si/eng/slovenia/publications/slovenianews/4445/4457/(last visited Sept. 27, 2007).
(8) E.g., Mislav Simatovic, Croatia's 50 Wealthiest, 597 NACIONAL: NEOVISNI NEWS MAGAZIN, Apr. 4, 2007, available at http://www.nacional.hr/en/articles/view/33809/18/.
(9) E.g., Eszter Balazs, Fotex Boss Tops List of Countries Richest, BUDAPEST SUN, Nov. 28, 2002, available at http://www.budapestsun.com/cikk.php?id=14776.
(10) See generally, Laura d'Andrea Tyson et al., Promoting Entrepreneurship in Eastern Europe Eastern Europe
The countries of eastern Europe, especially those that were allied with the USSR in the Warsaw Pact, which was established in 1955 and dissolved in 1991. , 6 SMALL BUS. ECON. 165 (1994).
(12) DAVID David, in the Bible
David, d. c.970 B.C., king of ancient Israel (c.1010–970 B.C.), successor of Saul. The Book of First Samuel introduces him as the youngest of eight sons who is anointed king by Samuel to replace Saul, who had been deemed a failure. BOLLIER, THE GLOBAL WAVE OF ENTREPRENEURIALISM: HARNESSING THE SYNERGIES OF PERSONAL INITIATIVE, DIGITAL TECHNOLOGIES, AND GLOBAL COMMERCE 14 (The Aspen Institute The Aspen Institute is an international nonprofit organization founded in 1950 dedicated to "fostering enlightened leadership, the appreciation of timeless ideas and values, and open-minded dialogue on contemporary issues. 1999) available at http://www.bollier.org/pdf/globwave.pdf; SHERRILL JOHNSON, YOUNG SOCIAL ENTREPREUNEURS IN CANADA 4 (Canadian Centre for Social Entrepreneurship Social entrepreneurship is the work of a social entrepreneur. A social entrepreneur is someone who recognizes a social problem and uses entrepreneurial principles to organize, create, and manage a venture to make social change. School of Business, University of Alberta 2003).
(13) See, Kurt Badenhausen, Best Places for Businesses and Careers, FORBES, May 5, 2005, available at http://www.forbes.com/2005/05/05/05bestplaces.html; Tyson, supra A relational DBMS from Cincom Systems, Inc., Cincinnati, OH (www.cincom.com) that runs on IBM mainframes and VAXs. It includes a query language and a program that automates the database design process. note 10, at 36, 38.
(14) Roisin Ni Mhaille Battel, Ireland's "Celtic Tiger For the Irish dance show, see .
Celtic Tiger (Irish: Tíogar Ceilteach) is a name for the period of rapid economic growth in the Republic of Ireland that began in the 1990s and slowed in 2001, only to pick up pace again in 2003 " Economy, 28 SCI (Scalable Coherent Interface) An IEEE standard for a high-speed bus that uses wire or fiber-optic cable. It can transfer data up to 1GBytes/sec.
(hardware) SCI - 1. Scalable Coherent Interface.
2. UART. ., TECH., & HUM. VALUES 93 (2003).
(15) NAT'L COMPETITIVENESS COUNCIL, OVERVIEW OF IRELAND'S PRODUCTIVE PERFORMANCE, 1980-2005 6, http://www.competitiveness.ie/ncc/reports/ncc_productivity_1980-2005/ ncc_productivity_1980-2005.pdf (Ireland is still behind the rest of the EU for many utilities).
(16) Battel, supra note 14, at 93.
(17) E.g., Index of Economic Freedom: Belarus, Heritage Foundation, http://www.heritage.org/index/country.cfm?id=Belarus (last visited Sept. 27, 2007) (stating that burdensome regulations inhibit business in Belarus).
(18) E.g., The Company Corporation, http://www.corporate.com/ (last visited Sept. 27, 2007).
(19) See generally STARTING A BUSINESS IN AUSTRIA, SCHONHERR RECHTSANWALTE 5, (Austrian Business Agency), available at http://www.aba.gv.at/en/pages/download.asp?file= downloads/StartingBusiness.pdf.
(20) See Establishing a Business in Russia: How to Set up and Register a Company in Russia, Company Formations, Way to Russia http://www.waytorussia.net/business/startingup.html (last visited Sept. 27, 2007).
(21) See, Edmund Andrews, Paulson Says U.S. Hurt by High Tax Rates, N.Y. TIMES, Jul. 25, 2007, available at http://www.nytimes.com/2007/07/25/business/ 25tax.html?_r=-1&oref=slogin (demonstrating that high tax rates inhibiting economic growth in US).
(22) See Index of Economic Freedom: Austria, Heritage Foundation, http://www.heritage.org/index/country.cfm?id=Austria (last visited Sept. 27, 2007).
(23) See Nathalie Martin, American Bankruptcy Laws Encouraging Risk-Taking and Entrepreneurship, EJOURNAL U.S.A., http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/ites/0106/ijee/martin.htm (last visited Sept. 27, 2007); Indepth: France--Student Protests, CBC News CBC News is the department within the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation responsible for the news gathering and production of news programs on CBC television, radio and online services. Online, Mar. 28, 2006, http://www.cbc (1) (Cell Broadcast Center) See cell broadcast.
(2) (Cipher Block Chaining) In cryptography, a mode of operation that combines the ciphertext of one block with the plaintext of the next block. .ca/news/background/france-studentprotests/ (stating that overly burdensome labor laws restricting liberty to hire and fire has discouraged business in France).
(24) See, BENJAMIN TAL TAL - Transaction Application Language , FOR LOVE OR MONEY? A STUDY OF ENTREPRENEURSHIP IN CANADA (CIBC World Markets CIBC World Markets is the investment banking division of the Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce. It helps governments, large companies, and other large institutions obtain capital and credit and is a primary dealer in U.S. Treasury securities. , Inc. 2005) available at http://www.cibc CIBC Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce
CIBC Centres Interinstitutionnels de Bilan de Compétences
CIBC Commonwealth Institute of Biological Control (Trinidad)
CIBC Commercial International Brokerage Company .com/ca/pdf/entrepreneurshipstudy.pdf; see also Study: Trends in Business Bankruptcies, Statistics Canada, Oct. 12, 2006 http://www.statcan.ca/Daily/English/061012/d061012c.htm.
(25) See Hon Hon abbr (= honourable, honorary) → en títulos . Maxime Bernier Maxime Bernier, PC, MP (born January 18, 1963) is Canada's Minister of Foreign Affairs.  A businessman and lawyer, he was elected to the Canadian House of Commons in the January 2006 federal election to represent the riding of Beauce with 67% of the vote, the highest , Minister of Industry, Keynote Address keynote address
An opening address, as at a political convention, that outlines the issues to be considered. Also called keynote speech.
Noun 1. for the Information Technology Association of Canada Information Technology Association of Canada (or Association canadienne de la technolgie de l'information) is a lobby group representing members (companies) of Canada's information and communications technologies (ICT) industry. in Ottawa, Canada (Feb. 6, 2007).
(26) Statistics Canada, supra note 24.
(28) See, TAL, supra note 24.
(29) OFFICE OF THE SUPERINTENDENT OF BANKRUPTCY Superintendent of Bankruptcy (Canada)
The role of the Superintendent of Bankruptcy is to ensure that bankruptcies and insolvencies in Canada are conducted in a fair and orderly manner. CANADA, INSOLVENCY IN CANADA IN 2006 (2007), available at http://strategis.ic.gc.ca/epic/site/bsf-osb.nsf/vwapj/Insolvency Canada2006_E.pdf/$FILE/InsolvencyCanada2006_E.pdf.
(30) RICH PERLINE, ROBERT AXTELL, & DANIEL TEITELBAUM, VOLATILITY AND ASYMMETRY Asymmetry
A lack of equivalence between two things, such as the unequal tax treatment of interest expense and dividend payments. OF SMALL FIRM GROWTH RATES Growth Rates
The compounded annualized rate of growth of a company's revenues, earnings, dividends, or other figures.
Remember, historically high growth rates don't always mean a high rate of growth looking into the future. OVER INCREASING TIME FRAMES (SBA OFFICE OF ADVOCACY 2006), available at http://www.sba.gov/advo/researcldrs285tot.pdf.
(31) See example, PRICEWATERHOUSCOOPERS AND NATIONAL VENTURE CAPITAL ASSOCIATION, Q2 2006 VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTING REACHES HIGHEST LEVEL SINCE 2002 AT $6.3 BILLION (2006), available at http://nvca.org/pdf/MoneytreeQ22006.pdf.
(32) Daisy Sarma, The Top 10 IPOs of 2006, THE MONEY TIMES, Jan. 2, 2007, http://www.themoneytimes.com/articles/20070101/ the_top_10_ipos_of_2006-id-102586.html
(33) See e.g., Robert Gawn, Going public has gotten better in Massachusetts, THE BOSTON GLOBE, May 16, 2006, available at http://www.boston.com/business/globe/globe100/ Globe_100_2006/articles/going_public_has_gotten_better in massachusetts ipo_growth in 05_nearly_doubled/; compare, Roy Harris Roy Ellsworth Harris (February 12, 1898 in Chandler, Oklahoma, United States - October 1, 1979), was an American classical composer. He wrote much music on American subjects, becoming best known for his Symphony No. 3. , Maybe Next Year, CFO See Chief Financial Officer. MAG (MAGnetic) A common abbreviation for magnetic. For example, "mag tape" means magnetic tape. ., Oct. 1, 2005, available at http://cfo.com/article.cfm/3220008?f=search.
(34) SMALL BUSINESS ASSOCIATION, THE SMALL BUSINESS ECONOMY FOR DATA YEAR 2005, A REPORT TO THE PRESIDENT 9 (United States Government Printing Office United States Government Printing Office: see Government Printing Office, United States. Dec. 2006), available at http://leeds.colorado.edu/uploadedFiles/Faculty_and_Research/ Research_Centers/Business_Research_Division/sb_econ2006.pdf.
(35) Frequently Asked Questions, Small Business Association, http://www.sba.gov/advo/stats/sbfaq.txt (citing the U.S. Department of Commerce) (last visited Nov. 20, 2007).
(36) Aude Lagorce & Padraic Cassidy, Delta Air Lines Exits Bankruptcy, MARKET WATCH, Apr. 30, 2007, http://www.marketwatch.com/news/story/delta-air-lines-emerges-bankruptcy/ story.aspx?guid=%7B13D92E05-7633-4376-B8E8-3EE20E25D790%7D; see also Jennifer Bails, How One Airline Survived--Twice, PITTSBURGH TRIB TRIB Tributary
TRIB Tire Retread Information Bureau
Trib Chicago Tribune Newspaper
TRIB Transfer Rate of Information Bits (ANSI formula for calculating throughput)
TRIB Transmission Rate of Information Bits .-REV., Oct, 10, 2004, http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/s_260256.html.
(37) Compare, Bankruptcy Statistics, US Courts, http://www.uscourts.gov/bnkrupctystats/statistics.htm (last visited Nov. 20, 2007).
(38) WILLIAM SHANKLIN, SIX TIMELESS MARKETING BLUNDERS 6 (Lexington Books 1998).
(39) Adrienne Leigh, Buying a Franchise: Go Into Business for Yourself, Not by Yourself, Hous. Bus. J., Aug. 24, 2007, http://masshightech.bizjournals.com/masshightech/othercities/ houston/stories/2007/08/27/focus11.html?b=1188187200%5E1511128.
(40) Dealing with Licenses, The World Bank Group, (2007) http://www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreTopics/DealingLicenses/, (showing that the U.S. spends 13.4% of its income per capita on construction and utility costs).
(42) Enforcing Contracts, The World Bank Group, (2007), http://www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreTopics/EnforcingContracts/. (U.S. is now at 9.4%).
(43) Id. (showing that Canada is now at 16.2%).
(44) Paying Taxes, The World Bank Group, (2007), http://www.doingbusiness.org/ExploreTopics/PayingTaxes/.
(45) Id. (showing that Canada now Canada Now (more formally CBC News: Canada Now) is the early-evening national news program aired on CBC Television, the main English television network of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation, between 2000 and 2007. has a total tax rate of 45.9).
(46) Id. (showing that China now has a total tax rate of 73.9; India's is 70.6; Austria's is 54.6).
(47) Economy Rankings, The World Bank Group, (2007) http://www.doingbusiness.org/economyrankings/, (showing current rankings are from 1-174).
(48) Id. (showing that now Canada is ranked as #2).
(50) Id. (showing that Canada is now ranked #7, but the U.S. is still ranked #3).
(51) WORLD BANK, DOING BUSINESS 2007: HOW TO REFORM 8 (2007), available at http://www, doingbusiness.org/documents/ DoingBusiness2007_FullReport.pdf.
(52) Id. at 97.
(53) Id. at 118.
(54) Id. at 141.
(55) See generally Rachel Konrad, Reverse Brain Drain Reverse brain drain refers to the process where human capital moves in reverse from a more developed country to a less develop country that is developing rapidly.
Reverse brain drain can occur when scientists or engineers migrate to a more developed country to learn in its Threatens U.S. Competitiveness, Study Says, UNION TRIB., Aug. 21, 2007, available at http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/business/ 20070821-2102-reversebraindrain.html (discussing the increasing number of U.S. patents filed by foreigners).
(56) See generally JEFFREY SOHL, CTR See click-through rate. . FOR VENTURE RESEARCH, THE ANGEL INVESTOR An individual who invests his or her own money in a private company, which is typically a startup. An angel investor is not an employee or member of a bank, venture capital firm or other financial institution that normally makes such investments. MARKET IN 2006: THE ANGEL MARKET CONTINUES STEADY GROWTH (2006), http://unhinfo.unh.edu/news/docs/2006angelmarketanalysis.pdf (overview of the angel investor market in the United States).
(57) See generally Arizona Angels, http://www.arizonaangels.com (last visited Sept. 26, 2007) (homepage for the Arizona Angels, an Arizona-based investment group); Desert Angels, http://www.edesertangels.com (last visited Sept. 26, 2007) (homepage for the Desert Angels, an Arizona-based investment group).
(58) See ROBERT FROST, MOUNTAIN INTERVAL Mountain Interval is a 1916 poetry collection written by Robert Frost. Frost made several alterations in the sequencing of the collection and released the new edition in 1920. 75 (NEW YORK New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of HENRY HOLD AND COMPANY 1999) (1920), http://www.bartleby.com/119/1.html.
(60) See The World Factbook: Hungary, CIA CIA: see Central Intelligence Agency.
(1) (Confidentiality Integrity Authentication) The three important concerns with regards to information security. Encryption is used to provide confidentiality (privacy, secrecy). , http://www.cia.gov/library/publications/theworld-factbook/geos/hu.html (last visited Sept. 26, 2007) (complete profile of Hungary including an economic overview); The World Factbook: Slovenia, CIA, http://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/geos/si.html (last visited Sept. 26, 2007) (complete profile of Slovenia including an economic overview).
(61) See generally Raphael Amit, James Brander & Christoph Zott, Venture-Capital Financing of Entrepreneurship: Theory, Empirical Evidence, and a Research Agenda (Draft: Feb. 1, 1999), available at http://www-management.wharton.upenn.edu/amitresearch/docs/ VCfeb1.pdf (discusses venture funds financing entrepreneurial activity).
(62) See generally ROBERT D. HISRICH, MICHAEL P. PETERS, & DEAN A. SHEPARD, ENTREPRENEURSHIP: Starting, Developing, and Managing a New Enterprise (McGraw-Hill 2007) (1989).
(63) See generally ROBERT D. HISRICH, SMALL BUSINESS SOLUTIONS: HOW TO FIX AND PREVENT THE THIRTEEN BIGGEST PROBLEMS THAT DERAIL BUSINESS (McGraw-Hill 2004).
(64) See generally Alan Hunter Alan C. Hunter (born February 14, 1957) was one of the original five video jockeys (VJ's) on MTV from 1981 to 1987 (along with Nina Blackwood, Mark Goodman, Martha Quinn, and J. J. Jackson). , Centre for Peace and Reconciliation Studies, Coventry University The expanding main campus is situated on the east side of Coventry city centre, which boasts one of the most innovative (and unusual-looking) university libraries in the UK. The university is particularly noted for its world-renowned automotive design and engineering degree courses as , China: Soft Power and Cultural Influence, http://www.ipra2006.com/papers/CRPBC/ChinaSoftPowerAndCulturallnfluence.doc (discussing the growing influence of Chinese entrepreneurs throughout China and the world).
(68) Douglas G. Duncan, Jobs in a Changing American Economy, MORTGAGE BANKING, June 1, 2004, at 2, available at http://www.allbusiness.com/personal-finance/real-estate-mortgage-loans/ 170082-1.html.
(69) See John Bradley John Bradley may refer to:
(70) See Kevin H. O'Rourke, Industrial Policy, Employment Policy and the Non-Traded Sector, 27 J. OF THE STAT. & SOC. INQUIRY SOC'Y OF IRELAND 61, 67 (1994) ("[W]hile manufacturing and traded-sector service companies pay 10 per cent corporation tax, firms in the non-traded services sector pay a 38 per cent rate."), available at http://www.tara.tcd.ie/bitstream/2262/2104/1/jssisiVolXXVII_6192.pdf.
(71) See Bradley & Wright, supra note 69, at 228 (graph displays an increase in Ireland's unemployment numbers throughout the 1980s).
(72) See Lukin Robinson, Book Note, MONTHLY REV., April 1999 at 1 (reviewing JOSEPH K. ROBERTS, IN THE SHADOW OF EMPIRE: CANADA FOR AMERICANS (1998)) ("In population, income and wealth, Canada is about one-tenth the size of the United States."), available at http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_ml132/is_11_50/ai_54517447.
(73) See generally Geoff Lewis, Who in the Worm is Entrepreneurial, CNN CNN
or Cable News Network
Subsidiary company of Turner Broadcasting Systems. It was created by Ted Turner in 1980 to present 24-hour live news broadcasts, using satellites to transmit reports from news bureaus around the world. Money, June I, 2007, http://money.cnn.com/magazines/fsb/fsb_archive/ 2007/06/01/100049637/index.htm (discusses the ease of starting a new business in various countries including the United States and Canada).
(76) See generally THE NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SEED AND VENTURE FUNDS ET AL., SEED AND VENTURE CAPITAL: STATE EXPERIENCE AND OPTIONS MAY 2006 1-4 (2006), http://www.nasvf.org/web/nasvfinf.nsf/pages/svcp.html/$file/Seed% 20and%20Venture%20Capital%20Report%20-%20Final.pdf (discusses history and current state of the venture capital market).
(77) See generally Lena Lena (lē`nə, Rus. lyĕ`nə), river, easternmost of the great rivers of Siberia, c.2,670 mi (4,300 km) long, rising near Lake Baykal, SE Siberian Russia. Lee, Entrepreneurship Education--A Compendium com·pen·di·um
n. pl. com·pen·di·ums or com·pen·di·a
1. A short, complete summary; an abstract.
2. A list or collection of various items. of Related Issues (NUS NUS n abbr (BRIT) (= National Union of Students) → sindicato de estudiantes
NUS n abbr (Brit) (= National Union of Students) → syndicat des étudiants
Entrepreneurship Centre, Working Paper No. WP2005-14, 2005), available at http://unpan1.un.org/intradoc/groups/public/documents/APCITY/UNPAN023986.pdf (discussing the recent trend of entrepreneurship being taught in universities worldwide).