Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,474,287 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

We the people.


The American Revolution was sparked, in part, because the right to trial by jury had been snatched away.

As founding father John Adams declared more than two centuries ago: "Representative government and trial by jury are the heart and lungs of liberty. Without them we have no other fortification against being ridden like horses, fleeced like sheep, worked like cattle, and fed and clothed like swine and hounds."

Yet, today, too many Americans are plagued with ho-hum attitudes when a jury duty summons arrives in the mail. Many concoct excuses to get out of it. Most don't even bother to show up at the courthouse.

Consider these numbers from the final report of the Florida Supreme Court Work Group on Standards for Jury Panel Sizes: Of nearly 1.7 million Floridians summoned for jury duty last year, the statewide average "summoning yield" (calculated by dividing the number of prospective jurors available to serve by the number of prospective jurors summoned) was about 30 percent. That's 10 percent below the national average. Florida's counties range from a low of about 12 percent to a high of about 50 percent.

It's frustrating to judges, like 18th Circuit Judge Charles Holcomb in Titusville, who had to postpone a trial because not enough jurors reported for duty. He was driven to institute a policy of ordering jury skippers to appear before him to explain themselves and possibly be fined, something most judges are reluctant to do.

Grappling with what to do about juror no-shows, the Supreme Court's work group, chaired by Second Judicial Circuit Judge Thomas Bateman, noted, "Indifferent enforcement damages the legitimacy of the jury process. Moreover, those who do not report for service often realize that there are no consequences for their behavior."

Rather than taking an initial hard line of contempt of court and fines, the court's work group recommends giving second chances for Floridians to carry out this crucial civic duty. One suggestion, authorized by Florida law, is to allow jurors to pick a backup date, if the first one is inconvenient. This postponement policy has worked well in Leon County, where Judge Bateman presides, helping boost the compliance rate to 90 percent.

For those jurors who repeatedly ignore summons, the work group urges judges to lower the boom by imposing at least $100 fines and holding no-shows in contempt. Second summons no-shows should be ordered to serve as many as eight hours of community service, spending a portion of that time at the courthouse learning the importance of the American jury system. Part of that education should include a history lesson about the struggle to produce the modern jury of one's peers (as detailed on the Florida Supreme Court's Web page at www.flcourts.org under "Jury Information").

* Jury summons from 1783 British East Florida, published in the St. Augustine East Florida Gazette on April 26, 1783: Only male property owners were eligible for jury service.

* Under the 1838 Florida Constitution, only free, white males could serve as jurors.

* While women were first admitted to practice law in Florida in the late 1890s, it was not until 1949 that Florida allowed women to volunteer for jury service; but few did. In 1961, in Hoyt v. Florida, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld Florida's voluntary jury law for women, concluding that "despite the enlightened emancipation of women," they occupied a unique position "as the center of home and family life." Finally, in 1967, the Florida Legislature passed a law requiring compulsory jury duty for women.

* It wasn't until 1984 that the Florida Supreme Court ruled it unlawful for attorneys to use peremptory challenges to excuse jurors solely because of their race. Not until 1994 was this same ruling extended to the practice of excluding women from juries solely because of their gender.

"This history shows that the Florida jury system is healthy, but in constant need of tending," Chief Justice Barbara Pariente said last year, when she proclaimed May as Juror Appreciation Month.

"We have never had the perfect jury system in Florida, just as the world we live in is itself imperfect. But we remain committed to the ideal that a jury of peers is the best system of justice, since it allows people chosen from the community to determine whether the vast power of the state can take away the life, liberty, or property of one of their own."

Attending jury service breathes meaning into participatory democracy and gives power to the voice of every citizen. "We the People" will not work if jurors will not come when called.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Florida Bar
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:right to trial by jury; Florida
Author:Bookman, Alan B.
Publication:Florida Bar Journal
Article Type:President's page
Date:May 1, 2006
Words:761
Previous Article:Comment on proposals for settlement.(Letters)(Letter to the editor)
Next Article:Looking back.(Letters)(Letter to the editor)
Topics:

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles