Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,550,395 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Ups and downs: a REIT dilemma.


Investors, professional property managers, and real property owners can pool their resources in a REIT REIT

See: Real Estate Investment Trust


REIT

See real estate investment trust (REIT).
, each enjoying the benefit of the others' contributions.

A publicly traded real estate investment trust (REIT) offers investors the opportunity to indirectly own professionally managed equity or mortgage interests in real property by purchasing shares or certificates of beneficial interest in the REIT. A REIT can be thought of as a mutual fund for real estate because many investors are pooling their capital in a professionally managed endeavor. Under the Internal Revenue Code The Internal Revenue Code is the body of law that codifies all federal tax laws, including income, estate, gift, excise, alcohol, tobacco, and employment taxes. These laws constitute title 26 of the U.S. Code (26 U.S.C.A. § 1 et seq.  of 1986 as amended a·mend  
v. a·mend·ed, a·mend·ing, a·mends

v.tr.
1. To change for the better; improve: amended the earlier proposal so as to make it more comprehensive.

2.
 (the "Code" or "I.R.C."), a REIT is not generally subject to federal income taxes.[1] Public corporations and certain publicly traded partnerships Publicly Traded Partnership

A limited partnership that also has interests traded in the equity securities market.

Notes:
This is also known as a master limited partnership.
See also: Master Limited Partnership, Partnership, Public Company
, on the other hand, generally are subject to two tiers of U.S. taxation. A REIT also offers the owners of equity or mortgage interests in real property the means to achieve their goals of liquidity, growth, and development through the capital infusions Capital infusion

Often refers to the cross-subsidization of divisions within a firm. When one division is not doing well, it might benefit from an infusion of new funds from the more successful divisions.
 received by the REIT from the public. For purposes of this discussion, we will assume that the owners are actually partners in existing real property partnerships.

The formation of a REIT can bring together owner, professional property manager, and investor, all of whom enjoy the rewards of the property and services each contributes to the venture. This article focuses on certain of the more important issues which the investors, the property managers, and the existing real estate partnerships and its partners face when entering the public capital markets.

Organizational and Operational Basics

Organizational Basics. I.R.C. [subsections] 856 through 859 lay out an intricate organizational framework for a REIT. In order to qualify as a REIT, an entity must meet eight organizational requirements. The entity 1) must be a corporation, trust, or association; 2) which is not an insurance company or financial institution; 3) which would be taxable as a domestic corporation if it were not a REIT; 4) which elects to be taxed as a REIT; 5) which has centralized cen·tral·ize  
v. cen·tral·ized, cen·tral·iz·ing, cen·tral·iz·es

v.tr.
1. To draw into or toward a center; consolidate.

2.
 management by trustees or directors; 6) in which at least 100 persons; 7) own transferable shares or certificates; and 8) in which less than six individuals do not own more than 50 percent of the value of the equity.[2]

Further, at the end of each quarter of the tax year, the REIT's assets must meet four tests which prove that its assets are in the nature of real estate. Annually, its sources of income are similarly tested: It must meet three source-of-income tests. Finally, detailed distribution (the REIT generally cannot retain its earnings) and recordkeeping rules must be met. A REIT which meets the above tests receives conduit conduit /con·du·it/ (kon´doo-it) channel.

ileal conduit  the surgical anastomosis of the ureters to one end of a detached segment of ileum, the other end being used to form a stoma on the
 tax treatment (i.e., "flow through" treatment much like a partnership) so that only the shareholder is taxed because the REIT is allowed to deduct de·duct  
v. de·duct·ed, de·duct·ing, de·ducts

v.tr.
1. To take away (a quantity) from another; subtract.

2. To derive by deduction; deduce.

v.intr.
 the dividends it pays to shareholders.[3]

Operational Basics and the Commercial Real Estate Market. There are several types of REITs, such as the equity REIT Equity REIT

A Real Estate Investment Trust that assumes ownership status in the property it invests in enabling investors of the REIT to earn dividends on rental income from the property and appreciation in property resale. Antithesis of a Mortgage REIT.
, the externally advised REIT, the hybrid REIT (which owns equity and mortgage interests in real property), the mortgage REIT Mortgage REIT

An REIT that invests in loans secured by real estate which derive income from mortgage interest and fees.


mortgage REIT 
, the self-administered REIT, the self-managed REIT, and the umbrella partnership or UPREIT (and the "DOWNREIT").[4]

Commercial real estate in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area.  consists of five major types of property (hotels, offices, apartments, industrial, and retail) and has recently been valued at approximately $4 trillion One thousand times one billion, which is 1, followed by 12 zeros, or 10 to the 12th power. See space/time.

(mathematics) trillion - In Britain, France, and Germany, 10^18 or a million cubed.

In the USA and Canada, 10^12.
. REITs own only approximately three percent of this market.[5] Given the preferred tax treatment enjoyed by the REIT and the ease of access into the public market (even the "average" investor can afford to invest), it generally makes sense that the REIT industry has an excellent opportunity to expand its real estate ownership position. The recent dividend yield of equity REITs, at 6.1 percent, is greater than the 30-year Treasury bond yield and almost four times that of the S&P 500.[6]

A REIT generally must remain passive in its investments and its income must come from these passive-investment sources. Thus, the REIT generally owns and operates commercial real estate such as office buildings, shopping centers shopping center, a concentration of retail, service, and entertainment enterprises designed to serve the surrounding region. The modern shopping center differs from its antecedents—bazaars and marketplaces—in that the shops are usually amalgamated into , apartments, warehouses, and hotels which produces income (and provides much-needed cash flow).

The REIT generally must obtain capital from outside sources in addition to its internally generated earnings because only a small portion of its earnings may be retained. In order to obtain this capital, the REIT may issue shares or certificates of different classes, preferences, and/or participations. Similarly, the REIT may issue debt obligations (secured and unsecured Unsecured

A loan or equity interest that is given without any guarantee of payment, performance, satisfaction or opportunity for return from the recipient. No property, interest or security is used as collateral in either a guarantee or a pledge.
).

Today's REIT investor perceives that he or she will receive distributions of the REIT's cash flow because the Code requires certain distributions; however, the investor must similarly realize that, in order for the REIT to grow (by the acquisition of new property or improvement of existing property), and since the REIT must distribute its funds, the REIT must have the "ability to readily tap the public debt and equity markets at attractive rates."[7]

Even though, with respect to a REIT, the terminology of financial analysis differs slightly when compared to a public non-REIT corporation, the actual financial analysis of such items as performance and growth of the REIT turns on the same basic concepts but with certain modifications and nuances. For example, earnings are generally measured, not by net income, but by such items as "funds from operations Funds From Operations (FFO)

Used by real estate and other investment trusts to define the cash flow from trust operations; earnings with depreciation and amortization added back.
" (or FFO FFO

See: Funds from operations
, which is essentially earnings before interest expense, taxes, depreciation and amortization expense or "EBITDA (Earnings Before Interest, Taxes, Depreciation and Amortization) A metric used to show a company's profitability, but not its cash flow. EBITDA became popular in the 1980s to show the potential profitability of leveraged buyouts, but has become " less its interest expense) or "funds available for distribution" (or FAD FAD - ["FAD, A Simple and Powerful Database Language", F. Bancilon et al, Proc 13th Intl Conf on VLDB, Brighton, England, Sep 1987]. , also referred to as "cash available for distribution" or CAD because it adjusts FFO for recurring re·cur  
intr.v. re·curred, re·cur·ring, re·curs
1. To happen, come up, or show up again or repeatedly.

2. To return to one's attention or memory.

3. To return in thought or discourse.
 capital expenditures).[8] As another example, the "net asset value" (or NAV See navigation system and navigation bar. ) per share places a "current value" on the assets of the REIT and divides that value by the number of outstanding shares. This NAV concept is common to mutual funds in general and, similarly, the valuation process of the net assets Net assets

The difference between total assets on the one hand and current liabilities and noncapitalized long-term liabilities on the other hand.


net assets

See owners' equity.
 normally turns on discounting projected "net operating income Operating Income

The profit realized from a business' own operations.

Notes:
This would not include income from things such as investments in other firms. Also referred to as operating profit or recurring profit.
" (NOI NOI Net Operating Income
NOI Notice of Intent
NOI Nation of Islam
NOI Notice of Inquiry
NOI Neuro Orthopaedic Institute
NOI New Organizing Institute
NOI Notice of Interest
NOI No Offense Intended
NOI National Olympiad in Informatics
) streams or on "capitalizing" the NOI,[9] in much the same fashion as an analyst could value any other income-producing property.

Before investing in a REIT, investors should look at several indicators such as the financial strength as evidenced by the REIT's balance sheet and its cash flows and the strength of the REIT's management because these factors generally continue to be two of the most important factors to consider. Most REITs today are internally managed (unlike the REITs of old which were externally managed by an investment adviser much like a mutual fund).[10] Today's "typical REIT ... is a fully integrated real estate company with internal ability to do property management, development, leasing and asset management."[11] The internally managed public REIT generally relies on a board of directors or trustees and on audit, compensation, and executive committees; thus, a diversified diversified (di·verˑ·s  and experienced management team is a key component of today's REIT, but independent directors or trustees help to provide the checks and balances necessary to ensure that fiduciary duties Noun 1. fiduciary duty - the legal duty of a fiduciary to act in the best interests of the beneficiary
legal duty - acts which the law requires be done or forborne
 are met. In summary, then, management makes the "go forward" decisions with respect to acquisitions and with respect to the development of acquired properties;[12] and management's success on acquisitions can be measured by analyzing the financial results. For example, a comparison of the acquisition price with the NOI of the property indicates whether the acquisition was a success.

The Trap

Avoiding the two tiers of taxation imposed by the Code on "regular" or "C" corporations is an important business planning technique in the United States. The C corporation is taxed on its income with no deduction deduction, in logic, form of inference such that the conclusion must be true if the premises are true. For example, if we know that all men have two legs and that John is a man, it is then logical to deduce that John has two legs.  for its dividends paid to shareholders,[13] and the shareholder is taxed on the dividends received from the corporation.[14] Thus, generally the dividend is taxed to both the corporation and the shareholder. In sharp contrast, partnerships and S corporations are "flow-through" entities which essentially avoid the entity-level tax; the income is subject to tax only at the partner or shareholder's level.[15] Under I.R.C. 87704, certain publicly traded partnerships are treated as C corporations for tax purposes. If the partnership goes public in order to obtain capital, its income will similarly be subject to two tiers of income tax. A publicly traded corporation necessarily flunks the tests to qualify as an S corporation.[16] Thus, even though I.R.C. [sections] 351 generally allows a single real estate partnership to contribute its property to a new corporation ("Newco") without gain recognition in exchange for enough stock to constitute "control" of Newco under I.R.C. [sections] 368(c), if the resulting Newco will be a publicly held corporation, then it will be a C corporation, and its income will be subject to two levels of tax. As noted above, a REIT generally is not subject to federal income tax, while the shareholders will generally be subject to tax on its distributions.

Accordingly, an existing real estate partnership with capital-intensive needs may wish to convert to a REIT because a publicly held REIT is able to attract capital and enjoys flow-through benefits similar to those of partnerships and S corporations under the Code.[17] Recognizing the needs of the economy as early as 1960, the U. S. Congress passed REIT-related legislation.[18] This legislation and that which followed were intended to allow the average-means investor the vehicle with which to invest in real estate projects otherwise unavailable. However, more recent amendments to the Code provide that a partnership which converts to a corporation which then elects REIT status may be a taxable transaction Taxable transaction

Any transaction that is not tax-free to the parties involved, such as a taxable acquisition.
 to the transferring partnership and, thus, ultimately to the partners under I.R.C. [sections] 351(e) as a transfer to an "investment company."[19] The typical conversion from partnership to (publicly held) REIT generally will be taxed to the partners, thus resulting in immediate income tax on each partner's share of "built-in gain."[20] "Built-in gain" means the difference between the date-of-transfer fair market value and adjusted basis of the property. This article assumes that the property has appreciated in value over the adjusted basis such that no built-in loss exists on the date of transfer. This article further assumes that the partners of the existing real estate partnership(s) want to avoid taxation with respect to the transfer if at all possible although the desire to defer de·fer 1  
v. de·ferred, de·fer·ring, de·fers

v.tr.
1. To put off; postpone.

2. To postpone the induction of (one eligible for the military draft).

v.intr.
 income recognition does not necessarily follow in every circumstance Circumstance or circumstances can refer to:
  • Legal terms:
  • Aggravating circumstances
  • Attendant circumstance
.

UPREIT: The Answer

An umbrella partnership REIT (UPREIT) can be used in order to satisfy the partners' needs to further defer built-in gain and still attract the investors needed for capital. In an UPREIT, a REIT is formed into which investors pool their money in exchange for REIT shares. Meanwhile, an "umbrella" or "operating" partnership is formed into which the REIT contributes the public's cash in exchange for a general partner's interest in the umbrella partnership. The umbrella partnership also transfers limited partner interests to the existing partners ("limited partners") of the partnerships owning the real property ("existing partnerships") in exchange for the partnership interests in the existing partnerships(s) (or, in the alternative, in exchange for the assets of the existing partnership). It is the author's opinion that the cleaner of the two alternatives of the immediately preceding sentence is to transfer in exchange for partnership interests rather than for partnership property.[21] I.R.C. [sections] 721(a) should apply to the exchange such that no gain will be recognized on the transfers despite the investment company type treatment provided for in I.R.C. [sections] 721(b) because the umbrella partnership does not meet the definition of an investment company.[22] The cash infusion can then be used to further the purposes of the UPREIT and its properties. Often, the purposes furthered are debt paydown which, as discussed below, may result in additional tax consequences.[23]

Income and Asset Tests

The Code and the U. S. Department of the Treasury Income Tax Regulations ("Regulations") provide an intricate set of income and asset tests which must be met in order for an entity to qualify as a REIT.[24] These income and asset tests boil down boil 1  
v. boiled, boil·ing, boils

v.intr.
1.
a. To change from a liquid to a vapor by the application of heat:
 essentially to requirements that the type and quantity of the income and assets test positive as real property related income and assets. Regulations [sections] 1.856-3(g) provides that a REIT may "look through" the partnership(s) of which it is a partner to the partnerships' income and assets and may apply its proportionate pro·por·tion·ate  
adj.
Being in due proportion; proportional.

tr.v. pro·por·tion·at·ed, pro·por·tion·at·ing, pro·por·tion·ates
To make proportionate.
 share (based on its capital interest in each partnership) of each item of income or assets to meet the REIT's income and assets tests under the Code.[25] For example, under I.R.C. [sections] 856(c)(4), at the close of each quarter of the REIT's taxable year Taxable year

The 12-month period an individual uses to report income for income tax purposes. For most individuals, their tax year is the calendar year.
, the composition of the REIT's assets must meet two tests which generally require that the assets consist in large part of equity or mortgage interests in real property.[26] Thus, the UPREIT "looks through" the umbrella partnership and existing partnership(s) to the underlying assets of each in order to determine that the entity does indeed qualify for favorable fa·vor·a·ble  
adj.
1. Advantageous; helpful: favorable winds.

2. Encouraging; propitious: a favorable diagnosis.

3.
 treatment as a REIT under I.R.C. [sections] 856.

Distributions/Voting Rights/Conversion Rights

In order for a public corporation to qualify as a REIT, the UPREIT must be operated in compliance with the REIT-distribution requirements of the Code and Regulations.[27] In addition to the distributions to REIT shareholders (i.e., the investors), the limited partners receive distributions on each limited partnership unit. A limited partner's distribution on a limited partnership unit generally equals the dividend paid on each share of the REIT, but despite this "economic equivalence" of a share and a unit, the limited partners have no voting rights Voting rights

The right to vote on matters that are put to a vote of security holders. For example the right to vote for directors.


voting rights

The type of voting and the amount of control held by the owners of a class of stock.
 in the REIT.[28] The limited partners' interests in the umbrella partnership generally are convertible to shares in the REIT; the conversion will generally be taxable. However, if the conversion rights are not properly structured, the transfer of the convertible units to the limited partner itself could be taxable rather than the later conversion of the rights.[29] By converting the rights, the limited partner can obtain voting shares Voting Shares

Shares that give the stockholder the right to vote on matters of corporate policy making as well as who will compose the members of the board of directors.

Notes:
Different classes of shares, such as preferred stock, sometimes don't allow for voting rights.
 and/or liquidity because the shares, which are readily tradeable, can then be sold for cash.

Additional Formation Issues

Anti-abuse Regulations. Under the "anti-abuse" Regulations promulgated prom·ul·gate  
tr.v. prom·ul·gat·ed, prom·ul·gat·ing, prom·ul·gates
1. To make known (a decree, for example) by public declaration; announce officially. See Synonyms at announce.

2.
 pursuant to subchapter K of the Code, the IRS An abbreviation for the Internal Revenue Service, a federal agency charged with the responsibility of administering and enforcing internal revenue laws.  has broad powers to disregard the form of a transaction or series of transactions the principal purpose of which is to substantially reduce the present value of the partners' total tax liability in a manner that is inconsistent with the intent of subchapter K of the Code.[30] Clearly UPREIT practitioners must be concerned with these anti-abuse Regulations since UPREITs were specifically created as a means for the limited partners to defer income tax on built-in gain upon contribution of the property to the umbrella partnership instead of to the REIT. Regulations [sections] 1.701-2(d), Example 4, blesses a specific UPREIT structure in this regard because the partnership was bona fide [Latin, In good faith.] Honest; genuine; actual; authentic; acting without the intention of defrauding.

A bona fide purchaser is one who purchases property for a valuable consideration that is inducement for entering into a contract and without suspicion of being
 and each partnership transaction was entered into for a substantial business purpose, because the form of each partnership transaction satisfied the principle of substance over form, and because the tax consequences to each partner of partnership operations and of transactions between the partner and partnership accurately reflected the partners' economic agreement and clearly reflected the partner's income. But, as with any example, Example 4 does not answer all of the questions with respect to the application of the anti-abuse Regulations to UPREITs.[31] Therefore, the practitioner must carefully structure the form and substance of the UPREIT with the knowledge and awareness that abuses can be dealt with severely.

Contribution in Formation. In the formation of an UPREIT, when the limited partners contribute their existing partnership interests to the umbrella partnership in exchange for limited partnership interests in the umbrella partnership, I.R.C. [sections] 721(a) generally provides for nonrecognition of gain or loss to the limited partners although liability can trigger I.R.C. [sections] 752 deemed distributions and potential gain.[32] Certain other transactions during the formation of the UPREIT structure may cause an otherwise nontaxable I.R.C. [sections] 721(a) contribution to take on taxable characteristics, as follows.

Distribution of Marketable Security marketable security

A security that may be resold by one investor to another. Most securities are marketable; they develop secondary markets for trading. Also called negotiable security.
. Recently added I.R.C. [sections] 731(c) works in conjunction with I.R.C. [sections] 731(a) to force gain recognition if the fair market value of a distributed marketable security exceeds the distributee partner's adjusted basis in the partnership interest because I.R.C. [sections] 731(c) provides that the term "money" includes marketable securities Marketable Securities

Very liquid securities that can be converted into cash quickly at a reasonable price.

Notes:
Marketable securities are very liquid as they tend to have maturities less than one year, and the rate at which these securities can be bought or sold has
. Accordingly, when the existing partnership exchanges its property for umbrella partnership limited partnership interests (i.e., a marketable security), and then distributes the umbrella limited partnership interests (i.e., marketable securities) to the limited partners, unless an exception or limitation applies, the distribution should be a taxable event Taxable event

An event or transaction that has a tax consequence, such as the sale of stock holding that is subject to capital gains taxes.
 to the limited partner. Exceptions[33] and limitations[84] generally do apply to such distributions so that the distributions are not taxable; however, the practitioner should beware be·ware  
v. be·wared, be·war·ing, be·wares

v.tr.
To be on guard against; be cautious of: "Beware the ides of March" Shakespeare.

v.
 of I.R.C. [sections] 731(c).

Contribution of Encumbered Encumbered

A property owned by one party on which a second party reserves the right to make a valid claim, e.g., a bank's holding of a home mortgage encumbers property.
 Property/Pay-down of Debt. Contributions of encumbered property which result in relief from liability for a partner can cause an imposition The printing of pages on a single sheet of paper in a particular order so that they come out in the correct sequence when cut and folded.  of tax on the contributing partner under the deemed distribution rules of I.R.C. [subsections] 752(b) and 731.[35] Additionally, the umbrella partnership could use the cash received from the REIT to pay down debt encumbering a property. Generally, the pay-down of debt will similarly result in an I.R.C. [sections] 752(b) deemed distribution of money to the partner although proper planning can substantially alleviate Alleviate
To make something easier to be endured.

Mentioned in: Kinesiology, Applied
 the tax consequences.[36]

Disguised dis·guise  
tr.v. dis·guised, dis·guis·ing, dis·guis·es
1.
a. To modify the manner or appearance of in order to prevent recognition.

b. To furnish with a disguise.

2.
 Sales. I.R.C. [sections] 707(a)(2)(B) provides "disguised sale" treatment on various types of partnership transactions. Disguised sale treatment can result in gain to a partner that contributes property to a partnership and as part of the transaction receives a related distribution from the partnership. Further, a contribution to the umbrella partnership of encumbered property by a partner for which contribution the partner receives a partnership interest and cash or debt reduction[37] may be subject to disguised sale treatment.[38] Finally, the conversion rights received by limited partners could result in disguised sale treatment.[39]

Built-in Gain. I.R.C. [sections] 704(c) applies a broad range of controls on built-in gain property contributed to a partnership. I.R.C. [sections] 704(c) generally anchors the built-in gain to the contributing partner and requires that the contributing partner recognize that built-in gain upon the sale of the property. For example, if a partner contributes property with a date-of-contribution fair market value equal to $250,000,000 and with an adjusted basis of $100,000,000, the built-in gain on the date of contribution is $150,000,000. The Code generally allows this built-in gain to go unrecognized until a later time; however, when recognized, it generally must be borne by the contributor so that no shifting of tax consequences is permitted. I.R.C. [sections] 737 similarly anchors the built-in gain when a distribution of built-in gain property is made to the partners. I.R.C. [sections] 704(c) provides that the "tax" depreciation on the built-in gain property be allocated among the partners so that the contributing partner's built-in gain is, over time, eliminated. Even though the older I.R.C. [sections] 704(c) Regulations prescribe pre·scribe
v.
To give directions, either orally or in writing, for the preparation and administration of a remedy to be used in the treatment of a disease.
 an often onerous on·er·ous  
adj.
1. Troublesome or oppressive; burdensome. See Synonyms at burdensome.

2. Law Entailing obligations that exceed advantages.
 "ceiling rule" in the allocation of depreciation, more recent Regulations modify the onerous nature of these required allocations.[40] Each party to the transaction must beware of these Code-specific economic consequences and negotiate accordingly. For example, only certain allocation methods are acceptable and an acceptable method for Code purposes may be advantageous to one side and detrimental det·ri·men·tal  
adj.
Causing damage or harm; injurious.



detri·men
 to the other. The UPREIT will benefit from either the traditional method with curative curative /cur·a·tive/ (kur´ah-tiv) tending to overcome disease and promote recovery.

cu·ra·tive
adj.
1. Serving or tending to cure.

2.
 allocations or the remedial REMEDIAL. That which affords a remedy; as, a remedial statute, or one which is made to supply some defects or abridge some superfluities of the common law. 1 131. Com. 86. The term remedial statute is also applied to those acts which give a new remedy. Esp. Pen. Act. 1.  allocation method while the contributing partners will benefit most from the traditional method.[41] These determinations should be made pre-formation.

Publicly Traded Partnership (PTP (1) See peer-to-peer.

(2) (Picture Transfer Protocol) An ISO standard for transferring photos from a digital camera to a computer or photo printer.
). I.R.C. [sections] 7704 provides that certain partnerships be treated as a PTP, and thus, taxed as a corporation. Thus, under I.R.C. [sections] 7704, the umbrella partnership could be taxed as a corporation if it does not fit within the PTP exceptions. Devastatingly, PTP status visited on the umbrella partnership can cause the REIT to lose its status as a REIT.[42]

Existing Partnerships Terminate. The existing partnerships will be "terminated" under I.R.C. [sections] 708(b)(1)(B) and, thus, may elect to "step up" the assets pursuant to I.R.C. [sections] 754.[48] The existing partnership(s) should consider making I.R.C. [sections] 754 elections on their final partnership tax returns, Forms 1065.

DOWNREIT: An Alternative

As discussed above, the UPREIT is usually structured as such beginning at the initial planning stages of the REIT formation, with the umbrella partnership formed to effect the plan. The UPREIT has an advantage over an existing simple REIT because the existing UPREIT can acquire properties through the issuance of limited partnership units without the limited partner(s) recognizing gain. In sharp contrast, under I.R.C. [sections] 351, a transaction in which an existing REIT exchanges shares for properties generally will not qualify for nonrecognition of gain to the shareholder if the control requirement of I.R.C. [sections] 351 cannot be met.[44] There is no such control requirement for the umbrella partnership under the Code; therein lies the advantage.

Enter the DOWNREIT, a REIT structure which is similar to the one used in the UPREIT, but which can be effectuated by an existing REIT without many of the acquisitive and other issues inherent either in a REIT or in the conversion of a REIT to an UPREIT.[45] For example, the DOWNREIT does not require a central operating partnership; rather, a new partnership is formed for each acquisitive exchange. Each exchange which enters into DOWNREIT solution does so as a tax-deferred exchange of properties for newly formed limited partnership interests with the REIT as the general partner. The REIT may be a general partner in numerous limited partnerships. Each transaction may be uniquely structured in conjunction with the formation of a new partnership.[46] Thus, a DOWNREIT is centralized at the REIT level instead of at the umbrella partnership level as is the case in an UPREIT. The DOWNREIT has advantages and disadvantages to the UPREIT, but the capital markets are more enamored en·am·or  
tr.v. en·am·ored, en·am·or·ing, en·am·ors
To inspire with love; captivate: was enamored of the beautiful dancer; were enamored with the charming island.
 with the UPREIT because of the ease of analyzing and predicting its financial condition when compared with the DOWNREIT.[47] Necessarily the transaction costs Transaction Costs

Costs incurred when buying or selling securities. These include brokers' commissions and spreads (the difference between the price the dealer paid for a security and the price they can sell it).
 are greater With the DOWNREIT because of the customized nature of the agreements and negotiations.[48] The DOWNREIT offers fewer conflict of interest issues because the limited partners tend to have less control than in the typical UPREIT and, thus, should be of greater value to an investor.[49]

Conclusion

Investors, professional property managers, and real property owners can pool their resources in a REIT, each enjoying the benefit of the others' contributions. Congress provided the vehicle for the accomplishment of each party's goal early on with preferential pref·er·en·tial  
adj.
1. Of, relating to, or giving advantage or preference: preferential treatment.

2.
 tax treatment to boot. Even so, when an existing partnership is targeted for acquisition by a REIT, the existing simple REIT is unable to attract the existing partners to the exchange because the partners' gain on the exchange would not be tax deferred. Further, an existing partnership generally cannot simply convert to a publicly held REIT without the exchanging partners recognizing gain immediately. The UPREIT was developed to fill the void. However, existing simple REITs are at a distinct disadvantage when compared to the UPREIT, and thus, the DOWNREIT was developed to allow the existing simple REIT to compete with UPREITs for capital.

[1] I.R.C. of 1986 as amended, Subtitle sub·ti·tle  
n.
1. A secondary, usually explanatory title, as of a literary work.

2. A printed translation of the dialogue of a foreign-language film shown at the bottom of the screen.

tr.v.
 A, Ch. 1M, Part II. A REIT must meet a strict regime of requirements in order to escape tax. This article only tangentially tan·gen·tial   also tan·gen·tal
adj.
1. Of, relating to, or moving along or in the direction of a tangent.

2. Merely touching or slightly connected.

3.
 discusses those requirements which include income, asset, and distribution tests. The REIT must also beware of the securities laws, a topic not covered not covered Health care adjective Referring to a procedure, test or other health service to which a policy holder or insurance beneficiary is not entitled under the terms of the policy or payment system–eg, Medicare. Cf Covered.  here.

[2] See Mount, Real Estate Investment Trusts, Tax Mgmt. (BNA BNA Bureau of National Affairs, Inc.
BNA Birds of North America
BNA block numbering area (US Census)
BNA British North America
BNA Banco Nacional de Angola (National Bank of Angola) 
) 742, Portfolio Description Sheet, at (iii) (hereinafter here·in·af·ter  
adv.
In a following part of this document, statement, or book.


hereinafter
Adverb

Formal or law from this point on in this document, matter, or case

Adv. 1.
, 742 T.M.).

[3] See 742 T.M., supra A relational DBMS from Cincom Systems, Inc., Cincinnati, OH (www.cincom.com) that runs on IBM mainframes and VAXs. It includes a query language and a program that automates the database design process.  note 2, Portfolio Description Sheet, at (iii). [4] See P. FASS FASS Faculty of Arts and Social Sciences (National University of Singapore)
FASS Federation of Animal Science Societies
FASS Florida Agricultural Statistics Service
FASS Financial Acquisition Support Services
, M. SHAFF, AND D. ZIEF, REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUSTS HANDBOOK (1999) (Handbook) [sections] 1.0111][a], at 1-9 to 1-10 for a discussion.

[5] See Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.01, at 1-6.

[6] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.02[4][d][iii], at 1-54 to 1-57.

[7] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0214], at 1-29; [sections] 1.02 [4] Id] [ii], at 1-54 (the stock market treats REITs more like income, than growth, stocks).

[8] See Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0111][b] and [c], at 1-10 to 1-13 for a discussion.

[9] See Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0111][c], at 1-11 to 1-12; [sections] 1.0214][d], at 1-44 to 1-52 for a discussion of the valuation issues.

[10] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0313][a], at 1-22 to 1-27.

[11] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0313][b], at 1-126.

[12] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 1.0218][g], at 1-96 to 1-98.

[13] I.R.C. subtitle A, ch. 1, subch. C.

[14] Exceptions to this general premise exist (e.g., I.R.C. [sections] 243).

[15] I.R.C. subtitle A, ch. 1, subch. K and subch. S.

[16] I.R.C. subtitle A, ch. 1, subch. S.

[17] I.R.C. Subtitle A, Ch. 1 M, Part II.

[18] See 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-1 (hereinafter, 742 T.M.).

[19] A discussion of I.R.C. [sections] 351(e) is beyond the scope of this article but transfers of interests which result in "diversification Diversification

A risk management technique that mixes a wide variety of investments within a portfolio. It is designed to minimize the impact of any one security on overall portfolio performance.

Notes:
Diversification is possibly the greatest way to reduce the risk.
" of investment to the transferor are targeted when the transferee is a REIT. See 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-48. Also beyond the scope of this article is the exception to nonrecognition under I.R.C. [sections] 357(c) (liability in excess of basis).

[20] 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-48. However, the conversion of a single partnership to a REIT generally may not result in diversification if the public is not involved. See Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 5.0211] [b] [ii] [1](a), at 5-12 to 5-13. This article assumes that the property has appreciated in value such that no built-in loss exists.

[21] See supra notes 30 through 32 and accompanying text for discussion; see Treas. Reg REG,
n.pr See random event generator.
. [sections] 1.701-2(d), Ex. 4.

[22] 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-48; Treas. Reg. [sections] 1.351-1(c)(1) (as amended in 1996); Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.01[1], at 6-2.

[23] See supra notes 30 through 34 and accompanying text.

[24] See I.R.C. subtitle A, ch. 1M, part II and related Treasury Regulations.

[25] In Priv. Ltr. Rul. 9502037 and Priv. Ltr. Rul. 9452032, the IRS applied the look-through rules to multitiered partnerships. For a discussion of controversy surrounding the impact of Treas. Reg. [sections] 1.856-3(g) on a REIT which owns partnership interests, see Crnkovich, Fisher, and Cullins, Will IRS Threaten Current Tax Treatment of REITs owning Partnership Interests?, J. TAX'N (Jan. 1999) 39 through 45.

[26] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 4.05, at 4-68 to 4-86; 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-4 to A-27.

[27] A qualifying REIT's deduction for dividends paid is a statutorily prescribed pre·scribe  
v. pre·scribed, pre·scrib·ing, pre·scribes

v.tr.
1. To set down as a rule or guide; enjoin. See Synonyms at dictate.

2. To order the use of (a medicine or other treatment).
 minimum amount under I.R.C. [sections] 857(a)(1). See 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-27 to A-48.

[28] Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.01[1], at 6-3.

[29] I.R.C. [sections] 707(a)(2)(B); I.R.C. [sections] 741; see also Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.0111], at 6-3 (conversion rights should be payable, at the UPREIT's option, in cash or in shares, and "structured as a right of redemption Right of redemption

The right to recover property that has been attached by paying off the debt .
" from the umbrella partnership).

[30] Treas. Reg. [sections] 1.701-2(b) (as amended in 1995).

[31] See Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.0112], at 6-4 to 6-6, for a discussion of the questions.

[32] I.R.C. [subsections] 752(a), 752(b) and 731(a)(1).

[33] Treas. Reg. [sections] 1.731-2(d)(1) (as amended in 1996); Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.01[3], at 6-6 to 6-10.

[34] I.R.C. [sections] 731(c)(3)(B); Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.0113], at 6-8 to 6-10.

[35] 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-48.

[36] A discussion of this topic is beyond the scope of this article. The reader can refer to 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-49 through A-50; and to Handbook, supra note 4, at [sections] 6.0114], at 6-10 through 6-19 for a discussion which analyzes, indepth, such issues as the allocation of nonrecourse liabilities Nonrecourse Liability is any liability of the Company treated as a “nonrecourse liability” under United States Treasury Regulation Section 1.704-2(b)(3). , I.R.C. [sections] 754 elections, using guarantees to maintain basis, and at-risk basis under I.R.C. [sections] 465.

[37] See I.R.C. [sections] 752.

[38] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 6.0115], at 6-19 to 6-23.

[39] See supra note 28 and accompanying text; 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-49 through A-50.

[40] Treas. Reg. [sections] 1.704-3 (as amended in 1997).

[41] See generally, Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 6.0116], at 6-23 to 6-25; 742 T.M., supra note 2, at A-50.

[42] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 6.0117], at 6-25 to 6-26.

[43] Id. at [sections] 6.0119], at 6-28.

[44] See I.R.C. [subsections] 351(a), 368(c).

[45] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 1.0214] Id, at 1-42 to 1-44; [sections] 6.01110], at 6-29 to 6-30.

[46] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 1.0214] [c], at 1-42 to 1-44.

[47] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 1.0214] [c], at 1-42 to 1-44.

[48] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 6.03, at 6-32.

[49] Handbook, supra note 4, [sections] 1.0214] [c], at 1-43.
COPYRIGHT 1999 Florida Bar
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1999 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:real estate investment trusts
Author:Jordan, Brian K.
Publication:Florida Bar Journal
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Jul 1, 1999
Words:5021
Previous Article:When the tenancy by the entirety doctrine meets the Bankruptcy Code: clash of the Titans.(Florida)
Next Article:You should have called me sooner.(use of appellate lawyers)
Topics:



Related Articles
A boost for REITs. (real estate investment trusts)
Real estate financing trends. (services of real estate investment trusts, commercial finance companies and pension funds) (Staying Alive 'Till '95...
Pension funds show heightened interest in REITs. (real estate investment trusts)
Real estate debt securities favored in first half of '98.
Most frequently asked questions, and answers, about REITs.(Banking & Finance)
Real estate tops ISS industry governance rankings.(Finance: real estate)(Institutional Shareholder Services)
Wells closes $786m sale.(FINANCE)(Wells Real Estate Investment Trust Inc.)(Brief Article)
Lightstone's $300m offering.(Lightstone Securities)(Brief Article)
Wells Funds attract $1.56B in investments in 2005.(FINANCE)
Understanding Real Estate Investment Trusts

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles