Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,678,741 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Two faces of nondisclosure: asking the right questions--and doing it well--can reduce the amount of nondisclosure in life and health insurance applications.


Does nondisclosure equal antiselection? Not always. This underwriter would broadly define antiselection as a state that exists when the proposed insured is aware of facts in his health habits (or lack thereof), medical history, avocations, and other scenarios that are intentionally not disclosed at the time of application.These facts are, by inference, material and would have led to adverse underwriting action if they had been revealed.

Hence, we often use the term nondisclosure as a synonym synonym (sĭn`ənĭm) [Gr.,=having the same name], word having a meaning that is the same as or very similar to the meaning of another word of the same language. Some are alike in some meanings only, as live and dwell.  for antiselection.

Which would be fine if it were always true.

Unfortunately for those who bandy bandy /ban·dy/ (band´e) bowed or bent in an outward curve.  words about imprecisely im·pre·cise  
adj.
Not precise.



impre·cisely adv.
, the fact is that while all antiselection involves nondisclosure, not all nondisclosure equates to antiselection.

Who cares? We do.

If every tobacco devotee would simply tell the truth, we would not need to spend money checking their urine, oral fluid and/or (rarely) blood for telltale evidence of their affliction with "smoker's amnesia amnesia (ămnē`zhə), [Gr.,=forgetfulness], condition characterized by loss of memory for long or short intervals of time. It may be caused by injury, shock, senility, severe illness, or mental disease. ."

But, they don't always tell, so we do screen.

The rising popularity of pharmaceutical database profiles is another example of how progressive insurers seek out antiselective nondisclosure--in this case, with regard to the use of prescription remedies.

Nearly all insurers ask about prescription use as an application question.While the predominant value of these database-generated profiles is not detection of antiselective intentions, they do alert insurers when unacknowledged medications associated with impairments conferring excess mortality and morbidity are being taken.

We have now confirmed that intentional nondisclosure of material facts is FACTS I Federal Agencies' Centralized Trial-Balance System  the same as antiselection.

What about nonintentional, or incidental, nondisclosure? Fact is, incidental nondisclosure is many, many times more prevalent in all domains of underwriting than its sinister counterpart.

How can this be? It is a function of the mechanisms that induce applicants not to disclose information deemed material to insurability.There are at least five such mechanisms occurring every day in conventional (hold that thought) underwriting:

* The question is inadequate--They asked about "liver, pancreas and gallbladder disorders" but I had sclerosing cholangitis sclerosing cholangitis Primary sclerosing cholangitis, see there , a bile duct bile duct or biliary duct
n.
Any of the excretory ducts in the liver that convey bile between the liver and the intestine, including the hepatic, cystic, and common bile ducts. Also called gall duct.



bile duct

1.
 condition.

* The question is not understood--95%-plus of insurance buyers do not speak even rudimentary medicalese.

* The question was not asked properly--This is prevalent among younger producers, property/casualty agents who don't sell much life or health coverage and individuals from other domains of finance who include insurance in their repertoire (sans any real training therein). One of my personal favorite blatantly improper variations on the theme of an application question is "You don't smoke, do you?" Inventive technique of encouraging nondisclosure, don't you think?

* The insured was given information by his physician which leads him to not answer properly. In a medical report on chronic lymphocytic leukemia chronic lymphocytic leukemia
n. Abbr. CLL
Lymphocytic leukemia occurring mainly in older adults, characterized by slow onset and gradual progression of symptoms.
, the physician author acknowledged that he did not tell patients in the early, symptom-free years of this fatal malignancy malignancy: see cancer.  that they had "cancer." How could we expect this individual to answer a "cancer question" correctly (especially if the word "leukemia leukemia (lkē`mēə), cancerous disorder of the blood-forming tissues (bone marrow, lymphatics, liver, spleen) characterized by excessive production of immature or mature " was not included)?

* The question was not asked at all. Sadly, this does happen. Recently, when asked to opine on a challenged claim, one point of contention was that the agent, knowing the proposed insured's family well and thus being privy to the fact that the individual in question had been a "guest in a facility devoted to remedying intemperance A lack of moderation. Habitual intemperance is that degree of intemperance in the use of intoxicating liquor which disqualifies the person a great portion of the time from properly attending to business. Habitual or excessive use of liquor. Cross-references

Alcohol.
" (or more candidly, dried out via inpatient alcohol rehab), opted to, shall we say, gloss over Verb 1. gloss over - treat hurriedly or avoid dealing with properly
skate over, skimp over, slur over, smooth over

do by, treat, handle - interact in a certain way; "Do right by her"; "Treat him with caution, please"; "Handle the press reporters gently"
 this aspect of the medical history.

You can't answer if you're not asked.

Another scenario that begs for inadvertent nondisclosure is when we ask "in the past five years, have you ...?"

What if the issue at hand occurred four and a half years ago? Memories dim with time."Did I see that doctor in 2000 or was it back in 1999?"

Is this really antiselection? I would think it depends on the individual circumstances.

What can we do about incidental/unintentional/ inadvertent nondisclosure? Do a better job of asking our questions.The operative definition of which is teleunderwriting, which just happens to be the proven antidote for most (but not all) occasions of incidental nondisclosure.

Hank George, a Best's Review columnist, is the principal in his own consulting and training firm, Hank George Inc. He may be reached at insight@bestreview.com.
COPYRIGHT 2005 A.M. Best Company, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Underwriting Insight
Comment:Two faces of nondisclosure: asking the right questions--and doing it well--can reduce the amount of nondisclosure in life and health insurance applications.(Underwriting Insight)
Author:George, Hank
Publication:Best's Review
Article Type:Column
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Nov 1, 2005
Words:692
Previous Article:Big winners: those life insurers who can successfully make the transition from helping consumers accumulate wealth to helping them distribute it...
Next Article:Entering the blogosphere: agents and actuaries are writing insurance's first blogs.(Blogs)(Column)
Topics:



Related Articles
Underwriting Is Still Needed Online.
20 Questions.(successful online underwriting)(Industry Overview)
Checking in the Risk.(life insurance industry)
Take It to the Bank.(strategies for banks and insurance companies to team up and market services)
Enhancements to CPA Life Insurance Plan announced. (member news).(Brief Article)(Statistical Data Included)
Cultural differences: limited access to medical records and testing requirements can make it difficult for insurers to do business in other...
Critical mass: critical illness coverage holds promise for insurers, but not without support from producers. (Life/Health: Critical Illness).
Cutting IT can be costly: reducing the budgets for information technology programs will not save companies money in the long run....
Reassessing underwriting strategies: protective-value studies can help assess mortality risks as well as value the possible cost of losing good...
Avoiding the arbitrage trap: some life insurance companies are being targeted by investment firms that attempt to create blocks of policies that will...

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles