Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,522,042 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

This plan could fly.


Byline: The Register-Guard

The political climate in Washington, D.C., is chilly for proposals to create wilderness areas - just ask Sen. Ron Wyden, whose bill for 177,000 acres of new wilderness near Mount Hood died a cold and lonely death last year. A new proposal should find a warmer reception, while providing a model for future wilderness additions in Oregon.

Oregon Reps. Greg Walden and Earl Blumenauer unveiled their proposal Tuesday. It would expand wilderness acreage on and around Mount Hood by 40 percent, or 75,000 acres, and designate 15 miles of streams as wild and scenic waterways. The two congressmen also propose a number of steps to address transportation problems, regulate development and improve forest health in the Mount Hood region.

Walden and Blumenauer are unlikely allies. Walden, from Hood River, is a Republican representing one of the most rural districts in the country. Blumenauer, of Portland, is an urban Democrat. But the boundary between their districts runs over the summit of Mount Hood. The two explored their shared interests on a 41-mile hike around Mount Hood last summer, and forged the type of legislative partnership that might succeed in getting a wilderness bill through Congress.

Walden brings to the partnership his chairmanship of the House Subcommittee on Forests and Forest Health. No Mount Hood wilderness bill is likely to clear the House without Walden's support. Blumenauer brings credibility on environmental issues; his support will help persuade Democrats that Walden has moved toward middle ground.

The Walden-Blumenauer proposal will disappoint those who had hoped to see a greater expansion of wilderness. It would add protection to less than half as much land as Wyden's proposal. Even Wyden's bill was seen by wilderness advocates as inadequate; the Oregon Natural Resources Council has pushed for a 265,000-acre expansion. Yet as Wyden's effort showed, asking for more can mean getting nothing.

The exclusive focus on Mount Hood is also a disappointment. Areas elsewhere in Oregon are equally deserving candidates for wilderness designation. Environmentalists hope that two of them - 23,000 acres in Southern Oregon's Soda Mountain National Monument, and the 11,500-acre Copper Salmon area east of the coastal town of Port Orford - can be added to the Mount Hood legislation. Those additions would be welcome, but they should be made only if they would not sink the Walden-Blumenauer plan.

Wyden and Gordon Smith should replicate the Walden-Blumenauer partnership in the Senate, and if they can, expand the proposal. Fifty years from now, Oregonians will not be wishing their grandparents had designated fewer public lands as wilderness. Future generations will not benefit, however, from overreach- ing proposals that leave their supporters empty-handed.

When an opportunity for a significant wilderness expansion presents itself, Oregonians should take it.

COPYRIGHT 2005 The Register Guard
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Editorials; Proposal expands the Mount Hood wilderness
Publication:The Register-Guard (Eugene, OR)
Article Type:Editorial
Date:Dec 2, 2005
Words:457
Previous Article:'We do not torture'.(Editorials)(Editorial)
Next Article:Voters wanted more.(Editorials)(Smoking prevention programs are shortchanged)(Editorial)
Topics:



Related Articles
BWCA: the embattled wilderness. (Minnesota's Boundary Waters Canoe Area)
Taming the wilderness. (protecting land after it receives Wilderness designation) (Currents)
A timely wilderness plan.(Editorials)(Bipartisan agreement on Mount Hood is possible)(Editorial)
More wilderness needs protection.(Columns)(Column)
How to add wilderness.(Editorials)(An incremental, collaborative approach pays off)(Editorial)
Second Sisters fire burns 300 acres.(Fires)
Wildfire west of Waldo Lake grows.(Fires)(Highway 242 is closed for the second time this summer, this time by the Lake George blaze)
Crews work on stubborn Lake George, Waldo fires.(Fires)(The blaze near Sisters has doubled in a day, remaining six miles from Black Butte Ranch)
Fire danger results in tight restrictions.(Fires)(Activities such as smoking, driving on a trail and using a chain saw are prohibited or limited)
Add to wilderness bill.(Editorials)(Copper Salmon area deserves protection)(Editorial)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles