Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,715,772 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Think Tanks: Who's Hot And Who's Not.


The results of a new study comparing economic think tank visibility in the media.

In recent years, think tanks have become an increasingly visible mechanism for presenting informed knowledge and policy expertise. Both within Washington's Beltway and across the country, the total number of think tanks has grown considerably.

What does this trend imply? First, think tanks are exerting more and more influence policymakers, academic circles, and the media. Influence is an ambiguous term and the source of much confusion. For the purposes of this report, we can understand influence within the context of the bridge that think tanks provide between research and the policymaking pol·i·cy·mak·ing or pol·i·cy-mak·ing  
n.
High-level development of policy, especially official government policy.

adj.
Of, relating to, or involving the making of high-level policy:
 process. Think tank scholars are economists, political scientists, and sociologists whose careers have, for some, led them through the corridors of government to the halls of research.

A second implication of the proliferation proliferation /pro·lif·er·a·tion/ (pro-lif?er-a´shun) the reproduction or multiplication of similar forms, especially of cells.prolif´erativeprolif´erous

pro·lif·er·a·tion
n.
 of think tanks is the increased specialization A career option pursued by some attorneys that entails the acquisition of detailed knowledge of, and proficiency in, a particular area of law.

As the law in the United States becomes increasingly complex and covers a greater number of subjects, more and more attorneys are
 of their research areas. "Full service" institutes that cover the vast spectrum of foreign policy and domestic economics studies are now difficult to establish. Smaller but more specialized spe·cial·ize  
v. spe·cial·ized, spe·cial·iz·ing, spe·cial·iz·es

v.intr.
1. To pursue a special activity, occupation, or field of study.

2.
 institutes are intensifying in·ten·si·fy  
v. in·ten·si·fied, in·ten·si·fy·ing, in·ten·si·fies

v.tr.
1. To make intense or more intense:
 the competition for ideas affecting policymaking.

How do think tanks, therefore, differentiate their own research from that of their competitors? This brings us to the third implication of think tank proliferation, namely the increase in what Kent Weaver
For other meanings, see Weaver (disambiguation).


The Weavers are small passerine birds related to the finches.

These are seed-eating birds with rounded conical bills, most of which breed in sub-Saharan Africa, with fewer species in tropical
 calls the "user-friendliness" of these institutes. After all, how do think tanks survive? The short answer is that they get people to listen. And to this end, they are distributing more and more digestible digestible

having the quality of being able to be digested.


digestible energy
the proportion of the potential energy in a feed which is in fact digested.

digestible protein
see digestible protein.
 policy briefs to their target audiences in addition to more traditional studies.

The other component crucial to think tank survival is funding. Funders frequently ask for indicators of think tank effectiveness and impact on the policymaking process. But it is difficult to prove impact because scholarly ideas will take various routes to implementation and will experience several refinements before they change public policy decisions. Indeed, a number of scholars are often capable of claiming "paternity The state or condition of a father; the relationship of a father.

English and U.S. Common Law have recognized the importance of establishing the paternity of children.
" for any finalized See finalization.  policy idea that makes an impact.

Many private funders prefer to donate money to those think tanks exhibiting impact, direct or indirect, on policy. A think tank can make itself heard through several major avenues of influence. In this study, I have attempted to quantify Quantify - A performance analysis tool from Pure Software.  the visibility of major think tanks using measures of press visibility as my gauge. The first and most basic channel is through public education, facilitated by writing op-ed pieces for newspapers and magazines. Scholars can also be interviewed by journalists. In both cases, scholars cannot necessarily ascertain the flow of information, nor whether the information they disseminate dis·sem·i·nate  
v. dis·sem·i·nat·ed, dis·sem·i·nat·ing, dis·sem·i·nates

v.tr.
1. To scatter widely, as in sowing seed.

2.
 actually reaches its intended audience. Still, measuring the number of

citations is a good place to begin our evaluation of a think tank's or a scholar's effectiveness.

The second avenue of influence is through testimony before congressional heatings. Again, it is practically impossible to measure the impact of heatings on policymaking. Pronounced biases may have already emerged, as with a scholar who becomes a "favorite" and is frequently asked to testify To provide evidence as a witness, subject to an oath or affirmation, in order to establish a particular fact or set of facts.

Court rules require witnesses to testify about the facts they know that are relevant to the determination of the outcome of the case.
. Nevertheless, cataloguing who testifies and how often is a valid indication of influence.

I have also included an table with statistics for leading academic/university-based economists who are most visible in the public policy debate. Alan Blinder Alan Stuart Blinder (October 14, 1945 - ) is an American economist, on the faculty of Princeton University, and was an adviser to John Kerry during the latter's 2004 presidential campaign. He graduated from Syosset High School in Syosset, New York. , Rudiger Dornbusch, Martin Feldstein Martin Stuart "Marty" Feldstein (born November 25, 1939 in New York City) is an American economist. He is currently the George F. Baker Professor of Economics at Harvard University, and the president and CEO of the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER). , Paul Krugman Paul Robin Krugman (born February 28, 1953) is an American economist. Krugman, a liberal, is currently a professor of economics and international affairs at Princeton University. , and Jeffrey Sachs Jeffrey David Sachs (born November 5, 1954, in Detroit, Michigan) is an American economist known for his work as an economic advisor to governments in Latin America, Eastern Europe, the former Yugoslavia, the former Soviet Union, Asia, and Africa.  are widely recognized as some of the most influential non-think tank or government-based economists. They are often referred to for applied economics research and timely economics commentary. In general, the data offer a valuable basis of comparison of the impact of think tank-based scholars on policymaking. To see whom the press and Congress consult when economic policy debate becomes critical, the sample period I considered was from July July: see month.  1, 1997 through June June: see month.  30, 1999, when the global financial crisis was breaking. To view a full and updated version of this report, you may go to the following Website: http://n.ruble.tripod.com This articlearticle or section has multiple issues:
* It may contain original research or unverifiable claims.
* It needs additional references or sources for verification.
.

Top Tanks

1. Brookings Brookings, city (1990 pop. 16,270), seat of Brookings co., E S.Dak., on the Big Sioux River; inc. 1883. A trade center in a livestock and grain region, Brookings is an important seed-processing point.

2. Institute for International Economics

3. American Enterprise Institute The American Enterprise Institute for Public Policy Research (AEI) is a conservative think tank, founded in 1943. According to the institute its mission "to defend the principles and improve the institutions of American freedom and democratic capitalism — limited government,

Top Talkers

1. Fred (Friendly Rollabout Engineered for Doctors) A mobile medical conferencing unit. See videoconferencing.

1. FRED - Robert Carr. Language used by Framework, Ashton-Tate.
2.
 Bergsten

2. Robert Robert, Henry Martyn 1837-1923.

American army engineer and parliamentary authority. He designed the defenses for Washington, D.C., during the Civil War and later wrote Robert's Rules of Order (1876).

Noun 1.
 Litan

3. Nicolas Lardy lard  
n.
The white solid or semisolid rendered fat of a hog.

tr.v. lard·ed, lard·ing, lards
1. To cover or coat with lard or a similar fat.

2.


The Competitors

The American Enterprise Institute (AEI AEI American Enterprise Institute
AEI Archive of European Integration
AEI Australian Education International
AEI Automotive Engineering International
AEI Australian Education Index
AEI Albert Einstein Institute
)

The Brookings Institution Brookings Institution, at Washington, D.C.; chartered 1927 as a consolidation of the Institute for Government Research (est. 1916), the Institute of Economics (est. 1922), and the Robert S. Brookings Graduate School of Economics and Government (est. 1924).  (Brookings)

The Cato Institute "Cato" redirects here. For Cato, see Cato.
The Institute's stated mission is "to broaden the parameters of public policy debate to allow consideration of the traditional American principles of limited government, individual liberty, free markets, and peace" by striving "to achieve
 (Cato)

The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities The Center on Budget and Policy Priorities (CBPP) is a non-profit think tank which describes itself as a "policy organization ... working at the federal and state levels on fiscal policy and public programs that affect low- and moderate-income families and individuals.  (CBPP CBPP

see contagious bovine pleuropneumonia.
)

The Economic Policy Institute (EPI EPI

exocrine pancreatic insufficiency.
)

The Economic Strategy Institute (ESI (Edge Side Includes) A markup language for Web pages that enables elements of a Web page to be dynamically assembled in servers distributed throughout the Internet. )

The Heritage Foundation (Heritage)

The Hudson Institute The Hudson Institute is a corporatist-leaning U.S. think tank, founded in 1961 in Croton-on-Hudson, New York, by the futurist Herman Kahn and other colleagues from the RAND Corporation.  (Hudson Hudson, towns, United States
Hudson.

1 Industrial town (1990 pop. 17,233), Middlesex co., E central Mass., on the Assabet River, in an apple-growing region; settled c.1699, inc. 1866.
)

The Institute for International Economics (IIE See Apple II. )

The Milken Milk´en

a. 1. Consisting of milk.
 Institute (Milken)

The Progressive Policy Institute (PPI (1) (Pixels Per Inch) The measurement of the resolution of a monitor or scanner. For example, a monitor that is 16 inches wide and displays 1600 pixels across its width would have a resolution of 100 ppi (1600 divided by 16). )

The Urban Institute (Urban)

Most Cited On A Per Scholar Basis: IIE

IIE economists are cited, on a per scholar basis, more than the other think tanks considered. Its 28 citations per scholar rank higher than Brookings, with 21 per scholar, followed by ESI with slightly above 16, AEI with approximately 9 citations per scholar, and Urban and Cato with close to 8 citations per scholar. Total think tank citations are somewhat misleading as not all think tanks have the same size research staff, let alone overhead. In terms of weighted impact, citations per scholar is the measure of most relevance for average quality and reach of an institution.

[GRAPH OMITTED]

Most Cited Economist (Worldwide): Bergsten

Fred Bergsten of lie figures as the most cited think tank-based economist in the total press (U.S. press, international press, and economics press). There are 11 Brookings scholars in the top 30, including 3 in the top 5; five AEI scholars in the top 30; three ESI scholars in the top 30; three lie scholars in the top 31, including 2 in the top 5.
Scholar                   Think Tank       Focus       Total Press

Bergsten, Fred               IIE            Int.         154 (1)
Litan, Robert             Brookings      Dom./Int.       128 (2)
Lardy, Nicholas           Brookings         Int.          92 (3)
Reischauer, Robert        Brookings         Dom.          80 (4)
Goldstein, Morris            IIE            Int.          68 (5)
Moore, Stephen               Cato           Dom.          62 (6)
Mastel, Greg                 ESI            Int.          52 (7)
Prestowitz, Clyde            ESI            Int.          49 (8)
Moon, Marilyn               Urban           Dom.          46 (9)
Bernstein, Jared             EPI            Dom.         40 (10)
Glassman, James              AEI         Dom./Int.       39 (11)
Aaron, Henry              Brookings         Dom.         35 (12)
Reynolds, Alan              Hudson          Int.         34 (13)
Gale, William             Brookings         Dom.         32 (14)
Posen, Adam                  lIE            Int.         31 (15)
Hassett, Kevin               AEI         Dom./Int.       29 (16)
Chimerine, Lawrence          ESI            Int.         28 (17)
Makin, John                  AEI         Dom./Int.       27 (18)
Lindsey, Lawrence            AEI         Dom./Int.       26 (19)
Gaddy, Clifford           Brookings         Int.         23 (20)
Katz, Bruce               Brookings         Dom.         22 (21)
Bosworth, Barry           Brookings         Int.         21 (22)
Lav, Iris                    CBPP           Dom.         20 (23)
Rector, Robed              Heritage         Dom.         20 (23)
Greenstein, Robert           CBPP           Dom.         19 (25)
Tanner, Michael              Cato        Dom./Int.       19 (25)
Burtless, Gary            Brookings      Dom./Int.       18 (27)
Stein, Herbert               AEI            Dom.         18 (27)
Crandall, Robert          Brookings      Dom./Int.       16 (29)
Lincoln, Edward           Brookings         Int.         16 (29)


Ranking of most cited think tank scholars in the total press in parenthesis parenthesis: see punctuation.


The left parenthesis "(" and right parenthesis ")" are used to delineate one expression from another. For example, in the query list for size="34" and (color = "red" or color ="green")
; July 1, 1997 - June 30, 1999

U.S. Press: The Big Four

Consider how visible the sample of think tanks was in the four most prominent American American, river, 30 mi (48 km) long, rising in N central Calif. in the Sierra Nevada and flowing SW into the Sacramento River at Sacramento. The discovery of gold at Sutter's Mill (see Sutter, John Augustus) along the river in 1848 led to the California gold rush of  daily newspapers: The Washington Post, The Washington Post, The

Morning daily newspaper published in Washington, D.C., the dominant paper in the U.S. capital and one of the nation's leading newspapers. Established in 1877 as a Democratic Party organ, it changed orientation and ownership several times and faced
 New York Times, The New York Times, The

Morning daily newspaper, long the U.S. newspaper of record. From its establishment in 1851 it has aimed to avoid sensationalism and to appeal to cultured, intellectual readers.
 Wall Street Journal, and USA Today USA Today

National U.S. daily general-interest newspaper, the first of its kind. Launched in 1982 by Allen Neuharth, head of the Gannett newspaper chain, it reached a circulation of one million within a year and surpassed two million in the 1990s.
.

* The total number of think tank economics citations published by the first three influential newspapers over the period is strikingly similar at about 340 citations. USA Today, for its part, is half as likely as the rest to refer to think tank scholars, with 154 total citations.

* Brookings is three times as likely to be cited in The Washington Washington, town, England
Washington, town (1991 pop. 48,856), Sunderland metropolitan district, NE England. Washington was designated one of the new towns in 1964 to alleviate overpopulation in the Tyneside-Wearside area.
 Post as the nearest think tanks, Cato and IIE. Brookings is also the most cited think tank on economics topics in The New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
 Times and USA Today. The Wall Street Journal refers mostly to AEI economists.

* Brookings' economists appear as the most cited for domestic economics topics in the U.S. press, more than twice as likely to be cited than AEI in second place. Five other think tanks split the remaining domestic citations relatively evenly.

* IIE scholars are the most cited economists for international economics expertise in the U.S. press. Brookings' economists are the next most likely to be referred to for insight on international economics with ESI close behind. These three institutes capture almost all (82%) of the international citations in the leading U.S. newspapers.

* Both Brookings and lie scholars are cited, on a per scholar basis, more often than the other think tank scholars in the U.S. press. Their economists average slightly more than 14 citations during the two-year time period. ESI counts 10 citations per scholar in the U.S. press. Urban Institute and Cato scholars are next most cited, with about 7 citations per scholar. AEI and EPI score a little above 6 citations per scholar.

Most Cited In Media: Brookings

* The Brookings Institution figures as the most cited think tank in the sample for economics citations, gathering 30% of the citations in the total written media. IIE is second most cited overall, with 19% of the citations, AEI third with 11%, and ESI with 9%. Several institutions (6 out of 12) generate each 4% or less of the citations (Figure 1).

[Figure 1 ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

* Brookings is the most cited think tank for economics topics in the U.S. press; lie is the most cited think tank in the international press; Brookings is also the most cited think tank on economics topics in the economics publications (Figure 2).

[Figure 2 ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

Most Cited Economist (U.S. Press): Robert Litan

* Robert Litan of Brookings figures as the most cited think tank-based economist in the U.S. press. Fred Bergsten of IIE is second, and Robert Reischauer, then with Brookings and now heading the Urban Institute, is third.

* Overall, there are 4 Brookings scholars in the top 10 most cited in the U.S. press, and 8 in the top 30. lie registers 2 scholars in the top 10 most cited in the U.S. press and 3 in the top 30. AEI has 6 in the top 30 but none in the top 10. Cato counts 3 scholars in the top 30, with 1 in the top 10. ESI counts 3 scholars in the rankings.
Scholar                  Think Tank        Focus         U.S. Press

Litan, Robert            Brookings       Dom./Int'l       100 (1)
Bergsten, Fred              IIE            Int'l           76 (2)
Reischauer, Robed        Brookings          Dom.           70 (3)
Moore, Stephen              Cato            Dom.           58 (4)
Lardy, Nicholas          Brookings         Int'l           47 (5)
Moon, Marilyn              Urban            Dom.           44 (6)
Goldstein, Morris           IIE            Int'l           39 (7)
Aaron, Henry             Brookings          Dom.           32 (8)
Bernstein, Jared            EPI             Dom.           32 (8)
Mastel, Greg                ESI            Int'l           32 (8)
Prestowitz, Clyde           ESI            Int'l          29 (11)
Reynolds, Alan             Hudson          Int'l          28 (12)
Gale, William            Brookings          Dom.          26 (13)
Glassman, James             AEI          Dom./Int'l       24 (14)
Chimerine, Lawrence         ESI            Int'l          20 (15)
Makin, John                 AEI          Dom./Int'l       20 (15)
Lav, Iris                   CBPP            Dom.          18 (17)
Greenstein, Robert          CBPP            Dom.          17 (18)
Hassett, Kevin              AEI             Dom.          17 (18)
Rector, Robert            Heritage          Dom.          17 (18)
Stein, Herbert              AEI             Dom.          17 (18)
Tanner, Michael             Cato            Dom.          17 (18)
Gaddy, Clifford          Brookings         Int'l          15 (23)
Lindsey, Lawrence           AEI          Dom./Int'l       15 (23)
Posen, Adam                 IIE            Int'l          13 (25)
Bosworth, Barry          Brookings       Dom./Int'l       12 (26)
Hahn, Robert                AEI             Dom.          12 (26)
Mitchell, Daniel          Heritage          Dom.          12 (26)
Niskanen, William           Cato            Dom.          12 (26)
Lincoln, Edward          Brookings         Int'l          11 (30)


Ranking of most cited think tank scholars in the U.S. press in parenthesis; July 1, 1997 - June 30, 1999

Most Cited By Economics Press: Brookings

What about the three of the most influential and popular economics publications, namely The Economist, Foreign Affairs foreign affairs
pl.n.
Affairs concerning international relations and national interests in foreign countries.
, and Business Week?

* Brookings represents almost half of the citations in the economics press, IIE represents almost a quarter, Heritage and EPI account for 6% each, and AEI and ESI come in at 5% and 4%, respectively. The other think tanks in the sample account for 0-2% each.

[GRAPH OMITTED]

* Brookings is almost twice as likely to be cited in The Economist for economics expertise as IIE. IIE gains equal "visibility" to Brookings in Foreign Affairs. And Business Week appears to rely primarily on Brookings for economics citations, while lie and EPI are a distant second and third.

* IIE counts almost 3 citations per scholar in the economics press and Brookings slightly more than 2. All the other think tanks register less than one citation Citation

(foaled 1945) U.S. Thoroughbred racehorse. In four seasons he won 32 of 45 races, finished second in ten, and third in two. He won the 1948 Triple Crown, and became the first horse to win $1 million. He set a world record in 1950 by running a mile in 1:33 3/5.
 per scholar in the economics press.

* The economics press refers to Brookings scholars on domestic economics topics more than all the other think tanks combined. It also appears that the economics press turns specifically to IIE and Brookings for international economics commentary. As one would expect, the total number of citations on international economics topics is almost double the total number of citations on U.S. domestic economics topics among these three magazines.

Most Personal Appearances on the Hill: Rivlin Rivlin (Hebrew: ריבלין‎) may refer to:
  • Alice Rivlin (b. 1931), American economist


The data reveal that Alice Rivlin Alice Mitchell Rivlin (born March 4, 1931 in Philadelphia) is an economist, a former U.S. Cabinet official, and an expert on the budget. She is currently on the board of directors of the New York Stock Exchange.

Rivlin is an alumna of The Madeira School, earned a B.A.
 of Brookings has testified on the Hill about economics topics more than any other think tank economist in this study. Fred Bergsten of IIE and Wendell Wendell is a name that has many uses:

Places
  • Wendell, Idaho, USA
  • Wendell, Massachusetts, USA
  • Wendell, Minnesota, USA
  • Wendell, North Carolina, USA
People
  • Wendell Anderson - Minnesota, USA politician
 Primus of the CBPP are tied for second.

Most Cited By International Press: IIE

Compare the numbers collected from international newspapers intended for English 1. English - (Obsolete) The source code for a program, which may be in any language, as opposed to the linkable or executable binary produced from it by a compiler. The idea behind the term is that to a real hacker, a program written in his favourite programming language is  speakers: Financial Times, Asian Wall Street Journal, Wall Street Journal Europe, and The International Herald Tribune International Herald Tribune

Daily newspaper published in Paris. It has long been the staple source of English-language news for American expatriates, tourists, and businesspeople in Europe.
.

* In this batch of international sources, IIE scholars are the most cited. Their 29% of overall citations ranks ahead of Brookings' 23% share. ESI economists are the third most cited in the international press with a 12% share of visibility in the international press; AEI is fourth with 10%; Hoover 7%; Heritage 6%; Hudson 4%; and EPI 4%. Five of 13 think tanks represent 3% or less of the citations in the international press.

* IIE ranks far ahead of the other think tanks in citations per scholar in the international press. It counts 11 citations per scholar, second highest being ESI with about 6 citations per scholar, and Brookings with 4 citations per scholar in the international press.

Most Appearances Before Congress: Heritage And Brookings

* The results indicate that Brookings and Heritage economists lead the sample in terms of absolute number of appearances before Congress. Moreover, when they do appear, they comment more widely on domestic economics issues than they do on international economics topics. AEI, which is third in number of appearances, also tends to testify more frequently on domestic economics topics, although it is recognized for its international economics commentary as well.

[ILLUSTRATION OMITTED]

* Not surprisingly, the think tanks specializing in the study of international economics make a strong showing before Congress on international trade matters. IIE economists, in particular. are almost twice as likely as the next leading think tank economists to deliver testimony on international economics topics (21 for IIE versus 11 for AEI, ESI, and Heritage).

Most Personal Appearances on the Hill: Rivlin

The data reveal that Alice Rivlin of Brookings has testified on the Hill about economics topics more than any other think tank economist in this study. Fred Bergstein of IIE and Wendell Primus of the CBPP are tied for second.
Scholar                   Think Tank     Total

Rivlin, Alice             Brookings      11 (1)
Bergsten, Fred               IIE         8 (2)
Primus, Wendell              CBPP        8 (2)
Burtless, Gary            Brookings      6 (4)
Butler, Stuart             Heritage      6 (4)
Cohen, Ariel               Heritage      6 (4)
Hahn, Robert                 AEI         6 (4)
Lindsey, Lawrence            AEI         6 (4)
Steuerle, Eugene            Urban        6 (4)
Beach, William             Heritage      5 (10)
Glassman, James              AEI         5 (10)
Greenstein, Robert           CBPP        5 (10)
Penner, Rudolph             Urban        5 (10)
Reischauer, Robert        Brookings      5 (10)
Schott, Jeffrey              lie         5 (10)
Sweeney, John              Heritage      5 (10)
Vasquez, Ian                 Cato        5 (10)
Chimerine, Lawrence          ESI         4 (18)
Makin, John                  AEI         4 (18)
Litan, Robert             Brookings      4 (18)
Scott, Robert                EPI         4 (18)


Leading think tank economists appearing before Congress; July 1, 1997 - June 30, 1999

Most Hill Appearances (International Economic Issues): Bergsten and Schott

Fred Bergsten appears as the think tank economist most likely to comment before Congress on international economics issues, and his lie colleague Jeffrey Schott is tied for second with John Sweeney John Sweeney is the name of:
  • John Sweeney (labor leader), (1934-), American president of AFL-CIO.
  • John Sweeney (journalist), , BBC journalist.
  • John E. Sweeney, (1955-), American politician.
  • John Roland Sweeney, (1931-2001), Canadian politician and educator.
 of Heritage and Ian Vasquez of Cato.
                                        International
                                          Economics
Scholar                   Think Tank        Topics

Bergsten, Fred               IIE            8 (1)
Schott, Jeffrey              IIE            5 (2)
Sweeney, John              Heritage         5 (2)
Vasquez, Ian                 Cato           5 (2)
Chimerine, Lawrence          ESI            4 (5)
Lindsey, Lawrence            AEI            4 (5)
Makin, John                  AEI            4 (5)
Griswold, Daniel             Cato           3 (8)
Mastel, Greg                 ESI            3 (8)
Rivlin, Alice             Brookings         3 (8)


Leading think tank economists appearance before congress on international economics topics; July 1, 1997 - June 30, 1999

Summary In Brief
                 Total       US Press      Intl Press
                 Cities       Cities         Cities

AEI               177          128             43
Brookings         526          367            100
Cato              119          104             13
CBPP               64           57             5
EPI                95           71             16
ESI               149           90             54
Heritage           95           60             28
Hudson             41           22             19
IIE               311          159            121
Milken             14           8              4
PPI                11           9              1
Urban              69           66             0
Total             1671         1141           404

              Econ. Press
                 Cities      Testimony

AEI                6            27
Brookings          59           36
Cato               2            19
CBPP               2            14
EPI                8            10
ESI                5            11
Heritage           7            36
Hudson             0             7
IIE                31           21
Milken             2             0
PPI                1             2
Urban              3            15
Total             126           198


July 1, 1997-June 30, 1999

Notables And Quotables: The Big Nine (Think Tank Vs. Non-Think Tank Economists)
                        The Wash.      The NY      The       USA
                           Post         Times      WSJ      Today

Begsten, Fred               28           30         23         4
Blinder, Alan                5           25         25         8
Bornbusch, Rudiger           9           16         21         4
Feldstein, Martin            7           41         26         3
Krugman, Paul               19           65         10        10
Litan, Robert               34           34         16        17
Reischauer, Robert          61           46         34        22
Rivlin, Alice               24            0         24        17
Sachs, Jeffrey              28           66          7         2
Total                      215          323        186        87

                           The       Asian        WSJ       IHT
                            FT        WSJ       Europe

Begsten, Fred               30         34         23         5
Blinder, Alan               14         16         12         0
Bornbusch, Rudiger          15         16         19         2
Feldstein, Martin           18         26         21         2
Krugman, Paul               74         40         23         2
Litan, Robert                2          7         12         1
Reischauer, Robert           3          0         10         0
Rivlin, Alice               24         17         26         0
Sachs, Jeffrey              56         27         22         7
Total                      236        183        168        19

                           The        Foreign     Business
                        Economist     Affairs       Week

Begsten, Fred               9            2            5        193
Blinder, Alan               3            3            4        115
Bornbusch, Rudiger          6            1           16        125
Feldstein, Martin           9            6            3        162
Krugman, Paul              17           10            8        278
Litan, Robert               4            1            7        135
Reischauer, Robert          3            0            1        180
Rivlin, Alice               3            0            1        136
Sachs, Jeffrey             17            6            4        242
Total                      71           29           49       1195


These totals do not count citations from James Glassman's Washington Post column or Paul Krugman's column in The New York Times; July 1, 1997 - June 30, 1999

Nicolas S. Ruble is a freelance writer. This article is drawn from his report, "An Assessment of American Think Tank Visibility in the Media."
COPYRIGHT 2000 International Economy Publications, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2000, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:ratings based on media coverage
Author:RUBLE, NICOLAS S.
Publication:The International Economy
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Sep 1, 2000
Words:3090
Previous Article:Dubya's Treasury Chief.(candidates for the post of Treasury Secretary should George W. Bush become president)
Next Article:A Nation of Owners.(United States)(Brief Article)
Topics:



Related Articles
From bad to worse.
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR.
P.S.: FURILLO IS GOING STRONG; LONGTIME JOURNALIST, TALK-SHOW HOST HASN'T LOST TOUCH WITH L.A.(SPORTS)(Statistical Data Included)
AFTERNOON DELIGHTS; FOR DRIVE HOME, RADIO STATIONS CATER TO MANY MOODS.(L.A. LIFE)
IT'S NO BULL, OTHERS HAVE SHOT AT TITLE.(SPORTS)
Think Tanks: who's hot and who's not; the latest study comparing economic think tank visibility in the media. The hot economists and hot topics....
Bias schmias.(WHAT LIBERAL MEDIA? The Truth About Bias and the News by Eric Alterman Basic Books)
In March, "Who's Who" revealed efforts by John Podesta and Harold Ickes, both former White House chiefs of staff under Bill Clinton, to found a...
Caitlin Wachs.(Spotlight)(Brief Article)(Cover Story)
DON'T PARDON THESE TURKEYS.(U)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles