Printer Friendly
The Free Library
5,074,106 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

The not so United States: on many of today's hottest issues, the states are ignoring Washington and going their own way. Is this what the Founding Fathers had in mind?


If you're paid the minimum wage at your part-time job, you might want to flip burgers or stock shelves in Washington State, which has enacted the highest minimum wage in the country, $7.63 an hour. Are you itching to help fight global warming global warming, the gradual increase of the temperature of the earth's lower atmosphere as a result of the increase in greenhouse gases since the Industrial Revolution. ? Then think about moving to California, where lawmakers are considering the toughest greenhouse-gas curbs in the nation. Do you believe in evolution? If so, you may want to steer clear of Kansas, which wants its public high schools to teach the subject with skepticism.

Politicians, especially in Washington, often speak about "the American people An American people may be:
  • any nation or ethnic group of the Americas
  • see Demographics of North America
  • see Demographics of South America
" as if they were of one voice on matters of concern to the nation. While that ideal has never truly reflected reality, it may be even less true today as states increasingly strike out on their own on a wide range of issues, from health care to gay marriage, from stem-cell research Noun 1. stem-cell research - research on stem cells and their use in medicine
biological research - scientific research conducted by biologists

embryonic stem-cell research - biological research on stem cells derived from embryos and on their use in medicine
 to the environment.

In doing so, the states are, in effect, challenging the federal government to go along with them, try to stop them, or just get out of their way.

TAKING THE LEAD

Here are some recent actions taken by various states:

* 17 STATES & THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA District of Columbia, federal district (2000 pop. 572,059, a 5.7% decrease in population since the 1990 census), 69 sq mi (179 sq km), on the east bank of the Potomac River, coextensive with the city of Washington, D.C. (the capital of the United States).  have adopted higher minimum wages than the federal minimum of $5.15 an hour, which critics say is too low. (See chart, p. 14, and Debate, p. 27.) Washington State tops the list, with Oregon ($7.50) and Connecticut ($7.40) not far behind. The federal minimum was last raised by Congress in 1997.

* CALIFORNIA, NEW JERSEY, MARYLAND, CONNECTICUT ILLINOIS have allocated state funds for stem-cell research, which many scientists believe could lead to new methods for fighting degenerative diseases like Parkinson's. President Bush has tightly limited federal funding in this area; in July he vetoed a bill that would have increased such funding, citing moral concerns about the use of discarded embryos, from which scientists extract stem cells stem cells, unspecialized human or animal cells that can produce mature specialized body cells and at the same time replicate themselves. Embryonic stem cells are derived from a blastocyst (the blastula typical of placental mammals; see embryo), which is very young .

* OHIO Ohio, state, United States
Ohio, midwestern state in the Great Lakes region of the United States. It is bordered by Pennsylvania (NE) West Virginia (SE), Kentucky (S), Indiana (W), and Michigan and Lake Erie (N).
, TEXAS & 17 OTHER STATES have amended their state constitutions to ban same-sex marriage Noun 1. same-sex marriage - two people of the same sex who live together as a family; "the legal status of same-sex marriages has been hotly debated"
couple, twosome, duet, duo - a pair who associate with one another; "the engaged couple"; "an inseparable
, while a federal constitutional amendment failed to win congressional approval this summer. (Massachusetts is the only state that currently permits same-sex marriage, as a result of a State Supreme Court ruling in 2004.)

* THE CALIFORNIA LEGISLATURE is considering a bill that would make the state the first to impose limits on the emissions of all greenhouse gases. The Bush administration has often argued that such limits would stunt the growth of the nation's economy.

* SOUTH DAKOTA South Dakota (dəkō`tə), state in the N central United States. It is bordered by North Dakota (N), Minnesota and Iowa (E), Nebraska (S), and Wyoming and Montana (W).  enacted a law in March that bans all abortions except those necessary to save the life of the mother. Supporters of the law said it was meant as a challenge to Roe v. Wade Roe v. Wade, case decided in 1973 by the U.S. Supreme Court. Along with Doe v. Bolton, this decision legalized abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy. , the 1973 Supreme Court decision that legalized abortion in the U.S.

FEDERALISM & THE CONSTITUTION

To some extent, states have always had their own laws and policies on issues like education and taxes. Indeed, that was precisely the point of the federal system the Founding Fathers designed in the Constitution: The federal government and the states each have certain powers, holding each other in check while everyone reaps the benefits of a large, unified nation. The debate over just how strong the federal and individual state governments should be--and which issues should be decided at the federal and state levels--has been going on for more than two centuries.

Right now, the states appear to be aggressively pushing their own agendas. "I think this is up there among the eras of greatest distance among the states," says John D. Donahue, a professor at Harvard's Kennedy School of Government. "It's because we have fairly intense cleavages in values, preferences, points of view among the population, and in some of these areas they do tend to cluster state by state."

There have been other points in American history when states went their own ways on high-profile issues and state laws were radically different. The most prominent examples are slavery before the Civil War, and later the Jim Crow laws Jim Crow laws, in U.S. history, statutes enacted by Southern states and municipalities, beginning in the 1880s, that legalized segregation between blacks and whites. The name is believed to be derived from a character in a popular minstrel song. , which limited the rights of blacks until the 1960s.

"Is it any more extreme [today] than having slavery in Virginia and laws excluding blacks from voting in Illinois when they could [vote] in Maine?" asks Pauline Maier Pauline Maier, born in 1938 in St. Paul, Minnesota, is the William R. Kenan Jr. Professor of American History at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. A popular scholar of the American Revolution, the preceding era and post-revolutionary America, she holds a bachelor's degree , a professor of American history at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Massachusetts Institute of Technology, at Cambridge; coeducational; chartered 1861, opened 1865 in Boston, moved 1916. It has long been recognized as an outstanding technological institute and its Sloan School of Management has notable programs in business, . "Not all states march in sync."

In some ways, this landscape is a red state/blue state divide (a reference to the states that tend to vote Republican and Democratic, respectively), but it goes beyond cultural hot buttons to issues like legal reform and health care. In April, Massachusetts became the first state to enact near-universal health-care coverage, accomplishing what the federal government has failed to do over many decades.

This state activism has turned federalism--once a favorite concept of conservatives seizing on states' rights states' rights, in U.S. history, doctrine based on the Tenth Amendment to the Constitution, which states, "The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.  to buck liberal national laws and court decisions--into an equal-opportunity idea embraced just as readily by liberals.

"Much of the association of federalism with conservative politics is the result of historical accident," Richard Thompson Ford, a Stanford University Stanford University, at Stanford, Calif.; coeducational; chartered 1885, opened 1891 as Leland Stanford Junior Univ. (still the legal name). The original campus was designed by Frederick Law Olmsted. David Starr Jordan was its first president.  law professor, argued in an article on Slate.com last year. "There is nothing inherently conservative about limitations on the power of Congress and the executive."

STATES AS LABORATORIES

Some states appear to be motivated by the belief that the federal government has not done enough on some issues.

"Look what states are doing on global warming," says Man Ehrenhalt, executive editor of Governing magazine Governing is a national monthly magazine, edited and published since 1987 in Washington, D.C., whose subject area is state and local government in the United States. The magazine covers policy, politics and the management of government enterprises. . "Many of them are involved in climate change, and that may well force the federal government's hand. Stem-cell research--states are doing that because the Bush administration doesn't want to do very much."

The states have previously served as laboratories for changes later adopted at the federal level, such as during the early 20th century, historians say. For instance, President Franklin Delano Roosevelt's federal New Deal programs-including the Social Security Act, which provides income for retirees and unemployment benefits for workers who lose their jobs--were modeled after state programs.

The crystal ball, then, would indicate that some of the issues the states are grappling with will eventually get sorted out nationally in federal legislation. But that may not happen overnight, or on every issue.

Give it a decade before the spillover spill·o·ver  
n.
1. The act or an instance of spilling over.

2. An amount or quantity spilled over.

3. A side effect arising from or as if from an unpredicted source:
 gets sorted out, according to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 Donahue.

"If you look through American history there's an ebb and flow the alternate ebb and flood of the tide; often used figuratively.

See also: Ebb
 of more state autonomy and more federal authority," he says. "Within another 10 years, we're going to see another season of centralization, and I think we'll have convergence on a lot of issues."

AMENDMENTS BANNING SAME-SEX MARRIAGE

* ALABAMA

* ALASKA

* ARKANSAS

* GEORGIA

* KANSAS

* KENTUCKY

* LOUISIANA

* MICHIGAN

* MISSISSIPPI

* MISSOURI

* MONTANA

* NEBRASKA

* NEVADA

* NORTH DAKOTA North Dakota, state in the N central United States. It is bordered by Minnesota, across the Red River of the North (E), South Dakota (S), Montana (W), and the Canadian provinces of Saskatchewan and Manitoba (N).

* OHIO

* OKLAHOMA

* OREGON

* TEXAS

* UTAH Utah, state, United States
Utah (y`tä'), Rocky Mt. state of the W United States.


PERMITS GAY MARRIAGE

Pam Belluck is Boston bureau chief for The New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
 Times.
HIGHER MINIMUM WAGES

* MASSACHUSETTS

* ALASKA         $7.15
* CALIFORNIA     $6.75
* CONNECTICUT    $7.40
* DELAWARE       $6.15
* DISTRICT OF
  COLUMBIA       $7.00
* FLORIDA        $6.40
* HAWAII         $6.75
* ILLINOIS       $6.50
* MAINE          $6.50
* MARYLAND       $6.15
* MASSACHUSETTS  $6.75
* MINNESOTA      $6.15
* NEW JERSEY     $6.15
* NEW YORK       $6.75
* OREGON         $7.50
* RHODE ISLAND   $7.10
* VERMONT        $7.25
* WASHINGTON     $7.63

STATE VOTER TURNOUT: HIGH & LOWS

Percentage of eligible voter who cast
ballots in the 2004 presidential election

HIGHEST %

Minnesota       75
Wisconsin       74
Maine           74
Oregon          71
New Hampshire   70
South Dakota    69

LOWEST

Hawaii           48
Texas            52
Arkansas         52
South Carolina   52
Georgia          54
Arizona          54

SOURCE: U.S. ELECTION ASSISTANCE COMMISSION


BACKGROUND

The debate over states' rights and the power of the federal government is as old as the nation. While the Constitution gave a lot more power to the federal government than it did to the states, Article 10 said that "powers not delegated to the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area.  by the Constitution ... are reserved to the States."

CRITICAL THINKING

* Note the observation of Harvard professor John Donahue For other uses, see John Donahue (disambiguation).

John Frederick Donahue [Jiggs] (April 19, 1894 - October 3, 1949) was right fielder in Major League Baseball who played briefly for the Boston Red Sox during the 1923 season. Listed at 5' 8", 170 lb.
, who says there are "fairly intense" differences in values between people in various sections of the U.S. What do you think might account for the cultural/political differences that so sharply divide people who live in different regions?

* Ask students to consider one of the important issues raised in the article: the minimum wage. Why might states like Washington or Delaware set their minimum wages higher than states like Alabama or Ohio?

* Ask students why they think the Founding Fathers established a federal system under which the national and state governments could keep each other in check.

DISCUSSION QUESTIONS

* Explain why you would--or would not--consider moving to a different state because of that state's social and/or economic policies.

* Do you feet so strongly about a social or economic issue that you think the federal government or your state government should enact a law relevant to that issue?

WRITING PROMPT

* Have students write five-paragraph essays in which they identify social and/or economic issues they believe should be dealt with at the federal level and those that might better be dealt with by the states.

WEB WATCH

http://quickfacts.census.gov/qfd/index.html US. Census Bureau Noun 1. Census Bureau - the bureau of the Commerce Department responsible for taking the census; provides demographic information and analyses about the population of the United States
Bureau of the Census
 economic and social data on each state.

www-personal.umich.edu/~mejn/election/University of Michigan maps of the U.S. show the "red state/blue state" split. See accompanying maps showing more complex gradations of political affiliations.

1. The Founding Fathers established a form of government in which the national and state governments would each retain certain powers. This system is called

a democracy.

b parliamentarian par·lia·men·tar·i·an  
n.
1. One who is expert in parliamentary procedures, rules, or debate.

2. A member of a parliament.

3.
.

c nationalism.

d federalism.

2. One example of differences in state policies were "Jim Crow laws," which

a permitted businesses to disregard environmental regulations.

b limited the rights of blacks in the South.

c provided special tax breaks for the wealthy.

d provided public funds See Fund, 3.

See also: Public
 for religious schools.

3. Why do its backers want more funding for stem-cell research?

4. Why does President Bush oppose taws taws  
pl.n. Chiefly Scots
1. A whip or leather thong used to drive a spinning top.

2. A leather whip divided at the end into strips, formerly used to punish children:
 requiring big cuts in greenhouse gas emissions? He says

a such limits would hurt the U.S. economy.

b most Americans don't understand the impact of greenhouse gases.

c such laws are poorly written.

d there is no proof that greenhouse gases are harmful.

5. The "red state/blue state divide" refers to

a differing levels of economic development in states.

b differing forms of government in states.

c states that tend to vote Republican and Democratic respectively.

d the dates when states joined the U.S.

6. One good example of a federal program that began in the states is--,which provides income for retirees. (two words)

IN DEPTH QUESTIONS

1. Why do you believe the federal, government and many state governments disagree on issues of concern to the American people?

2. Identify at least two values that you believe all Americans share and explain why you believe people share these values.

3. Explain why a particular issue identified in the article is important to you.

ANSWER KEY

1. [d] federalism.

2. [b] limited rights of blacks in the South.

3. They believe stem-cell, research could lead to new methods of fighting disease. (Similar wording is acceptable.)

4. [a] such limits would hurt the U.S. economy.

5. [c] states that tend to vote Republican and Democratic respectively.

6. Social Security
COPYRIGHT 2006 Scholastic, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:NATIONAL
Author:Belluck, Pam
Publication:New York Times Upfront
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Sep 18, 2006
Words:1845
Previous Article:Election lottery: vote to win.(voting participation to be increased with lottery)(Survey)
Next Article:Guess who's looking at your Web page: college-admissions officials and employers are starting to check out candidates on Web sites like Facebook and...
Topics:



Related Articles
Letters.
Clueless: What women don't know about politics.(gender gap )(Brief Article)
Personal past-life experience of Irene Hickman, DO.(excerpt from Regression Therapy: A Handbook for Professionals, vol. 1)(Excerpt)
Chinese whispers. (Letters).(Letter to the Editor)
LETTERS IN THE EDITOR'S MAILBAG.(Letters)(Letter to the Editor)
The kids are all right: three teens who are being raised by gay parents are taking on the conservative establishment to defend their...
LETTERS IN THE EDITOR'S MAILBAG.(Letters)(Letter to the Editor)
1865's 14TH AMENDMENT - CIRCA 2006.(Government)
Letter from the editor.(Letter to the editor)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles