Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,550,337 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

The moment of consecration.


Mark Plaiss is correct to note that the Vatican's recognition of the Anaphora of Addai and Mari

Mari, ancient city, Mesopotamia

Mari (mä`rē), ancient city of Mesopotamia (modern Syria). It is on the middle Euphrates, south of its junction with the Habor (Khabur). The site was discovered by chance in the early 1930s by Arabs digging graves and has subsequently been excavated by the French.
 is, in many ways, exceptional ("This, Too, Is My Body," May 19). I suspect, however, that the decision was meant primarily as an ecumenical gesture toward the Assyrian Church Assyrian Church: see Nestorian Church.; I doubt that it signals any theological reversal on the consecration of the bread and wine. Plaiss's piece thus seems off the mark.

Plaiss rightly insists that the entire Eucharistic Prayer is important, and that it is only "by faith" that we believe the bread and wine to become Christ's body and blood "sometime" during the Eucharistic Prayer. Still, theological reflection permits us to say more. The early church fathers saw no problem with asserting both that the Eucharist is confected per precem ("through prayer") and that, after enunciating the words of Jesus ("This is my body ..."), the bread is no longer bread but Christ's body. Plaiss's citations from the Catechism and the New General Instruction retrieve this both/and patristic mindset. Even so, one can ask if the entire Eucharistic Prayer is equally sanctifying. Aren't the words of institution more important in this regard than, say, the words of petition for the unity of the church?

Absent from Plaiss's piece is any attention to the sacrificial reality of the Eucharist. It is neither only--nor ultimately--prayer that is offered to God during the Eucharistic liturgy. As a re-presentation of the sacrifice of redemption, the Eucharist naturally emphasizes the narrative of the Last Supper Last Supper, in the New Testament, meal taken by Jesus and his disciples on the eve of the passion. Jesus broke bread and passed a cup of wine among the disciples, identifying himself with the bread and the wine and linking the meal to his impending death on the cross. The meal was an anticipation both of Jesus' death and of the eschatological banquet referred to in several Old Testament passages and by Jesus himself., at which Jesus willingly offers himself for the sins of the world. If the church offers this same sacrifice in the course of the Eucharistic Prayer, granting an exalted role to the words of institution is hardly "misleading." Indeed, even though Addai and Mari lacks Jesus' dicta dicta n. the plural of dictum. from the Supper, Jesus' sacrificial intention is most evident, which may be why the Vatican can identify its "continuity with the Last Supper."

While I don't miss the ringing of bells during the Eucharist, that "ringing" still sounds (albeit inaudibly) in the gestures of genuflection or bowing that follow Jesus' words. This highlighting of the words of institution reflects a deep truth about our experience of liturgical prayer. We would like to think that our prayer is devoutly attentive, and that our desire and intention are always pure, especially when participating in the "Great Prayer" of thanksgiving and consecration. But experience teaches us something different. Attention comes only (and intermittently) with long practice, along with occasional visitations of grace. Given this reality, it seems wise that the church underscores the only words of the Eucharistic Prayer that are infallibly pure and efficacious, namely, those spoken in persona Christi.

Why haven't we "heard more" about the Addai and Mari statement? I'd wager that it is because the hierarchy does not see its decision as incompatible with Roman theology concerning the words of institution. Christ's dicta stand as the fulcrum of the Eucharistic Prayer, even when we understand the entire prayer as sanctifying.

MICHON M. MATTHIESEN

Brookline, Mass.

THE AUTHOR REPLIES:

Michon Matthiesen wonders if "one can ask if the entire Eucharistic Prayer is equally sanctifying." The answer is obviously yes; the Anaphora of Addai and Mari is proof of that. Since the anaphora lacks the words of institution, it is the entire anaphora that is "sanctifying." Actually, Matthiesen answers her own musing later in her letter: "Jesus' sacrificial intention is most evident [in the Anaphora of Addai and Mari], which may be why the Vatican can identify its 'continuity with the Last Supper.'" Exactly.

As for my "misleading" comment, I said the ringing of the bells at the consecration was "misleading," not that the words of institution are. I wrote that if bells are to be rung, the more appropriate place is at the "Great Amen," when we know through faith that the bread and wine are now certainly the body and blood of Jesus Christ.

MARK PLAISS
COPYRIGHT 2006 Commonweal Foundation
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Publication:Commonweal
Article Type:Letter to the editor
Date:Jul 14, 2006
Words:653
Previous Article:My father's story.(Letter to the editor)
Next Article:The dictates of conscience.(Letter to the editor)



Related Articles
Singapore consecrations called `valid but illegal'.
Taste and See.
Cardinal confirms kneeling.(rubrics for celebration of Mass)(Brief Article)
From Yvonne Dienesch. (Letters to the Editor).
Reaction to gay bishop varied: Robinson pleads for reconciliation.(World)
Churches break talks with ECUSA: consecration of gay bishop cited as problem.(World)
Pick and choose.(Letters)(Letter to the Editor)
More fallout from gay bishop conflict.(World)
Errata.
Open letter rebukes retired Carey: archbishop calls accusations 'baseless'.(WORLD)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles