Printer Friendly
The Free Library
22,738,802 articles and books

The impact of virtual manipulatives on first grade geometry instruction and learning.

This study investigated the impact of virtual manipulatives on first grade students' academic achievement as well as on student attitudes, behaviors, and interactions.

Thirty-one (31) first grade students were randomly assigned as·sign  
tr.v. as·signed, as·sign·ing, as·signs
1. To set apart for a particular purpose; designate: assigned a day for the inspection.

 to either a treatment or control group. Both groups studied identical objectives, but the treatment group used virtual manipulatives for practice. A pretest pre·test  
a. A preliminary test administered to determine a student's baseline knowledge or preparedness for an educational experience or course of study.

b. A test taken for practice.

 and posttest post·test  
A test given after a lesson or a period of instruction to determine what the students have learned.
 at both the first and second grade levels was conducted.

The pretests showed that the treatment group began lower than the control group, and at a significantly lower level (p < 0.05) on the first grade level of testing. Posttest results showed that the treatment group outscored the control group on both grade level tests, though not at a significant level (p > 0.05). The treatment group had significant improvements (p < 0.05) on both grade level tests, while the control group only had significant improvements (p < 0.05) on the second grade level of testing.


The treatment group teacher recorded her daily thoughts regarding the virtual manipulatives. She also noted her observations regarding student attitudes, behaviors, and interactions. She reported increased instructional time, repetition REPETITION, construction of wills. A repetition takes place when the same testator, by the same testamentary instrument, gives to the same legatee legacies of equal amount and of the same kind; in such case the latter is considered a repetition of the former, and the legatee is entitled  of practice activities, time-on-task, and feedback. She found that students showed increased motivation and challenged themselves to higher levels.

Teachers are using computer and Internet Internet

Publicly accessible computer network connecting many smaller networks from around the world. It grew out of a U.S. Defense Department program called ARPANET (Advanced Research Projects Agency Network), established in 1969 with connections between computers at the
 resources more frequently with their students. Seventy-six percent (76%) of teachers report using computers daily for planning and/or and/or  
Used to indicate that either or both of the items connected by it are involved.

Usage Note: And/or is widely used in legal and business writing.
 teaching, and 63% report using the Internet for instruction (CEOForum, 2001). The integration of computers into the daily instruction of students has become more than acceptable practice, it has come to be expected (Miller & McInerney The name McInerney (mac-en-er-nee) - also spelt McInerny, McInnerny or McEnearney - is of Irish Gaelic origin where it is found in the modern Irish form of Mac an Airchinnigh (pronounced mock-on-arc-kenny) and in the old and literary form of Mac an Oirchinnigh and Mac an Oirchindig. , 1994-1995). This expectation is partially a result of the large financial and time investments made on computer systems and Internet accessibility. One estimate suggests that over $6 billion was spent in 1999-2000, and technology expenditures have tripled in K-12 schools during the last decade (Sivin-Kachala & Bialo, 2000). In 2000, the average public school contained 110 computers. Instructional rooms with Internet access See how to access the Internet.  increased from 3% in 1994 to 77% in 2000. Nearly 98% of schools had Internet access in 2000, an increase from 35% in 1994 (CEOForum, 2001; Snyder Snyder, city (1990 pop. 12,195), seat of Scurry co., NW Tex., in a prairie and mesquite region; inc. 1907. Oil production is the city's main industry; natural gas is also refined and processed. , 2002). The increase in computer and Internet access has made web-based instruction and classroom activities a viable option for educators, and illustrates the tremendous faith that is placed on the capability of computers and Internet to improve instruction (D'Amico D'Amico is an Italian surname which may refer to:
  • Antonio D'Amico (b. 1959)
  • Frank D'Amico, Canadian politician
  • Anthony "Fat Tony" D'Amico, fictional character on The Simpsons animated series
  • Gigi D'Amico, music producer and sound engineer
, 1990)

Mere faith in technology and the Internet doesn't does·n't  

Contraction of does not.
 justify the adoption of and expenditures for computer and web-based resources. A call for accountability in all areas of education has been a dominant theme in recent years. Many opinions exist regarding the effectiveness and appropriateness of technology use with young children and these are forcefully force·ful  
Characterized by or full of force; effective: was persuaded by the forceful speaker to register to vote; enacted forceful measures to reduce drug abuse.
 shared in a variety of venues. These opinions range from a call for a moratorium A suspension of activity or an authorized period of delay or waiting. A moratorium is sometimes agreed upon by the interested parties, or it may be authorized or imposed by operation of law.  on computers in elementary classrooms (Fool's Gold fool's gold: see pyrite. : A Critical Look at Computers in Childhood [Alliance for Childhood, 2000]) to the response to that article by Thornburg Thornburg may refer to:

  • Thornburg, Pennsylvania
  • Thornburg, Iowa
  • Alan Z. Thornburg (born 1967), American lawyer
  • Jeremy Thornburg (born 1982), American football player
  • Lacy Thornburg (born 1929), American judge
 (2000), who promotes the use of technology as an effective learning tool with students of all ages.

One concern regarding young children using computers is that computer environments are not concrete, asserting as·sert  
tr.v. as·sert·ed, as·sert·ing, as·serts
1. To state or express positively; affirm: asserted his innocence.

2. To defend or maintain (one's rights, for example).
 the belief that children construct knowledge through interaction with materials and people, and that children cannot handle the symbolic representations present in a computer environment (Barnes & Hill, 1983; Wood, Willoughby Willoughby (wĭl`əbē), city (1990 pop. 20,510), Lake co., NE Ohio, on the Chagrin River, near Lake Erie; settled c.1800, inc. as a city 1951. Manufactures include rubber products, electronic components, and clothing. , & Specht n. 1. (Zool.) A woodpecker. , 1998). However, what is "concrete" to a child may have more to do with what is meaningful and manipulable than with physical characteristics. Moyer Moyer is a surname, and may refer to:
  • Bill Moyer
  • Charles Moyer, President of the Western Federation of Miners
  • Jamie Moyer, Major League Baseball pitcher
  • John Moyer, bassist for the band Disturbed
  • Paul Moyer, television broadcaster
See also
, Bolyard, and Spikell (2002) defined a virtual manipulative ma·nip·u·la·tive  
Serving, tending, or having the power to manipulate.

Any of various objects designed to be moved or arranged by hand as a means of developing motor skills or understanding abstractions, especially in
 as "an interactive, web-based visual representation of a dynamic object that presents opportunities for constructing mathematical knowledge" (p. 373). Virtual manipulatives tend to be more than just electronic replications of their physical counterparts. They typically include additional features or options that expand on what a physical manipulative can offer. Some virtual manipulatives are able to present a representation that would not be easily made or even possible with physical manipulatives, an attribute shared with many types of computer simulations.


The use of virtual manipulatives is still relatively new in the classroom, and research on their impact is limited. Reimer and Moyer (2005) described a study on third graders learning about fractions with virtual manipulatives that showed statistically significant gains in students' conceptual knowledge. They also reported that the student surveys and interviews indicated that the manipulatives provided immediate and specific feedback, were easier and faster to use than traditional methods, and enhanced students' enjoyment while learning.

Previous studies, in math and other areas, have compared the symbolic computer environment to the "concrete" environment, though not with the use of virtual manipulatives. These studies indicate that children are able to transfer symbolic learning from the computer environment to the actual environment.

The well-known Logo programming language is a prime example of an effective method for working with symbolic concepts by using an interactive computer environment. The programming involved in Logo promotes abstract thinking and returns a concrete visual picture (Allocco et al., 1992). Comparisons between Logo and non-Logo students have shown that Logo students are more effective in solving problems involving concepts and applications. They also score higher on figure classification, quantitative reasoning, and have shown a significant improvement in the achievement of geometry geometry [Gr.,=earth measuring], branch of mathematics concerned with the properties of and relationships between points, lines, planes, and figures and with generalizations of these concepts.  skills (Robinson, Feldman, & Ulhig, 1987). Computers not only enhance children's learning experiences by allowing them to visualize connections among various topics (Enderson, 1997), but can indeed facilitate their cognitive development, leading to students investigating ideas beyond grade-level expectations (Duarte, Young, & DeFranco, 2000).

In a study comparing the symbolic computer environment to the "concrete" environment, a researcher (Ainsa, 1999) used M & M's as math manipulatives to measure children's ability to accomplish a mathematical task and the use of a computer to do a similar task. The study found that 101 subjects, aged four to six, showed no significant differences in their abilities to match colors and numbers, identify shapes, count items, or perform addition and subtraction subtraction, fundamental operation of arithmetic; the inverse of addition. If a and b are real numbers (see number), then the number ab is that number (called the difference) which when added to b (the subtractor) equals . The researcher indicated that a combination of approaches yielded in enthusiastic learning, although the students tended to request M & M's anytime a math concept was discussed. A similar study showed that third grade children who used both physical manipulatives and computers demonstrated sophistication so·phis·ti·cate  
v. so·phis·ti·cat·ed, so·phis·ti·cat·ing, so·phis·ti·cates
1. To cause to become less natural, especially to make less naive and more worldly.

 in classification and logical thinking. The children also showed more foresight (graphics, tool) Foresight - A software product from Nu Thena providing graphical modelling tools for high level system design and simulation.  and deliberation deliberation n. the act of considering, discussing, and, hopefully, reaching a conclusion, such as a jury's discussions, voting and decision-making.

DELIBERATION, contracts, crimes.
 in classification than did children who used only manipulatives (Clements, Nastasi, & Swaminathan, 1993).

Shade and Watson (1990) conducted a study in which young children learned to classify clas·si·fy  
tr.v. clas·si·fied, clas·si·fy·ing, clas·si·fies
1. To arrange or organize according to class or category.

2. To designate (a document, for example) as confidential, secret, or top secret.
 a unique array of objects, such as tables, cars, lamps, and so forth., based on the simple concept of inside or outside. Children aged 18 to 42 months spent one hour manipulating computer graphic objects in and around the background scene of a house and yard. These students were then asked to classify the matching "real" objects. The study found that around the age of 36 months, the computer manipulation of the objects enabled the children to be able to correctly classify the series of actual objects.

Another study (Clements et al., 1993) involved asking young children to create "bean bean, name applied to the seeds of leguminous trees and shrubs and to various leguminous plants of the family Leguminosae (pulse family) with edible seeds or seed pods (legumes). The genera and species encompassed by the term bean are many and variable.  stick pictures" in either a felt board or computer environment. Students could freely select and arrange beans See JavaBeans. , sticks, and number symbols on a computer, just like the real bean stick environment. The results of the study showed that the computer environment actually offered equal, and sometimes greater, control and flexibility to young children.


This study used virtual manipulatives that were created or reviewed by the MarcoPolo Educational Foundation ( This included virtual manipulatives from the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics The National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (NCTM) was founded in 1920. It has grown to be the world's largest organization concerned with mathematics education, having close to 100,000 members across the USA and Canada, and internationally.  Illuminations site (, the National Library of Virtual Manipulatives (, Arcytech (, and Math Cats (http://www.mathcats. com/).

The study focused on whether or not the virtual manipulatives were effective practice activities when used with first grade students during a geometry unit. These activities were compared to the typical geometry practice activities as recommended in the midwestern school district's adopted math text, which was authored by a national text publisher. The NCTM's standards were also listed as the foundation of the math text. The following questions were investigated:

1. What differences exist among the academic achievement of first grade students who use the virtual manipulatives and those students who use the traditional text-recommended practice activities?

2. What are the treatment teacher's impressions and observations on student attitudes, behaviors, and interactions when using the virtual manipulatives?

Population and Sample

The population for this study was first graders who receive geometry instruction. The sample of this population was all 31 first grade students enrolled at an urban, midwestern elementary school elementary school: see school. . The students were randomly assigned to either the treatment or control group for the duration of the geometry unit, which lasted for 13 instructional days. The school had a free and reduced lunch percentage of 43.4%. Demographically, the first grade class included 21 Caucasian Caucasian or Caucasoid: see race. , 2 Hispanic Hispanic Multiculture A person of Mexican, Puerto Rican, Cuban, Central or South American, or other Spanish culture or origin, regardless of race Social medicine Any of 17 major Latino subcultures, concentrated in California, Texas, Chicago, Miam, NY, and elsewhere , 1 Native American, 3 African-American, 1 Middle-Eastern, and 3 Asian students. According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

 a parent/guardian survey, with all households responding, 77.4% of the students' households had home computers and 64.5% had Internet access.

As shown in Figure 1, 75% of the treatment group had home computers and 68.8% had Internet access. In the control group, 80% had home computers and 60% had Internet access.

As shown in Figure 2, in the treatment group, for students who had home computers, parents reported that their child used the computer an average of 2.9 hours per week. In the treatment group, for students who had Internet access, parents reported that their child accessed the Internet an average of 0.5 hours per week. In the control group, for students who had home computers, parents reported that their child used the computer an average of 3.0 hours per week. In the control group, for students who had Internet access, parents reported that their child accessed the Internet an average of 0.8 hours per week.

The teachers in the study were randomly assigned to be either the control or treatment group teacher. The classroom teachers involved in the study had comparable academic and teaching backgrounds. The control group teacher held a Bachelor's degree in Elementary Education elementary education
 or primary education

Traditionally, the first stage of formal education, beginning at age 5–7 and ending at age 11–13.
 plus 18 hours of graduate credit. She had taught for nine years. Her mathematics teaching preparation included a university elementary math methods course, as well as district staff development courses. The treatment group teacher held a Bachelor's degree in Elementary Education with an endorsement in special education plus 24 hours of graduate credit. She had taught for seven years. Her mathematics teaching preparation included a university elementary math methods course, as well as district staff development courses. For reporting purposes, the pseudonym pseudonym (s`dənĭm) [Gr.,=false name], name assumed, particularly by writers, to conceal identity. A writer's pseudonym is also referred to as a nom de plume (pen name).  of this treatment group teacher is Karla.


The timing of this study corresponded to the instructional timing and sequence planned by the classroom teachers. Both sections of the students received geometry instruction as outlined in a nationally published math textbook textbook Informatics A treatise on a particular subject. See Bible. . The objectives covered in the geometry unit were that students be able to: identify spheres, cylinders, rectangular rec·tan·gu·lar  
1. Having the shape of a rectangle.

2. Having one or more right angles.

3. Designating a geometric coordinate system with mutually perpendicular axes.
 prisms, cones Cones
Receptor cells that allow the perception of colors.

Mentioned in: Color Blindness
, and pyramids; copy a plane shape and be able to transform a shape into a larger/smaller shape; draw a plane shape with a given number of sides; draw a shape with a given number of corners; identify and draw plane shapes that are the same size and shape; state a rule for a given pattern; use problem solving problem solving

Process involved in finding a solution to a problem. Many animals routinely solve problems of locomotion, food finding, and shelter through trial and error.
 strategies to continue a pattern; draw lines of symmetry symmetry, generally speaking, a balance or correspondence between various parts of an object; the term symmetry is used both in the arts and in the sciences. ; and identify and show equal parts in a plane shape.

Students in the control group used their student textbooks for instructional purposes, and used physical manipulatives and corresponding worksheets for practice. The treatment group used the same textbooks for instructional purposes, but used virtual manipulatives for practice. If a virtual manipulative was not available for an objective, the students in the treatment group completed the same worksheet activity as the control group, however, they never touched an actual physical manipulative throughout this study. Each treatment group student had a Macintosh[R] iBook[R] laptop computer A portable computer that has a flat LCD screen and usually weighs less than eight pounds. Often called just a "laptop," it uses batteries for mobile use and AC power for charging the batteries and desktop use. Today's high-end laptops provide all the capabilities of most desktop computers.  that was connected to the Internet by way of a wireless network. The computers were only used during the designated math time. The treatment group teacher was provided with a laptop Same as laptop computer.

laptop - portable computer
 connected to a projector for instructional use during math only.

Data Collection

The tests and assessment activities used for both groups were those provided by the publishers of the textbook. Prior knowledge of geometry concepts such as patterns, shape identification, and symmetry was measured for each child using the Grade One Form A and Grade Two Form A tests from the text's publisher. These assessments were given as a pretest during the first class period of the geometry chapter, prior to any geometry instruction. The corresponding Grade One Form B and Grade Two Form B tests were given as a posttest on the final day of the geometry chapter, following all of the instruction and practice activities. While the Grade Two tests were given to accommodate possible ceiling effects of the pretests and posttests, only first grade students were involved in this study. For the tests, students in the treatment group did not use their computers; they completed the tests just as the control group did.

Daily assessment activities were used by the teachers, but are not reported, as the data was not disaggregated Broken up into parts.  by the content of each virtual manipulative or activity. In addition, the treatment group classroom teacher (Karla) maintained a daily journal to record her impressions regarding student time-on-task, work behaviors Work behavior is a term used to describe the behavior one uses in the workplace and is normally more formal than other types of human behavior. This varies from profession to profession, as some are far more casual than others. , effectiveness of the virtual manipulatives, and overall thoughts on the instructional process.

Statistical Analysis Plan

Group descriptive statistics descriptive statistics

see statistics.
, such as mean and standard deviation In statistics, the average amount a number varies from the average number in a series of numbers.

(statistics) standard deviation - (SD) A measure of the range of values in a set of numbers.
, were calculated to classify and summarize sum·ma·rize  
intr. & tr.v. sum·ma·rized, sum·ma·riz·ing, sum·ma·riz·es
To make a summary or make a summary of.

 data. For the comparisons between individual practice activities, t-tests with [alpha] = 0.05 were conducted. A corrected, more conservative value of [alpha] = 0.05/number of tests conducted was used when appropriate. A 2x2 (pretest-posttest by control-treatment) mixed model ANOVA anova

see analysis of variance.

ANOVA Analysis of variance, see there
 with [alpha] = 0.05 was conducted to examine changes from pretest to posttest.


Grade One Test Results

Again, the first graders took two different sets of pretests and posttests, one at the first grade level and one at the second grade level. As displayed in Figure 3, on the first grade level pretest the treatment group had a mean of 22.2 out of 31 items (a mean of 71.6%), with a standard deviation of 4.8. The control group had a mean of 27.7 (89.5%) with a standard deviation of 1.8. On the posttest, the treatment group had a mean of 30.0 (96.8%) with a standard deviation of 1.0. The control group had a mean of 29.9 (96.3%) with a standard deviation of 1.2. Levene's Test In statistics, Levene's test is an inferential statistic used to assess the equality of variance in different samples. Some common statistical procedures assume that variances of the populations from which different samples are drawn are equal.  of Equality of Error Variance The discrepancy between what a party to a lawsuit alleges will be proved in pleadings and what the party actually proves at trial.

In Zoning law, an official permit to use property in a manner that departs from the way in which other property in the same locality
 showed that on the pretest, the error variance was not equal across groups. This violated vi·o·late  
tr.v. vi·o·lat·ed, vi·o·lat·ing, vi·o·lates
1. To break or disregard (a law or promise, for example).

2. To assault (a person) sexually.

 the assumption of homogeneity Homogeneity

The degree to which items are similar.
 of variances. However, according to Green, Salkind, and Akey (2000):
    If the group sizes are equal or approximately equal (largest/
    smallest < 1.5) then the F statistic is robust for unequal
    variances. That is, the actual [alpha] stays close to the nominal
    [alpha] (level set by researcher). The only time one need worry is
    when the group sizes are sharply unequal (largest/smallest > 1.5)
    and a statistical test shows that the population variances are
    unequal. (p. 155)

The ratio of treatment group size to control group size in this study was 16/15 = 1.07 (less than 1.5). This indicated that the F statistic statistic,
n a value or number that describes a series of quantitative observations or measures; a value calculated from a sample.


a numerical value calculated from a number of observations in order to summarize them.
 was robust.

A 2x2 (pretest-posttest by control-treatment) mixed model ANOVA was conducted. The results for the ANOVA indicated a significant main effect for the within factor, F (1, 29) = 54.16, p = 0.000, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.7, a significant main effect for the between factor, F (1, 29) = 14.68, p = 0.001, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.3, and a significant interaction between pretest to posttest and group membership, F (1, 29) = 17.654, p = 0.000, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.4, a large effect size (Green et al., 2000).

Because the interaction between pretest to posttest and group membership was significant, the main effects were ignored. Follow-up follow-up,
n the process of monitoring the progress of a patient after a period of active treatment.



follow-up plan
 tests were conducted on the simple main effects to explain the interaction, with the alpha value corrected to 0.025. There was a significant difference (p = 0.000) between the groups at the time of pretest. There was no significant difference (p = 0.747) between the groups at the time of posttest. There was a significant difference (p = 0.000) from pretest to posttest for the treatment group. There was no significant difference (p = 0.036) from pretest to post-test for the control group. The 95% confidence intervals confidence interval,
n a statistical device used to determine the range within which an acceptable datum would fall. Confidence intervals are usually expressed in percentages, typically 95% or 99%.
 displayed in Figure 4 also reflect the follow-ups.


A t-test t-test,
n an inferential statistic used to test for differences between two means (groups) only. This statistic is used for small samples (e.g.,
N < 30). Also called
t-ratio, stu-dent's t.
 was conducted to analyze the overall change for each group from pretest to posttest. The treatment group had a mean change of 7.81 with a standard deviation of 4.87. The control group had a mean change of 2.13 with a standard deviation of 2.00. The t-test showed a significant difference between groups, with a p value of 0.000. The effect size was 1.47, a large effect size (Cohen cohen
 or kohen

(Hebrew: “priest”) Jewish priest descended from Zadok (a descendant of Aaron), priest at the First Temple of Jerusalem. The biblical priesthood was hereditary and male.
, 1988).

Grade Two Test Results

As displayed in Figure 5, at the second grade level of testing, the treatment group had a pretest mean of 15.1 out of 24 items (a mean of 62.8%), with a standard deviation of 5.1. The control group had a mean of 17.3 (72.0%) with a standard deviation of 2.7. On the posttest, the treatment group had a mean of 22.3 (93.0%) with a standard deviation of 1.5. The control group had a mean of 20.6 (86.0%) with a standard deviation of 2.7.

Levene's Test of Equality of Error Variance showed that on the pretest, the error variance was not equal across groups. This violated the assumption of homogeneity of variances. Since the ratio of treatment group size to control group size in this study was 16/15 = 1.07 (less than 1.5), the F statistic was robust (Green et al., 2000).

A 2x2 (pretest-posttest by control-treatment) mixed model ANOVA was conducted. The results for the ANOVA indicated a significant main effect for the within factor, F (1, 29) = 52.35, p = 0.000, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.6, a nonsignificant non·sig·nif·i·cant  
1. Not significant.

2. Having, producing, or being a value obtained from a statistical test that lies within the limits for being of random occurrence.
 main effect for the between factor, F (1, 29) = 0.071, p = 0.792, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.002, and a significant interaction between pretest to posttest and group membership, F (1, 29) = 7.17, p = 0.012, partial [[eta].sup.2] = 0.2, a large effect size (Green et al., 2000).

Because the interaction between pretest to posttest and group membership was significant, the main effects were ignored. Follow-up tests were conducted on the simple main effects to explain the interaction, with the alpha value corrected to 0.025. There was no significant difference (p = 0.145) between the groups at the time of pretest. There was no significant difference (p = 0.037) between the groups at the time of posttest. There was a significant difference (p = 0.000) from pretest to posttest for the treatment group. There was a significant difference (p = 0.004) from pretest to posttest for the control group. The 95% confidence intervals displayed in Figure 6 also reflect the follow-ups.


A t-test was conducted to analyze the overall change for each group from pretest to posttest. The treatment group had a mean change of 7.25 with a standard deviation of 4.74. The control group had a mean change of 3.33 with a standard deviation of 3.20. The t-test showed a significant difference between groups, with a p value of 0.012. The effect size was 0.94, a large effect size (Cohen, 1988).


On the first grade level pretest, the treatment group scored significantly lower than the control group (22.2 for treatment and 27.7 for control). At posttest, following the completion of the geometry unit, the treatment group closed the gap and actually slightly outscored the control group, though not at a significant level (30 for treatment and 29.9 for control). The post hoc post hoc  
adv. & adj.
In or of the form of an argument in which one event is asserted to be the cause of a later event simply by virtue of having happened earlier:
 analysis demonstrated a significant change within the treatment group from pretest to posttest, but no significant change within the control group. The change data also showed that the treatment group had a significantly greater overall improvement during the geometry unit.

On the second grade level pretest, the treatment group scored slightly lower than the control group (15.1 for treatment and 17.3 for control). At posttest, following the completion of the geometry unit, the treatment group again surpassed the control group, but the difference was not statistically significant (22.3 for treatment and 20.6 for control). The post hoc analysis demonstrated a significant change within both the treatment and control groups from pretest to posttest. The change data also showed that the treatment group had a significantly greater overall improvement.

At both grade levels of posttesting, both groups of first graders actually ended up with excellent group mean scores, the lowest being the control group at the second grade test level with a group mean of 86.0%. Based on the data, the case could be made that all participating students from both groups would be ready for third grade level geometry instruction as second graders in their next academic year. The treatment group did overcome large gaps and had significant improvements from pretest to posttest at both grade levels. The control group only showed a significant improvement at the second grade test level. The results indicate that the use of the virtual manipulatives as an instructional tool was extremely effective for the treatment group, and perhaps more effective than the use of the traditional text activities. This echoes an observation by Bennett (1992) in a review of computers in math education: "The computer appears to be a successful teaching tool when it is used by good teachers using appropriate teaching methods. It will make a good teacher better; it will not make a poor teacher an excellent teacher" (p. 39).

At the very least, the results suggest that the virtual manipulatives were as effective as the traditional text activities. Also, students at this grade level demonstrated their ability to transfer what they learned in the symbolic environment of the computer to the paper and pencil environment of their tests. It needs to be reemphasized that the treatment group never touched actual physical geometry manipulatives during this study.

What may ultimately be more important is what Karla wrote in her daily journal regarding the amount, type, and quality of feedback provided by the virtual manipulatives. Instant feedback is regarded as an effective and motivational feature of computers and video games See video game console.  (Chaffin, Maxwell, & Thompson Thompson, city, Canada
Thompson, city (1991 pop. 14,977), central Man., Canada, on the Burntwood River. A mining town, it developed after large nickel deposits were discovered in the area in 1956.
, 1982). Video games, which are so appealing to children, are a model of how instant feedback can motivate them. As soon as a child makes a decision in a video game, they know within a matter of seconds the results of that decision and will often return to try a different decision path. In terms of student interaction and motivation, Jenkins (2002) wrote:
    Games create opportunities for leadership, competition, teamwork and
    collaboration--for nerdy kids, not just for high-school football
    players. Games matter because they form the digital equivalent of
    the Head Start program, getting kids excited about what computers
    can do.

The level of feedback that is present in video games is recommended for educational software (November, 2002). In the case of the color pattern virtual manipulative, students did not have to wait for Karla to check their work. With the click of a button, the computer directly and immediately indicated if they were correct. The virtual manipulative allowed a student to ask for a hint if needed. Students did not have to wait for Karla to offer advice. Features such as use of colors not of the white race; - commonly meaning, esp. in the United States, of negro blood, pure or mixed.

See also: Color
 on the virtual geoboard and the ability to mark sides and corners on the shape spinner provided indirect feedback for the students. While such features didn't provide direct feedback on the students' accuracy, they definitely made it easier for the students to self-regulate and make adjustments individually and privately. Karla also noted that these same indirect features made it easier for her to check their work by quickly glancing at the computer screens as she moved around the classroom. Karla's observations mirror what Shute and Miksad (1997) discussed in their study of the use of computers with preschoolers: "Under real-life classroom conditions, the computer may indeed be beneficial by providing feedback more readily than a busy teacher" (p. 251).

Karla also discussed the students' attitudes, behaviors, and interactions when using the virtual manipulatives. One behavioral behavioral

pertaining to behavior.

behavioral disorders
see vice.

behavioral seizure
see psychomotor seizure.
 advantage was the amount of instructional time saved by using the virtual manipulatives. Students did not have to clean-up rubber bands from geoboards, they did not have to put away pattern blocks, they did not have pass out manipulatives, and re-doing an activity was not an ordeal ordeal, ancient legal custom whereby an accused person was required to perform a test, the outcome of which decided the person's guilt or innocence. By an ordeal, appeal was made to divine authority to decide the guilt or innocence of one accused of a crime or to . The benefit of this time saved was the increased amount of time-on-task and increased number of repetitions of a practice activity. Karla often noted that her students were able to do more practice with the virtual manipulatives than her previous classes had done when using actual manipulatives.

Karla also discussed the flexibility of the virtual manipulatives. Several of them were used for more than one objective. As the students became more comfortable with using the virtual manipulatives and the computers, they were able to spend less time learning simply how to use them, and could focus more on the objectives for the lesson. One example of this flexibility of use is how the geoboard virtual manipulative was used for three objectives on three different days.

Flexibility of a virtual manipulative does not just refer to how many objectives it can cover. It also refers to how the virtual manipulative can do some things that actual manipulatives cannot do as effectively or efficiently. Karla noted that the shape spinner's ability to rotate a three-dimensional shape enhanced the students understanding of sides and corners. Students were able to see how a three-dimensional shape was comprised of several individual faces that were comprised of the sides and corners they were identifying. Karla reported that this allowed students to go more in-depth than previous classes had done without the virtual manipulative. She also observed that the virtual manipulatives allowed students to adapt the activity to meet an appropriate level of challenge. While using the pattern blocks virtual manipulative, students could create patterns ranging from simple to complex. Either way, it was the students' private choice. More often than not, Karla noted that students challenged themselves to higher levels, using the features of the virtual manipulative.

Another benefit of the virtual manipulatives was that they allowed for every child to have equal access to the same high quality lessons and activities. Students did not have to wait to take turns to share actual manipulatives, which again increased time-on-task and number of repetitions. In terms of educational equity, if these virtual manipulative were used in an entire school district, it would mean that all children would have equal access to high quality and effective materials.

A final benefit was that two of Karla's students that have difficulty with the motor skill of writing were able to easily use the virtual manipulatives. This allowed them to focus on the math objective instead of on the difficulty of using a pencil or stretching a rubber band across an actual geoboard. Karla reported that these two students typically struggled in math. These students excelled when using the virtual manipulatives.

To obtain all the necessary equipment for this study, four computers were borrowed from a local university, 11 computers were borrowed from Apple Computer, Inc., one computer was borrowed from the state Department of Education, and one computer was borrowed from the school. The wireless base station was borrowed from the state Department of Education, and the projector was borrowed from the school district. It is unfortunate that the school was only able to provide one computer and did not simply have all of the necessary technology available onsite. The two computers that would have been available in the teachers' classrooms at the school were all at least seven years old and incapable of running the virtual manipulatives. Also, no projection device was available. The school had a computer lab with a projector and modern computers, but the lab was not available for the times of this study. The lab is typically not available to classroom teachers as it is used to teach "specials" and to cover teachers' preparation periods. This is yet another barrier to effective technology integration at this school and many others. All of the "good stuff" is in a lab, and all the "old stuff" is in the classroom, typically with no projection device. Some solutions that schools are implementing to overcome this barrier include the use of mobile wireless labs, laptops for every student, or a combination of computer labs and laptops or modern computers in classrooms.

At the completion of this research project, Karla wrote a reflection essay discussing the impact of the virtual manipulatives on the students and her own teaching. She found that the virtual manipulatives kept students focused, increased the quality and quantity of practice, adapted to appropriate difficulty levels, and had other features not available when using traditional paper and pencil or actual manipulative activities. She discussed the need for teachers to be proficient pro·fi·cient  
Having or marked by an advanced degree of competence, as in an art, vocation, profession, or branch of learning.

An expert; an adept.
 with the use of the virtual manipulatives, have time to find appropriate computer activities, have access to presentation systems, and to have some basic computer troubleshooting Troubleshooting is a form of problem solving. It is the systematic search for the source of a problem so that it can be solved. Troubleshooting is often a process of elimination - eliminating potential causes of a problem.  skills. She ended her thoughts with the following:

I have enjoyed working with this project. My students have enjoyed it as well. It was enlightening en·light·en  
tr.v. en·light·ened, en·light·en·ing, en·light·ens
1. To give spiritual or intellectual insight to:
 for me to see how virtual manipulatives could be used to help meet our objectives.

Students learned the geometry objectives we worked on, and I have learned so much more about using virtual manipulatives as practice activities. I will definitely be using them in the future.


The population of all first-grade students receiving geometry instruction was limited to a sample consisting of first-grade students enrolled at one elementary school. This sampling procedure limits the generalizability of the results. The sample size was n = 31, which limited the statistical power of the experiment. If there was a real effect size associated with the treatment that was too small, it was possible that it would remain undetected, producing a Type II error. Two different teachers taught the treatment and control groups. Although the objectives and instruction were planned to be identical for each day, it was impossible to control for differences between teachers. Finally, the text publisher created the dependent measures. No information regarding the validity or reliability of those measures could be obtained from the publisher.


It would be beneficial to repeat this study with a larger sample size to increase the statistical power. If a researcher only had access to the same type of equipment as in this study, they could repeat the study within different buildings in a school district to gather more data. However, matching the study to the planned instructional timing of the geometry unit would be critical. To better control any potential teacher effect, it is recommended that the same teacher teach all the groups in the study if possible.

A longitudinal study longitudinal study

a chronological study in epidemiology which attempts to establish a relationship between an antecedent cause and a subsequent effect. See also cohort study.
 following a cohort cohort /co·hort/ (ko´hort)
1. in epidemiology, a group of individuals sharing a common characteristic and observed over time in the group.

 of students through several years of instruction would be useful for determining any long-term Long-term

Three or more years. In the context of accounting, more than 1 year.


1. Of or relating to a gain or loss in the value of a security that has been held over a specific length of time. Compare short-term.
 impacts of the virtual manipulatives and the use of technology. Due to the grade level of the students in this study, standardized test A standardized test is a test administered and scored in a standard manner. The tests are designed in such a way that the "questions, conditions for administering, scoring procedures, and interpretations are consistent" [1]  data was not available. A longitudinal study would be able to include more types of data as students move through elementary school.

Case studies of individual students who are using technology could provide more insight into their attitudes and behaviors. In addition, student interactions, time-on-task, and repetitions of practice activities could be recorded as quantitative data. Surveys could be conducted to gauge student opinions on the use of the virtual manipulatives, similar to those reported by Reimer and Moyer (2005).

Finally, and perhaps most importantly Adv. 1. most importantly - above and beyond all other consideration; "above all, you must be independent"
above all, most especially
, further research should investigate the amount and types of feedback incorporated into virtual manipulatives. Both qualitative and quantitative information could be gathered regarding what elements of feedback are most beneficial for students and teachers. Developers of virtual manipulatives could use this information to make future virtual manipulatives even more effective tools for teaching and learning.


Ainsa, T. (1999). Success of using technology and manipulatives to introduce numerical numerical

expressed in numbers, i.e. Arabic numerals of 0 to 9 inclusive.

numerical nomenclature
a numerical code is used to indicate the words, or other alphabetical signals, intended.
 problem solving skills in monolingual/bilingual early childhood classrooms. Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science, 18(4), 361-369.

Alliance for Childhood (2000). Fool's gold: A critical look at computers in childhood. Retrieved June 11, 2006, from To receive a file transmitted over a network. In any communications session, "download" means receive, and "upload" means send. The download/upload often implies a big/little scenario, in which data is being downloaded from the "big" server into the "little" user's computer. .htm

Allocco, L., Coffey, J., Dalton Dalton, city (1990 pop. 21,761), seat of Whitfield co., extreme NW Ga., in the Appalachian valley; inc. 1847. It is a highly industrialized city in a farm area. , A. M., Dariano, J., Dioguardi, J., Galterio, L., et al. (1992). To teach or not to teach Logo: Reflecting on Logo's use as a problem-solving tool. Educational Technology, 32(8), 23-27.

Barnes, B., & Hill, S. (1983). Should young children work with microcomputers--Logo before Lego? The Computing computing - computer  Teacher, 10(9), 11-14.

Bennett, J. (1992). Computers in mathematics education: A "not really for the researcher" review of recent unique findings. School Science and Mathematics, 92(1), 38-39.

CEOForum. (2001). Key building blocks for student achievement in the 21st century. Washington, DC: CEO (1) (Chief Executive Officer) The highest individual in command of an organization. Typically the president of the company, the CEO reports to the Chairman of the Board.  Forum on Education & Technology.

Chaffin, J., Maxwell, B., & Thompson, C. (1982). The application of video game formats to education software. Exceptional Children, 49(2), 173-178.

Clements, D. H., Nastasi, B. K., & Swaminathan, S. (1993). Young children and computers: Crossroads and directions from research. Young Children, 48(2), 56-64.

Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral science behavioral science
A scientific discipline, such as sociology, anthropology, or psychology, in which the actions and reactions of humans and animals are studied through observational and experimental methods.
 (2nd ed.). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

D'Amico, J. (1990). Three lessons I learned from a year of computer based instruction. Journal of Computer-based Instruction, 17(3), 103-109.

Duarte, V., Young, M., & DeFranco, T. (2000). What experts say and do regarding the use of technology in the mathematics classroom. Journal of Research and Development in Education, 33(4), 223-231.

Enderson, M. (1997). Old problems, new questions: Using technology to enhance math education. Learning and Leading with Technology, 25(2), 28-32.

Green, S., Salkind, N., & Akey, T. (2000). Using SPSS A statistical package from SPSS, Inc., Chicago ( that runs on PCs, most mainframes and minis and is used extensively in marketing research. It provides over 50 statistical processes, including regression analysis, correlation and analysis of variance.  for Windows; analyzing and understanding data (2nd ed.). Upper Saddle River Saddle River may refer to:
  • Saddle River, New Jersey, a borough in Bergen County, New Jersey
  • Saddle River (New Jersey), a tributary of the Passaic River in New Jersey
, NJ: Prentice-Hall.

Jenkins, H. (2002). Art form for the digital age. Retrieved June 11, 2006, from

Miller, M., & McInerney, W. (1994-95). Effects on achievement of a home/school computer project. Journal of Research on Computing in Education, 27(2), 198-210.

Moyer, P., Bolyard, J., & Spikell, M. (2002). What are virtual manipulatives? Teaching Children Mathematics, 8(6), 372-377.

November, A. (2002, August). Leadership: Managing the transition. Keynote address keynote address
An opening address, as at a political convention, that outlines the issues to be considered. Also called keynote speech.

Noun 1.
 at the Leadership Talks Technology Academy, Administrator Days. Kearney, NE.

Reimer, K., & Moyer, P. (2005). Third-graders learn about fractions using virtual manipulatives: A classroom study. Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching, 24(1), 5-25.

Robinson, M. A., Feldman, P., & Ulhig, G. E. (1987, Fall). The effects of Logo in the elementary classroom. Education, 434-441.

Shade, D., & Watson, J. A. (1990). Computers in early education: Issues put to rest. Theoretical links to sound practice, and the potential contribution of microworlds. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 6(4), 375-392.

Shute, R., & Miksad, J. (1997). Computer assisted instruction and cognitive development in preschoolers. Child Study Journal, 27(3), 237-253.

Sivin-Kachala, J., & Bialo, E. R. (2000). 2000 research report on the effectiveness of technology in schools. Washington, DC: Software and Information Industry Association According to its mission statement, "the Software & Information Industry Association (SIIA) is the principal trade association for the software and digital content industry. .

Snyder, T. (2002). Digest Digest: see Corpus Juris Civilis.

(1) A compilation of all the traffic on a news group or mailing list. Digests can be daily or weekly.

(2) Any compilation or summary.
 of education statistics, 2001. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Education, National Center for Education Statistics The National Center for Education Statistics (NCES), as part of the U.S. Department of Education's Institute of Education Sciences (IES), collects, analyzes, and publishes statistics on education and public school district finance information in the United States; conducts studies .

Thornburg, D. (2000). Should young children use computers? Retrieved June 11, 2006, from

Wood, E., Willoughby, T., & Specht, J. (1998). What's happening with computer technology in early childhood education settings? Journal of Educational Computing Research, 18(3), 237-243.


Lincoln Public Schools Lincoln Public Schools is the only public school district in Lincoln, Nebraska, USA. It is the second largest of Nebraska's 596 school districts, surpassed only by Omaha Public Schools. LPS educates more than 32,100 students in 54 schools.

The current superintendent is E.


DAVID BROOKS David Brooks is the name of:
  • David Brooks (journalist) (born 1961), commentator for The New York Times and other publications
  • David Brooks (politician) (1756–1838), United States representative in the Fifth United States Congress

University of Nebraska-Lincoln



Lincoln Public Schools

Comparison of Home Computer and Internet Access Between Groups

                 Treatment  Control

Home Computer    75         80
Internet Access  68.8       60

Figure 1. Comparison of home computer and Internet access between groups

Note: Table made from bar graph.

Comparison of Home Computer and Internet Use Between Groups

              Hours of use per week
              Treatment  Control

Computer Use  2.9        3
Internet Use  0.5        0.8

Figure 2. Comparison of home computer and Internet use between groups

Note: Table made from bar graph.

Grade One test Results

Tests     Treatment  Control

Pretest   22.2       27.7
Posttest  30         29.9

Figure 3. Grade one test results

Note: Table made from line graph.

Grade Two Test Results

Tests     Treatment  Control

Pretest   15.1       17.3
Posttest  22.3       20.6

Figure 5. Grade two test results

Note: Table made from line graph.
COPYRIGHT 2006 Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education (AACE)
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2006, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Lyon, Tammy
Publication:Journal of Computers in Mathematics and Science Teaching
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Dec 22, 2006
Previous Article:Computer use and mathematical literacy: an analysis of existing and potential relationships.

Related Articles
A teaching philosophy: rhetoric or reality?
Mathematics Autobiographies: A Window into Beliefs, Values, and Past Mathematics Experiences of Preservice Teachers.
Numbers game: sick of hearing about poor scores, non-existent retention and student apathy when it comes to mathematics? Overhauling your curriculum...
Integrating internet-based mathematical manipulatives within a learning environment.
Designing a virtual field trip.
Middle school mathematics classroom practices and achievement: a TIMSS-R analysis.
Pre-service elementary teachers' understanding of geometric similarity: the effect of dynamic geometry software.
Third-graders learn about fractions using virtual manipulatives: a classroom study.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters