Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,559,005 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

The global-warming God: must it now be appeased?


FOR years, I have been concerned that a major hurricane strike on New Orleans New Orleans (ôr`lēənz –lənz, ôrlēnz`), city (2006 pop. 187,525), coextensive with Orleans parish, SE La., between the Mississippi River and Lake Pontchartrain, 107 mi (172 km) by water from the river mouth; founded  could provoke legislation on global warming global warming, the gradual increase of the temperature of the earth's lower atmosphere as a result of the increase in greenhouse gases since the Industrial Revolution.  that will do absolutely nothing about tropical cyclones This is a list of notable tropical cyclones, subdivided by basin and reason for notability. North Atlantic basin
Main article: List of notable Atlantic hurricanes
Main article: List of retired Atlantic hurricanes
, but harm the U.S. economy for decades. We began seeing the shape of things to come when Robert F. Kennedy Jr. claimed that Katrina's severity was related to President Bush's reluctance to cap carbon-dioxide emissions, and Hillary Clinton declared she wanted to establish a commission to investigate the government's response to the hurricane.

Hurricane Katrina's magnitude was not changed by global warming. In fact, despite a hundred news stories to the contrary, it's not at all clear that any such warming will result in more frequent, let alone more intense, tropical cyclones. Take, for example, the recent rise in hurricane frequency in the Atlantic Basin; it's as if we have returned to the 1930s, '50s, and '60s, when storm activity reached a ferocious fe·ro·cious  
adj.
1. Extremely savage; fierce. See Synonyms at cruel.

2. Marked by unrelenting intensity; extreme: ferocious heat.
 height before settling down for several decades.

Keep in mind, however, that there are some differences between now and then. Today's hurricanes tend to concentrate in Florida and the Gulf of Mexico Noun 1. Gulf of Mexico - an arm of the Atlantic to the south of the United States and to the east of Mexico
Golfo de Mexico

Atlantic, Atlantic Ocean - the 2nd largest ocean; separates North and South America on the west from Europe and Africa on the east
, whereas in mid-century they repeatedly struck the Atlantic coast--all the way to Canada. This is worth noting because, in a warming world, simple reasoning predicts that activity should have moved north, not south. Obviously things are not so simple with hurricanes and climate change.

But the North Atlantic is just one of the world's many hurricane basins. In general, there are more tropical cyclones per year in the eastern North Pacific--off the Mexican coast--but few notice them because they rarely hit land as consequential con·se·quen·tial  
adj.
1. Following as an effect, result, or conclusion; consequent.

2. Having important consequences; significant:
 cyclones. Instead, they peter out as they migrate westward into cooler waters. In fact, only one subtropical sub·trop·i·cal  
adj.
Of, relating to, or being the geographic areas adjacent to the Tropics.


subtropical
Adjective

of the region lying between the tropics and temperate lands

 ocean, the South Atlantic, has virtually none of these storms.

So, rather than focusing exclusively on what's happening in our provincial part of the North Atlantic, we should be asking what is happening to hurricane activity around the planet. And the answer is ... nothing. More specifically, there has been no significant movement in either frequency or strength despite a warming trend since 1975, a cooling trend in mid-century, and a warming trend in the early 1900s that was similar to what we see today.

Yes, there is a much-cited paper in the scientific magazine Nature by Kerry Emanuel Kerry Emanuel is an American professor of meteorology currently working at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Boston. His work in atmospheric dynamics is well regarded among the meteorological community.  that claims that hurricanes have doubled in power in the last 30 years. But there are at least tour manuscripts in review at Nature that challenge this result. Indeed, people who normally stay out of the global-warming catfight cat·fight  
n.
1. A fight between or among cats.

2. Informal A vociferous dispute: a catfight between farmers and the government over subsidies. 
, like the University of Colorado's Roger Pielke Roger Pielke can refer to:
  • Roger A. Pielke - meteorologist
  • Roger A. Pielke (Jr) - his son
 Jr., have been blogging that the peer-review process at Science--Nature's American competitor--has been badly compromised on the subject of global warming and weather-induced damages.

The Emanuel argument simply does not stand up to scrutiny. Put it this way: Since Atlantic hurricanes Atlantic hurricane refers to a tropical cyclone that forms in the Atlantic Ocean usually in the Northern Hemisphere summer or autumn, with one-minute maximum sustained winds of 74 mph (64 knots, 33 m/s, 119 km/h).  have a roughly equal chance of striking the U.S., and if they had doubled in power, then surely the amount of damage they have caused--after adjusting for population and property-value changes--would show an obvious upward trend. But, when allowing for these factors, as Pielke has, we cannot detect any such tendency. In any case, if hurricanes had actually doubled in power, then the insurance companies would already have been blown to smithereens smith·er·eens  
pl.n. Informal
Fragments or splintered pieces; bits: The fragile dish broke into smithereens.
. They're still here.

Another paper, by Peter Webster Peter Webster is an English artist and sculptor, best known for his sculpture of the British athlete Steve Ovett, which was exhibited in Preston Park, Brighton. Webster also created the statue of Max Miller, the English comedian, currently on display in the grounds of the Royal  and colleagues, that argues along similar lines has just appeared in Science magazine. It attempts to show that while the global frequency of tropical systems shows no trend since the 1970s, the percentage of extremely strong hurricanes has been increasing relative to the weaker storm systems. This is an example of very selective data citation using post-1970 satellite observations of tropical systems. However, in the North Atlantic, hurricane-hunter reconnaissance flights have been flying since 1944. Guess what? Between 1944 and 1970, the percentage of extremely strong hurricanes declined relative to the weaker storms. Relative storm strength in the '40s and '50s is similar to what it is today. So, over the longer term, there has been no trend in hurricane intensity. How could Science's peer reviewers have missed this?

What of research published a year ago by Tom Knutson, which showed that hurricane winds will increase by 6 percent over the next 80 years as a result of planetary warming? Hurricane frequency varies tremendously from year to year and between decades, so such a small change couldn't be discerned for at least 50 years. Moreover, Knutson's work assumes that ocean-surface temperatures will continue to warm while nothing else changes. But this isn't realistic, for warming may increase the frequency of El Nino--poison to Atlantic hurricanes. Warming may also have an impact on the high-pressure systems that generate the trade winds, thereby placing hurricanes in less favorable environments, and consequently making them less able to inflict major damage.

Clearly, a lot of things can be overlooked in a computer simulation. For example, in the Knutson paper, over half of the simulated behavior of hurricanes is related to the warming of the sea surface. This is an eminently testable hypothesis, as we have a century's worth of data on Atlantic hurricanes and water temperature. When the statistical correspondence between the two is checked, just 10 percent of inter-annual hurricane behavior can be traced to temperature changes. That's right, 90 percent of hurricane fluctuation from year to year is related to factors other than ocean temperature.

How could this be? Let's define a perfect hurricane, like Katrina, as one whose surface barometric ba·rom·e·ter  
n.
1. An instrument for measuring atmospheric pressure, used especially in weather forecasting.

2. Something that registers or responds to fluctuations; an indicator:
 pressure approaches 26.5 inches. A storm this strong requires rare conditions. Warm water is just one: That's why there have been only four such storms in the Atlantic over the last 100 years. There must also be, for example, an efficient venting mechanism at the top of the storm, at around 40,000 feet, and there can be no dry air intruding in·trude  
v. in·trud·ed, in·trud·ing, in·trudes

v.tr.
1. To put or force in inappropriately, especially without invitation, fitness, or permission:
 into its circulation. In reality, there are often many bands of relatively dry air within a hurricane, owing to owing to
prep.
Because of; on account of: I couldn't attend, owing to illness.

owing to prepdebido a, por causa de 
 the rainstorms feeding into the eye that gather up moisture. When a significant dry band gets near the center, the winds will drop. Katrina was probably ready to undergo one of these wind-reduction cycles, but, unfortunately, New Orleans got in the way.

Yet still we hear that warmer oceans mean that storms will become more ferocious. We shouldn't. One of the peculiarities of hurricane behavior is that there is a threshold, at 28[degrees]C, where storms reach an intensity of Category 3 ("severe"). (In the last 50 years there have been just two such storms over cooler waters.) But once the temperature exceeds 28[degrees]C, there is no relationship between warmer water and intensity. At any temperature above the threshold, each storm has an equal chance of reaching Category 4 or 5.

Every August, the surface temperature of the Gulf of Mexico exceeds that threshold. This year it was very warm south of Louisiana CODE, OF LOUISIANA. In 1822, Peter Derbigny, Edward Livingston, and Moreau Lislet, were selected by the legislature to revise and amend the civil code, and to add to it such laws still in force as were not included therein. : 31 [degrees]C--about as hot as it was in 1997 and 1998. And, given that the Gulf reaches the magic 28 [degrees]C threshold every year, no matter whether the planet is warming or cooling, there is no practicable, economical policy that can ever drive temperatures below this figure.

I don't expect this information to have any effect on policy. I'm just shouting into the hurricane.

Mr. Michaels is senior fellow in environment studies at the Cato Institute "Cato" redirects here. For Cato, see Cato.
The Institute's stated mission is "to broaden the parameters of public policy debate to allow consideration of the traditional American principles of limited government, individual liberty, free markets, and peace" by striving "to achieve
 and professor of environmental sciences at the University of Virginia.
COPYRIGHT 2005 National Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:HURRICANE KATRINA II
Author:Michaels, Patrick J.
Publication:National Review
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Oct 10, 2005
Words:1235
Previous Article:Soft corps: the recent, sad history of the Army Corps of Engineers.(HURRICANE KATRINA)
Next Article:Debating immigration: an analyst defends herself, and her critics rejoin.(PUBLIC POLICY)(Column)
Topics:



Related Articles
As globe warms, hurricanes may speed up.(Brief Article)
"Journalism seems to have recovered its reason for being," was how Washington Post media critic Howard Kurtz began an article celebrating the...
Warming to Rita.(Editorials)(Climate change linked to hurricane intensity)(Editorial)
The wind and the fury: has climate change made hurricanes fiercer, or are such claims hot air?(Cover Story)
What global warming may do to future storms.(OPINION)(Brief Article)
Politics meets science: in November 2005, a gathering in Montreal will try to set the agenda for what happens on the global warming file after the...
Hurricanes and CD jewel cases.(EARTH TALK: Questions & Answers About Our Environment)
From Baffin Island to New Orleans.
Diamond--in the rough after Katrina.(chemical affects)
Be prepared for hurricane hell, says meteorologist.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles