Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,506,802 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

The burger court: McDonald's gets McNasty.


Casual observers of the trial English critic Auberon Waugh Auberon Alexander Waugh (IPA: /ˈɔːbərən ˈwɔː/) (November 17, 1939 – January 16, 2001) was a British author and journalist.  calls "the best free entertainment in London" can be forgiven for thinking that the so-called "McLibel" trial has something to do with Greenpeace, since it is members of a group called London Greenpeace who are in the dock. But in this British version of the O.J. case -- the longest-running libel trial in English history -- the defendants are simply admirers of Greenpeace's form of direct action. They knew the name carried weight and decided to appropriate it for themselves. Greenpeace, which is sympathetic to the cause, looks on in amused tolerance.

In 1989, a pair of "unwaged unwaged
Adjective

(of a person) not having a paid job
" dissidents named Dave Morris Dave Morris (born in 1957) is a British gamebook author of the 1980s and 1990s. He is most famous for the Fabled Lands series, but also wrote the Virtual Reality, Blood Sword, Dragon Warriors and Golden Dragon series, as well as penning a single Fighting Fantasy gamebook (The Keep  and Helen Steel stood on a London street handing out a six-page "London Greenpeace" leaflet called "What's Wrong With McDonald's." It accused the American McDonald's corporation (which has 580 outlets on English shores) of abusing its workers, producing unhealthy food unhealthy food Any food that is not regarded as being conducive to maintaining health; UFs include fats, in particular of animal origin, 'fast' foods–low in fiber and vitamins; 'junk food'–eg, potato and corn chips, pretzels, crackers–high in salt  and destroying "vast areas of Central American Central America

A region of southern North America extending from the southern border of Mexico to the northern border of Colombia. It separates the Caribbean Sea from the Pacific Ocean and is linked to South America by the Isthmus of Panama.
 rainforest" to raise its beef. The leaflet wasn't unusual -- many other activist groups have passed out similar ones. But this time, McDonald's wasn't taking the abuse lightly; it sued for libel, in a country where ifs significantly easier to prove in court that one's good name has been unfairly maligned ma·lign  
tr.v. ma·ligned, ma·lign·ing, ma·ligns
To make evil, harmful, and often untrue statements about; speak evil of.

adj.
1. Evil in disposition, nature, or intent.

2.
. Steel and Morris are now known as the "McLibel Two."

The trial has taken so long because, in England, libel defendants have to prove that what they said (or, in this case, handed out) was actually true. And that means a steady stream of expert defense witnesses in an effort to prove that McDonald's is, in fact, a corporate scourge.

All this testimony has produced some fascinating revelations. The owner of a key McDonald's supplier, for instance, reportedly testified that his company supplied Brazilian beef for the British market after a McDonald's edict A decree or law of major import promulgated by a king, queen, or other sovereign of a government.

An edict can be distinguished from a public proclamation in that an edict puts a new statute into effect whereas a public proclamation is no more than a declaration of a law
 banning such sales. (According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 a letter from a British McDonald's supplier, the internal order followed a complaint to McDonald's by Prince Phillip, who doubles as president of the World Wildlife Fund, that McDonald's was "tearing down the Brazilian rainforests and breeding cattle.")

There was a most enlightening exchange involving the McDonald's claim, cited in its widely available "Nutrition Guide," that "every time you eat at McDonald's you'll eat good nutritious food." According to McDonald's executives who testified in London, "nutritious" simply means that the food people ate "contained nutrients" -- as does all food everywhere.

McDonald's own cancer expert, Dr. Sidney Arnott, testified that a statement in the offending leaflet claiming that "a diet high in fat, sugar, animal products and salt and low in fiber, vitamins and minerals is linked with cancer..." was "a very reasonable thing to say" to the public. This testimony reportedly led McDonald's to amend its original complaint -- the company is now asking the defendants to prove that "McDonald's sells meals which cause cancer in their customers."

The defendants also dug out a priceless statement from Geoff Giuliano, the actor who was the original Ronald McDonald: "I brainwashed brain·wash  
tr.v. brain·washed, brain·wash·ing, brain·wash·es
To subject to brainwashing.

n.
The process or an instance of brainwashing.
 youngsters into doing wrong. I want to say sorry to children everywhere for selling out to concerns who make millions by murdering animals."

In May, at the McDonald's stockholders' meeting Chicago, CEO (1) (Chief Executive Officer) The highest individual in command of an organization. Typically the president of the company, the CEO reports to the Chairman of the Board.  Michael Quinlan was grilled about the case and urged to bring it to a speedy conclusion. "Rumors are flying "Rumors Are Flying" is a popular song.

It was written by Bennie Benjamin and George David Weiss and published in 1946.

It was popularized in 1946 by Frankie Carle and by Les Paul.
 that McDonald's is planning to withdraw its case against the defendants," says the U.S. McLibel Support Campaign. Could that be true? At McDonald's corporate headquarters in Chicago, they're maintaining a very low profile on the whole business, referring all calls to Mike Love in the London office. Efforts to reach Love were unavailing, but he told the London Independent that the company is "not seeking a way out of the case. We're confident of the strength of our case..."

The defendants are reportedly ready to settle for a charity donation and a simple statement that McDonald's won't pursue such libel actions against anyone else in Britain.

Contact: The U.S. McLibel Support Committee, P.O. Box 62, Craftsbury, VT 05826-0062/(802)586-9628. E-mail: dbriars@world-std.com.
COPYRIGHT 1995 Earth Action Network, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1995, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:McDonald's Corp. libel suit in Britain
Author:Motavalli, Jim
Publication:E
Date:Nov 1, 1995
Words:671
Previous Article:Going for the jugular. (Greenpeace critics)
Next Article:Paul Watson: the ocean's enforcer. (environmental activist)
Topics:



Related Articles
Brokers allege companies conspired to eliminate fees; cases focus on supposed striking of secret side deals. (real estate brokers) (Real Estate)
Dozen new restaurant outlets headed for downtown L.A. (Los Angeles, California)
Psychoanalyst loses long-running libel suit against 'New Yorker' writer. (Jeffrey Masson's suit against Janet Malcolm) (Brief Article)
Toward "hired gun" control. (libel and defamation suits)(Column)
Headlines alone may constitute libel, Ninth Circuit says.
TRUTH, TERROR, AND DAVID TRIMBLE.(What the Brits can teach Americans about libel law)
Back to Golden Oldies.(McDonald's restaurant in Manhattan Beach, California, returns to imitate original design)(Brief Article)
Litigious eaters make mockery of legal system. (Commentary).(suing fast food chains)(Brief Article)
Burgers, fries & small claims: franchisee hampered by a flood of suits from litigious diners.(Up Front)(Burger kING)
Court may widen SLAPP protection.(Up Front)(Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles