Printer Friendly
The Free Library
4,550,337 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

The Wings of the Dove.


I HAVE always had problems with Henry James. Good Henry James strikes me as inferior Marcel Proust, and bad Henry James as not worth pursuing down its labyrinthine lab·y·rin·thine
adj.
Of, relating to, resembling, or constituting a labyrinth.



labyrinthine

pertaining to or emanating from a labyrinth.
 ways. But our concern here is with James on film. There the high points were the rather free adaptation of Washington Square as The Heiress (1949) and the no less free version of The Turn of the Screw as The Innocents (1961). The several others are not worth mentioning, least of all Jane Campion's odious Portrait of a Lady, whose opening sequence alone is enough to turn a Jacobite into a Jacobin. The current remake of Washington Square, as reviewed here (Nov. 10), does not wash either.

Now, however, comes The Wings of the Dove, which, for the aforementioned reasons, I have been unable to read, but which, on screen, proves a rare delight. James readers inform me of oversimplifications, omissions, and crude additions; still, even they concede that Iain Softley's film, with a screenplay by Hossein Amini, is a notable achievement. To be sure, anyone can find some flaws here; how, for instance, does the impecunious im·pe·cu·ni·ous  
adj.
Lacking money; penniless. See Synonyms at poor.



[in-1 + pecunious, rich (from Middle English, from Old French pecunios, from Latin
 journalist Merton Densher manage to leave London and his job for a protracted pro·tract  
tr.v. pro·tract·ed, pro·tract·ing, pro·tracts
1. To draw out or lengthen in time; prolong: disputants who needlessly protracted the negotiations.

2.
, nonworking stay in Venice? Some changes result from the filmmakers' updating the action by a decade, but those strike me as altogether to the good.

So, in the film's dazzling opening sequences a young man sees a young woman on the crowded London Underground, approaches her, and seems to start a flirtation with her. It is unclear whether they know each other or not. Soon they are descending in a lift into which the fellow has followed the seemingly fleeing girl. On the way down, she remains aloof; in the next shot, on the way up, the two are in a passionate clinch. Thus retold re·told  
v.
Past tense and past participle of retell.
, this may not sound like much, but against the background of a quaint-looking subway, with two apparently proper Victorians behaving so turbulently, and with consecutive sequences in rapidly switching directions, a teasing suspense is created, complete with elevator-like frissons running up and down one's spine.

The lady in question is Kate Croy, being brought up by her affluent and calculating Aunt Maude (Charlotte Rampling, and excellent) to be a prosperous society lady, unlike her sorry wretch of a widowed father. The young man is Merton Densher, with whom Kate is having it on. They would marry, but the girl is mercenary enough to be seduced by her aunt's ultimatum to give up the penniless Densher and marry upward.

Besides the subway, there is the telephone, exuding its non-Jamesian but fascinating novelty -- a sense of intrigue, whose predestined pre·des·tine  
tr.v. pre·des·tined, pre·des·tin·ing, pre·des·tines
1. To fix upon, decide, or decree in advance; foreordain.

2. Theology To foreordain or elect by divine will or decree.
 tool it is. So, too, the new prevalence of electricity, promising a more conquerable world, and the revolutionized women's fashions, less confining and more enticing, adding to the sense of freedom and modernity. Sandy Powell, the costume designer, has wisely followed the period designs of the great Mariano Fortuny.

There arrives in London a young American heiress, Millie Theale, pretty and loaded. She and Kate become friends and, before you know it, the two of them and Merton are frolicking around Venice together. Having found out that Millie is mortally ill, Kate goes back to London, to let Millie have at least one love affair in her life -- with Merton. Then she would leave her money to him, and he and Kate could wed wealthily. Needless to say, things don't quite work out like that, although the movie does leave the ending a trifle fuzzy.

What is wonderful here is the contrast between London and Venice and their lifestyles. The film manages to make the two of them vividly, differently real. Especially remarkable is the Venice that Softley and his cinematographer, Eduardo Serra, have conjured up. Although some of the locales are the obvious ones, they are shot in unusual weather or at atypical times of day or night. The result is not a burstingly sunny Venice, as in David Lean's lush Summertime, but an ordinary, everyday city with sullen moods, rowdy goings-on, disquieting dis·qui·et  
tr.v. dis·qui·et·ed, dis·qui·et·ing, dis·qui·ets
To deprive of peace or rest; trouble.

n.
Absence of peace or rest; anxiety.

adj. Archaic
Uneasy; restless.
 crannies. Nevertheless, a Venice whose essence intoxicates.

It is nice that, for the interiors of Millie's rented abode One's home; habitation; place of dwelling; or residence. Ordinarily means "domicile." Living place impermanent in character. The place where a person dwells. Residence of a legal voter. Fixed place of residence for the time being. , the filmmakers could secure the very Palazzo Leporelli (a/k/a Barbaro) where James spent many months. More important, they show us less trodden trod·den  
v.
A past participle of tread.


trodden
Verb

a past participle of tread
 byways, as well as some phantasmagoric phan·tas·ma·go·ri·a   also phan·tas·ma·go·ry
n. pl. phan·tas·ma·go·ri·as also phan·tas·ma·go·ries
1.
a. A fantastic sequence of haphazardly associative imagery, as seen in dreams or fever.

b.
 revels, with a casual candor that lets the poetic jut out, almost unbidden un·bid·den   also un·bid
adj.
Not invited, asked, or requested; unasked: unbidden guests; comments unbid and unwelcome.
, from the quotidian quotidian /quo·tid·i·an/ (kwo-tid´e-an) recurring every day; see malaria.

quo·tid·i·an
adj.
Recurring daily. Used especially of attacks of malaria.
. Against this setting, the curious trio of principals stands out vulnerable, confused, adrift. It is superlatively enacted by Helena Bonham Carter Helena Bonham Carter (born May 26, 1966) is an Academy Award-nominated English actress, known for her roles in the films A Room with a View, Howards End, and Fight Club.  (Kate) and Linus Roache (Merton), and somewhat less well by Alison Elliott (Millie). Miss Elliott, so good in The Spitfire Grill, is here a little too bland, unable to convey the doom that Millie carries within. Elizabeth McGovern does little for her friend Susan; but Alex Jennings gets the most out of the fortune-hunting Lord Mark, and Michael Gambon, good always (and only) in repellent roles, scores as Kate's father.

The amazing thing is that Iain Softley, known hitherto chiefly for his adroit film about the early days of the Beatles, Backbeat, should have tackled Wings of the Dove at all, and then come up a winner. His scenarist sce·nar·ist  
n.
One who writes screenplays.


scenarist
the writer of scenarios, story lines for motion pictures.
See also: Films

Noun 1.
, Hossein Amini (who also did well by Thomas Hardy on the underrated Jude), deserves equal credit. What the film lacks is the convolutions and impotence that characterize Henry James, which suits me fine. I only wish there were not so much of Ed Shearmur's music on the soundtrack: a few measures less would have helped immeasurably.

Uncomprehending reviews may have harmed Beaumarchais, Edouard Molino's charming film about the adventures of the creator of Figaro, which he co-wrote with Jean-Claude Brisville, leaning on an unfinished manuscript by the great Sacha Guitry. I have no idea exactly who contributed what, or how much of it is factual (a good deal is) and how much invented, but I assure you this is a thinking man's swashbuckler, a funlover's history lesson, and everybody's civilized entertainment.

Pierre-Augustin Caron de Beaumarchais (1732 - 99) started out as a watchmaker and eventually became music-master to Louis XV's children. He married into wealth but, widowed, lost the fortune; made money again through various speculations, and landed in jail several times. The movie follows him through amorous escapades, his famous lawsuits, and his career in the secret service. He supported the Americans in their war of liberation
For the Napoleonic "War of Liberation", see War of the Sixth Coalition.
A War of liberation is a conflict which is primarily intended to bring freedom or independence to a nation or group.
 out of his own pocket, and was a friend to Ben Franklin (whom the movie portrays too grossly); he also fought for the financial rights of authors, published a definitive edition of Voltaire's works (on which, as on the Americans, he lost money), and just barely managed to survive the Terror, even though his brevet BREVET. In France, a brevet is a warrant granted by the government to authorize an individual to do something for his own benefit, as a brevet d'invention, is a patent to secure a man a right as inventor.
     2.
 of nobility was purchased, and the very name "Beaumarchais" was a fabrication fabrication (fab´rikā´shn),
n the construction or making of a restoration.
.

Not all of this is in the movie, but many things are: the love life, the intrigues, and the play-writing Beaumarchais practiced in his spare time, The Barber of Seville and Figaro's Marriage proving masterpieces. What is outstanding is the light, trenchantly witty, literate dialogue, much of it, alas, lost in the subtitles. The gifted Fabrice Luchini would be an even finer Beaumarchais if he could curb that quizzical quiz·zi·cal  
adj.
1. Suggesting puzzlement; questioning.

2. Teasing; mocking: "His face wore a somewhat quizzical almost impertinent air" Lawrence Durrell.
 smirk of his, and it would help if Sandrine Kiberlain, the leading lady, were more attractive.

But Michel Serrault, in the cameo role of Louis XV, is nothing short of sublime, and any number of famous or less-well-known others are not far behind. Especially fascinating is Claire Nebout as the Chevalier d'Eon, an adventurer who may well have been an adventuress ad·ven·tur·ess  
n.
A woman who seeks social and financial advancement by unscrupulous means. See Usage Note at -ess.

Noun 1. adventuress - a woman adventurer
adventurer, venturer - a person who enjoys taking risks
. Most engaging, too, is Manuel Blanc, as the hero's friend and factotum fac·to·tum  
n.
An employee or assistant who serves in a wide range of capacities.



[Medieval Latin fact
. What matters about Beaumarchais is the wit, the intelligence, the imagination suffusing every frame; of how many movies today can you affirm that?
COPYRIGHT 1997 National Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1997, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Simon, John
Publication:National Review
Article Type:Movie Review
Date:Dec 8, 1997
Words:1297
Previous Article:Beyond All Reason: The Radical Assault on Truth in American Law.
Next Article:Beaumarchais.
Topics:



Related Articles
Batman Returns.
Henry James made carnal: 'Wings of the Dove.' (film review of the Henry James novel)
Second annual gay guide to the Oscars.
Mommy's busy.(films and other topics; humor)(Column)(Brief Article)
'K-PAX': PSYCHODRAMA IS MORE THAN A LITTLE SPACEY.(L.A. Life)(Review)
OSCARS '98/THE NOMINEES.(L.A. LIFE)
`MRS. DALLOWAY' MAKES LUKEWARM CONNECTIONS ALONG THE WAY.(L.A. LIFE)
PERFORMANCES SOAR IN `DOVE'.(L.A. LIFE)
Henry James: Novels 1901-1902.(Henry James: Novels 1901-1902; The Sacred Fount; The Wings of the Dove )(Brief article)(Book review)
Henry James Novels 1901-1902.(Brief article)(Book review)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2008 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles