Printer Friendly
The Free Library
22,719,120 articles and books

The Newport Sex Scandal, 1919-21. (Essay).

THE STORY of persecution is as old as civilization itself. In colonial times, Quakers, Catholics, and witches were attacked and executed for beliefs contrary to Protestantism. Native Americans were pushed westward as America rapidly expanded during the 1800's; African Americans were bought and sold throughout the history of the slave trade slave trade

Capturing, selling, and buying of slaves. Slavery has existed throughout the world from ancient times, and trading in slaves has been equally universal. Slaves were taken from the Slavs and Iranians from antiquity to the 19th century, from the sub-Saharan
; and Jews were massacred in the Holocaust. Still today men and women with contrary beliefs, varying religious precepts and unpopular social activities are rooted out or isolated by their detractors. In Newport, Rhode Island Newport is a city in Newport County, Rhode Island, United States, about 30 miles (48 km) south of Providence. It is the home of Naval Station Newport, housing the United States Naval War College, the Naval Undersea Warfare Center, and a major United States Navy training center. , lies the history of the widespread persecution of gay men because of their personal sexual preference.

The history of the entrapment entrapment, in law, the instigation of a crime in the attempt to obtain cause for a criminal prosecution. Situations in which a government operative merely provides the occasion for the commission of a criminal act (e.g.  and persecution of homosexuals in Newport by the United States government warrants a discussion about the larger forgotten history of what is known as the Newport Sex Scandal The Newport Sex Scandal involved allegations in 1919 of "immoral conduct" (specifically, homosexuality) at the United States Navy base in Newport, Rhode Island, USA. Bibliography
John Loughery, The Other Side of Silence (____)
. Not only is this history important because of the injustices that were done, but also because these actions were the work of prominent leaders, among them Franklin D. Roosevelt. Fearing that sailors were being "corrupted" by local gay men, the Navy developed a program using sailors to entrap these men in sexual liaisons, whereupon they would be tried in a civil court of law.

Victims of the government's campaign against moral vice were humiliated by the largely circumstantial evidence circumstantial evidence

In law, evidence that is drawn not from direct observation of a fact at issue but from events or circumstances that surround it. If a witness arrives at a crime scene seconds after hearing a gunshot to find someone standing over a corpse and holding a
 that was educed against a number of suspects in courts of law. Those who were caught by the scandal gained notoriety, while many others watched their reputations plummet. According to Lawrence R. Murphy in Perverts by Official Order: The Campaign Against Homosexuals by the United States Navy United States Navy

Major branch of the U.S. military forces, charged with defending the nation at sea and maintaining security on the seas wherever U.S. interests extend. The Continental Navy was established by the Continental Congress in 1775.
 (1988), the duties of each man involved in the operation to uncover vices in Newport included gathering evidence about drug and alcohol abuse, obtaining information pertaining to "cocksuckers and rectum receivers and the ring leaders of this gang, arranging from time to time meetings whereas to catch them in the act," and searching for women who were pursuing the same risky business.

In the documents distributed by the lead investigators, Dr. Erastus M. Hudson and Ervin Arnold, a fourteen-year Navy veteran, was a paragraph giving advice that stated: "Men attached to and serving on this staff, must keep their eyes wide open This article contains links, text or other information that has been inserted due to a business arrangement by the Wikimedia Foundation rather than the usual Wikipedia editing process. It may or may not comply with all of Wikipedia's normal editorial standards. , observing everything and ears open for all conversation and make himself free with this class of men, being jolly and good natured, being careful as he pumps these men for information, making him believe that he is what is termed in the Navy as a 'boy humper,' making dates with them and so forth. Be careful not to arouse suspicion." Moreover, men who might tell their families of their work would be convicted of perjury if others from outside the investigation learned of their secrecy and methods of investigation.

Furthermore, when publicity about the navy's anti-gay crusade threatened the careers of senior officials like Assistant Secretary of the Navy Franklin D. Roosevelt, the government manipulated the military justice system to spare these individuals while undermining their critics, such as John R. Rathom, publisher of The Providence Journal. Many who were affected by this scandal were eventually lost track of. For instance, Jay Goldstein, who invited an operator by the name of William Crawford to his Golden Hill Street room, later expressed fears of men who were spying at the YMCA YMCA
 in full Young Men's Christian Association

Nonsectarian, nonpolitical Christian lay movement that aims to develop high standards of Christian character among its members.
, but quickly disappears from the chronicles of this witch hunt. What became of him is anybody's guess.

The most prominent man to be snared by the Navy's net was a Newport cleric and Navy chaplain, Rev. Samuel Neal Kent, who was also the head of the Newport sailors' welfare organization. The entrapment of Kent is illustrative of how the investigation proceeded. Once Kent had come under suspicion-it seems people questioned his friendship with one Arthur Green-he was invited for a drink by an investigator named Charles Zipf. After a night out they reportedly returned to the chaplain's quarters at the Emmanuel Church parish house, and Kent took Zipf to his room. Wrote Zipf in his report: "Kent threw his arms around me, and kissed me about the face. Repeatedly he tried to put his tongue in my mouth. His hand strayed and he felt of my penis. ... Kent made me promise not to say anything to the gang down at the YMCA." And Zipf acquiesced. Charged with engaging in homosexual activities, Kent denied the allegation and accused the Navy of using immoral methods to obtain evidence. Kent was ultimately acquitted in two sepa rate trials.

Men who were accused of homosexual activities were often followed or watched, and were ultimately slandered by vice investigators. Writes Murphy: "Never was adequate punishment meted out to those who perpetrated the campaign. To this day the stain of court-martial, a prison record, and dishonorable dis·hon·or·a·ble  
1. Characterized by or causing dishonor or discredit.

2. Lacking integrity; unprincipled.

 discharges remains on the records of the victims of government persecution." For instance, a number of regular attendees at the YMCA, including Albert Veihi, had been found guilty of sodomy sodomy

Noncoital carnal copulation. Sodomy is a crime in some jurisdictions. Some sodomy laws, particularly in Middle Eastern countries and those jurisdictions observing Shari'ah law, provide penalties as severe as life imprisonment for homosexual intercourse, even if the
 and lewd acts. Veihi's conviction, three counts of sodomy and one of oral coition coition

, was reduced from twenty years TWENTY YEARS. The lapse of twenty years raises a presumption of certain facts, and after such a time, the party against whom the presumption has been raised, will be required to prove a negative to establish his rights.
 to seven, and later a Christmas clemency Leniency or mercy. A power given to a public official, such as a governor or the president, to in some way lower or moderate the harshness of punishment imposed upon a prisoner.

Clemency is considered to be an act of grace.
 reduced his sentence to five years, three months. Others, like Thomas R. Brunelle and Jeremiah Fowler, were never brought to trial.

While drag shows were commonplace in the coastal town of Newport, the issue of homosexuality and the Navy was unresolved at this time. By May 1919, Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer refused Roosevelt's request to have the Justice Department begin a thorough investigation of Newport's Naval Training Station and the YMCA. Attorney General A. Mitchell Palmer was more concerned with his anti-Communist crusade than sexual perversion in Newport, Rhode Island. To overcome this resistance, Assistant Secretary of the Navy Franklin D. Roosevelt ordered a secret, undercover investigation to uproot the conditions of vice and depravity that he suspected in Newport. The secret investigations, their funding sources, and their personnel were concealed in an undercover Navy department entitled Section A, Office of the Assistant Secretary of the Navy.

Directly after the inception of this commission, FDR met with Erastus Hudson and Ervin Arnold to define the mission and work out the logistics of this operation. After that, FDR's confidential orders were signed into effect. The modus operandi [Latin, Method of working.] A term used by law enforcement authorities to describe the particular manner in which a crime is committed.

The term modus operandi is most commonly used in criminal cases. It is sometimes referred to by its initials, M.O.
 of the sting was simple enough, as described by the Committee on Naval Affairs Committee on Naval Affairs may refer to:
  • United States House Committee on Naval Affairs
  • United States Senate Committee on Naval Affairs
 in its Report, Alleged Immoral Conditions at Newport (R.I.) Naval Training Station, issued by Senators Lewis H. Ball and Henry W. Keyes Henry Wilder Keyes (May 23, 1863–June 19, 1938) was an American farmer, banker, and Republican politician from Haverhill, New Hampshire. Born in 1863 in Newbury, Vermont, he served in both houses of the New Hampshire state legislature before being elected Governor in 1916, , of the 67th Congress: "[P]articularly ar·tic·u·lar  
Of or relating to a joint or joints: the articular surfaces of bones.

[Middle English articuler, from Latin
 between the dates of May 5 and July 20, 1919, the enlisted men who acted as operators or detectives were instructed by both Hudson and Arnold to go forth into Newport and to allow immoral acts to be perfonned upon them, if in their judgment it was necessary for the purpose of running down and trapping or capturing certain specified alleged sexual perverts." Thus the Navy was dealing with issues of moral vice, including rampant drug use, prostitution, and bribery by the local police and mayor. Actually, the Department of the Navy had been receiving reports of rampant vice since World War I began. But two major inquiries-and the ones that came to the (rather overblown) attention of the media-occurred in 1919 and early in 1920.

The Foster Court of Inquiry held hearings under the leadership of Judge Advocate A legal adviser on the staff of a military command. A designated officer of the Judge Advocate General's Corps (JAGC) of the U.S. Army, Navy, Air Force, or Marine Corps.  William H. Drury in April and May 1919. The Foster Court of Inquiry convened on March 19, 1919, and announced its findings into the examination of evidence dealing with the Newport Sex Scandal on May 1, 1919. The court's questions dealt with drug use and civilian immorality, and the court brought forth a number of recommendations geared at resolving these problems. The court looked into the YMCA and decided that "unmarried enlisted men should be prohibited from renting rooms in Newport, with enforcement responsibilities assigned to the Training Station morale officer." The court added: "A more thorough investigation should be instituted under broader authority than pertains to the Commander to minimize the use of drugs and immorality among Naval personnel and civilians and others in the First Naval District."

The Dunn Board of Inquiry convened in Newport in the third week of January 1920. The Court had been assigned "to investigate the government's pursuit of homosexuals and alleviate growing public concern about the Rhode Island Rhode Island, island, United States
Rhode Island, island, 15 mi (24 km) long and 5 mi (8 km) wide, S R.I., at the entrance to Narragansett Bay. It is the largest island in the state, with steep cliffs and excellent beaches.
 Sex Scandal." Secretary of Navy Josephus Daniels called the court into existence after a letter of complaint was issued to the President of the U.S. by the Newport Minister's Union. According to Murphy, "the system of military justice was skillfully manipulated to protect military officers and enlisted men while placing civilians who questioned the government's conduct in awkward, defensive positions." Secretary Daniels endorsed the findings of the Dunn Court of Inquiry on March 3, 1921, the day before the Wilson Administration left office. Daniels wrote Roosevelt that "I have been sweating blood over the Newport case. It was not easy in all its phases. I believe the conclusion reached is just to all concerned."

The rediscovery of this history, including the accounts known as "The 'Ladies' of Newport" and "The Newport Sex Scandal, 1919-1921," calls for a new examination of FDR's efforts to permit unorthodox tactics to entrap persons engaged in activities defined as immoral. While his role remains unclear, he did sign the orders enabling a team of investigators to go to the limit in their efforts to clean up Newport. What we know is that Dr. Erastus M. Hudson and Ervin Arnold's team of sailors-turned-investigators were deployed to seduce and take out on dates the "Ladies" of Newport. It is interesting to note that Herbert O. Dunn "commended Hudson for conferring from time to time with Navy Department officials but criticized his extremely bad judgment in not making certain that senior officials were fully cogmzant of the details of the methods which were being employed by the organization under his command." Writes Lawrence R. Murphy (1984): "the use of immoral methods by his men was in direct contravention of the tra ditions of the Naval service. Arnold has used enlisted men ... to obtain evidence in the investigation of perversion which was contrary and repugnant to the traditions of the service." FDR had employed two civilians, created special naval offices for them, and allowed them to investigate vice in Newport without detailing the methods to be used.

For all the criticism of these methods, Secretary of Navy Josephus Daniels and FDR continued to attack the vice associated with military centers, especially the Newport Naval Station, which served the Atlantic Fleet. It was with the support of Congressional Republicans and Admiral William S. Sims--who was somewhat ambivalent in his dealings with Secretary Daniels and FDR--that the U.S. Senate Committee on Naval Affairs pursued the investigation that came to be known as the Newport Sex Scandal. FDR, who had previously appeared defiantly before the Dunn Board, was attacked for signing the order to create Section A.

THE NAVY'S self-styled crusade to protect young men from evil influences was based on its ostensibly lofty mission to "encourage enlistment in the Navy on the grounds that the average boy would leave the service better fitted in education, physical condition and have a very high personal morality and high standard of morality and honor." The Newport Sex Scandal represented the military's first foray into the persecution of homosexuals and homosexuality, and was quite possibly the first instance of homosexuals being singled out as a category for legal prosecution. The Navy's desire to protect enlisted servicemen from bodily "contamination" was present as early as 1917 in the writings of Secretary Daniels: "There lies upon us morally, to a degree far out reaching any technical responsibility, the duty of leaving nothing undone to protect these young men from the contamination of their bodies, which will not only impair their military efficiency, but blast their lives for the future and return them to their home s a source of danger to their families and to the community at large." It was this impulse to "purge" the body that led to the program of gay male persecution that followed a few years later.

In the end, few remembered Newport's gay community in the years from 1919 to 1921. But the scandal provides a glimpse into the first fledgling effort to identify and purge gay people from the U.S. military. The confused awkwardness of the attempt, the arbitrary way in which people were singled out, and the sleazy injustice with which these efforts were executed--through secrecy, entrapment, coerced confessions--provide an early instance of the vast witch hunt that the U.S. military would later undertake against its gay members. That policy would reach its full expression only after the Second World War, yet it is the policy that remains in force, in effect, down to the present day.


Bishop Perry Papers, University of Rhode Island History
The University was first chartered as the state's agricultural school in 1888. The site of the school was originally the Oliver Watson Farm, and the original farmhouse still lies on the campus today.
 Library's Special Collections, Subject Series, Group 29, Series VII, Box 9, Folders 331-336.

Cronon, E. David. The cabinet Diaries of Josephus Daniels: 1913-1921. Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 1963.

Katz, Jonathan. Government Versus Homosexuals. Ayer Company Publishers, 1975.

Murphy, Lawrence R. Perverts by Official Order: The Campaign Against Homosexuals by the United States Navy. Harrington Park Press, 1988.

Murphy, Lawrence R. "Cleaning up Newport: The U.S. Navy's Persecution of Homosexuals after World War I." Journal of American Culture, Fall, 1984 (v. 7, no. 3).

Benjamin Brenkert is a senior at Marist College in Poughkeepsie, New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
COPYRIGHT 2003 Gay & Lesbian Review, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2003 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:prosecution of gays in the military
Author:Brenkert, Benjamin
Publication:The Gay & Lesbian Review Worldwide
Geographic Code:1U1RI
Date:Mar 1, 2003
Previous Article:A Gay Purge at Harvard, 1920. (Essay).
Next Article:Gertrude Stein took the War like a man. (Essay).

Related Articles
Military disorder.
The third gender in twentieth-century America.
Lesbian baiting in the barracks.
A sham and a shame.
Queering church, churching queers.
Rants & raves.
The map of Asia.
"The importance of objective analysis" on gays in the military: a response to Elaine Donnelly's constructing the co-ed military.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters