The Economic Consequences of Professional Sports Strikes and Lockouts.
Dennis Coates [*]
Brad R. Humphreys [+]
The National Basketball Association National Basketball Association (NBA)
U.S. professional basketball league. It was formed in 1949 by the merger of two rival organizations, the National Basketball League (founded 1937) and the Basketball Association of America (1946). (NBA NBA
1. National Basketball Association
2. National Boxing Association
NBA (US) n abbr (= National Basketball Association) → Basketball-Dachverband (= ) lockout lockout, intentional closing up of a company, factory, or shop by an employer to prevent employees from working during a strike or labor dispute. The term lockout of 1998-1999 resulted in the cancellation of a significant number of games. According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. the claims made by proponents of sports-driven economic growth, cities with NBA franchises should experience significant negative economic losses from this work stoppage stoppage - /sto'p*j/ Extreme lossage that renders something (usually something vital) completely unusable. "The recent system stoppage was caused by a fried transformer." because of the lost spending in and around basketball arenas during this event. Although it will be several years before adequate data exist for a careful ex post evaluation of the effects of the lockout, an examination of the impact of past work stoppages in professional football and basketball can shed some light on the potential impact of the NBA lockout as well as the viability of professional sports The examples and perspective in this article or section may not represent a worldwide view of the subject.
Please [ improve this article] or discuss the issue on the talk page. as engines of economic growth in cities. The parameter (1) Any value passed to a program by the user or by another program in order to customize the program for a particular purpose. A parameter may be anything; for example, a file name, a coordinate, a range of values, a money amount or a code of some kind. estimates from a reduced-form empirical model of the determination of real per capita income Noun 1. per capita income - the total national income divided by the number of people in the nation
income - the financial gain (earned or unearned) accruing over a given period of time in 37 Standard Metropolitan Statistical Areas (SMSAs) over the period 1969-1996 suggest that prior work stoppages in professional football and baseball had no impact on the economies of cities with franchises. Further, the departure of professional basketball from cities had no impact on their economies in the following years. These results refute re·fute
tr.v. re·fut·ed, re·fut·ing, re·futes
1. To prove to be false or erroneous; overthrow by argument or proof: refute testimony.
2. the idea that attracting professional sports franchises represents a viable economic development strategy.
The recent labor difficulties between the players and owners in the National Basketball Association (NBA) resulted in the cancellation of a significant number of games. Such work stoppages present economists with a natural experiment on the effects of professional sports on local economic development. If, as sports-led development advocates argue, professional sports leverage greater economic activity, especially consumer spending Consumer demand or consumption is also known as personal consumption expenditure. It is the largest part of aggregate demand or effective demand at the macroeconomic level. , then the work stoppage must have the opposite effect. Local economies must take a hit because of the absence of play. This paper examines the economic consequences of work stoppages in professional sports leagues This article has no lead section.
To comply with Wikipedia's lead section guidelines, one should be written. on the economies of cities with professional sports franchises.
It will be a year or more before adequate data are available to conduct a careful ex post study of the economic consequences of the NBA lockout. However, the empirical analysis done by Coates and Humphreys (1999) implies two indirect methods for analyzing the effects of work stoppages in professional sports leagues on local economies.
The first method assesses the effects of work stoppages in both professional football and baseball to infer the likely impact of the NBA lockout. The NBA lockout during the 1998-1999 season lasted over 200 days and resulted in 424 games being lost, with 725 being played. As work stoppages in professional sports go, it was typical. For example, Major League Baseball "MLB" and "Major Leagues" redirect here. For other uses, see MLB (disambiguation) and Major Leagues (disambiguation).
Major League Baseball (MLB) is the highest level of play in North American professional baseball. had three significant work stoppages during the period 1969-1996. The least severe baseball strike A strike in baseball could refer to:
National Football League
NFL (US) n abbr (= National Football League) → Fußball-Nationalliga ) had two work stoppages during this period, in 1982 and 1987. The 1982 strike lasted 57 days and reduced the number of games played Games played (most often abbreviated as G or GP) is a statistic used in team sports to indicate the total number of games in which a player has participated (in any capacity); the statistic is generally applied irrespective of whatever portion of the game is contested. from 16 t o 9 per team. The 1987 strike lasted 24 days. The games scheduled for the third week of the season were cancelled, and the games in weeks 4 through 6 were played by replacement players.
None of these work stoppages led to the loss of an entire season. If one treats the 1987 NFL games played with replacement players as cancelled games, then, with the exception of the 1972 baseball strike, the work stoppages in baseball and football are roughly the same duration and about the same magnitude as the NBA lockout. Consequently, if the work stoppages in baseball and football had a measurable effect on local economies, then one might expect that the NBA lockout would affect the economy in cities where these teams play. However, professional basketball may differ from pro football and major league baseball in some fundamental way that would alter its overall impact on a Standard Metropolitan Statistical Area's (SMSA SMSA
standard metropolitan statistical area ) economy. For example, basketball fans may be drawn more from within the SMSA than football or baseball fans. If this is the case, the effects of football or baseball strikes may be poor guides to the effects of a basketball lockout.
The second method exploits NBA franchise moves over the last 30 years. If the local economy were affected by the departure of an NBA franchise in the past, then one might expect that the current work stoppage would affect the local economy in a similar way.
Although strikes have received considerable attention from economists, relatively little is known about the economic impact of professional sports strikes. Zipp (1996) examined the effect of the 1994 baseball strike on a sample of 17 SMSAs; Zipp (1997) extended this analysis to include counties in Florida The links in the column FIPS County Code are to the Census Bureau Info page for that county.
List of 67 counties in the U.S. state of Florida:
State Code State
FL 12 Florida
Index # on Map FIPS County Code County Name
1 001 Alachua County that host spring training games during the spring 1995 portion of this strike. In both cases, no significant impact of this strike on local economies was found. To our knowledge, no investigations of the impact of strikes or lockouts in other professional sports (or other baseball strikes) have been done.
The existing evidence on the effect of professional sports on the local economy can be divided into two distinct groups. One group includes economic impact studies commissioned by teams or other interested parties. These ex ante exercises typically conclude that attracting a new professional sports team or building a new stadium for an existing team will yield large positive gains for a city's economy.  These economic benefits flow directly from the construction and use of facilities and indirectly from "multiplier multiplier
In economics, a numerical coefficient showing the effect of a change in one economic variable on another. One macroeconomic multiplier, the autonomous expenditures multiplier, relates the impact of a change in total national investment on the nation's total " effects as the increase in employment and spending generated from building and using the facility circulate cir·cu·late
v. cir·cu·lat·ed, cir·cu·lat·ing, cir·cu·lates
1. To move in or flow through a circle or circuit: blood circulating through the body.
2. throughout the local economy.
The other group includes ex post studies carried out in academic settings. These may be formal cost-benefit studies of individual cities and their franchises or stadiums, like Hamilton and Kahn (1997) or Rosentraub and Swindell (1991). Alternatively, these studies may use econometric e·con·o·met·rics
n. (used with a sing. verb)
Application of mathematical and statistical techniques to economics in the study of problems, the analysis of data, and the development and testing of theories and models. techniques to estimate the effects of the sports environment on the economic vitality vi·tal·i·ty
1. The capacity to live, grow, or develop.
2. Physical or intellectual vigor; energy. of a city using time-series data on a single city, using cross-sectional data Cross-sectional data in statistics and econometrics is a type of one-dimensional data set. Cross-sectional data refers to data collected by observing many subjects (such as individuals, firms or countries/regions) at the same point of time, or without regard to differences in time. on a sample of cities, or using time-series cross-sectional data on a panel of cities over time. Among these empirical studies Empirical studies in social sciences are when the research ends are based on evidence and not just theory. This is done to comply with the scientific method that asserts the objective discovery of knowledge based on verifiable facts of evidence. are Baade and Dye (1990), Baade (1996), and Coates and Humphreys (1999). Rosentraub (1997) provides a thorough examination of these issues as well as a synthesis of the existing literature. The general conclusion of these studies is that stadiums and professional sport franchises have little or no positive effects on the local economy, although they may reduce real per capita income in some cases.
2. Empirical Analysis
We adopt the framework developed by Coates and Humphreys (1999) to analyze the effects of the professional sports environment on the economy in an SMSA containing now or at some time in the last 30 years a franchise in one or more of professional football, basketball, or baseball. This framework employs a linear reduced-form empirical model that relates the level of real per capita [Latin, By the heads or polls.] A term used in the Descent and Distribution of the estate of one who dies without a will. It means to share and share alike according to the number of individuals. personal income in a metropolitan area in a given year, [y.sub.it] to a vector of variables describing the economic and business climate in that area during that year, [x.sub.it], and to a vector of variables that capture the role of stadiums and franchises in the determination of economic activity, [z.sub.it]. This linear reduced-form empirical model is
[y.sub.it] = [beta][x.sub.it] + [gamma][z.sub.it] + [[micro].sub.it] (1)
where [beta] and [gamma] are vectors of parameters to be estimated and [[micro].sub.it] is a disturbance DISTURBANCE, torts. A wrong done to an incorporeal hereditament, by hindering or disquieting the owner in the enjoyment of it. Finch. L. 187; 3 Bl. Com. 235; 1 Swift's Dig. 522; Com. Dig. Action upon the case for a disturbance, Pleader, 3 I 6; 1 Serg. & Rawle, 298. term. By assumption, the disturbance term takes the form
[[micro].sub.it] = [e.sub.it] + [v.sub.i] + [u.sub.t], (2)
where [v.sub.i] is a disturbance specific to SMSA i that persists throughout the sample period, [u.sub.t], is a time t specific disturbance that affects all areas in the same way, and [e.sub.it] is a random shock in SMSA i at time t that is uncorrelated across SMSAs and over time. Estimated this way, the regression purges the effect of national events on each jurisdiction in a given year and generates an SMSA-specific impact. In other words Adv. 1. in other words - otherwise stated; "in other words, we are broke"
put differently , the level of income per capita at any point in time is determined by time- and location-specific events and the circumstances regarding sports franchises and stadiums.
In Equation 1, [x.sub.it] is a vector of variables that control for factors other than the professional sports environment that affect real per capita income in SMSAs. We employ four control variables in this study: the lagged level of real per capita income ([y.sub.i,t-1]), the growth rate of the population in each SMSA expressed in percentage terms, year dummy variables This article is not about "dummy variables" as that term is usually understood in mathematics. See free variables and bound variables.
In regression analysis, a dummy variable that capture other omitted factors that affect all SMSAs in the sample in each year, and SMSA-specific time trends that capture secular trends secular trend
The relatively consistent movement of a variable over a long period. A stock in a secular uptrend is an indicator that the security has experienced an extended period of rising prices. in individual SMSAs. 
The vector of sports environment variables, [Z.sub.it], contains a variety of dummy variables to capture some of the variation in the sports environment in each of the 37 SMSAs that currently have or at some time in the past 30 years had a professional football, basketball, or baseball franchise. This vector includes dummy variables indicating the presence of a football, basketball, or baseball franchise; dummy variables indicating the 10-year periods following all football, basketball, and baseball franchise entries and exits; variables indicating the 10-year period following construction or renovation of a stadium or arena; and variables indicating whether the stadium in each SMSA is a single- or a multiple-use structure. The term [Z.sub.it], also includes the seating capacity Noun 1. seating capacity - the number of people that can be seated in a vehicle or auditorium or stadium etc.
commodiousness, spaciousness, capaciousness, roominess - spatial largeness and extensiveness (especially inside a building); "the capaciousness of Santa's of all football, basketball, and baseball stadiums and those capacities squared. These capacity variables are intended to capture the idiosyncratic id·i·o·syn·cra·sy
n. pl. id·i·o·syn·cra·sies
1. A structural or behavioral characteristic peculiar to an individual or group.
2. A physiological or temperamental peculiarity.
3. nature of each individual professional sports venue and to reflect the incremental Additional or increased growth, bulk, quantity, number, or value; enlarged.
Incremental cost is additional or increased cost of an item or service apart from its actual cost. effects of renovation.
The entry, exit, and construction variables take on a value of one in 10 successive years: the year a franchise moves, or the year a stadium or arena opens, and the nine subsequent years, in order to capture the length of time it takes for the novelty Novelty is the quality of being new. Although it may be said to have an objective dimension (e.g. a new style of art coming into being, such as abstract art or impressionism) it essentially exists in the subjective perceptions of individuals. of a new franchise or stadium to wear off, as has been suggested by Baade (1996), or for the despair from losing a team to subside sub·side
intr.v. sub·sid·ed, sub·sid·ing, sub·sides
1. To sink to a lower or normal level.
2. To sink or settle down, as into a sofa.
3. To sink to the bottom, as a sediment.
4. . Baade and Sanderson (1997) estimate the novelty effect The novelty effect, in the context of Human Performance, is the tendency for performance to initially improve when new technology is instituted, not because of any actual improvement in learning or achievement, but in response to increased interest in the new technology. for 10 cities. They find effects in the range of from 7 to 10 years. The entry and departure variables are BBE BBE n abbr (US) (= Benevolent and Protective Order of Elks) → organizzazione filantropica , FRE FRE French
FRE Freddie Mac (stock symbol)
FRE Federal Rules of Evidence
FRE Freedom Realty Exchange
FRE Freedom Party
FRE Food and Resource Economics
FRE Free Range Eggs
FRE French Real Estate , RAE, BBD BBD
In currencies, this is the abbreviation for the Barbados Dollar.
The currency market, also known as the Foreign Exchange market, is the largest financial market in the world, with a daily average volume of over US $1 trillion. , FBD FBD Fluid(ized) Bed Dryer
FBD Fully Buffered DIMM (memory)
FBD Free Body Diagram
FBD Far Beyond Driven (album)
FBD Functional Block Diagram(s) , and BAD for baseball, football, and basketball entry and baseball, football, and basketball departure, respectively. Construction variables are BACO BACO British Academic Conference in Otolaryngology , FBCO FBCO Faith-Based and Community Organizations , BBFBC, and BBCO BBCO Boards, Bureaus, Centers and Offices
BBCO Brasilia Brazil Country Office for basketball-only, football-only, joint football and baseball, or baseball-only construction.
In order to determine the effect of the work stoppages in professional sports on local economies, two dummy variables were created, one each for baseball and football strikes. Each takes the value one in each year of a pro football or baseball work stoppage for cities that have franchises in those sports.
One might question the choice of SMSAs as the unit of measure in this analysis. A considerable amount of research conducted in the 1950s and 1960s found no impact of strikes on the national economy; perhaps SMSAs are large enough relative to the size of a professional sports team to obscure the effects of a strike. Neumann and Reder (1984) found evidence that strikes against some firms in an industry affected output of that industry in about a quarter of the 63 three-digit standard industrial classification (SIC) code industries they studied. The three-digit SIC code industries examined by Neumann and Reder (1984) are of comparable size to the SMSAS in our sample, which suggests that our geographic unit of measurement may not be too large for the question at hand.  We have more to say about this issue shortly.
Table 1 provides descriptive statistics descriptive statistics
see statistics. and variable definitions for the data used in this study. The data are annual and cover the period 1969-1996. Income and population data come from the Regional Economic Information System (REIS n. 1. The word is used as a Portuguese designation of money of account, one hundred reis being about equal in value to eleven cents.
1. A common title in the East for a person in authority, especially the captain of a ship. ) CD-ROM CD-ROM: see compact disc.
in full compact disc read-only memory
Type of computer storage medium that is read optically (e.g., by a laser). , distributed by the U.S. Department of Commerce, Bureau of Economic Analysis. Data on sports franchises, stadiums, and strikes come from Quirk quirk
1. A peculiarity of behavior; an idiosyncrasy: "Every man had his own quirks and twists" Harriet Beecher Stowe.
2. and Fort (1992), and the Information Please Sports Almanac almanac, originally, a calendar with notations of astronomical and other data. Almanacs have been known in simple form almost since the invention of writing, for they served to record religious feasts, seasonal changes, and the like. (Houghton Mifflin Houghton Mifflin Company is a leading educational publisher in the United States. The company's headquarters is located in Boston's Back Bay. It publishes textbooks, instructional technology materials, assessments, reference works, and fiction and non-fiction for both young readers Company 1996), and Noll and Zimbalist (1997a, b). The data set differs from that in Coates and Humphreys (1999) in two ways. First, two additional years of data are included. These additional years are beneficial because several new stadiums and new franchises came into existence in the early to mid-1990s.  The effects of these will now be more accurately captured because of the additional years of data. Second, data on franchise entries and exits were recoded, particularly for the early years of the data, to conform with histories reported in Quirk an d Fort (1992).
Random- and fixed-effects estimations of Equation 1 without the baseball and football strike variables included as regressors are shown in Table 2. The first point to note is that the random-effects results are consistent with those reported in Coates and Humphreys (1999). The sports environment variables as a group are clearly important variables. For the random-effects model, the F-statistic under the null hypothesis null hypothesis,
n theoretical assumption that a given therapy will have results not statistically different from another treatment.
n is 1.77; the 5% critical value with 19 and 905 degrees of freedom is about 1.62.  For the fixed-effects model, the F-statistic is 1.66 with 19 and 868 degrees of freedom. The critical value is, again, about 1.62. Consequently, in either the random- or fixed-effects model, the null hypothesis of no effect of the sports environment may be rejected.
Few of these variables are individually significant, however, and which ones are significant depends on random versus fixed effects. Of those that are individually significant in the random-effects specification, baseball stadium capacity and that capacity squared are so at the 5% level. Football stadium construction and basketball entry are also significant, but at the 10% level. In the fixed-effects estimation estimation
In mathematics, use of a function or formula to derive a solution or make a prediction. Unlike approximation, it has precise connotations. In statistics, for example, it connotes the careful selection and testing of a function called an estimator. , only entry of a basketball team and entry of a football team are individually significant.
The economic control variables are correctly signed and statistically significant in almost all model specifications. The parameter estimated for lagged per capita income and the growth rate of the population are shown in Table 2. Although not reported, all but one of the parameters on the SMSA-specific time trends are statistically significant, as are most of the parameters on the year dummies. Coupled with the significance of lagged real per capita income and the growth rate of the population, these results suggest that a considerable amount of non-sports-related factors that affect real per capita income have been accounted for.
Table 3 adds professional sports strike variables to the empirical model. These results use a fixed-effects estimator; a Hausman test The Hausman test is a test in econometrics named after Jerry Hausman. The test evaluates the significance of an estimators versus an alternative estimator.
If the linear model rejected a random-effects specification in favor of fixed effects for this model. Introducing the strike variables has virtually no effect on any of the other coefficient coefficient /co·ef·fi·cient/ (ko?ah-fish´int)
1. an expression of the change or effect produced by variation in certain factors, or of the ratio between two different quantities.
2. estimates. Interestingly, both strike variables have positive coefficients, the opposite of what one would expect based on the theory of sports-led development. Neither, however, is individually statistically significant. Additionally, an F-test on the null hypothesis that both coefficients are zero has a value of 0.956 in the random-effects model and a value of 0.908 in the fixed-effects model, clearly indicating that the null A character that is all 0 bits. Also written as "NUL," it is the first character in the ASCII and EBCDIC data codes. In hex, it displays and prints as 00; in decimal, it may appear as a single zero in a chart of codes, but displays and prints as a blank space. not be rejected. It does not appear that past work stoppages in professional baseball or football had a measurable impact on real per capita personal income in cities with these franchises.
Although imprecisely im·pre·cise
impre·cisely adv. estimated, the parameters on the strike variables suggest that real per capita income rises in SMSAs during years that the professional sports teams in these SMSAs are on strike. The increase in real per capita income associated with these strike years represents a small fraction of per capita income in the SMSAs in the sample: 0.38% of the average level of income in our sample in the case of baseball strikes and 0.17% in the case of football strikes. Still, this differs from the claims made by proponents of professional sports as engines of economic development; if professional sports make important contributions to the economy, then in their absence incomes should fall, not rise.
Several possible explanations exist for our results. One is substitution in private spending. Attending a professional sporting event is one of many entertainment options in metropolitan areas. Fans could alternatively go out to dinner and a movie or go bowling during a sports strike. If these alternative activities have higher local spending multipliers than does spending on professional sports, then income could be higher during strikes.
Differences in the impact of public and private spending represents a second explanation. Professional sporting events increase metropolitan government spending Government spending or government expenditure consists of government purchases, which can be financed by seigniorage, taxes, or government borrowing. It is considered to be one of the major components of gross domestic product. by driving up spending on public safety, crowd and traffic control, and so on. If this category of public spending declines during a strike and the metropolitan government either borrows less or collects fewer taxes or fees as a result of this decrease in spending, then additional money will remain in the pockets of private citizens. Furthermore, if the marginal impact of these additional private dollars exceeds the marginal impact of these dollars in public hands, then total income in the metropolitan area would increase. There would also be a decrease in deadweight loss Deadweight Loss
The costs to society created by an inefficiency in the market.
Mainly used in economics, the term "deadweight loss" can be applied to any deficiency due to an inefficient allocation of resources. in this case.
Finally, our results may reflect the effects of professional sports on the productivity of workers. If workers spend time discussing the outcome of last night's game rather than devoting this time to job-related activities, then these workers will be less productive in terms of output produced per unit of time. Less output will be produced and less income generated. Fewer such opportunities exist during sports strikes. Therefore, other things equal, during these strikes one would observe higher productivity, production, and income.
One might argue that the lack of statistical significance of the strike variables arises because the severity of the strikes varies dramatically. For example, during the smallest baseball strike, the ratio of games canceled to games played is 0.046. During the most severe baseball strike (1981), the ratio is 0.511. That is, fully a third of the scheduled games were lost that year. For football, the worst strike reduced the season from 16 to 9 games, a ratio of games lost to games played of 0.778. The 1987 NFL season lost only one week of games, though games for three additional weeks were played by replacement players.
To check for differential effects by severity of the work stoppage, separate dummy variables for each strike were created. These variables take a value of one for a city with a franchise in the sport suffering from the work stoppage in a particular year and a value of zero for all other years and all cities without a franchise in that sport. For the fixed-effects model reported in Table 3, the effects of these strike variables are mixed. The t-statistic is greater than one in absolute value for both the baseball strike of 1994 and the football strike of 1982. Neither variable is close to individually significant, however. Additionally, only the baseball strike of 1994 and the football strike of 1987 have the correct sign, indicating that the strike reduced economic vitality in cities with franchises. The F-statistic under the null of no significance of these strike variables is 0.878. The null cannot be rejected.
Including these strike variables can be viewed as a relatively strong test of the direct effect of professional sports on local economies. The evidence from these tests is clearly opposed to the notion that professional sports has any significant effect on the local economies. It also suggests that one should expect little or no repercussions repercussions npl → répercussions fpl
repercussions npl → Auswirkungen pl on the local economies of cities with professional basketball franchises despite the duration of the NBA lockout of l998-1999. 
Recall that Neumann and Reder (1984) found effects of strikes against some firms in an industry in only about 25% of the industries they studied. They hypothesize hy·poth·e·size
v. hy·poth·e·sized, hy·poth·e·siz·ing, hy·poth·e·siz·es
To assert as a hypothesis.
To form a hypothesis. that the strikes against a few firms have little impact on the industry as the unstruck firms expand production to fill the excess demand. In other words, the products of different firms in the industry are close substitutes for one another. Advocates of sports-led development might argue that the effects of strikes in professional sports have important effects on local income but that those effects are hidden by substitution into other recreation activities during the strike. But then the failure of these advocates to adequately consider substitution effects in their economic impact studies is laid bare. It is only by ignoring the substitution effects that large effects of stadiums, arenas, and franchises and of strikes can be consistent with the findings of this paper.
An alternative approach to assessing the importance of the lockout is to examine the effects of a professional basketball team leaving a city. In the results reported here, the basketball team departure variable is one for each of 10 years after a team leaves a city. The coefficient estimate is generally negative, consistent with the sports-led development hypothesis that professional sports is or can be an engine of economic growth. However, the departure variable is never individually statistically significant, though the t-statistic is generally slightly greater than one in absolute value.
The lockout is not, however, a permanent departure from the city. It seems a stretch to think that its effect will carry through 10 years. For this reason, an additional test of the departure of a basketball team examines the effect in the year after the team leaves. There are nine instances of NBA franchises departing de·part
v. de·part·ed, de·part·ing, de·parts
1. To go away; leave.
2. To die.
3. one city for another in the period 1969-1996. As an alternative to the previous models, additional models are estimated using a dummy variable that is equal to one in only the year following the departure of a basketball franchise. This variable is not statistically significant in either the random- or the fixed-effects model. In addition, it has a positive sign, suggesting that in the year after a basketball team leaves a city, real personal income per capita rises.
This positive sign is, of course, at odds with the theory of sports as a catalyst for economic development. Explanations for positive signs on the franchise departure variables include those mentioned previously in the discussion of positive coefficients on the strike variables. Because the departure of a franchise is a permanent event while strikes are temporary, the long-run effects of professional sports on metropolitan economies discussed by Coates and Eumphreys (1999), like compensating earnings differentials and substitution in public spending, also apply in this case.
In this paper we proceed from the assumption that professional sports can effectively enhance local economic development. Under this assumption, work stoppages in professional sports should have harmful effects on the economies of the regions that are home to franchises. If this is true, then the lockout in the NBA at the beginning of the 1998-1999 season will have negatively affected the economies of many major metropolitan areas in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. .
Fortunately, the evidence does not support the assertion that professional sports influence the economic health of SMSAs. Previous research has found little economic benefit and in some cases harmful effects of the sports environment on cities' economies. The results of this paper are consistent with those conclusions. Work stoppages in baseball and football have never had significant impacts on local economies. The departure of a franchise in any sport, particularly in basketball, has never significantly lowered real per capita personal income in a metropolitan area. This is good news for SMSAs with NBA teams. The recent lockout will likely have had no effect, and possibly even a beneficial effect, on their economies.
(*.)Department of Economics, University of Maryland Baltimore County The University of Maryland Baltimore County (UMBC) is a public university, part of the University System of Maryland, located in the southwest Baltimore County community of Catonsville. , 1000 Hilltop Circle, Baltimore, MD 21250, USA; E-mail firstname.lastname@example.org; corresponding author.
(+.)Department of Economics, University of Maryland Baltimore County, 1000 Hilltop Circle, Baltimore, MD 21250, USA.
We thank Andrew Zimbalist Andrew Zimbalist is an American economist. He is best known as one of the most prominent sports economists in the world.
Zimbalist is currently the Robert A. Woods Professor of Economics at Smith College. He received his B.A. , an anonymous referee, and seminar participants at the Congressional Budget Office The Congressional Budget Office (CBO) is responsible for economic forecasting and fiscal policy analysis, scorekeeeping, cost projections, and an Annual Report on the Federal Budget. The office also underdakes special budget-related studies at the request of Congress. for their helpful comments and Ryan Mutter mutter - To quietly enter a command not meant for the ears, eyes, or fingers of ordinary mortals. Often used in "mutter an incantation".
See also wizard. for research assistance.
Received October 1999; accepted March 2000.
(1.) See Crompton (1995) for a review of this literature and Noll and Zimbalist (1997) for a detailed discussion of the problems inherent to this approach.
(2.) The inclusion of a lagged dependent variable makes this model a dynamic panel model. Although lagged dependent variables cause bias in the parameter estimates, Monte Carlo Monte Carlo (môNtā` kärlō`), town (1982 pop. 13,150), principality of Monaco, on the Mediterranean Sea and the French Riviera. evidence in Judson and Owen (1997) suggests that the bias affects the parameter on the lagged dependent variable, not the parameters on the independent variables. Kiviet (1995) reports similar results from panels with time dimensions 20% of the sample in this study.
(3.) Consider the first four three-digit SIC code industries in the Food industry in the Neumann and Reder sample: Meat Products (SIC 201), Dairy Products dairy products dairy npl → produits laitier
dairy products dairy npl → Milchprodukte pl, Molkereiprodukte pl (SIC 202), Fats and Oils (SIC 207), and Miscellaneous Food Products (SIC 209). In 1982, the midpoint mid·point
1. Mathematics The point of a line segment or curvilinear arc that divides it into two parts of the same length.
2. A position midway between two extremes. of our sample, the annual value of shipments in the Meat Products industry was larger than the annual personal income in all but four of the SMSAs in our sample; annual shipments in the Dairy Products industry were larger than the annual personal income in all but eight of the SMSAs in our sample; annual shipments in Miscellaneous Food Products was close to the median personal income from our sample; and for Fats and Oils, the smallest of these four three-digit industries, eight SMSAs had personal income smaller than the annual value of shipments in this industry.
(4.) Newly opened stadiums include Camden Yards in Baltimore, Jacobs Field
• • [ in Cleveland, The Ball Park in Arlington, and Coors Field
• • [ in Denver. New franchises include the Colorado Rockies For the National Hockey League team (1976 – 1982), now known as the New Jersey Devils, see .
The Colorado Rockies are a Major League Baseball team based in Denver, Colorado. They are in the West Division of the National League. and Florida Marlins The Florida Marlins are a professional baseball team based in Miami Gardens, Florida. The Marlins are a member of the Eastern Division of Major League Baseball's National League. From to the present, the Marlins have played in Dolphin Stadium. .
(5.) The value 1.62 corresponds to an F-distributed random variable with 20 and 200 degrees of freedom.
(6.) But the caveat regarding differences between professional sports mentioned previously still applies.
Baade, Robert A. 1996. Professional sports as catalysts for metropolitan economic development. Journal of Urban Affairs 18:1-17.
Baade, Robert A., and Richard F. Dye. 1990. Stadiums and professional sports on metropolitan area development. Growth and Change 12:1-14.
Baade, Robert A., and Allen R. Sanderson. 1997. The employment effect of teams and sports facilities See:
Coates, Dennis, and Brad R. Humphreys. 1999. The growth effects of sports franchises, stadia and arenas. Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 18:601-24.
Crompton, John L. 1995. Analysis of sports facilities and events: Eleven sources of misapplication misapplication,
n the use of incorrect or improper procedures while administering treatment; results from inadequacy in experience, training, skills, or knowledge. May also result from impairment or incompetence. . Journal of Sport Management 9:14-35.
Hamilton, Bruce, and Peter Kahn. 1997. Baltimore's Camden Yards ballparks. In Sports, jobs and taxes: The economic impact of sports teams and stadiums, edited by Roger G. Noll and Andrew Zimbalist. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press, pp. 245-81.
Houghton Mifflin Company. 1996. Information Please Sports Almanac. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company.
Judson, Ruth A., and Ann L. Owen. 1997. Estimating dynamic panel data models: A practical guide for macroeconomists. Unpublished paper, Federal Reserve Board of Governors.
Kiviet, Jan F. 1995. On bias, inconsistency in·con·sis·ten·cy
n. pl. in·con·sis·ten·cies
1. The state or quality of being inconsistent.
2. Something inconsistent: many inconsistencies in your proposal. , and efficiency of various estimators in dynamic panel data models. Journal of Econometrics econometrics, technique of economic analysis that expresses economic theory in terms of mathematical relationships and then tests it empirically through statistical research. 68:53-78.
Neumann, George R., and Melvin W. Reder. 1984. Output and strike activity in U.S. manufacturing: How large are the losses? Industrial and Labor Relations Review Industrial and Labor Relations Review is a publication of the Cornell University School of Industrial and Labor Relations. It is an interdisciplinary journal publishing original research on all aspects of labor relations. 37:197-211.
Noll, Roger G., and Andrew Zimbalist. 1997a. Build the stadium, create the jobs! In Sports, jobs and taxes: The economic impact of sports teams and stadiums, edited by Roger G. Noll and Andrew Zimbalist, Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press, pp. 1-54.
Noll, Roger G., and Andrew Zimbalist. 1997b. Sports. jobs and taxes: The economic impact of sports teams and stadiums. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press.
Quirk, James P., and Rodney D. Fort. 1992. Pay dirt: The business of professional team sports. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Princeton University, at Princeton, N.J.; coeducational; chartered 1746, opened 1747, rechartered 1748, called the College of New Jersey until 1896. Schools and Research Facilities
Rosentraub, Mark S. 1997. Major league losers: The real cost of sports and who's paying for it. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of : Basic Books.
Rosentraub, Mark S., and David Swindell. 1991. The economic and political realities of a small city's investment in minor league baseball
Zipp, John F. 1996. The economic impact of the baseball strike of 1994. Urban Affairs Review 32:157-85.
Zipp, John F. 1997. Spring training. In Sports, jobs and taxes: The economic impact of sports teams and stadiums, edited by Roger G. Noll and Andrew Zimbalist. Washington, DC: The Brookings Institution Press, pp. 427-51.
Variable Definitions, Means, and Standard Deviations Standard Variable Mean Deviation Definition RPCPI 14,062.0 2377.1 Real per capita income DPOP 0.013 0.014 Growth rate of population (%) BBCAP 36.536 31.272 Baseball stadium capacity, thousands FBCAP 48.098 35.077 Football stadium capacity, thousands BACAP 10.473 9.966 Basketball stadium capacity, thousands BBCO 0.033 0.179 Baseball stadium constructed, last 10 years FBCO 0.096 0.295 Football stadium constructed, last 10 years BBFBC 0.102 0.303 Baseball/football stadium constructed, last 10 years BACO 0.225 0.418 Basketball arena constructed, last 10 years BBF 0.615 0.487 Baseball franchise present FBF 0.705 0.456 Football franchise present BAF 0.598 0.491 Basketball franchise present BBE 0.079 0.270 Any baseball franchise entered, last 10 years BAE 0.231 0.422 Any basketball franchise entered, last 10 years FBE 0.101 0.302 Any football franchise entered, last 10 years BBD 0.028 0.165 Any baseball franchise left, last 10 years BAD 0.103 0.304 Any basketball franchise left, last 10 years FBD 0.056 0.230 Any football franchise left, last 10 years BADS 0.008 0.0892 Year following basketball team departure BBST 0.093 0.291 Baseball franchise during a baseball strike FBST 0.052 0.222 Football franchise during a football strike BB72 0.022 0.147 Baseball franchise during 1972 baseball strike BB81 0.023 0.150 Baseball franchise during 1981 baseball strike BB94 0.024 0.153 Baseball franchise during 1994 baseball strike FB82 0.026 0.159 Football franchise during 1982 football strike FB87 0.026 0.159 Football franchise during 1987 football strike Base Model--Dependent Variable: Real Per Capita Personal Income Random Effects Fixed Effects Variable Coefficient t-Statistic Coefficient t-Statistic Constant 919.8 6.63 [RPCPL.sub.-1] 0.92 73.22 0.77 34.96 DPOP 1352.50 1.68 3691.60 3.39 BBCAP 15.38 2.41 9.75 0.65 FBCAP -4.41 -0.74 -10.43 -1.46 BACAP 1.37 0.12 0.47 0.04 BBCAP2 -0.10 -2.39 -0.99 -0.81 FBCAP2 0.02 0.61 0.05 1.23 BACAP2 -0.01 -0.05 -0.002 -.01 BACO -34.69 -1.21 -33.85 -1.02 FBCO 59.42 1.88 51.67 1.34 BBFBC -44.78 -1.34 22.68 0.51 BBCO -2.58 -0.05 -92.02 -1.59 BAFR -67.05 -0.57 -35.19 -0.25 FBFR 157.98 0.67 310.40 1.04 BBFR -332.30 -1.46 -6.18 -0.01 BBE 25.59 0.67 -8.12 -0.17 BAE 57.01 1.86 75.62 2.21 FRE 21.87 0.64 91.42 2.07 BBD 51.47 0.98 -91.36 -1.23 BAD -33.96 -1.09 1.32 0.04 FBD 52.14 1.08 -7.93 -0.14 [R.sup.2] .992 .993 N 999 999 Strike Effects--Dependent Variable: RealPer Capita Personal Income Strike Effects Constant Strike Effects Vary by by Sport Sport and Year Variable Coefficient t-Statistic Coefficient [RPCPI.sub.-1] 0.769 34.98 0.776 DPOP 3800.38 3.48 3771.17 BBCAP 10.70 0.71 9.19 FBCAP -10.65 -1.49 -10.75 BACAP 1.04 0.08 1.35 [BBCAP.sup.2] -0.11 -0.71 -0.09 [FBCAP.sup.2] 0.05 1.26 0.53 [BACAP.sup.2] -0.01 -0.05 -0.02 BAFR -44.03 -0.32 -45.95 FBFR 316.53 1.06 314.47 BBFR -36.01 -0.07 7.55 BBCO -98.35 -1.69 -88.01 FBCO 49.36 52.12 BACO -35.39 1.27 -37.60 BBE -12.01 -1.06 -9.12 FBE 90.45 -0.25 94.84 BAE 76.06 2.04 77.78 BBD -89.28 2.22 -86.60 FBD -5.58 -1.20 -14.59 BAD -0.02 -0.09 1.99 BBST 53.96 -0.003 -- FBST 23.48 1.31 -- BB72 -- 0.40 70.21 BB81 -- -- 66.93 BB94 -- -- -80.93 FB82 -- -- 96.11 FB87 -- -- -55.15 [R.sup.2] -- Variable t-Statistic [RPCPI.sub.-1] 34.81 DPOP 3.45 BBCAP 0.61 FBCAP -1.51 BACAP 0.10 [BBCAP.sup.2] -0.77 [FBCAP.sup.2] 1.27 [BACAP.sup.2] -0.09 BAFR -0.32 FBFR 1.05 BBFR 0.05 BBCO -1.52 FBCO 1.34 BACO -1.12 BBE -0.19 FBE 2.13 BAE 2.26 BBD -1.16 FBD -0.24 BAD 0.05 BBST -- FBST -- BB72 0.90 BB81 0.88 BB94 -1.02 FB82 1.20 FB87 -0.68 [R.sup.2] 0.992 SMSA=specific effects included but not reported.