Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,599,653 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

TRANSIENTS IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD? BLAME THE ACLU\Just try passing ordinances involving minimum standards of public\conduct.


Byline: Robert Teir

CITIES across the country are trying to improve the quality of urban life for their residents and visitors. Their efforts have involved cleaning up urban parks, making downtowns safer and more presentable pre·sent·a·ble  
adj.
1. That can be given, displayed, or offered: presentable gifts; presentable attire.

2. Fit for introduction to others: presentable relatives.
, and taking action against harassing beggars.

Frequently, these measures call upon the homeless and other people who make the streets their bedrooms, kitchens and bathrooms to conform to minimum standards of public conduct.

By passing these measures, a growing number of communities are trying to make their public spaces safe, attractive and welcoming to all.

But when a city takes up legislation to address street-order maintenance problems, it can generally count on opposition from the American Civil Liberties Union American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), nonpartisan organization devoted to the preservation and extension of the basic rights set forth in the U.S. Constitution. . If they actually adopt an ordinance, they should expect to be sued.

With these tactics, ACLU ACLU: see American Civil Liberties Union.  lawyers have become one of the single biggest obstacles to improving urban life.

In their lawsuits, and their arguments to the city councils as well as to the news media, the ACLU will argue that street-order maintenance initiatives are mean-spirited and unconstitutional.

Yet, the cities that have led the way in this area have solid records of treating the homeless in a progressive, tolerant and caring manner. Controls on aggressive begging, for instance, have been adopted in San Francisco, Seattle, Berkeley, Santa Cruz, Atlanta, New Haven, Conn., and Baltimore.

Restrictions on the colonization of urban parks have been adopted in West Hollywood, San Francisco, Dallas and Miami. Many of these cities are internationally known for their diversity and compassion.

The ACLU's constitutional arguments are similarly unavailing. Four courts in a row have upheld sidewalk and park use ordinances, including the California Supreme Court.

Similarly, the United States Supreme Court United States Supreme Court: see Supreme Court, United States.  has upheld the last three panhandling controls to come before it.

Yet, the ACLU is like the Energizer bunny: once wound up, it keeps on going, and keeps making the same arguments regardless of how many times it loses in court.

Its lawyers continue to argue for unlimited freedom of conduct in public spaces, and continue to belittle be·lit·tle  
tr.v. be·lit·tled, be·lit·tling, be·lit·tles
1. To represent or speak of as contemptibly small or unimportant; disparage: a person who belittled our efforts to do the job right.
 the interests of people who do not feel welcome in their urban parks, who are sick of sidewalks that are obstacle courses, and who feel threatened when asked for money after using an ATM machine.

The arguments that ACLU lawyers make in court are not only extreme, they would be unrecognizable to the framers of the Constitution.

In Dallas, they asserted a constitutional right to sleep in the public place of one's choosing. In San Francisco, they argued for a right to accost people on the street who demanded spare change.

At the South Carolina Supreme Court The South Carolina Supreme Court is the highest court in the state of South Carolina. The court is composed of a Chief Justice and four Associate Justices. Selection of Justices
Judges are selected by the legislature of South Carolina to serve terms of ten years.
, they argued for a right to scream as loud as one pleases, regardless of the impact on others.

And, recently, they went to federal court arguing for a constitutional right to sue national parks as rent-free retail space for T-shirt vendors.

In these cases, the ACLU and its allies are holding our public parks and sidewalks hostage.

They claim that limitations on where people can sleep and put their belongings are untenable so long as someone does not have a place to go.

The claim carries with it an implied threat: unless and until cities provide a laundry list of social programs, communities cannot have parks usable by most citizens.What is going on?

Perhaps the ACLU believes that, unless people confront the homeless, popular support for housing and poverty programs will diminish.

But the strategy of encouraging confrontation between urban residents and the homeless is likely to backfire.

By confusing issues of poverty and homelessness, the ACLU promotes the belief that poor people urinate urinate /uri·nate/ (u´ri-nat) to discharge urine.

u·ri·nate
v.
To excrete urine.



urinate

to void urine.
 and defecate def·e·cate
v.
To void feces from the bowels.



defe·cation n.
 in public, empty trash cans, harangue passers-by while asking for money, and scream at demons Demons
See also devil; evil; ghosts; hell; spirits and spiritualism.

ademonist

one who denies the existence of the devil or demons.

bogyism, bogeyism

recognition of the existence of demons and goblins.
 only they can see.

The poor do not act this way - street people do, but, by merging the two in the public's mind, the ACLU has undermined thoughtful efforts to help poor people. And they are using the most downtrodden members of the community as pawns for their political strategy.

The ACLU's arguments in favor of vagrancy vagrancy, in law, term applied to the offense of persons who are without visible means of support or domicile while able to work. State laws and municipal ordinances punishing vagrancy often also cover loitering, associating with reputed criminals, prostitution, and , loitering Loitering (IPA pronunciation: ['lɔɪtəˌrɪŋ] is an intransitive verb meaning to stand idly, to stop numerous times, or to delay and procrastinate.  and aggressive begging are not winning, even in cities that leftist left·ism also Left·ism  
n.
1. The ideology of the political left.

2. Belief in or support of the tenets of the political left.



left
 advocacy groups consider home base.

Therefore, to achieve their agenda, federal courts are their only hope.

The ACLU cannot win. They either will lose in court, and the rehabilitation of urban cores will continue, making them places where people want to spend time. Or, they will succeed in making urban spaces unmanageable, driving those with options away.

CAPTION(S):

PHOTO

Photo (Color) Daily ritual A homeless man searches through a park's trash bin. Daily News
COPYRIGHT 1996 Daily News
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 1996, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:VIEWPOINT
Publication:Daily News (Los Angeles, CA)
Date:Jan 7, 1996
Words:760
Previous Article:LANDMARK THEATER RISES FROM QUAKE RUBBLE.(TRAVEL)
Next Article:ASAP GETAWAYS\Arizona's a happening place in January.(TRAVEL)



Related Articles
Gang warfare: legal battle pits personal liberty against public safety.
COUNTY TARGETS GANGS; ORDINANCE WOULD PUNISH THE PARENTS @B DAILY NEWS STAFF AND WIRE SERVICES.(News)
ORDINANCE BROADENS REACH; MEASURE WILL HOLD GANG MEMBERS' PARENTS LIABLE.(News)
T.O. COUNCIL TO VOTE ON HOMELESS ISSUES.(NEWS)
EDITORIAL\ACLU strikes again\School district's special education needs are tied up in the courts.(Editorial)(Editorial)
AGOURA HILLS LAW USED AS MODEL TO CRACK DOWN ON BEGGARS.(NEWS)
NEIGHBORHOOD PREVIEW SOUGHT FOR NEW LAWS : WEBB WANTS CITY PROPOSALS AIRED.(NEWS)
LTD reviews signature gatherer case.(Courts)
CITY SUED OVER LAPD SKID ROW RAIDS.(News)
OFFICIALS: SKID ROW ARRESTS TO CONTINUE.(News)

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles