THE BLAME GAME; AS SWITZERLAND COMES UNDER MOUNTING SCRUTINY FOR FAILING TO ACCOUNT FOR MONEY BELONGING TO HOLOCAUST VICTIMS, LET US NOT FORGET SWEDEN, PORTUGAL, SPAIN AND EVEN . . . THE U.S.Byline: Si Frumkin I visited Switzerland twice. The first time was in 1947. I was a 16-year old Holocaust Holocaust (hŏl`əkôst', hō`lə–), name given to the period of persecution and extermination of European Jews by Nazi Germany. survivor, an ignorant kid without a country, without a respectable passport, without money. The Swiss let me come in because the organization ORT was willing to pay for me to go to school and try to catch up on the education I missed during the war. (Before the Russian revolution Russian Revolution, violent upheaval in Russia in 1917 that overthrew the czarist government. Causes The revolution was the culmination of a long period of repression and unrest. , one of my uncles was a co-founder of ORT so when the organization learned that I was alive they decided to help me, but that's another story.) The Swiss tolerated my presence, but just barely. I had to report to the police every three months, I had to register wherever I went, and no one was especially sympathetic. I didn't miss Switzerland or the Swiss when I left after six months or so. Many years later, when I went back to Switzerland to go skiing as an American with dollars in my pockets, I understood why so many people raved about how wonderful the Swiss were and what a great country it was. Being a rich - or anyway semi-rich - American in Switzerland was quite different from being a stateless Refers to software that does not keep track of configuration settings, transaction information or any other data for the next session. When a program "does not maintain state" (is stateless) or when the infrastructure of a system prevents a program from maintaining state, it cannot take poor person. Everyone smiled a lot, couldn't do enough for me, they were polite and caring, there were no problems with cops or bureaucrats. It was an altogether different country from the one I visited the first time around. You can gather by now that I am not a wild-eyed fan of Switzerland and the Swiss. Still, I think that the Swiss are being unfairly singled out by the media as the villains in the matter of Swiss banks, Nazi gold 'Nazi gold' refers to the assets in gold transferred by Nazi Germany to overseas banks during the Second World War. The regime maintained a policy of looting the assets of its victims to finance the war, collecting the looted assets in central depositories. , stolen and hidden Jewish bank accounts and all the rest. It isn't that all of the accusations are not true and well-deserved, far from it. What puzzles me is the apparent concentration of attention on the Swiss to the exclusion of all those other countries that have done the same things that the Swiss have, and which are not receiving even a fraction of the attention the Swiss are. Switzerland was not the only neutral European country that traded with the Nazis, permitted transfer of strategic materials, or excluded Jewish refugees In the course of history, Jewish populations have been expelled or ostracised by various local authorities and have sought asylum from antisemitism numerous times. The articles History of antisemitism and Timeline of antisemitism contain more detailed chronology of anti-Jewish fleeing for their lives. It is true that the Swiss asked the German government to stamp the passports of German Jews The Jewish presence in Germany is older than Christianity; the first Jewish population came with the Romans to the city Cologne. A "Golden Age" in the first millennium saw the emergence of the Ashkenazi Jews, while the persecution and expulsion that followed the Crusades led to the with a large ``J'' so they could be recognized and stopped at the border and that they allowed transports of wounded German soldiers to transit Switzerland on the way to Germany, but Sweden was just as adamant in excluding Jewish refugees - they made an exception for the ``Scandinavian'' Danish Jews Jews [from Judah], traditionally, descendants of Judah, the fourth son of Jacob, whose tribe, with that of his half brother Benjamin, made up the kingdom of Judah; historically, members of the worldwide community of adherents to Judaism. but not for Eastern Europeans. Sweden supplied Germany with steel and ball bearings ball bearings n → roulement m à billes . Spain transshipped oil and strategic materials to Germany and had a division fighting for Germany on the Eastern front. Turkey and Portugal cooperated with Hitler in every way they could. And every single European country in addition to Switzerland - Sweden, Turkey and Portugal - did exactly what Switzerland did when it came to Nazi gold and Jewish bank accounts and investments: They accepted and laundered gold regardless of its source and they appropriated and refused to return millions in Jewish deposits and property. In 1946, the Allies demanded that Switzerland return $58 million as settlement in full for the approximately $400 million it had received from Germany. But Portugal was told at the same time to return $51 million - almost as much as the Swiss - and returned only $4 million so far without anyone criticizing it. Spain is estimated to have received about $30 million and returned about $100,000, Turkey got about $5 million and kept it all, and we don't really know anything about Sweden, a neutral country and a major trading partner of Germany. And don't forget, in 1945-1947 an ounce of gold cost about $30 - today it is close to $400, so all these numbers have to be multiplied mul·ti·ply 1 v. mul·ti·plied, mul·ti·ply·ing, mul·ti·plies v.tr. 1. To increase the amount, number, or degree of. 2. Mathematics To perform multiplication on. by at least 10. Oh yes, the Western Allies The Western Allies were the democracies and their colonial peoples, within the broader coalition of Allies during World War II. The term is generally understood to refer to the countries of the British Commonwealth of Nations and part of the military of Poland (from 1939), exiled - the U.S., Great Britain Great Britain, officially United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, constitutional monarchy (2005 est. pop. 60,441,000), 94,226 sq mi (244,044 sq km), on the British Isles, off W Europe. The country is often referred to simply as Britain. and France - still hold about $70 million in Nazi gold - about five tons of it. It is supposed to be disposed dis·pose v. dis·posed, dis·pos·ing, dis·pos·es v.tr. 1. To place or set in a particular order; arrange. 2. of by the end of 1998, but I haven't seen anything in the press about distribution of this gold by these ``good guy'' governments to those who were persecuted and robbed by the Nazis, have you? Millions were deposited by Jews in the banks of neutral countries, including, of course, Switzerland. Sweden probably profited almost as much as the Swiss from deposits by Jews who trusted the solid, honest Scandinavian banks to guard their money. There was probably less money deposited in Spain or Turkey or Portugal, maybe not hundreds of millions, but surely tens of millions. I am puzzled. I welcome the attention the Swiss are getting, but isn't it only fair to start stressing that they are not the only ones whose hands are dirty? |
|
||||||||||||||

Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion