Supporting new teachers: are induction programs worth the cost?
"I had so little support," says one first-year teacher on teachers.net's Beginning Teachers chat board. Despite repeated requests for a lesson demonstration to help her understand the district's complex reading program, the professional development reading coach did not come into her classroom until nearly a month after she failed her first formal reading evaluation. "By January, I was burnt out and stopped handing back homework, stopped asking for any help and stopped caring."
"This was my first job, and I was not receiving any support at all," echoes another first-year teacher, whose contract has not been renewed for the 2007-2008 school year, on the Beginning Teachers chat board. "I struggled with the curriculum. Now that it's starting to make sense, I'm not getting the chance to prove that I can do the job."
Chances are, your district has heard similar complaints during exit interviews for years.
The Need for Induction Programs
When faced with the traditional sink-or-swim induction program, nearly 30 percent of new teachers will sink, leaving the profession within the first three years, according to the National Center for Education Statistics. Those who swim often follow a similar pattern of development: "Your first year will be rough," asserts one third-year teacher on the Beginning Teachers chat board. "The second year will be better. By your third year, you should begin to feel like you can make it. My school has no 'new teacher' program. ... I would like to see more support for new teachers. I think it would make a huge difference."
Education experts agree. Nationwide, teacher induction programs, for the most part, remain "underconceptualized, underfunded and underresourced activities," says Barnett Berry, founder and CEO of the Center for Teaching Quality, a research-based advocacy organization. Less than half of the states fund any new teacher induction program, and those that do rarely have all the components necessary for ensuring high quality. "If there's anything that we probably could do and should do to improve the quality of teaching and ensure the stability of the workforce, it is to provide better, more substantive support for our newest teachers," Berry says.
Studies demonstrate the positive effects that strong new teacher induction programs have on attrition rates and student performance. For instance, in Chicago Public Schools, novice elementary school teachers who received strong mentoring were 25 percent more likely to plan to remain in the same school, according to a 2007 report by the Consortium of Chicago School Research at the University of Chicago. Likewise, beginning high school teachers who received other supports, such as regularly scheduled collaboration with other teachers, observation of their teaching with feedback, and the principal's support and encouragement, were 50 percent more likely to remain in their schools than their colleagues who received little or no support.
Superintendent Maria Ann De La Vega notes that Ravenswood City School District in Palo Alto, Calif., went from a 75 percent teacher turnover rate to an 87 percent teacher retention rate within three years of beginning its partnership with the New Teacher Center at the University of California, Santa Cruz, a national nonprofit organization that works with districts to create new teacher and new principal induction programs. In addition, the district is seeing significant gains in student achievement since the program started: The number of students scoring as "proficient" in algebra has doubled, and the schools have seen 100-point gains on state achievement tests.
Fred Williams, executive director of recruitment and retention at Durham Public Schools in North Carolina, has seen similar results using the New Teacher Center model. After the program's first year of implementation, there was a 38 percent decrease in beginning teacher turnover. Also, when the district compared the performance of students taught by veteran teachers with beginning teachers in the program, the results revealed some new teachers demonstrating greater student achievement gains than their more experienced colleagues.
Likewise, after Oakland Unified School District in California introduced its state-funded Beginning Teacher Support and Assessment (BTSA) induction program in 2004, its retention rate rose from 50 to 75 percent. But Lisa Spielman, BTSA induction coordinator, cautions that induction programs are only part of the equation. If there's a lack of student discipline resources available at the school level, then both beginning and experienced teachers alike will feel stressed and burned out.
Analyzing the Costs
For a new teacher induction program to be effective, Ellen Moir, executive director of the New Teacher Center, believes it needs several key components: extensive mentor training and support; contextualized, classroom-based mentoring, including using a formative assessment system to monitor the beginning teacher's growth and development without threatening his or her job security; opportunities for beginning teachers to observe experienced teachers teaching; a chance for beginning teachers to network with each other, share their experiences and develop problem-solving strategies; and professional development for new teachers that includes having a mentor available who can translate the theory into classroom practice.
Although funding an effective program is not cheap, Moir believes that such programs virtually pay for themselves in the first five years. Using actual data for a medium-sized California school district, the New Teacher Center conducted a five-year cost-benefit analysis of the induction program. As expected, the district faced significant upfront costs to support its 119 new teachers over the first year. The project cost $6,606 per teacher: the district paid $2,300, the state supplied $3,665 as part of the BTSA program, and the beginning and mentor teachers and principals contributed the equivalent of $640 in total in personal time to participate in after-school meetings.
But the investment has paid off. After five years, data from the center shows that the $13,000 price tag of a two-year program yields about $21,500 in benefits to the student, state, district and society, from the district's recruitment and orientation savings to students' achievement gains, generating an $8,500 return on investment per new teacher.
On average, teachers in an induction program have a 2 percent attrition rate, compared to the state average of 4 percent, and only 17 percent of the benefits carne from reducing teacher attrition.
However, nearly half of the benefits came from increasing teacher effectiveness. Further analysis of the students' test scores showed that first- and second-year teachers in the induction program were as effective as fourth-year teachers who had not previously been in the program. Not only do students benefit by having a more effective teacher, but the district receives the equivalent of a fourth-year teacher while paying a beginning teacher's salary.
New teacher induction programs benefit experienced teachers as well, since mentors must participate in extensive training to learn how to meet the needs of adult learners, that is, the new teachers. Instructing and assessing new teachers is very different from teaching 20 first-graders, and teachers with 25 years of classroom experience don't intuitively know how to do it. If the mentors aren't trained, the programs will be far less effective, with the mentors trying to be buddies or simply leaving the new teachers floundering because they don't know how to explain the components of effective teaching.
"They love and are passionate about the position," Williams says. "It has given remarkable teachers the opportunity to do something else--to share some of the insights that they have gained over time, to really engage in very serious and thoughtful professional development, to nurture their own abilities."
Building District Programs
Despite their demonstrated benefits, many districts resist implementing comprehensive new teacher induction programs because it costs too much to fund all of the requisite components. After all, if a district is struggling to pay for enough teachers for every classroom, it will be tough to find an additional $13,000 for a two-year induction program for each new teacher. When it adds the cost of extending the program to the recommended three years and including a modified version for experienced, but new to the district, teachers, the price tag goes from expensive to cost-prohibitive.
To cut costs, some districts build their own teacher induction programs in-house. Columbus Municipal School District, a 4,000-student district in Columbus, Miss., developed two years ago its new teacher induction program, Strategic Training for Academic Results (STAR), based on a similar program in Flowing Wells, Ariz. In the program, which is funded with federal and local monies, novice and experienced teachers attend summer and monthly professional development workshops and work with a trained instructional coach who observes their teaching and offers feedback.
Although the district is seeing impressive results, says Melinda Lowe, professional development coordinator, it still shows a high teacher turnover rate due to military-related transfers at the nearby Air Force base. Out of the 62 first- and second-year teachers who participated in the program, six will be leaving.
Instead of military transfers, it's the high cost of living that contributes to teacher turnover in Fairfax County, Va., where many new teachers must work a second job to afford living there. Though reducing attrition remains a core goal of the district's new teacher induction program, Sharon Mullen, director of professional practice and training for Fairfax County Public Schools, acknowledges that improving the effectiveness of new teachers has assumed a larger role over the last five years: "Our job now is to make teachers better faster because they may not be staying for a long time, but they do have those kids in front of them."
The district's homegrown teacher induction program, Great Beginnings, now serves as a model program for other Virginia districts. All teachers new to the 165,000-student district participate in the program, with novice elementary teachers staying in the program for three years, beginning high school teachers following a two-year path, and experienced teachers who are new to the district undergoing a year-long induction. To further cut costs, the district uses a renewable federal Title II grant for the mentor resource teacher component of Great Beginnings. After undergoing training to become a mentor, recently retired teachers and those on childcare leave visit the schools weekly to work with novice teachers by observing their teaching or modeling lessons.
While Columbus and Fairfax developed and implemented a program, other districts still struggle with new teacher induction and limited resources. Budget cuts have led to fewer new teacher coaches in the School District of Philadelphia.
A former new teacher coach, Suzanne Newman, is known as a "school growth teacher" at the district, working with experienced and beginning teachers, leading professional development courses, analyzing student assessment scores to help teachers drive their instruction and observing classroom teachers.
"When funds need to be cut because administrators or the board think there's too much 'fluff,' it's the people whose job descriptions are not immediately touching the students that get the boot because we look like we're disposable," she says. "It's such a shame, but sometimes it takes too long to see the impact."
Some districts, like Durham, use grants to pay for an established, research-based program, creating self-sustainability. At Durham, whose three-year grant from Duke University and the Duke Endowment ends next year, six staff members are being trained to serve as mentor trainers endorsed in the New Teacher Center model, which allows the district to use in-house staff and the center's materials to create professional development courses.
"The human cost is still there," Williams says. "But we anticipate that there will be fewer and fewer beginning teachers because they will be staying in the profession longer, and thus the need to hire more begins to reduce, and the number of mentors ultimately will be reduced. The ultimate signal of success is that you make yourself obsolete."
Tools for New Teachers, Mentors and Administrators
Are you looking for a professional development program for mentor training? Do you want to point new teachers to an online support community? Do you have a new teacher induction program in place but need additional materials? If so, check out these Web-based resources.
Resources for beginning teachers, mentors and other school district personnel related to Connecticut's comprehensive induction program for new teachers.
Using a case-based, slice-of-life approach to instruction, districts hire CaseNEX to provide online professional development courses that allow new teachers to work with each other and a trained facilitator to find solutions for realistic problems dealing with assessment strategies, classroom management and curriculum design.
Center for Educator Recruitment, Retention & Advancement (CERRA)
A national model for teacher recruitment, CERRA's programs, which are free for South Carolina districts, support new and mentor teachers. A CERRA Web portal is in the works to facilitate communication between the participants and CERRA's staff.
Part of the U.S. Department of Education, this Web site provides teachers and administrators with free education publications and issue briefs.
Ideas for New Teachers and Education Students
The site offers "how-to" information on lesson planning and writing objectives as well as ideas about management and different instructional methods.
Supporting student, substitute and new teachers, as well as administrators and mentors, this resource links to a plethora of related Web sites and features books, Web seminars, staff development in-services, online mentoring and networking message boards.
LEARN North Carolina
A program of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Education, this K12 resource includes online professional development courses and ideas, classroom materials and advice for new teachers.
Mentoring in the 21st Century[TM] Resource Kit
This kit provides the tools schools and districts need to design and implement a comprehensive mentoring program.
The New Teacher Center
Home of the Santa Cruz/Silicon Valley New Teacher Project, the New Teacher Center works with districts across the country to establish effective induction programs for the first two years in practice, using a formative assessment model and providing professional development and support for new and mentor teachers.
A New Teacher Guidebook
This new teacher survival guide offers management and discipline tools, sites to visit and advice on how to organize.
PBS TeacherLine Peer Connection
Set to launch this month [September], this fee-based service provides instructional coaches with a searchable database of resources, such as videos, articles and online interactives from PBS TeacherLine resources; embedded tutorials designed to help teachers shift from child-centered to adult-focused instruction; and an online discussion board. Although the pilot program set to launch this fall is customized for middle school math teachers and coaches, it will be expanded to include other content areas and grade levels, and it will eventually access the entire library of PBS online resources.
Providing support to teachers of all experience levels, this Web site features podcasts of best practices, K12 lesson and unit plans, ideas for incorporating the latest technologies into the classroom, and links to other online resources.
Using a peer-support model, this site features an extensive library of lesson plans and classroom projects, grade- and subject-specific listservs, and chat rooms for teachers and administrators alike.
With everything from Web-based mentors and professional development courses to streaming videos and podcasts demonstrating best practices, this site is a one-stop shop for new and experienced teachers alike.
This K12 Web site includes over 12,000 pages of classroom-ready lessen plans and printable quizzes and worksheets as well as a wide variety of professional development resources that cover topics from survival tips for elementary school teachers to assessment strategies.
Steps for a Successful Teacher Induction Program
* Secure funding by winning grants, creating local bonds or sales taxes, matching government funds or reallocating district resources. Build in release time for mentors to observe new teachers as well as for new teachers to observe other teachers in their content areas.
* Use formative assessment to monitor the new teachers' growth and development over the course of the school year in addition to formal evaluations.
* Offer targeted professional development sessions for new teachers that cover everything from classroom management to assessment, and make a mentor available to help translate theory into actual classroom practice.
* Differentiate instruction for beginning teachers who are new to the profession and experienced teachers who are new to the district.
* Set regular meetings throughout the year for new teachers to network with each other, share instructional strategies and find solutions to their specific problems.
* Teach the mentors what they need to know to be effective in their new role, from assessing the new teacher's development to serving as ah instructional coach.
Center for Teacher Quality
Columbus Municipal School District
Durham Public Schools
Fairfax County Public Schools
Oakland Unified School District
Ravenswood City School District
School District of Philadelphia
Jennifer Maciejewski is a freelance writer based in Atlanta.
|Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback|
|Title Annotation:||ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION|
|Date:||Sep 1, 2007|
|Previous Article:||We've got mail: e-mail makes school communications safe and easy.|
|Next Article:||Madison Metropolitan (Wis.) School District www.madison.k12.wi.us.|