Summer reading : Daniel Terris.Saving the world is a dangerous business--especially for those whom we are trying to save. We spend a lot of time castigating ourselves for our indifference in the face of suffering. But some of our sharpest contemporary writers warn us that we should spend more of our moral capital on considering the consequences of the "good" that we do attempt. Michael Ignatieff's Virtual War (Henry Holt, $23, 246 pp.) brings a reflective journalist's eye to the ongoing crisis in Kosovo. Ignatieff was and remains a strong hawk in the Balkans, a card-carrying member card-carrying member n → miembro con carnet card-carrying member n → membre actif card-carrying member n → of the something-must-be-done brigade. Like other observers who covered the siege of Sarajevo The Siege of Sarajevo was the longest siege in the history of modern warfare, lasting from April 5 1992 to February 29 1996. It was fought during the Bosnian War between the forces of the Bosnian government, who had declared independence from Yugoslavia, and the Yugoslav and the ravages rav·age v. rav·aged, rav·ag·ing, rav·ages v.tr. 1. To bring heavy destruction on; devastate: A tornado ravaged the town. 2. of the war in Bosnia, Ignatieff brought to the later conflict in Kosovo a conviction that this time the Western powers should intervene early and forcefully to counter Slobodan Milosevic's campaign of ethnic cleansing ethnic cleansing The creation of an ethnically homogenous geographic area through the elimination of unwanted ethnic groups by deportation, forcible displacement, or genocide. . Virtual War contains admiring profiles of diplomat Richard Holbrooke Richard Charles Albert Holbrooke (born April 24, 1941) is an American diplomat, magazine editor, author, Peace Corps official, and investment banker. He is also the only person to have held the Assistant Secretary of State position for two different regions of the world (Asia and , NATO commander Wesley Clark, and UN prosecutor Louise Arbour--people, in Ignatieff's view, willing to take a hard line against Serbian violence. Supporters of human rights, Ignatieff tells us, need to get over their skittishness skit·tish adj. 1. Moving quickly and lightly; lively. 2. Restlessly active or nervous; restive. 3. Undependably variable; mercurial or fickle. 4. Shy; bashful. about military power. Ignatieff's prescriptions will not satisfy everyone. NATO's bombing campaign inflicted its own damage on Serbians and Kosovars alike, and people will be arguing for a long time about whether military intervention exacerbated the conflict or provided an important check on Serbian power. The real value of Virtual War, however, lies not in its prescription but in Ignatieff's probing analysis of the ethics of intervention--the consequences not for the Serbs or the Kosovars, but for the Western nations who were willing to wage an essentially gutless war. Kosovo involved a new kind of warfare: it required little mobilization or solidarity of purpose among the general population; lawyers monitored the military targets; precision bombing provided the illusion that intervention was not harming "ordinary" citizens; and protecting the lives of NATO NATO: see North Atlantic Treaty Organization. NATO in full North Atlantic Treaty Organization International military alliance created to defend western Europe against a possible Soviet invasion. soldiers was a higher priority than achieving military ends. The Kosovo war was "virtual" not only because it was fought on computer screens, but because the Western commitment to its goals was so shallow. Virtual war is a product of cultures of comfort, a luxury of the powerful. Ignatieff himself would have preferred a more wholehearted whole·heart·ed adj. Marked by unconditional commitment, unstinting devotion, or unreserved enthusiasm: wholehearted approval. whole military intervention in Kosovo, a more robust commitment to the protection of human rights. But even those of us who were more skeptical about the military intervention have much to learn from Ignatieff's probing analysis of the way bloodless blood·less adj. 1. Deficient in or lacking blood. 2. Pale and anemic in color: smiled with bloodless lips. 3. modern citizenries operate. We take moral credit for our interventions, but we delegate the sacrifice. The costs and consequences of our impulses to do good are a favorite topic of novelists as well. In Ian McEwan's Enduring Love (Anchor, $12, 262 pp.), the intervention is an unplanned impulse. A miscalculation mis·cal·cu·late tr. & intr.v. mis·cal·cu·lat·ed, mis·cal·cu·lat·ing, mis·cal·cu·lates To count or estimate incorrectly. mis·cal in a hot-air balloon puts a young boy and his grandfather in danger, and a disparate group of men converge to try to save them. The child lives, the grandfather does not, but what interests McEwan is the strange and tragic bond that develops between those who run across the field to attempt the rescue. McEwan's narrator NARRATOR. A pleader who draws narrs serviens narrator, a sergeant at law. Fleta, 1. 2, c. 37. Obsolete. , Joe Rose, finds himself torn between pride and guilt; more tellingly, he finds that the balloon accident has torn the fabric of the facade of his life. Lurking vulnerabilities suddenly emerge from beneath his steady success as a science writer, his loving relationship with his wife, and his pat convictions about the nature of the world. One of the other men involved in the balloon rescue begins to stalk Joe, believing that the accident had a higher purpose: to establish a divinely-inspired bond between the men. Caught in a web of feeling and confusion, Joe is drawn into ever deeper wells of irrationality as the aftermath of the incident unfolds. Like Ignatieff, McEwan explores the abyss between middle-class lives shrouded in material comfort and the demands of sudden human suffering. Joe's actions at the rescue are impulsive, uncalculated un·cal·cu·lat·ed adj. Not thought out in advance; spontaneous. , and even noble. But they are also out of step with the life he has lived. He is both deepened and endangered by his encounter. Visions of the good are set against one another in deadly competition in an extraordinary series by Philip Pullman. Written for children, these novels possess a depth and complexity that will challenge the most sophisticated reader. In The Golden Compass (Knopf, $10, 399 pp.), the first in a trilogy that is nearing completion, the young Lyra Belacqua finds herself in the middle of a battle between powerful adults who have begun to unlock the secrets of the universe but wish to use their newfound power not to liberate people but to enslave en·slave tr.v. en·slaved, en·slav·ing, en·slaves To make into or as if into a slave. en·slave ment n. them. In a story rich with elements of journey, fantasy, character, and
drama, Pullman launches a deep moral assault on smug convictions of
being right. His is a worthwhile caution in a time when our tools for
repairing the world may be more advanced than our capacity to use them
well.
Daniel Terris is director of the International Center for Ethics, Justice, and Public Life at Brandeis University. |
|
||||||||||||||||||||

ment n.
Printer friendly
Cite/link
Email
Feedback
Reader Opinion