Printer Friendly

Style over substance; Tolstoy's classic novel has been adapted for the big screen with Keira Knightley as the heroine. But does director Joe Wright succeed with this new translation? Alison Jones casts a critical eye.

Anna Karenina 12A, 130 mins It was Pirates Of The Caribbean This article is about the franchise. For other, more specific uses, see Pirates of the Caribbean (disambiguation). For real pirates, see Piracy in the Caribbean.
Pirates of the Caribbean
 that made Keira Knightley a star but it was Pride & Prejudice (2005) that set her on the path to becoming a credible actress. So no one can blame her for accepting director Joe Wright's return invitation to play another great literary heroine, Anna Karenina.

He even brought her Mr Darcy along for the cinematic ride, casting Matthew Macfadyen as her womanising brother, Oblonksy.

But the tormented Anna is a colder kettle of fish kettle of fish
n. pl. kettles of fish
1. A troublesomely awkward or embarrassing situation.

2. A matter to be reckoned with:
 than the spirited Lizzy Bennet.

Loving yet hypocritical, passionate yet tormented, Knightley's Anna is both 'heroine and anti heroine', a woman who abandons her own life and child for lust and love and is ultimately undone by it.

Adapted from Tolstoy's 1877 novel by Tom Stoppard Noun 1. Tom Stoppard - British dramatist (born in Czechoslovakia in 1937)
Sir Tom Stoppard, Stoppard, Thomas Straussler
, Wright's Anna K is stunning to look at.

Not just the luminous Knightley, who looks like she has stepped from the pages of Russian Vogue, but all the costumes and sets as well.

He has staged it as if it is in a theatre, the actors wandering about on and back stage as if they are in ordinary streets with life being played out amid the props and backcloths.

It is strange at first as one waits for the film to open out, yet it does so only occasionally.

What Wright accomplishes within these curious confines is often truly remarkable, even sending a horse race thundering across the boards.

But this also keeps the audience at a distance, reminding us that we are watching merely players and preventing us from truly engaging with Anna, her dissatisfaction with her dull marriage to the honourable and well-respected Karenina (Jude Law), and willingness to be swept away with a glance from Vronsky's limpid blue eyes.

Vronsky himself has been transformed from the dark and dangerous figure of the novel to a gilded youth with golden cherubic cher·ub  
1. pl. cher·u·bim
a. A winged celestial being.

b. cherubim Christianity The second of the nine orders of angels in medieval angelology.

2. pl.
 curls, played by Aaron Johnson.

While he and Anna make a spectacularly pretty pair, this Vronsky seems out of his depth at dealing with the morphine-induced mood-swings of an older woman who, having won her prize at the cost of her son and position in society, is tormented by the idea that he will grow distracted and bored, lured away by youth, beauty and a title.

There is also the parallel romance of Kitty and Levin, the farmer who wins back the Princess after she is spurned spurn  
v. spurned, spurn·ing, spurns
1. To reject disdainfully or contemptuously; scorn. See Synonyms at refuse1.

2. To kick at or tread on disdainfully.

 by Vronsky.

Though it does not have the melodrama of Anna and Vronsky, it is far deeper and more affecting, a near wordless scene with child's building blocks wonderfully touching.

It is easier to be moved by the sub-plots, to wonder how much better the film might have been had Kelly Macdonald Kelly Macdonald (born February 23 1976) is an Emmy Award-winning Scottish actress, born in Glasgow, Scotland. Personal life
Her parents divorced when she was quite young and she and her younger brother were raised by her mother on a council estate in the town of Newton
 played Anna rather than her cuckolded sister-in-law (infidelity seems to be a family failing).

We marvel not at what it is, but what it could have been.


Keira Knightley as Anna Karenina with her husband Karenina, Jude Law, and below with Vronsky played by Aaron Johnson
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2012 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:Features
Publication:Western Mail (Cardiff, Wales)
Date:Sep 7, 2012
Previous Article:Curtain up on another stage; After wowing audiences in Spamalot, actor Christopher Orton is now preparing for a very different role - that of writer....
Next Article:ONE of my favourite [...].

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters