Printer Friendly

Social justice and economic order according to natural law.

Social Justice: A Controversial Concept

The term social justice, as reported by Vallin, (1) became widely used in political debates in the middle of the nineteenth century when the "social question" demanded a new balance of economic forces in society. An interesting issue is why the term social was (and is) added to justice and how it was related to political economy. Vallin noted that social was opposed to individual to contrast the perspective of liberal individualism. (2) In the case of social Catholicism, it was mainly opposed to the term political to denote the reference to civil society as opposed to the state. However, this idea, mixing the principles of utility and justice, presents some theoretical difficulties due to different concepts of the law supporting the notion of justice.

Modern works on economic justice totally neglect the first theorizations of social justice and almost totally exclude the most historically relevant and influential ideas from their theoretical treatments. In general, in contemporary economic literature, we note a noncritical adoption of contemporary positive-analytical theories and, in particular, of Rawls' approach, (3) while the classic natural-law school is underrepresented.

In this article, we aim to present the first ideas of social justice as they emerged in the middle of the nineteenth century from an application of Thomistic natural-law principles to social economics. In order to highlight the singularity of this approach and the difficulty of its correct application in economics, in the next section, we will propose a brief survey of different views of the law. Then, after presenting the neo-Thomistic origins of social justice, we will discuss the difficulties of its application due to the differences in understanding the law, even among proponents of social Catholicism.

The Changing Idea of Justice

Justice and utility represent the two main principles acting as the reference point for the development of economic and political theories. The idea of justice maintained a privileged position in social thought until the modern age when utility emerged as a new reference and replaced it. (4) The principle of justice as a criterion for judging social results reemerged in the middle of the nineteenth century directly related to the development of the social question. Since that time, it has constantly been adopted by "dissenting" economists as a principle, at least complementary to utility, useful for evaluating the legitimacy and desirability of economic outcomes.

The introduction of the notion of justice in economics implies a reference to the principles defining rights and the law. However, there are many theoretical frameworks for understanding rights and the law. A double distinction concerning the notion of right (law) assumes extreme importance. First, we can distinguish the perspectives of natural law (classical or modern) from legal positivism A school of Jurisprudence whose advocates believe that the only legitimate sources of law are those written rules, regulations, and principles that have been expressly enacted, adopted, or recognized by a governmental entity or political institution, including administrative, . Second, the different traditions of natural law--the classic-scholastic and the modern tradition--produce relevant differences in the interpretation of this notion. In this work, we mainly focus on the distinction between classic natural law versus modern natural law, which also entails the medieval versus modern perspective and that assigned a prevalence to the ethical versus the economic-utilitarian judgment. (5) The former affirms the inseparability of ethics and economics, while the latter is in fact based on the separability sep·a·ra·ble  
adj.
Possible to separate: separable sheets of paper.



sep
 of these matters. (6)

Among the many theorizations developed by classical philosophers, Aristotle's principles of justice--as exposed in the fifth section of Nicomachean Ethics Nicomachean Ethics (sometimes spelled 'Nichomachean'), or Ta Ethika, is a work by Aristotle on virtue and moral character which plays a prominent role in defining Aristotelian ethics.  (7)--remain the cornerstone of all definitions of this notion. (8) Aristotle distinguished between a general justice (a comprehensive virtue) and three specific forms: distributive, corrective, and reciprocity based. Distributive justice DISTRIBUTIVE JUSTICE. That virtue, whose object it is to distribute rewards and punishments to every one according to his merits or demerits. Tr. of Eq. 3; Lepage, El. du Dr. ch. 1, art. 3, Sec. 2 1 Toull. n. 7, note. See Justice.  concerned honors and goods to be divided among the participants in some form of collective action in proportion to their merit. Corrective justice was oriented to offset inequalities in exchange (or due to fraud and violence), and it was based on "harmonic" proportionality. Finally, reciprocity based justice applies to community exchanges and was based on reciprocal proportionality (relative to status) to keep and strengthen social ties.

The scholastic tradition, in particular Thomas Aquinas, reelaborated these principles. Aquinas' theory of knowledge and action was based on the idea of practical reasonableness that separated the role of reason from that of will. (9) He exalted the role of reason in human action and, in particular, in the ability to understand what is good. In Aquinas, jus is the just thing in itself and concerns acts or states of affairs as subjects of a relationship. Justice is relational and intersubjective; it concerns any relation necessary to avoid a wrong. In particular, justice entails both rights and duties in a relationship, (10) and equality is intended in the sense of right proportion. As a consequence, legal justice (corresponding to the general justice of Aristotle) is the power and liberty to identify the common good and to correctly establish rights and obligations in intersubjective relationships complemented by the principle of moral necessity. In general, justice was applied to the "extended self," man and his whole possessions (material, relational, and human capital) through the notion of decency, suitability, or appropriateness. (11) On the other hand, in Aquinas, the specific forms of justice fall into two types: distributive justice and commutative justice COMMUTATIVE JUSTICE. That virtue whose object is, to render to every one what belongs to him, as nearly as may be, or that which governs contracts.
     2. The word commutative is derived from commutare, which signifies to exchange. Lepage, El. du Dr. ch. 1, art.
. (12) The reason is probably that the same idea of legal justice prevents the distinction between exchange and reciprocity.

The natural-law school evolved and gave a predominance to will over reason and focused on only one side of the relationship of justice proposed by Aquinas. (13) In Suarez's (1610) De Legibus The de Legibus is a dialogue written Marcus Tullius Cicero during the last years of the Roman Republic. It bears the same name as Plato’s famous dialogue, The Laws.  justice remains a moral power, but it is interpreted as an attribute of any man over his property; it predominantly refers to what is due to him. Similarly in Grotius' (1625) De Jure [Latin, In law.] Legitimate; lawful, as a Matter of Law. Having complied with all the requirements imposed by law.

De jure is commonly paired with de facto, which means "in fact.
 Belli ac Pacis it is a quality of the person that enables him to have or to do something just. Justice is referred to persons: power and liberty related exclusively to the beneficiary of the just relationship. (14) In this shift of focus, the person becomes a "right holder" and not a part in a relationship with an objective state of justice: obligation shifts out of focus.

A further more relevant change, however, occurred with the Enlightenment when the principle of right practical reason lost importance and was substituted by utility. With Hobbes, there is the definitive separation of right from law and of obligation from liberty. His view that man had full rights in the state of nature and that the law limits such rights turns Aquinas' perspective upside down, producing a bifurcation Bifurcation

A term used in finance that refers to a splitting of something into two separate pieces.

Notes:
Generally, this term is used to refer to the splitting of a security into two separate pieces for the purpose of complex taxation advantages.
 between rights and duty. The work of David Hume is of particular interest for signalling a major change of perspective in modernity: experience and not reason is the prime source of useful knowledge about political and social life. Rules of morality develop through human experience, and, therefore, they are artifices that are accepted because of their social utility. Justice is a "geometrical" system of formal laws that impartially protects the life and property of all. Justice arises from human conventions because of the public utility it produces. (15) This approach was to affect the entire development of economic theory.

It is precisely in the middle of the nineteenth century that ideas on the interaction between justice and political economy emerged and some preliminary theories were formulated. Besides the claimed humanism of John Stuart The name John Stuart can refer to:
  • John Stuart, 4th Earl of Atholl (d. 1579)
  • John Stuart, 3rd Earl of Bute (1713–1792), Prime Minister of Great Britain from 1762–1763.
 Mill, who was able to go marginally beyond utilitarianism utilitarianism (y'tĭlĭtr`ēənĭzəm, y , Walras defined himself as a follower of natural law as developed by Quesnay. (16) He wrote a work on justice to contrast the pragmatic socialism of Proudhon who adopted a positive view of law. According to according to
prep.
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.

2. In keeping with: according to instructions.

3.
 Walras, political economy is an intersection of natural, moral, and historical facts. Value responds to general objective laws, while property is related to moral principles that derive from natural law. The law is therefore relevant, but there is no point in inquiring into the rights or wrongs of the present situation because they are a mix of objective laws, the theory of value (which cannot be the object of principles of justice) and natural laws such as the property right. The latter is subject to the principles of justice, but, because property is a natural law, we cannot question its distribution but only the way it is acquired. As a consequence, justice was subordinated to political-economy laws. (17)

To conclude this section, we note that in the nineteenth century no economist systematically theorized social justice. In general, the attribution of the term social to justice was intended to refer to rules and institutions intentionally produced in the polity. The notion of social justice was instead defined and introduced by Jesuits into Roman Catholic social economy as a coherent system of thought based on Aquinas' classic natural law.

The Introduction of Social Justice in the Neo-Thomistic Philosophy of Law

In the nineteenth century, the Thomistic tradition of natural law based on practical reasonableness was reproposed by Jesuits to counter individualistic utilitarianism and materialistic liberalism. However, they also had to counter the drift of the natural-law school.

Aquinas proposed a legal framework based on right reason and on the possibility of discovering and communicating what is good and, consequently, what is just. Obligation is the rational necessity of some means to achieve the common good. Duty is not separable sep·a·ra·ble  
adj.
Possible to separate: separable sheets of paper.



sep
 from rights because the good objectively connects them in a relationship. This view changed with modernity, in the same tradition as natural law, as the role of reason (and therefore the discovery of objective good) was abridged in favor of the concept of will. (18) Suarez already interprets obligation as essentially the effect of an act of will by a superior, directed to moving the will of an inferior. (19) In Cajetan, legal justice orients the parts to the whole, distributive justice the whole to the parts, while commutative justice orients the parts to one another. Soto adopted the same framework but used the notion of "the state" for the whole. This constituted a major shift from Aquinas' position where legal justice is the basis of all justice and all obligations and where obligation is not primarily defined as that of citizens toward the state. In fact, in Aquinas, anyone in charge of a common stock has duties of distributive justice; moreover, commutative justice also concerns the interactions between the state and private actors.

The neo-Thomist school of the nineteenth century intended to revive Aquinas' original framework and to apply it as an integrated system able to connect philosophy of law and social sciences. (20) It represented an attempt to build social sciences' compatibility with religion, and its aim was to provide an alternative to both liberalism and socialism. It became the official social philosophy of the church with Leo Leo, in astronomy
Leo [Lat.,=the lion], northern constellation lying S of Ursa Major and on the ecliptic (apparent path of the sun through the heavens) between Cancer and Virgo; it is one of the constellations of the zodiac.
 XIII's encyclical letter Noun 1. encyclical letter - a letter from the pope sent to all Roman Catholic bishops throughout the world
encyclical

letter, missive - a written message addressed to a person or organization; "mailed an indignant letter to the editor"
 Aeterni Patris in 1881. The theoretical definition of social justice was a true innovation of nineteenth century neoThomism. Unlike the liberal approach of Walras, neo-Thomism was oriented to developing analytical instruments out of classic natural law to systematically question economic facts according to principles of justice. Luigi (Prospero) Taparelli D'Azeglio was one of the most important scholars who renewed Thomistic thought and was largely responsible for its adoption as the official social philosophy of the Church. (21)

In Taparelli, the concept of social justice is developed according to a precise idea of man and society. Man is conceived as an intelligent being, that is to say, gifted with the faculty of knowledge and will. Society is defined by the identification of a unity of ends, "deriving from a cognition unity, producing a union of will, here is the essential idea of society," (22) which refers to the unity constituted by the being and by operation and to the "natural sociability of man," (23) the principle of which lies in the law of justice and benevolence BENEVOLENCE, duty. The doing a kind action to another, from mere good will, without any legal obligation. It is a moral duty only, and it cannot be enforced by law. A good wan is benevolent to the poor, but no law can compel him to be so.

BENEVOLENCE, English law.
. (24) As a consequence, the "social being" can be achieved only when the communality typical to the social dimension does not result in the simple identification of an end but when it also concerns the will of humans that are joined in a common intent "in a way that nobody can claim it for himself if not by communicating it to others, craving and getting for them the same thing he craves and gets for himself." (25)

On the grounds of this assumption, Taparelli develops what he calls social law (diritto sociale), which springs from the idea of order and develops as a "non-material non-power" (26) or, again, as an "unrestrictable power-according-to-reason," (27) that is to say, the voice of a moral order tending toward social justice as a "justice between man and man." (28) It is in this juridical Pertaining to the administration of justice or to the office of a judge.

A juridical act is one that conforms to the laws and the rules of court. A juridical day is one on which the courts are in session.


JURIDICAL.
 dimension that the social being unfolds an essential property of human nature, (29) developed around the hendiadys hen·di·a·dys  
n.
A figure of speech in which two words connected by a conjunction are used to express a single notion that would normally be expressed by an adjective and a substantive, such as grace and favor instead of gracious favor.
 universal-general versus singular-particular, abstract versus concrete, species versus individual, abstract individual versus concrete man. Universal is what pertains to nature, the particular is what derives from human facts.

Developing these concepts, Taparelli attempts a conciliation conciliation: see mediation.  between idealism and empiricism empiricism (ĕmpĭr`ĭsĭzəm) [Gr.,=experience], philosophical doctrine that all knowledge is derived from experience. For most empiricists, experience includes inner experience—reflection upon the mind and its  by means of what he conceives as a "tempered philosophy." The latter, from the perspective of the universal, founds the origins of society "in the nature of man, by nothing more than combining the analysis of the idea, and the natural fact with the prime moral principle"; (30) relative to the particular, it founds it in the "very facts of man." (31) In this way, if society is a necessary consequence of human nature, at its basis we can find only moral order, understood as an order oriented to obtaining truth and good. (32)

It is interesting to remark that in Taparelli the idea of social justice, as "justice between man and man" is developed from the idea of right, which can be pursued by men thanks to their usual inclination toward justice as a tendency to "ragguagliar le partite par·tite  
adj.
Divided into parts.



[Latin parttus, past participle of part
" (balance the entries). (33) However, social justice intended in this way is completely abstract; it deals only with man in abstract terms those which express abstract ideas, as beauty, whiteness, roundness, without regarding any object in which they exist; or abstract terms are the names of orders, genera or species of things, in which there is a combination of similar qualities.

See also: Abstract
, as a "replicated unit." (34) Conversely, from an actual perspective, men are naturally unequal, and we should refer to both perspectives to properly single out the concept and principle of justice.

Consequently, if from the universal (abstract) point of view justice is first of all a "specific natural equality"--that of humans from an abstract perspective as "pure reasoning animal"--where the relationship means only "humanity replicated two times," then from the particular (concrete) point of view, the relationship is between naturally unequal men--because "all men are between them naturally unequal in respect of individuality, as they are naturally equal in respect of the species." (35)

The concept of justice consequently acquires different value if applied to particular goods or to the common good. In the former case, justice is defined as commutative com·mu·ta·tive  
adj.
1. Relating to, involving, or characterized by substitution, interchange, or exchange.

2. Independent of order.
 because it is elaborated between equals and it would apply as a "balance of quantity." (36) In the latter, it would be distributive and would have to be balanced as the "proportions in the share of the common good." (37) We can have full justice only when both cases are considered.

The concept of social justice developed by Taparelli unfolds from the fundamental principle of any morals--do good--that represents a duty of love that leads one to recognize (admit) the diversities in behavior according to justice, and from the right of independence, as a recognition of the right not to be reasonably hindered to achieve our good. (38) In this way, "the social fact, considered at its maximum generality, presented us subjects as intelligent beings and human society as men, that is to say made of intelligence and sense," (39) in relation to which the joint aspiration to an end is the attribute that gives that subject the status of social being, as the communality of intents and therefore of will.

As a consequence, in Taparelli, "social justice consists of rightly measuring collisions of rights, and in assuring" in fact what lively right asks. (40) This clearly is a reformulation of the legal justice of Thomas Aquinas and is probably closer to the original compared to other followers of natural law. The interesting issue is why he called it social, thus risking political misunderstandings. This inevitably produces a shift from Aquinas' notion of community to the modern notion of society. The thesis of Calvez and Perrin is that the term legal could have had a flavor of legal positivism, and this notion could have been confused with the socialist "philosophical voluntarism voluntarism

Metaphysical or psychological system that assigns a more predominant role to the will (Latin, voluntas) than to the intellect. Christian philosophers who have been described as voluntarist include St. Augustine, John Duns Scotus, and Blaise Pascal.
." (41) Probably, however, Taparelli intended to develop a concept to allow Catholic scholars to prudently elaborate progressive tools to study the imbalances of the social order in the modern context without the excessive simplifications and rigidities of the legal positivists. Taparelli's work was followed by other excellent studies connecting moral philosophy and economic issues (in general relating to relating to relate prepconcernant

relating to relate prepbezüglich +gen, mit Bezug auf +acc 
 the social question) such as those of Liberatore, Lehmkuhl, and Cathrein. (42) Taparelli himself applied his ideas to social economy in some articles in Civilta Cattolica. (43)

We can underline how the definition of commutative and distributive justice in Taparelli and Walras is remarkably similar. Walras proposes his (liberal-progressive) idea of justice founded on reciprocity of rights and obligations: "equality of conditions; inequality of positions: here is the law of the social world. The state for all, and each for himself." (44) However, charity is not included in this justice, even if it can be a completion of it, but it has no right to intervene before justice has pronounced its last word. (45) In this, we find a separation between exchange and charity and an idealization idealization /ide·al·iza·tion/ (i-de?il-i-za´shun) a conscious or unconscious mental mechanism in which the individual overestimates an admired aspect or attribute of another person.  of the (unrestricted) market exchanges that are instead under the critical investigation of Catholic (and socialist) thinkers. Walras (who writes after Taparelli) studied natural law and probably achieved a good understanding of these issues. However, the influence of the enlightenment version of natural law is clear when we consider that in Walras' positivistic pos·i·tiv·ism  
n.
1. Philosophy
a. A doctrine contending that sense perceptions are the only admissible basis of human knowledge and precise thought.

b.
 view the market obeys natural laws and is able to produce the common good, while in the Thomistic tradition the effective achievement of the common good must be effectively analyzed in practice, and it is not possible (scientifically) to conceive a priori a priori

In epistemology, knowledge that is independent of all particular experiences, as opposed to a posteriori (or empirical) knowledge, which derives from experience.
 the efficiency of markets. In Thomistic terms, exchange is not the mechanical functioning of a market. Exchange is defined in a context of justice and is therefore never clearly separable from charity. (46)

The Controversies on the Meaning of Economic Justice

The close relationship between the definition of economic justice and the natural-law view of social interactions caused some difficulties among Roman Catholic social economists to precisely use this notion. In particular, the exact context in which the different notions of justice had to be applied and the relationships with charity were protagonists of a continuous change. (47) In particular, some different positions were put forward by, on the one hand, what we would nowadays call liberal-conservative Catholic scholars, such as the economist Charles Perin and Claudio Jannet and, on the other, the reformers of social Catholicism including La Tour-du-Pin La Tour-du-Pin is a commune of the Isère département, in France.

Coordinates:  
 and most of the Austro-German scholars. (48)

Charles Perin avoided the use of social justice and preferred the simple notion of justice, fundamentally interpreted as commutative justice. This would be the less controversial kind of justice where the principle suum cuique is easily identified, but a wide set of problems arose relative to the correct criteria for evaluating rights and obligations. The problem is how far we can rely on the impersonal market (which economists say is efficient in objectively evaluating social scarcity) to measure the just value of certain goods (like labor) or whether we should take into account the personality of the exchangers as in the Aristotelian-Thomistic tradition. This issue is exemplified by the use of the term natural justice in Rerum Novarum Rerum Novarum (Translation: Of New Things) is an encyclical issued by Pope Leo XIII on May 15 1891. Overview
Rerum Novarum was an open letter, passed to all Catholic bishops, that addressed the condition of the working classes.
 where the just salary is said to be the result of a free bargain between man and man, with the limit that salary should in any case be sufficient to grant a decent life to the worker. (49) Requested to clarify this notion of natural justice, Cardinal Zigliara explained that natural justice in the above text had to be understood as commutative justice. (50) Similarly, Heinrich Pesch reaffirmed that commutative justice involves rendering to another exactly what is his strict due (the principle of equivalence Noun 1. principle of equivalence - (physics) the principle that an observer has no way of distinguishing whether his laboratory is in a uniform gravitational field or is in an accelerated frame of reference ) like the just price for goods, the just wage, and so forth. However, he added, "anyone who is completely imbued with the sense of commutative justice will quite naturally also be inclined to deal equitably with his fellow citizens" and therefore not "insist on his rights no matter what the consequences are for his neighbor, even though the law is on his side." (51)

In any case, the act of fairness is not mere liberality lib·er·al·i·ty  
n. pl. lib·er·al·i·ties
1. The quality or state of being liberal or generous.

2. An instance of being liberal.
; it derives from a sense of decency and obligation that cannot be separated from a correct price. As a consequence, commutative justice is not a justice of the perfect market; it is part of legal (or social) justice, applying the same principles.

The wider controversies concerned distributive justice. The thorny problem was to understand at what level of society this justice can be defined. (52) Conservative scholars were reluctant to attribute this task to the state, while they did not deny this justice in organizations or in specific forms of collective action through patronage. (53) Reformers envisaged a major role for the state, blending distributive justice and charity at that level because the state was seen as an ethical state and an agent of progress. Liberals tended to affirm that charity suffices to solve the social question and should be spontaneously given; the state could limit its intervention to enforce commutative justice where the idea of right is stricter. Social Catholics instead asked for an intervention to foster rights and to enforce a whole set of positive laws to grant justice.

Social justice, however, was the most problematic concept. Sometimes it was assimilated to legal justice, and sometimes it was expressed as something different. Antoine defined legal justice as involving the common good of society as a whole, including the state that has an important role in it. (54) However, he complicated the thing, arguing that social justice may be understood in strict terms or in a metaphorical sense.

In the metaphorical sense, it refers to the health of society. It is best rendered with the term social order because order is conformity with the ideal state of society. Antoine says that there is much confusion on this term: some understand it as a subjective virtue that induces citizens to contribute to the common good; others interpret it as a state of society that concretizes a specific ideal. The latter is the sense used by socialists, and many use the term justice for equity.

In the proper sense, the object of social justice is the right to the social good. In this case, the social good can be interpreted in its production or in its enjoyment. As a consequence, it comprises both the right of society to demand from each person a contribution to the production of the good and the right of each person in relation to society to enjoy this good. Therefore, we have a two-way relationship that has to be regulated by social justice. In this sense, social justice includes legal, distributive, and commutative justice.

Consequently, Antoine affirmed that if we want to appoint social justice as the justice that has to exist in society, then it includes all the other kinds of justice (and maybe also equity). (55) If, instead, we wish to understand social justice as the justice where society, considered as a moral being, is the subject or the term, then it is no different from legal and distributive justice. Finally, if, more precisely, we understand social justice as a juridical bond of society, the principle of unity of society, this is legal justice.

The second generation of Roman Catholic social economists intensively studied the problem of a right economic order and related it to social justice, as Taparelli originally did. (56) The concept of a just order is central in this analysis oriented to the study of the relationship between the individual and social utility, and this can be considered an application of the principle of social justice. In fact, Taparelli (1854) argued that "the good of man on earth, the supreme and only good, is ORDER: ORDER in the use of his individual faculties, the ORDER of social relations." (57) Natural law is the application of human rationality to the experience of intersubjective relationships. The regulating principle of relationships is rationally extracted from the dialectic confrontation between the positions of the social parts. This should give rise to some practical rules that evolve with the context. Institutions have the task of enabling this process and are, at the same time, the result of the process. The economic order is therefore important to obtain just economic situations as it helps the dialectic confrontation between parts. No impersonal mechanism, such as the market in neoclassical economics, achieves this.

Heinrich Pesch connected social justice to the concrete institutional order. Metaphorically, social justice means social order, the "objectively well ordered condition of the social body, the correspondence of actual social conditions to the ideal juridical state of affairs." (58) Pesch distinguishes legal justice from social justice. Social justice has as its object "the claim to the well-being of society" (59) that can be understood in a twofold manner, "in fieri IN FIERI. In the course of execution; a thing commenced but not completed. A record is said to be in fieri during the term of the court, and, during that time, it may be amended or altered at the sound discretion of the court. See 2 B. & Adol. 971. , and in facto esse, ... how it comes into being, and how it is enjoyed." (60) Therefore, social justice includes
   both the claims of society on those in authority, as well as on
   each of its members, on its citizens, and on the various
   occupations and stations in life, for promoting and preserving the
   public welfare; and it includes also the right of every citizen and
   of the various classes, occupations, and levels of society to share
   in the enjoyment of the social good. It is the function of social
   justice to govern both kinds of claims; and thus we may distinguish
   between contributive and distributive social justice. It takes both
   of these aspects together to make up the integral notion of social
   justice.

   Social justice, therefore, requires the fulfilment of all
   obligations as well as the realization of all claims which have the
   well-being of society as their object. (61)


Here again, inevitably, the shadow of the state appears behind the idea of economic order.

Conclusion: Social Justice and the Economist

In this article, we have illustrated the presuppositions, the genesis, and the evolution of the notion of social justice elaborated by nineteenth-century neo-Thomistic thought and applied by Roman Catholic social economists. We have highlighted the differences in the meaning of social justice and the effects on the interaction with economics due to the differences that exist inside the classic natural law school and with the modern natural school. The case of Walras has helped us to single out the turning point in favor of an abstract economic reasoning produced by the modern concept of natural law. The latter prevents practical inquiries into the effective state of economic affairs by separating the moral from the material value. No such separation between facts and values, between the morals and the law is possible in Thomistic natural law. This does not prevent the definition of any objectivity of rights and duties, even if it requires more sophisticated philosophical (hermeneutical) work. Moreover, classic natural law allows the use people make of property rights to be questioned while modern natural law takes them to be absolute. In accordance with classic natural law and its epistemology epistemology (ĭpĭs'təmŏl`əjē) [Gr.,=knowledge or science], the branch of philosophy that is directed toward theories of the sources, nature, and limits of knowledge. Since the 17th cent. , justice determines efficiency and cannot be separated from it even for analytic purposes. Only in positivistic terms can we conceive a trade-off between justice and efficiency.

We have argued that the application of the Aristotelian-Thomistic principles to the contemporary economy presented some difficulty even for the same Roman Catholic social economists. In general, we have observed an unnecessary complexification and hybridization hybridization /hy·brid·iza·tion/ (hi?brid-i-za´shun)
1. crossbreeding; the act or process of producing hybrids.

2. molecular hybridization

3.
 of the notion of justice that has not helped with clarity and application (which could also be due to the interaction with economic theories popular at the time). In particular, it was difficult to translate an idea of law conceived for a small political community into the new context of industrial society structured by states claiming the monopoly of politics and law. That probably led Taparelli to propose the notion of social justice in opposition to positive law. Other scholars simply acknowledged the new role of monopolistic states in the economic order and shifted this notion to include them. However, it remains difficult for economists who are not acquainted with classical natural law to understand the interpretative role of justice, achievable through a complex mediation between rational and practical plans of reasoning as in the Thomistic tradition. The result is a continuous tendency to refer to individual rights and to separate rights from obligations--particularly obligations connected to property--in opposition to the relational and objective nature of Thomistic justice. That, on the one hand, tends to minimize the value of human interaction in exchange and to exalt the mechanical functioning of markets. On the other hand, it produces an opposite noncritical tendency to invoke the state and positive-law intervention to correct the bad functioning of impersonal markets.

Stefano Solari

Department of Economics

University of Padua History
The university was founded in 1222 when a large group of students and professors left the University of Bologna in search of more academic freedom. The first subjects to be taught were jurisprudence and theology.
 

Italy

Daniele Corrado

Department of Philosophy of Law

University of Padua

Italy

Notes

(1.) See R. P. J. Vallin, "Aux origines de l'expression 'justice sociale,'" Chronique Sociale de France 68, no. 5 (1960): 379-92.

(2.) Vallin, "Aux origines," 382.

(3.) On the other hand, Rawls himself reveals a very limited perspective on contemporary moral philosophy. We refer to John Rawls John Rawls (February 21, 1921 – November 24, 2002) was an American philosopher, a professor of political philosophy at Harvard University and author of A Theory of Justice (1971), Political Liberalism, , and The Law of Peoples. , Lectures on the History of Moral Philosophy (Cambridge: Harvard University Press The Harvard University Press is a publishing house, a division of Harvard University, that is highly respected in academic publishing. It was established on January 13, 1913. In 2005, it published 220 new titles. , 2000).

(4.) C. B. Macpherson, The Rise and Fall of Economic Justice (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1987).

(5.) Gerson Moreno-Riano, "Natural Law and Modern Economic Theory," Journal of Markets & Morality 8, no. 2 (Fall 2005): 387-413 highlights the implications of the adoption of classic natural law for economic theorizing.

(6.) A related but distinct issue concerns methodology, the distinction between practical judgment and conventional theory (formal rationalism rationalism [Lat.,=belonging to reason], in philosophy, a theory that holds that reason alone, unaided by experience, can arrive at basic truth regarding the world. ), which can affect the way justice is introduced into economic reasoning.

(7.) Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics (Batoche: Books Kitchener, 1999).

(8.) A detailed account of the evolution of the idea of justice is given in Social Justice in the Ancient World, ed. K. D. Irani and M. Silver (Westport, Conn.: Greenwood Press, 1995) and Ancient and Medieval Economic Ideas and Concepts of Social Justice, ed. T. Lowry (Leiden: Brill, 1998).

(9.) Daniel Westberg, Right Practical Reason--Aristotle, Action, and Practice in Aquinas (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1994).

(10.) John Finnis This articlearticle or section has multiple issues:
* Its factual accuracy is disputed.
* Its neutrality or factuality may be compromised by weasel words.
* It does not cite any references or sources.
, Natural Law and Natural Rights (Oxford: Clarendon Law Series, 1980).

(11.) R. Goodwin, "Aquinas' Justice: An Interpretation," The New Scholasticism scholasticism (skōlăs`tĭsĭzəm), philosophy and theology of Western Christendom in the Middle Ages. Virtually all medieval philosophers of any significance were theologians, and their philosophy is generally embodied in their  63, no. 3 (1989): 275-85.

(12.) Actually, the definition of Aristotle includes a reciprocal justice in exchange that in the course of time has been lost or incorporated in the commutative principle, see R. Goodwin, "Aquinas' Justice."

(13.) John Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights, 45.

(14.) Ibid., 207.

(15.) "Public utility is the sole origin of justice, and that reflections on the beneficial consequences of this virtue are the sole foundation of its merit ... the rules of equity or justice depend entirely on the particular state and condition, in which men are placed, and owe their origin and existence to that UTILITY, which results to the public from their strict and regular observance...." David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals, in Essays (1751; repr., London, 1882), 179 and 183; e-book: Essays, Moral, Political, and Literary, vol. 2, http://socserv2.mcmaster.ca/~econ/ugcm/3ll3/hume/index.html.

(16.) Quesnay assumed a naturalistic position deeply affected by the approach of medicine. He defined the natural right (Droit [French, Justice, right, law.] A term denoting the abstract concept of law or a right.

Droit is as variable a phrase as the English right or the Latin jus. It signifies the entire body of law or a right in terms of a duty or obligation.
 naturel) as "le droit Le Droit (established on March 27, 1913) is a Canadian daily newspaper, published in Ottawa, Canada and is operated by Gesca since 2000. History
The newspaper was launched at that period as a tool to condemn Bill 17, an Ontario legislation that abolished education
 que l'homme a aux choses propres a sa jouissance Jou´is`sance

n. 1. Jollity; merriment.
" then he defined justice as "une regle naturelle et souveraine, reconnue evidemment par les lumieres de la raison, qui determine evidemment ce qui appartient a soi meme, ou a un autre" (113) and moral law as "la regle de toute action humaine de l'ordre moral conforme a l'ordre physique evidemment plus avantageux au genre humain" (121). See Francois Quesnay, "Observations sur le droit naturel des hommes reunis en societe," Journal de l'Agriculture, du Commerce et des Finances, repr. in Oeuvres economiques Completes et Autres Textes, ed. C. There, L. Charles, and J.-C. Perrot, vol. 1 (1765; repr., Paris: Institut National d'etudes Demographiues, 2005).

(17.) Leon Walras, L'economie Politique et la Justice (1860; repr., Paris: Economica, 2001): 167.

(18.) In Aquinas, reason discovers good and good moves the will, which is passive, see Westberg, Right Practical Reason.

(19.) We should note that Suarez held an eclectic position, trying to conciliate con·cil·i·ate  
v. con·cil·i·at·ed, con·cil·i·at·ing, con·cil·i·ates

v.tr.
1. To overcome the distrust or animosity of; appease.

2.
 Thomism with nominalism nominalism, in philosophy, a theory of the relation between universals and particulars. Nominalism gained its name in the Middle Ages, when it was contrasted with realism. , which placed more emphasis on will and less on objective truth.

(20.) However, Misner notes that Taparelli used a modern language and concepts not totally comparable with Aquinas' system, P. Misner, "The Predecessors of Rerum Novarum within Catholicism," Review of Social Economy 49, no. 4 (1991): 444-64.

(21.) See also T. C. Behr, "Luigi Taparelli Luigi Taparelli D’Azeglio (1793–1862) was an Italian Catholic scholar of the Society of Jesus who coined the term social justice. He cofounded the journal Civiltà Cattolica in 1850 and wrote for it for twelve years.  D'Azeglio, S.J. (1793-1862) and the Development of Scholastic Natural-Law Thought as a Science of Society and Politics," Journal of Market and Morality 6, no. 1 (2003): 99-115, and A. Chafuen Rismondo, "I precursori italiani del personalismo economico ..." in Il Coraggio della Liberta, ed. E. Colombatto and A. Mingardi (Soveria Mannelli: Rubettino, 2002), 109-44.

(22.) "Unita di fine, derivante da una unita di cognizione, producente unione di volonta, ecco l'idea essenziale di societa." L. Taparelli, Saggio Teoretico di Diritto Naturale Appoggiato sul Fatto (Livorno: V. Mansi, 1840), 133.

(23.) Ibid., 137.

(24.) Ibid., 140.

(25.) "Talche niuno possa arrogarselo se non comunicandolo cogli altri, bramando e procacciando per essi cio che brama e procaccia per se." Ibid., 133.

(26.) Ibid., 142.

(27.) "Irrefragabile potere-secondo-ragione." Ibid., 144.

(28.) Ibid., 144. Taparelli defines natural law as "the morals proceeding from natural principles which demonstrates how man should use the faculty of will." Ibid., 25.

(29.) Ibid., 141.

(30.) "Rinvenuta nella natura dell'uomo, con nulla piu che combinare l'analisi dell'idea, e il fatto naturale con il principio primo morale." Ibid., 134.

(31.) Ibid., 142.

(32.) Ibid., 143.

(33.) Ibid., 144.

(34.) "Unita replicata," ibid., 145.

(35.) "Tutti tut·ti   Music
adv. & adj.
All. Used chiefly as a direction to indicate that all performers are to take part.

n. pl. tut·tis
1.
 gli uomini sono fra loro naturalmente disuguali, per cio che s'aspetta alla individualita, come sono uguali naturalmente, per cio che s'aspetta alla specie SPECIE. Metallic money issued by public authority.
     2. This term is used in contradistinction to paper money, which in some countries is emitted by the government, and is a mere engagement which represents specie.
." Ibid., 145.

(36.) Ibid., 145.

(37.) Ibid., 146. Interestingly, inspired by Aquinas' charity principles, Taparelli justifies progressive taxation--contrary to Aristotle's geometrical proportion that is proportional.

(38.) Ibid., 147.

(39.) Ibid., 165.

(40.) Ibid., 44.

(41.) See J.-Y. Calvez and J. Perrin, The Church and Social Justice (London: Burns and Oates, 1959).

(42.) See M. Liberatore, Ethica et Ius Naturae, vol. 3 of Institutiones Philosophiae (Rome: Typis civilitatis catholicae, 1857); M. Liberatore, Principii di Economia Politica Politica is the undergraduate journal of the Department of Political Science at the University of California, Berkeley. Politica solicits original student essays on topics broadly political.  (Rome: A. Befani, 1889); V. Cathrein, Moral Philosophie, 5th ed. (Freiburg: Herdersche, 1911).

(43.) See L. Taparelli, "Analisi critica dei primi pri·mi  
n.
A plural of primo.
 concetti dell'economia sociale," Civilta Cattolica 8 (1857): 546-59 and 11 (1857): 17-34.

(44.) Walras, L'economie Politique et la Justice, 173. Commutative justice, according to Walras, is based on a balance, the equality of each individual given its nature of free person. This justice presupposes that "tous les individus possedent en commun les valeurs que la nature a donnees a tous en commun." Ibid., 178. Distributive justice is based on an inequality of merit due to the different aptitudes, talents, and efforts of people.

(45.) Ibid., 184.

(46.) In fact, Taparelli insists on the adoption of the practical approach to the economy. See R. F. Crespo, "Freedom and Coordination in Economics: An Epistemological Analysis," Journal of Markets & Morality 7, no. 1 (2004): 47-62.

(47.) This encyclical letter Rerum Novarum (1891) did not explicitly propose the notion of social justice. Pius XII Pius XII, 1876–1958, pope (1939–58), an Italian named Eugenio Pacelli, b. Rome; successor of Pius XI. Ordained a priest in 1899, he entered the Vatican's secretariat of state.  finally officially introduced this concept into Roman Catholic social doctrine with Quadragesimo Anno Quadragesimo Anno is an encyclical by Pope Pius XI, issued 15 May 1931, 40 years after Rerum Novarum (thus the name, Latin for 'in the fortieth year'). Written as a response to the Great Depression, it calls for the establishment of a social order based on the  (May 15, 1931) and Divini Redemptoris Divini Redemptoris was an anti-communist encyclical issued by Pope Pius XI. External links
  • Encyclical
 (March 19, 1937).

(48.) An account on the French debate on the definition of social justice can be found in Aux Sources du Catholicisme Social, ed. Robert Talmy (Tournai [BE]: Desclee & Co., 1963).

(49.) The original passage in Rerum Novarum is: "45. Let the working man and the employer make free agreements, and in particular let them agree freely as to the wages; nevertheless, there underlies a dictate of natural justice more imperious im·pe·ri·ous  
adj.
1. Arrogantly domineering or overbearing. See Synonyms at dictatorial.

2. Urgent; pressing.

3. Obsolete Regal; imperial.
 and ancient than any bargain between man and man, namely, that wages ought not to be insufficient to support a frugal fru·gal  
adj.
1. Practicing or marked by economy, as in the expenditure of money or the use of material resources. See Synonyms at sparing.

2. Costing little; inexpensive: a frugal lunch.
 and well-behaved wage-earner."

(50.) Reported by Talmy, Aux Sources du Catholicisme Social, 196.

(51.) H. Pesch, Lehrbuch der Nationalokonomie (Freibourg: Herder, 1905-1926); H. Pesch, Teaching Guide to Economics, five volumes/ten books, trans. Rupert J. Ederer (Lewiston: Edwin Mellen Press, 2002-2003), 2:273.

(52.) In the 1930s, Monsignor Ryan argued that the production process (in general) can be considered a form of collective action to which distributive justice applies when we consider the rewards attributed to the factors of production. See J. A. Ryan, Distributive Justice (New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: Macmillan, 1939).

(53.) See Charles Perin, Le Patron Le Patron, literally translated as "The Boss", is a website that serves as a French spelling and grammar checker, serving as a tool for students or learners [1].  (Paris: Lecoffre, 1886).

(54.) In this way, C. Antoine in his Cours d'economie Sociale, 6th ed. (1896; repr., Paris: Lib. Felix Alcan, 1921), 127, affirms that "le role de la justice legale c'est d'obliger chaque associe, dans la mesure de ses forces, a cooperer au bien commun" and there may be the coercion of law. As a consequence, this implies that for people, legal justice means "preter concours Concours or EU concours is a recruitment competition and examination to select staff to all institutions of the European Union. Explanation of Open Competition  exige par l'autorite en vue du bien commun," the authority has to demand of citizens all that is due from them. Ibid., 138.

(55.) Ibid., 141.

(56.) In this Pesch's theories show a clear influence of the theoretical system developed by Adolf Wagner--who was also a Christian economist even though he cannot be included in social Catholicism.

(57.) L. Taparelli, Esame Critico degli Ordini Rappresentativi nella Societa Moderna (Rome: Tip. della Civilta Cattolica. 1854), 257.

(58.) H. Pesch, Lehrbuch der Nationalokonomie, 2:274.

(59.) Ibid., 2:275.

(60.) Ibid.

(61.) Ibid.
COPYRIGHT 2009 Acton Institute
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2009 Gale, Cengage Learning. All rights reserved.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Solari, Stefano; Corrado, Daniele
Publication:Journal of Markets & Morality
Article Type:Essay
Date:Mar 22, 2009
Words:6305
Previous Article:The violence of aggregation: Amartya Sen's possibility of social choice.
Next Article:Poverty, dignity, economic development, and the catholic church.
Topics:


Related Articles
Reflexive Social Justice.
What the Heck is 'social justice'?
Social theory & its relation to social problems: an essay about theory and research with social justice in mind.
Natural law and modern economic theory.
Can social justice be achieved? From Aristotle to Friedrich Hayek: Bertrand de Jouvenel's analysis of the Desirability and Possibility of a Just...
From Social Justice to Criminal Justice: Poverty and the Administration of Criminal Law.
From Social Justice to Criminal Justice: Poverty and the Administration of Criminal Law.
Teacher education and the struggle for social justice.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2014 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters