Printer Friendly

Should physical education be required?

Many teens aren't exactly eager to run, stretch, or do push-ups. But, say educators and health-care professionals, exercise is good for both your physical and mental health. So why are physical-education classes becoming rarer in U.S. public schools? "Right or wrong, a lot of schools are dropping PE, art, and music to make room for math, science, English, and the things that [students] are going to get tested on," says Karen Silberman, former executive director of the National Coalition for Promoting Physical Activity.

Rachel Varner, 12, a seventh-grader at Olympic View Middle School in Mukilteo, Washington, says that as kids get older, gym class at her school becomes less of a priority. "A sixth-grader s expected to do PE for the whole year, Rachel told JS. But when you are a seventh- or eighth-grader, you take PE only for a semester and then do computers the other semester." In some schools, kids don't have to take PE at all.

What do you think? Should PE classes he required?

YES "PE should be required or else most kids will become couch potatoes and will be fat, says Kristen Campbell, 13, a ninth-grader at Colony High School in Ontario, California.

Teresa Fedor, an Ohio state Senator, has introduced a bill that would require PE and set standards for PE programs at Ohio schools. "It's really important to have a quality physical-education program so we have a chance for our children to be healthy," Fedor says.

Kirsten Poulin, 12, who agrees that exercise is important, has an additional reason for requiring PE. "The games kids play in gym are usually fun," she says. Kirsten, a seventh-grader at St. Peter and Sacred Heart School in Auburn, Maine, adds, "If PE were not required, [my] junior high would probably not have enough people to play any games."

NO There are only so many hours in a school day, says Michael Cappetta, 15, a sophomore at Chagrin Falls High School in Ohio. "With today's teens more focused on getting the good grade and taking as many academic classes as you can," he says, "it can be a nuisance to have to spend 50 minutes of your day [taking PE], when really you would rather be doing something else."

Given all the academic courses required of kids today, many people agree that PE should be an elective (class taken by choice). As Tommy Price, superintendent of Columbia County schools in Georgia, says, "If a child wants to take band, which is a year-round course, and Spanish, which is a year-round course, PE is out." Making gym an elective, adds Michael, would enable students to have more "control over their lifestyle."

[check] VOTE NOW! Should physical education be required?

Vote online at
COPYRIGHT 2005 Scholastic, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.
Craig Meehan (Member): Gym should be an elective 3/26/2009 7:47 PM
I think gym should be required for freshman and junior year. You middle schoolers' say gym is easy, and t is in 6-8 grade... but high school is a lot more gym longer periods of gym and a lot more physical. The grade depends how good you do that day not if you showed up and changer... and i had to swim in 6-8 grade i would rather do that than what i do in gym now. We don,t play a lot of games 2 for every 5 classes. usually it's 84 minuets of running
2 complaint(s) reported. Report abuse
Maya Weatherall (Member):  4/13/2009 10:24 AM
I think PE should not be an elective because we all need to stay fit. Then on top of that some kids in this world are way to fat and need a lot of excerise. If they don't get the excerise then they could die of of diabetes. So I know people say that PE is really hard and tiring but it is important to stay fit everyday.
4 complaint(s) reported. Report abuse
Rayna W (Member): PE should be an elective. 8/26/2009 9:29 AM
Yes, In highschool PE is much more harder. But if kids are fat, wouldn't they want to do something about it on their own? I'm already in cheerleading and I go to the regular gym to stay fit. Isn't that enough?
4 complaint(s) reported. Report abuse
Gloria A. Rodriguez (Member):  10/25/2010 1:49 PM
Im in high school and I angoy PE the only people i see complain about it have weight problems. Its not the class that is hard it that they think its hard because they dont have the endurance to do it.
2 complaint(s) reported. Report abuse

 Reader Opinion




Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Title Annotation:NEWS DEBATE
Publication:Junior Scholastic
Geographic Code:1USA
Date:Sep 5, 2005
Previous Article:A devil of a problem.
Next Article:It's cool to have class: basketball star Chris Bosh and others tell JS readers about the importance of teamwork and respect.

Related Articles
Public Education Needs Support Of Religion, Says Philly Supt.
Should gym be required in school? (Debate).
Health education check-up.
The end of recess: higher standards are squeezing out playtime at schools throughout the country. Some educators not only disapprove, but they're...
Minneapolis scores with online physical education course.
The P.E. advantage.
Not your father's PE: obesity, exercise, and the role of schools.

Terms of use | Copyright © 2016 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters