Russia: the end of an unnoticed revolution?Prologue
This story begins in August 1991 when hope of true democratic reform dramatically became alive in Russia. It ends in June 1996, just as those hopes may be dashed in the first round in the presidential elections. The contenders are: Gennadi Ziuganov (the Communist Party Communist party, in China
Communist party, in China, ruling party of the world's most populous nation since 1949 and most important Communist party in the world since the disintegration of the USSR in 1991. candidate), Boris Yeltsin “Yeltsin” redirects here. For other uses, see Yeltsin (disambiguation).
Boris Nikolayevich Yeltsin (IPA: [bʌˈrʲis nʲikoˈlajevɨtɕ ˈjelʲtsɨn] , Vladimir Zhirinovski (more fascist than Liberal-Democratic as his party is misleadingly labeled), and Grigori Yavlinsi (the real liberal democrat Liberal Democrat
a member or supporter of the Liberal Democrats, a British centrist political party that advocates proportional representation
Liberal Democrat n (BRIT) → ). But the last two don't really count: Zhirinovski and his LDPR's belligerent attempt to scare anybody who does not behave (Yeltsin, Communists, anti-Russian legislators in neighbouring countries with Russian minorities, and the West) does not work in the strange combination of atomization Atomization
The process whereby a bulk liquid is transformed into a multiplicity of small drops. This transformation, often called primary atomization, proceeds through the formation of disturbances on the surface of the bulk liquid, followed by their and polarized A one-way direction of a signal or the molecules within a material pointing in one direction. society that is Russia today Russia Today may refer to
The real choice will be between Ziuganov and Yeltsin, between ending the Russian Democratic Revolution and remaining stuck in the present limbo where there is at least hope for the future even if there are no moves toward that future. If the Communists (CPRF CPRF Communist Party of the Russian Federation
CPRF Canadian Psychiatric Research Foundation
CPRF Cerebral Palsy Research Foundation
CPRF Committee for the Peaceful Reunification of the Fatherland
CPRF Collaborative Planning, Forecasting and Replenishment ) win under Ziuganov, we in Russia will live the grim and scary consequences of this vote. He is not a social democrat social democracy
A political theory advocating the use of democratic means to achieve a gradual transition from capitalism to socialism.
social democrat n. as some Westerners like to believe, and the bulk of his party comrades even less so. To be more precise, his CPRF is best described as a national socialist party Many political parties in various contexts have referred to themselves as National Socialist parties. Because there is no clear definition of national socialism, the term has been used to mean very different things. . The only alternative is Boris Yeltsin--even with the Chechen war There have been two Chechen Wars:
There is great irony in Russian Democrats having to support Yeltsin as the lesser evil. For evil he certainly is in 1996. But it didn't start out this way just five years ago.
In the early seventies, a popular joke furtively fur·tive
1. Characterized by stealth; surreptitious.
2. Expressive of hidden motives or purposes; shifty. See Synonyms at secret. told in Moscow kitchens (and there were a myriad of such jokes, as humor was our only weapon against the repressive regime, and the safest place to tell them was the kitchen, far away from the possibly bugged telephone) went as follows:
In the year 2000, a customer enters a Moscow cafe and orders a cup of tea and a fresh issue of Pravda (the Communist Party newspaper with a compulsorily huge circulation--about 11 million in the 1970s).
"But the Soviet power has been overthrown, and Pravda isn't published any more," says the waiter.
"Okay, then bring me a cup of coffee, and today's Pravda."
"I have said, `I can't!' Pravda is not published any more!"
"Oh, in that case bring me just some hot chocolate and Pravda."
The waiter gets angry: "How many times do I have to repeat; there is no more Soviet rule and no newspaper called Pravda!"
"Yes, I know. But I so enjoy hearing you say it!"
In the `70s that was only wishful thinking wishful thinking Psychology Dereitic thought that a thing or event should have a specified outcome ; then came the revolution.
Incredibly in August 1991, this dream of a Russia without Pravda came true. After six years of Gorbachev's cosmetic perestroika which simply restructured the same old communist system, people came to the realization that life could be changed and had to be changed. The hard-line Communists tried to stop the winds of change by attempting to overthrow the non-elected and spineless President of the U.S.S.R. (Gorbachev never trusted his people enough to try to win general presidential elections.)
This move brought an unexpected reaction by the people. Under the pretext of defending the "rightful" president of the USSR USSR: see Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. , Russians engaged in mass civil dis-obedience against the new rulers. Hundreds of thousands of Muscovites Muscovites may refer to:
Please discuss this issue on the talk page and help summarize or split the content into subarticles of an article series. ). The status of the puppet Russian Soviet Federation Socialist Republic Socialist Republic is a republic governed on the principles of socialism usually by a communist or a socialist party. They are usually focused on a centrally planned economy, but sometimes they mix their economy with elements of a free market (RSFSR RSFSR: see Russia. ) in the framework of the U.S.S.R. was at that moment very uncertain--of all the Union republics, it had been the most puppet. Yet about one-third of its parliamentary members elected a year earlier had been backed by the anti-communist Democratic Russia (DR) movement which also backed Yeltsin, who previously had been one of the chief--though dissenting--Communist leaders. Yeltsin had quit the Party in 1990, as did most of his close supporters who joined the DR movement. On June 12, 1990, the Russian Parliament proclaimed sovereignty for the RSFSR while still staying in the framework of the Communist (Gorbachev)-led U.S.S.R. Then 11 months later, the RSFSR struck another step for independence by starting its own TV channel.
All this went almost unnoticed by Western media. They did not even cover the first session of the first democratically-elected Russian Parliament, instead focusing their attention on "Gorbachev--the good Communist." But hard-liners or "bad" Communists did take notice and tried to stop the process of Russia going out-of-control with their infamous "Putsch" on August 19, 1991. But they did not succeed in stopping the people's move toward democratic change. Three days and nights of active confrontation with the people followed, with Soviet tanks burned and seized by the Russians (as we called ourselves in that struggle). I was there the night the first barricade went up on August 20/21. With tracer bullets passing over my head, I witnessed the death of a young man who truly was a Martyr of the Unnoticed Revolution. I and my colleagues at the barricade felt real fear at being on the streets--but, knowing the significance of what was happening, to be left out and stay at home was even more alarming.
For two days, crowds ravaged rav·age
v. rav·aged, rav·ag·ing, rav·ages
1. To bring heavy destruction on; devastate: A tornado ravaged the town.
2. the streets and squares of Moscow, destroying Soviet leaders' monuments. Some armed groups occupied buildings that had belonged to the Communist Party and immediately banned the Party as a criminal organization. The KGB KGB: see secret police.
Russian Komitet Gosudarstvennoy Bezopasnosti
(“Committee for State Security”) Soviet agency responsible for intelligence, counterintelligence, and internal security. chief, a leading putschist, was arrested and sent to prison And indeed, just as the old joke went, Pravda was closed down.
One of the DR's most prominent leaders, Father Glen Yakunin (a dissenting Orthodox priest who had spent several years in prison), led a group to KGB headquarters, opened the archives of this grim organization and exposed the close collaboration between the top Orthodox Church hierarchy and the KGB. Another political ex-dissident, Eugene Savostianov, became the Chief of Moscow Regional State Security branch, and the leader of the DR movement. Arkadi Murashov took over as head of the Moscow Police.
On August 21, the Russian Tricolor tricolor
describes a coat color of dogs and cats which has orange and black patches (similar to the tortoiseshell) but has in addition patches of white hair; see tortoiseshell. flag flew over the White House (and later over the Kremlin!), replacing the Communist Red Flag. It was quite an emotional moment. When I saw it first go up, I must confess that I, a 45-year-old father, unashamedly un·a·shamed
Feeling or showing no remorse, shame, or embarrassment:
una·sham cried! Here was the symbol of my Motherland's revival, the three-centuries-old flag of Russia “Russian Flag” redirects here. For a list of Russian flags, see List of Russian flags.
The flag of Russia is a tricolor of three equal horizontal fields, white on the top, blue in the middle and red on the bottom. , banned by the Bolsheviks in 1917. When I was a little boy, my grandmother once furtively drew for me the white, blue and red stripes, and said, "Look, this is the real flag of your country. Remember it!" and then quickly destroyed the drawing. As late as 1990, members of the militant Democratic Union had been arrested by the Gorbachev police for openly waving this flag. And now it was flying over the Kremlin!
The red flag's territory soon shrunk even more. By December 1991 the U.S.S.R. ceased to exist (it was not "replaced" by the Commonwealth of Independent States Commonwealth of Independent States (CIS), community of independent nations established by a treaty signed at Minsk, Belarus, on Dec. 8, 1991, by the heads of state of Russia, Belarus, and Ukraine. Between Dec. 8 and Dec. (CIS Cis (sĭs), same as Kish (1.)
(1) (CompuServe Information Service) See CompuServe.
(2) (Card Information S ), as many Westerners think: the CIS never existed as a state, being from the very beginning a loose organization, looser than NATO NATO: see North Atlantic Treaty Organization.
in full North Atlantic Treaty Organization
International military alliance created to defend western Europe against a possible Soviet invasion. or even the OECD OECD: see Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development. ). We had witnessed the rebirth after 74 years of the Russian state. The August revolution had destroyed--or so we believed--an anti-human ideology and fearful entity called the U.S.S.R. Now, we hoped, we could look forward to economic reform that would make Russia just another prosperous country of the free world, and win for her a place somewhere between Canada and Japan (which was also a bit late to join the free world community, but did it very successfully).
Did not Understand--or Did not Believe?
All that was clear in Moscow, but the farther one got from main centres of Russian intellectual and political life, the less the public understood what had "really" happened. The long-suffering and long-repressed, hard-drinking "simple" people of Russian provinces, and especially the agricultural ones, viewed all these tumultuous events in Moscow with naive cynicism: they were just another planned campaign, another "game of the Bosses." And right they were. The old Communist nomenklatura no·men·kla·tu·ra
1. The system of patronage to senior positions in the bureaucracy of the Soviet Union and some other Communist states, controlled by committees at various levels of the Communist Party.
2. (used with a pl. had kept its vested positions, not only in most republics and provinces but also in the "centres." The key middle level of administration of enterprises, industrial, agricultural, service, even educational, were completely controlled by the Communist-appointed "Red directors" (even though they had ceased to call themselves Communists), on the official pretext that they were "specialists." Similar "specialists" went on managing the Armed Forces and the police. (The Moscow police chief remained an exception.) Much of the immense fund of money accumulated by the Communist party (in August 1991--about 300 billion rubles--$50-$100 billion) had "disappeared" somewhere into the hands of the ex-nomenklatura, whatever it called itself now; while those who seemed to know where the monies had gone just happened to commit suicide Verb 1. commit suicide - kill oneself; "the terminally ill patient committed suicide"
kill - cause to die; put to death, usually intentionally or knowingly; "This man killed several people when he tried to rob a bank"; "The farmer killed a pig for the holidays" . The old system built up over seven decades proved to be much more crush-proof than its surface ideology. And people felt it.
One could see this in the reactions of ordinary people. For example, on New Years' Eve 1992, a Moscow TV journalist interviewed workers who had to be on duty while others were out celebrating the holiday. At one of Moscow's railway stations The following is a list of railway stations (also called train stations) that is indexed by country. :Further information: List of IATA-indexed train stations Africa
tr.v. pa·tron·ized, pa·tron·iz·ing, pa·tron·iz·es
1. To act as a patron to; support or sponsor.
2. To go to as a customer, especially on a regular basis.
3. asked, "What Party do you mean?" The worker was a bit embarrassed, "Ah, the Communist Party has been overthrown, I forgot. Well, I mean, the Democratic Party!" Old habits die slowly; old ways of thinking may take even longer.
By that time, hundreds of political parties had been created, and a couple of those dwarf parties were using the label "the Democratic Party." However, they had nothing to do with the Yeltsin government, which saw itself "above" political parties. Half a dozen new Communist parties There are, at present, a number of communist parties active in various countries across the world, and a number who used to be active. The formation of communist parties in various countries was first initiated by the formation of the communist Third International by the Russian were allowed to re-emerge (and Pravda reopened), but that was not where power or the Bosses were. "If the Bosses wanted now to be called Democrats, that's what we will call them": that was what the little drunk railway employee thought. And he was right. Less than three years later, in 1995, the Yeltsin-appointed Chernomyrdin government and the Presidential administration organized their own political party, called "Russia Our Home." We used to have "The Party-and-the-Government." Now the new-old elite set up a "Party-of-the-Government"--ideologically different but functionally analogous to the late CPSU CPSU Communist Party of the Soviet Union
CPSU Community and Public Sector Union
CPSU Commonwealth Policy Studies Unit (UK)
CPSU California Polytechnic State University (San Luis Obispo, California) .
An old friend of mine from university days who had become a Big Boss in his native North Caucasian North Caucasus may mean:
n. pl. phra·se·ol·o·gies
1. The way in which words and phrases are used in speech or writing; style.
2. , and also their ideology. They do not stand for Communism anymore. Instead of just managing the economy and getting some perks for this position as in the Soviet Union, they want to own it in a "capitalistic cap·i·tal·is·tic
1. Of or relating to capitalism or capitalists.
2. Favoring or practicing capitalism: a capitalistic country. " way. And that means we live now in an absolutely different country, with much the same elite but which now has new and different goals and aspirations.
I am not sure the emergence of the New Russia was ever understood or even really noticed by the Western public. I remember in 1992, when I was still full of revolutionary enthusiasm, being shattered by a remark made by a young Canadian MA student. At the end of a two-hour, wide-ranging discussion in which we had conversed about world problems and the Canadian and Russian economic and political situation, he gave me his photo and wrote on the back, "Our meeting has shown that in spite of all ideological differences, Russians and Canadians can find a common language." "What differences do you mean?," I asked, puzzled. He thought it over and blushed ...we both understood that he had stereotyped me in the typical Westerners' mentality: I was a Russian, a "Red Russian," therefore, supposed to be a born communist. Thus a Russian, if he is not a refugee, is doomed to being stamped a commie com·mie also Com·mie
[Short for Communist.]
Adjective . According to according to
1. As stated or indicated by; on the authority of: according to historians.
2. In keeping with: according to instructions.
3. this stereotype there were only two types: bad commies like Stalin (who was not a Russian, by the way) or the movie KGB spies, or good commies like Gorbachev. Once I understood this I could see why Gorbachev is still so popular in the West. He has, from his very first days, corresponded to the stereotype, he was understandable, unlike the mysterious "maverick" Boris Yeltsin.
It is easier to think that instead of the big Bad Soviet Union (which also was very incorrectly and unjustly called "Russia" in the Western press) now we have a tamer "CIS." But I repeat, there is no such country (even though it is shown on the world map at Montreal's Dorval airport). Instead, we have a brand-new country born in 1991, called the Russian Federation Russian Federation: see Russia. , with the same Russian-speaking majority but based on absolutely different principles of social organization. Understanding it requires a different mentality.
A New Ruling Class
According to the results of an interesting sociological study published last year in the Kuranty (a Moscow independent pro-Democrat daily), 23 percent of the top private entrepreneurs in Russia are exmembers of the above-mentioned new/old nomenklatura, including some ex-top Communists like the ex-premier under the Gorbachev government Nikolai Ryzhkov Nikolai Ivanovich Ryzhkov (Russian: Николай Иванович Рыжков, Nikolaj Ivanovič Ryžkov , who is now president of the mighty private Tver Universal Bank. Most of these people used Communist party money and connections for their start. They control half of the privatized industry, one-fifth of the banking and more than one-quarter of the stocks listed on the Moscow exchange. Another 17 percent of the present business elite which controls more than one-third of the stock exchange businesses has come through the professional Young Communist League The Young Communist League was or is the name used by the youth wing of various Communist parties around the world. The name YCL of XXX (name of country) was generally taken by all sections of the Communist Youth International. (Komsomol) structures. Another 15 percent (two-thirds in private banking) have come through the system of the former State Bank of the U.S.S.R. A further eight percent were children of the high-ranking Communist nomenklatura and had advanced themselves through using the money and connections of their families. About 15 percent had been employed in scientific and research institutions and used their knowledge for starting their businesses; and only 5 percent of the elite were real Western-style self-made men. (The remaining 20 percent were no longer in these positions by the end of the period of study.) These people manage the privatized economy of the country not with a view of enhancing the "world socialist revolution" or building the "just society," but rather to make a quick buck. And they do make it.
But they have inherited an ugly, structurally unbalanced half-economy of a half-Soviet Union with a huge and unnecessary military-industrial complex mil·i·tar·y-in·dus·tri·al complex
The aggregate of a nation's armed forces and the industries that supply their equipment, materials, and armaments.
Noun 1. , which most of them try to manage with their old professional skill. The "ex-Red" directors do not want to close the old outdated enterprises (for example, the old factories producing coal in order to produce coke to produce iron to make into steel to produce machinery to produce tanks). Hence, the slow pace of the reform. To hold on to their jobs the workers support the directors--now owners--of these enterprises. In addition, the directors have close links with their only possible customer, the military headquarters of the shrinking Russian army inherited from the Soviet superpower, with 10 times the number of generals needed. The generals need armed soldiers and tanks to justify their existence. They also need a new enemy to replace the U.S. and NATO, and find one in the unnecessary and shameful war in Chechnya (approved by the New Ruling Class but not by the Russian population--after beginning the Chechen war, President Yeltsin's popularity fell from 53 percent during the April 1993 referendum, to an unprecedented 6 percent in March 1995). Knowing that Yeltsin is indebted to them for coming to his defence during the new Communo-Fascist putsch of October 1993, the generals are in a good position to apply government pressure. This is especially true since the government members are drawn mainly from the ex-nomenklatura, Red Directors--most of the radical Democrats having resigned in 1994.
Agriculture: On the Farms
The same "old ruling class in new clothes" dominates agriculture. Agricultural policy Agricultural policy describes a set of laws relating to domestic agriculture and imports of foreign agricultural products. Governments usually implement agricultural policies with the goal of achieving a specific outcome in the domestic agricultural product markets. , both at parliamentary and government levels, is in the hands of the so-called Agrarian Party Agrarian Party is the name of at several political parties:
tr.v. de·mor·al·ized, de·mor·al·iz·ing, de·mor·al·iz·es
1. To undermine the confidence or morale of; dishearten: an inconsistent policy that demoralized the staff. and robbed of initiative over the long decades of Party/Government rule, gives cynical support to the local bosses on the grounds that "all politicians lie anyway, but since my boss may refuse me daily fodder for my cow if he were to discover I did not vote in the proper way, I'll vote as he wishes." Those who have ventured into becoming private farmers have no assurance the land given to them (usually the worst land in the area) by the local collective or state farm really belongs to them as there is no coherent land-ownership legislation, amendments to this effect having been blocked by the Agrarian and other pro-Communist parties in Parliament. As Izvestia (no. 9, 1995) pointed out, "farmers are strangled stran·gle
v. stran·gled, stran·gling, stran·gles
a. To kill by squeezing the throat so as to choke or suffocate; throttle.
b. by the monopolistic state system of purchasing, treatment and distribution of agricultural production."
This has resulted in a food crisis deeply affecting the lives of all ordinary Russians. In 1994 imports of meat and poultry at world prices to Russia increased 4.5-fold; and butter by 24-fold. Most of the food sold in Moscow now is imported and prices are practically the same as in Canada (sometimes even higher: for example, in August 1995 milk cost $1.40 a litre in Moscow) even though salaries are not comparable.
The number of private farmers in Russia increased from 270 000 to just 280 000 between 1993 and 1994 which, in a country that had been agriculturally based and which has a population five times that of Canada, is extremely few. Many of those farmers are unable to efficiently run their agricultural operations, and, in order to survive, turn to various local commercial activities.
The Agrarian Party's anti-farmer policy gets ideological support from numerous pro-Communist and "Patriotic" (Russian chauvinist chau·vin·ism
1. Militant devotion to and glorification of one's country; fanatical patriotism.
2. Prejudiced belief in the superiority of one's own gender, group, or kind: "the chauvinism . . . ) organizations who ridicule the existing small pro-Democratic Peasants' Party Peasants' Party or Peasant Party may refer to one of the following political parties:
A subdivision of the Slavic languages that includes Belarusian, Russian, and Ukrainian. tradition requires collective economies, adding that the huge North American North American
named after North America.
North American blastomycosis
see North American blastomycosis.
North American cattle tick
see boophilusannulatus. grain crop is the product of huge corporate farms exploiting the hired labour of "simple Americans and Canadians." So, the Agrarians maintain, the only possible way to future affluence is to keep the megafarms operating, and not what they call the "ridiculous family farms."
Adopt-a-Professor: The New Poverty
To gain credibility for these fallacious arguments they search out academics able to clothe them in intellectual respectability. (You and I understand that this is rubbish but they manage nonetheless to find "patriotically minded" Russian scholars and even Canadian Studies' specialists who repeat that rubbish in their academic writings.) Many former democratic-minded people from academic circles have become aggressively servile ser·vile
1. Abjectly submissive; slavish.
a. Of or suitable to a slave or servant.
b. Of or relating to servitude or forced labor. officials at the service of the new elite, some even became members of this elite and ridicule their old Democratic Russia movement comrades, branding them as "demschiza" (that is, "democratic schizoids"). Some serve as consultants of Agrarian and other pro-Communist and ultra-patriotic parties, including that of Zhirinovsky. Even the notorious, overtly Nazi party Nazi Party
German political party of National Socialism. Founded in 1919 as the German Workers' Party, it changed its name to the National Socialist German Workers' Party when Adolf Hitler became leader (1920–21). called the Russian National Unity Russian National Unity (RNU) or All-Russian civic patriotic movement "Russkoye Natsionalnoye Edinstvo" (Russian: Всероссийское , which is openly anti-intellectual, prints articles in its newspaper claiming to be authored by "such-and-such, Ph.D."
Why is it so easy to buy an intellectual in Moscow? The explanation for this mass betrayal in what was a revolutionary force--the Moscow intellectuals--is very simple. It is the widespread poverty of the population, especially of those working in the state budget sector, which includes science and education. Average salaries and wages in Russia are now equal to about US$100 a month: "but how do they live?" you ask. I asked the same question when I learned that the average monthly salary in Georgia was about $8. The monthly salaries of the Fellows of the Russian Academy of Sciences Russian Academy of Sciences (Russian: Росси́йская Акаде́мия Нау́к, Research range between $25 and $60. I am richer than others because on top of my $60 I get a special well-publicized honorary "President Yeltsin's stipend for Outstanding Scholars for 1994-1996"--unindexed, of course, which in mid-1995 was equivalent to $16 per month. I should add that I also receive a special allowance for knowing English and French languages. For each of those I had to pass a separate three-hour exam. These allowances were never indexed (despite a 2000-fold increase of prices between 1990 and 1994) and today I receive an extra pay allocation of 35 rubles for my English and 15 rubles for my French--which means that I receive one Canadian cent for the English and less than half a Canadian cent for the French.
At the same time, the monthly salary of a typical Red Director exceeds US$3000; and in general, the top 10 percent of the salaried employees (mostly top officials and the New Rich--which is sometimes the same) earn 26 times that of the bottom 10 percent of the new social ladder (differences you can find only in Latin America Latin America, the Spanish-speaking, Portuguese-speaking, and French-speaking countries (except Canada) of North America, South America, Central America, and the West Indies. ). Yet these 10 percent are really the "middle class" of Russia. They are in the middle in the sense of being between the top 1 percent who are of the rich and the majority who are poor. According to official statistics, between 30 and 50 percent of Russians live in real poverty, with incomes under the living minimum, spending their meagre mea·ger also mea·gre
1. Deficient in quantity, fullness, or extent; scanty.
2. Deficient in richness, fertility, or vigor; feeble: the meager soil of an eroded plain.
3. incomes only on the cheapest foodstuffs foodstuffs npl → comestibles mpl
foodstuffs npl → denrées fpl alimentaires
foodstuffs food npl → and trying to survive for the time being.
Only 5 percent of respondents in a 1994 opinion poll believed that the privatization privatization: see nationalization.
Transfer of government services or assets to the private sector. State-owned assets may be sold to private owners, or statutory restrictions on competition between privately and publicly owned campaign was launched in the interests of all society (65 percent responded: "in the interests of a few people" or "of the administration"). Sixty-four percent were sure their salaries would not increase if they worked harder. And among agricultural workers, like employees in education, medicare and culture, only 6 percent of respondents said they "hoped to get wage increases through boosting their labour efficiency"! That makes the present-day Russia a powder keg powder keg
1. A small cask for holding gunpowder or other explosives.
2. A potentially explosive situation or thing.
1. if radical reforms are not undertaken--such as cutting government spending Government spending or government expenditure consists of government purchases, which can be financed by seigniorage, taxes, or government borrowing. It is considered to be one of the major components of gross domestic product. on the useless industries (beginning with the military-industrial complex and still-collectivized agriculture) and the huge (and growing) bureaucratic machine.
Instead, we have the trillion-ruble Chechen war, growing appetites of the military, prestigious government-sponsored mega-projects and optimistic promises to completely rebuild Grozny, the Chechen's ruined capital (the size of Quebec City) destroyed by the federal army under our eyes. It is destroyed, as the generals explain with a criminal naivete na·ive·té or na·ïve·té
1. The state or quality of being inexperienced or unsophisticated, especially in being artless, credulous, or uncritical.
2. An artless, credulous, or uncritical statement or act. , because "it is a Russian city, and Russian land, so we cannot allow the Chechens to secede!" In one bizarre scene on TV, the Minister of Defence actually demonstrated the typical happy smile with which, according to him, a typical young Russian soldier "dies for Russia"!
And there are the ex-Democrats, ex-professors, who, having joined the Presidential Council, justify the Chechen war from a "scientific" point of view on the same TV screen! I know one of them, a man I had profoundly respected as honest and open. After he left the university to go to the Very Top, I was pleased: I saw it as proof that Democrats are getting power and President Yeltsin's personal attention! But then I saw him on the TV screen justifying this war.
I was heart-sickened by his hypocrisy. But when I took over the Moscow University course (on the economic and social geography of Canada), I came to better understand why this man whom I had so respected had "sold out," purporting this war just, and reporting to Yeltsin (and the public) only pleasant things about the President's actions. When I finished the course (18 hours of lecturing plus exams), I was paid an equivalent of US$23. One buck an hour! A mere pittance pit·tance
1. A meager monetary allowance, wage, or remuneration.
2. A very small amount: not a pittance of remorse. of what one would make as a "Yeltsin Advisor." So, of course, this former friend did not want to return to the university. He wanted to be able to afford to drink milk--real, white, tasty milk--every day! That is not something which Russian professors can easily afford nowadays.
This is why so many economists and political scientists have left the ranks of the demschiza. It pays more to advise the nomenklatura democrats who now surround Yeltsin, or even Zhirinovsky. But you have to be willing to give them only the advice they want to hear. What they want from you is simply a good "wordification" of their primitive ideas--as we called it mockingly in the good old communist times.
In some ways, the New Times in Russia really do resemble the Old, so perhaps the people in the West and in the Russian provinces who have not "noticed" our revolution may not be that wrong. Maybe it will take a whole generation's life span to prove that the new Russian Federation and the old so-hated Soviet Union are in reality different countries. But all has not been without hope. As I look back over the last few years I am proud to have witnessed some of the steps which have taken us closer to democracy in creating the new Russian Federation. In October 1994, our Democratic Russia movement become a federal political party and we have some good political allies (including the small but growing Peasants' Party). Also, we have some good members in the present Parliament. And we must not forget that once we even had our candidate elected as the President of the New Russia, the first-ever elected leader in the millennium-old history of our motherland moth·er·land
1. One's native land.
2. The land of one's ancestors.
3. A country considered as the origin of something. . He always won when we supported him. But then he turned his back on the very reforms he personified from 1991 to 1993. (Now, he will have to do without us!)
Our country abounds in resources, our people are naturally clever, witty, educated, and intelligent. They are only awakening. And the most important thing: we definitely still have Freedom, and that really makes Russia different from the Soviet Union. One proof is that I dare to publish what I write. So everything is not so bad, as long as the people have freedom to think, to discuss and to choose.
This world is small and interdependent, so it is in the interests of the whole world, including our dear Northern Neighbour and almost physical twin Canada, to help us to retain this freedom. As the first step to helping us, please, just try to believe in us. Do not lose faith in us and our revolution in these difficult times.