Printer Friendly
The Free Library
14,709,470 articles and books
Member login
User name  
Password 
 
Join us Forgot password?

Roadblocks to learning: studying under fire in Israel.


When I travel to Israel, I travel to a war zone. It is a war between two divergent yet connected people, a war that is dominated by the shadow of Jewish history Jewish history is the history of the Jewish people, faith, and culture. Since Jewish history encompasses nearly four thousand years and hundreds of different populations, any treatment can only be provided in broad strokes.  and the denial of Palestinian rights. Conflictual narratives, resulting in daily destruction and death, shape this war. Israel is a new nation with an old history. A small number of Jews have remained in Israel/Palestine for millennia, but the majority of today's Israelis are immigrants or the children of immigrants. They are Holocaust survivors There are many famous Holocaust survivors who survived the Nazi genocides in Europe and went on to achievements of great fame and notability. Those listed here were, at the very least, residents of the parts of Europe occupied by the Axis powers during World War II who survived , exiles from North Africa, other Middle Eastern countries, South Africa South Africa, Afrikaans Suid-Afrika, officially Republic of South Africa, republic (2005 est. pop. 44,344,000), 471,442 sq mi (1,221,037 sq km), S Africa. , Asia, and Eastern Europe Eastern Europe

The countries of eastern Europe, especially those that were allied with the USSR in the Warsaw Pact, which was established in 1955 and dissolved in 1991.
. Most of the Palestinians have roots in the area that extend back over centuries, long before Zionism was a movement, and long before the establishment of any nation state in the region. As a result, Israelis share with Palestinians a historical legacy of displacement, oppression, reactivity, and fear. Israel is a model of a threatened people with a history of victimization victimization Social medicine The abuse of the disenfranchised–eg, those underage, elderly, ♀, mentally retarded, illegal aliens, or other, by coercing them into illegal activities–eg, drug trade, pornography, prostitution.  who are victimizing others in their struggle for survival.

While the pilot prepares to land at Ben Gurion Ben Gur·i·on   , David Originally David Grün. 1886-1973.

Polish-born Israeli political leader. Active in the Zionist movement, he founded the Mapai Party in 1930 and organized the resistance against the British after World War II.
 airport, I prepare for the routine interrogation interrogation

In criminal law, process of formally and systematically questioning a suspect in order to elicit incriminating responses. The process is largely outside the governance of law, though in the U.S.
 foreign travelers receive before they enter the county. I am questioned extensively about my purpose for being there, my course work, my friends, my family, and others I know in Israel. I am asked where I plan to go, and if my plans include travel to the West Bank and Gaza. Leaving the airport, I observe those entering the airport undergoing the "for Israelis and Westerners" version of a checkpoint. In a noncombative manner, soldiers search cars and open trunks. In contrast, checkpoints for Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza are often unpredictable, hostile, and humiliating hu·mil·i·ate  
tr.v. hu·mil·i·at·ed, hu·mil·i·at·ing, hu·mil·i·ates
To lower the pride, dignity, or self-respect of. See Synonyms at degrade.
 experiences. Either way, these security rituals are constant reminders of the continuing Israeli/Palestinian conflict, and of Israeli security vigilance. The military presence is a vivid and normalized aspect of daily life for Israelis, but jarring to Americans and others not used to such an obvious military presence.

The Lesley University Lesley University is a private university with campuses at Boston and Cambridge, in the U.S. state of Massachusetts. Lesley College was founded by Edith Lesley in 1909 as The Lesley School, focused on early childhood education as a part of a larger international kindergarten  building where I teach is located in the coastal town of Netanya. Before anyone can enter the building, they must go through a security check. This experience is replicated throughout Israel. My bag is searched before I enter a store. I must show my key or identification to enter my hotel. These security measures Noun 1. security measures - measures taken as a precaution against theft or espionage or sabotage etc.; "military security has been stepped up since the recent uprising"
security
 have sensitized sensitized /sen·si·tized/ (sen´si-tizd) rendered sensitive.

sensitized

rendered sensitive.


sensitized cells
see sensitization (2).
 me to the daily life of Israelis. For them, roadblocks, bombings, interruptions in public transit, and the constant ringing of cell phones as a way to stay in touch constitute the landscape of "normal" everyday life.

I teach in the Counseling and Psychology division of Lesley University's Graduate School of Arts and Social Sciences (GSASS) in Cambridge, Massachusetts This article is about the city of Cambridge in Massachusetts. For the English university town, see Cambridge, England. For other places, see Cambridge (disambiguation).
Cambridge, Massachusetts is a city in the Greater Boston area of Massachusetts, United States.
, and have traveled to Israel for the last eight years to teach in Lesley's GSASS extension in Netanya, just north of Tel Aviv Tel Aviv (tĕl əvēv`), city (1994 pop. 355,200), W central Israel, on the Mediterranean Sea. Oficially named Tel Aviv–Jaffa, it is Israel's commercial, financial, communications, and cultural center and the core of its largest . The course I teach, "Psychology of Women," is a requirement in an interdisciplinary master's degree master's degree
n.
An academic degree conferred by a college or university upon those who complete at least one year of prescribed study beyond the bachelor's degree.

Noun 1.
 program in Women's Studies women's studies
pl.n. (used with a sing. or pl. verb)
An academic curriculum focusing on the roles and contributions of women in fields such as literature, history, and the social sciences.
 and the Arts. This two-year program serves women working in social services social services
Noun, pl

welfare services provided by local authorities or a state agency for people with particular social needs

social services nplservicios mpl sociales 
, education, and the arts. Integrating knowledge and research from the fields of gender studies, history, psychology, spirituality/religion, and the arts, it is a cross-disciplinary study of women's development, relevant psychological theories, and their application to women's lives. Students are organized into cohort groups, and take all their courses together. This program, like most of Lesley's programs in Israel, has a set curriculum, no electives, and is taught in an intensive delivery model. Classes meet for five consecutive days and for eight hours a day, usually during holiday breaks in the fall, spring, and summer.

Students have had ample opportunity to get to know each other by the time they take this course. As they move through the degree program, it is the teacher who becomes the new member of each cohort group, and I am not only a new member but also an American. Last summer, I was the students' first American First American may refer to:
  • First American (comics), A superhero from America's Best Comics
  • First American, a division of the now-defunction Bank of Credit and Commerce International.
 teacher and therefore a magnet to negative expectations based on rumors and prior experiences with other Americans. Students expected to be judged by American-derived radical feminist notions of women's liberation Women's Liberation
Noun

a movement promoting the removal of inequalities based upon the assumption that men are superior to women Also called: (women's lib)
, and unfairly criticized for the ongoing conflict with the Palestinian people For other uses of "Palestinian", see Definitions of Palestine and Palestinian.

Palestinian people (Arabic: الشعب الفلسطيني,
. I, too, had apprehensions based on my own and colleagues' past experiences in Israel. I have often heard Americans speak disparagingly dis·par·age  
tr.v. dis·par·aged, dis·par·ag·ing, dis·par·ag·es
1. To speak of in a slighting or disrespectful way; belittle. See Synonyms at decry.

2. To reduce in esteem or rank.
 about Israeli students, describing them as highly critical, defensive, and arrogant. Both the students and I needed to deal with cultural stereotypes and their impact on the classroom experience. However, it was my responsibility to foster a climate of acceptance and create an experience that was welcoming and nonjudgmental non·judg·men·tal  
adj.
Refraining from judgment, especially one based on personal ethical standards.

Adj. 1. nonjudgmental
.

The students in this course, as in other Lesley courses in the Israeli extension, reflect ways power and privilege get allocated across Israeli society as a whole. Most of them (about 70%) are middle-class Ashkenazi Jews
This article is about Ashkenazi Jews. For people with Ashkenazi as a surname, see Ashkenazi (surname).
Ashkenazi Jews, also known as Ashkenazic Jews or Ashkenazim (Standard Hebrew: sing.
, of European descent. They represent the dominant culture in Israel. A minority of students are Mizrachim from North Africa and Sepharadi descendents of the Spanish Diaspora exiled from Spain in the 15th century. They represent the demographic majority, but economically disadvantaged, sectors of Jewish Israeli society. Occasionally, Palestinian Israeli women also enroll in the course. This past year there were none. I have not yet taught recent immigrants from Russia and Ethiopia, as they can't yet afford this relatively expensive graduate program. (The cost of the Lesley program is almost triple that of an Israeli graduate program.)

This past year there were twenty students in the class, twelve of them from metropolitan Jerusalem, Tel Aviv, and Haifa. The remaining students came from all over the country. They came from partly collectivized col·lec·tiv·ize  
tr.v. col·lec·tiv·ized, col·lec·tiv·iz·ing, col·lec·tiv·iz·es
To organize (an economy, industry, or enterprise) on the basis of collectivism.
 moshavim and from kibbutzim

Main article: Kibbutz
The following is a list of kibbutzim (Hebrew: קיבוצים‎ in Israel: (year of settlement in brackets)
 whose collective economy is based in agriculture or industry. A few women traveled from the Golan Heights Golan Heights, strategic upland region (2003 est. pop. 10,500), c.500 sq mi (1,250 sq km), SW Syria. It borders S Lebanon, NE Israel, and NW Jordan. It takes its name from the ancient city of Golan and was known as Gaulanitis in New Testament times. , located several hours away by train, while others traveled by public transportation from settlements dotted throughout the West Bank. As in an American classroom, their very efforts to be there contributed to their motivation and the tenor of the classroom experience. Also as in the United States United States, officially United States of America, republic (2005 est. pop. 295,734,000), 3,539,227 sq mi (9,166,598 sq km), North America. The United States is the world's third largest country in population and the fourth largest country in area. , tensions between those from the dominant culture and those from subordinate cultures were also part of the fabric of the classroom. What makes this different from an American classroom is the specific impact of the close and continuous state of war on the society at large and on women in particular. The ongoing state of war creates camaraderie and a sense of connection across the differences that divide Jewish Israelis.

Each day there were at least a few people late for class. They were detained because of a roadblock, or because a suspicious person on a bus caused everyone to disembark dis·em·bark  
v. dis·em·barked, dis·em·bark·ing, dis·em·barks

v.intr.
1. To go ashore from a ship.

2. To leave a vehicle or aircraft.

v.tr.
 and await the arrival of the authorities. These students arrived tense and tired. In addition to handling issues familiar to many working women, they may have also heard disturbing news about a family member doing military service, about a bombing near where they lived, or perhaps their child or another family member was leaving for an induction center or returning from military service. As the family caretakers, Israeli women's roles in the caring and maintenance of their families and communities include these daily challenges. The students jokingly refer to the course as a vacation from their daily lives. I observed, however, that this "vacation" was constantly interrupted at break times by the students' rush to use their cell phones to check on their families' safety. This ongoing apprehension about what was happening outside the classroom also influenced the course.

Israeli reality is framed within a military context, and the ongoing war between Palestinians and Israelis inescapably shapes women's roles. The distinctive nature of the struggle between Israelis and Palestinians contributes to an environment in which politically created borders determine if one is a legitimate citizen of the state or living under occupation. If one is a Palestinian living within the pre-1967 borders of Israel The British Mandate
The Sykes-Picot Line
The Sykes-Picot agreement of 1916 divided the Middle East between British and French spheres of influence. "Palestine" was designated as an "international enclave".
, as opposed to a Palestinian living within the territories occupied after 1967, one has constricted con·strict  
v. con·strict·ed, con·strict·ing, con·stricts

v.tr.
1. To make smaller or narrower by binding or squeezing.

2. To squeeze or compress.

3.
 rights of citizenship, secondary to those of a Jewish Israeli. If one lives within the Occupied Territories This article is about occupied territory in general: for more specific discussion of the territories captured by Israel in the Six-Day War, see Israeli-occupied territories.

Occupied territories
, there is no ongoing access to Israel or rights as citizens of a state if you are Palestinian. These basic rights are core issues in the ongoing struggle and a source of tension throughout the society. In this context, Israeli Jewish women are the guardians of the home, producers within the economy, and the reproducers of a nation of warriors. Allied with Israeli men, they are at once complicit com·plic·it  
adj.
Associated with or participating in a questionable act or a crime; having complicity: newspapers complicit with the propaganda arm of a dictatorship.
 in the production of the nation state and locked into the traditional roles it requires.

This condition is normally taken for granted Adj. 1. taken for granted - evident without proof or argument; "an axiomatic truth"; "we hold these truths to be self-evident"
axiomatic, self-evident

obvious - easily perceived by the senses or grasped by the mind; "obvious errors"
, but when Palestinian Israeli women are present, the discussion shifts. In previous classes, Palestinians have addressed the prejudice they experienced within Israeli society. When Israeli Jewish women have spoken of school, home or work in ways that are inclusive of inclusive of
prep.
Taking into consideration or account; including.
 everyone in the class, Palestinian Israelis have often spoken up to insist that what is being generalized does not apply to them. Over the years I have noticed that when they have spoken of discrimination, Sephardi and Mizrachi women also speak up about their secondary status.

This shift in discourse testifies to the hegemony of the European experience in Israel and the implicit silencing of Palestinian, Sephardi, and Mizrachi women. The voices of subordinated Palestinian women lent support to other marginalized women not identified with the dominant culture. This dynamic illustrates the interrelatedness in·ter·re·late  
tr. & intr.v. in·ter·re·lat·ed, in·ter·re·lat·ing, in·ter·re·lates
To place in or come into mutual relationship.



in
 of gender, race, ethnicity, sexuality, and class within the larger external environment. However, it also reminds us that the classroom is a place where voices that are externally dismissed can be internally inclusive. As in the American classroom, the larger sociocultural so·ci·o·cul·tur·al  
adj.
Of or involving both social and cultural factors.



soci·o·cul
 context attributes power to those who are members of the dominant class, yet those who are denied power can influence, shift, and change boundaries and identities. When minority identities speak up, their voices can be heard.

At the same time, dissonance in external realities and lack of attunement Attunement is a process, similar to synchronization, wherein previously diffuse systems come into alignment, often spontaneously. It is distinct from synchronized dancing, swimming, or other human aesthetic activities that are preplanned, practiced and then performed.  can silence rather than support students. In the early morning of my first day of class there was a bombing at the bus station in Tel Aviv. Three people were killed, and many more were injured. In the teachers' lounge I mentioned to an Israeli colleague that I would take a few moments at the beginning of my class to recognize the attack and the losses. Her response was that if they did that every time there was an incident, no teaching would take place. I felt sharply aware of the striking differences between Israeli and American daily realities. What was distinctive to me was normative to my colleague. I recalled the value of bringing the tragedy of September 11th into an American classroom and how students felt relief to be able to talk about it and its impact on their lives. However, the nature and frequency of violence and terrorism in Israel and Palestine contributes to an accepted norm of silence in public places. Silence reflects the desire to pretend all is well. It lets one go about one's day and take the violence in stride Adv. 1. in stride - without losing equilibrium; "she took all his criticism in stride"
in good spirits
.

Nonetheless, I did start the class by recognizing the early morning tragedy. I introduced myself, told the students that I heard about the bombing on television that morning, and offered to halt the planned beginning to make room for discussion. Their silence filled the room. In hindsight, I was addressing my own need to raise the issue, not theirs. I assumed that they would want to stop the ordinary to recognize the profundity of such death, but for them the classroom was a "vacation" from daily lives, not a place to recognize the destruction of war. My expectation treaded on their collective "business as usual" behavior. Further, the students also did not want to begin their course work with an unknown American faculty member leading them outside their normative behavioral comfort zone to address politics, conflicts, losses, and fears about the charged nature of what they refer to as the "situation." Just calling this conflict a "war" would require breaking silences and barriers that are hard to address even in the most intimate of circumstances.

Although this beginning was unsettling un·set·tle  
v. un·set·tled, un·set·tling, un·set·tles

v.tr.
1. To displace from a settled condition; disrupt.

2. To make uneasy; disturb.

v.intr.
, I went on to discuss the goals, objectives, and responsibilities for the course. The course addressed three main areas and provided examples and structured discussions within each: critical and constructivist con·struc·tiv·ism  
n.
A movement in modern art originating in Moscow in 1920 and characterized by the use of industrial materials such as glass, sheet metal, and plastic to create nonrepresentational, often geometric objects.
 thinking; the history of emerging psychological theory and feminist responses; and second wave feminist theories and praxis. The students had the opportunity to become familiar with questioning the voice of authority, examining the concept that knowledge is constructed and situated, and that "truth" is shaped by beliefs and values. I used mythology to emphasize the role of the narrator NARRATOR. A pleader who draws narrs serviens narrator, a sergeant at law. Fleta, 1. 2, c. 37. Obsolete.  in shaping attitudes and belief systems about women's, and consequently, men's lives. An example of such a myth is the story of King David and Baathsheva. As the story goes, David viewed Baathsheva from a rooftop and ordered his men to bring her to him. He had sex with her and returned her to her home and husband. This myth has been glorified glo·ri·fy  
tr.v. glo·ri·fied, glo·ri·fy·ing, glo·ri·fies
1. To give glory, honor, or high praise to; exalt.

2.
 throughout western civilization Noun 1. Western civilization - the modern culture of western Europe and North America; "when Ghandi was asked what he thought of Western civilization he said he thought it would be a good idea"
Western culture
 as a love story, but if we examine the scripture we realize that this could be interpreted as a case of kidnapping and rape. In the classroom we discussed the role of the narrator, the intended audience, and the promulgation PROMULGATION. The order given to cause a law to be executed, and to make it public it differs from publication. (q.v.) 1 Bl. Com. 45; Stat. 6 H. VI., c. 4.
     2.
 of myths that reflect the victimization of women as normative and acceptable.

Students examined the developmental and gendered nature of epistemology, how we learn what we know. We analyzed the roles of narrators, what gets left out, and ways mythology maintains and reinforces stereotypes about women. Students also experimented with retelling re·tell·ing  
n.
A new account or an adaptation of a story: a retelling of a Roman myth. 
 myths from women's perspectives. Engaging in this exercise at the beginning of the course allowed students to experience the connections between critical thinking, theory, and application. It also helped them see how re-narrating and re-framing from a strength-based perspective are essential aspects of feminist therapy feminist therapy Psychiatry Psychotherapy that incorporates feminist/women's rights–I am woman, HEAR ME ROAR–philosophy into therapeutic goals; FT attempts to empower ♀ and battle societal barriers to self-actualization .

This study of myth and narration also helped students explore the power of language and values attached to gender. The fact that in Hebrew the word used for "gender" (min) means kind or type allowed us to probe more deeply the significance of the word and its social value. Gender is indeed more than a kind or a type. Differences between male and female are not neutral. Addressing gender critically was especially relevant in a context where military agendas rely on the polarization of gender roles and the exclusion of ideas that transgress the goals of the military. This section of the course employed critical thinking as a tool for students to investigate consciousness, the limitations of dichotomous di·chot·o·mous  
adj.
1. Divided or dividing into two parts or classifications.

2. Characterized by dichotomy.



di·chot
 thinking, and an emphasis on the value of communication and relationship building.

The second area of study addressed mainstream psychological theories, their origins, approaches to the study of women and gender, and the consequent impact of these theories on the clinical treatment of women. This domain contextualized the political and sociocultural environments of western society, especially in the ways they influenced values attached to gender and the use of gendered power to distinguish women from men in oppressive and hurtful ways. Students explored the witch hunts of the sixteenth-eighteenth century Europe as a sociohistorical moment used to reinforce cultural notions of the inferiority of women and to exclude women from the healing professions. We used this historical moment to illustrate the impact of history when written exclusively by the victors. We viewed the film, The Burning Times (Armstrong 1990), and responded to artwork of that period that illustrated the abuse of women by both the Church and the State.

Along similar lines, students read narratives of the Renaissance that addressed the flowering of a new age but excluded any reference to the abuse of women by the Church and collaborating nation states. As such materials showed, we are educated in ways that suppress narratives of women's and other oppressed op·press  
tr.v. op·pressed, op·press·ing, op·press·es
1. To keep down by severe and unjust use of force or authority: a people who were oppressed by tyranny.

2.
 people's suffering, while critical inquiry provides information that attests to women's resistance to being written out of history. This thinking informed our discussion of the basic tenets of modern psychiatry, its pathologizing of women, and the resistance to such pathologizing by women analysts and activists. The curriculum included the works of women pioneers who challenged prevailing and emergent psychoanalytic views of women as the weaker sex, the dictum that biology is destiny, and the belief that all women want their wombs filled.

The third area of study included second wave feminist theorists who raised important issues regarding research, clinical diagnosis, treatment, and advocacy for the rights and dignity of women. Students were introduced to the concept of psychological resilience Resilience in psychology is the positive capacity of people to cope with stress and catastrophe. It is also used to indicate a characteristic of resistance to future negative events. , its embeddedness within relationships, its connection to empowerment and empathy, and its role in creating systems of mutual social support. The relevance of this theoretical body of work to students' sociopolitical so·ci·o·po·li·ti·cal  
adj.
Involving both social and political factors.


sociopolitical
Adjective

of or involving political and social factors
 context was clear and evident as they addressed the impact of the military nature of their society on their everyday experience. Our focus on ways people, and women in particular, develop a sense of capacity within a world that has historically represented them as inferior to the dominant cultural notions of ability was central both to the course and to their life situations.

In an effort to create varied experiences and to strengthen intellectual bonds, the students were divided into small reading groups that met each day for an extended lunch period. They would select an article and create a presentation to the class based on the theme of the article. These articles addressed developmental milestones Developmental milestones are tasks most children learn, or physical developments, that commonly appear in certain age ranges. For example:
  • Ability to lift and control the orientation of the head
  • Crawling begins
  • Walking begins
  • Speech begins
 in women's lives, specific clinical concerns, and the psychological impact of living in a militarized mil·i·ta·rize  
tr.v. mil·i·ta·rized, mil·i·ta·riz·ing, mil·i·ta·riz·es
1. To equip or train for war.

2. To imbue with militarism.

3. To adopt for use by or in the military.
 environment. Students were drawn primarily to the articles that addressed issues of reproduction. They had impassioned discussions of the imperative to marry and have children, what they referred to as the pronatalist nature of contemporary Israeli society and its connection to the ongoing war. They spoke painfully of Israel's ever-present state of war and vigilance.

They also discussed their survival fears and the connection of these fears to Jewish identity Jewish identity is the subjective state of perceiving oneself as as a Jew and as relating to being Jewish. Jewish identity, by this definition, does not depend on whether or not a person is regarded as a Jew by others, or by an external set of religious, or legal, or sociological  and to the state of Israel. They noted that the currently diminishing social benefits and resources did not relax the social expectation that Jewish Israeli women raise large families and care for them. They also examined that same situation from the Palestinian perspective, expressing concerns about the pressures on Palestinian women to reproduce and the impact of those same pressures on them. This demographic discussion exposed a prevailing conundrum about values, contexts, and positionalities where, ironically, both Israeli and Palestinian women experienced a parallel pressure to reproduce. The connection between the current state of conflict, the gendered nature of war, and the significance of women's role in producing soldiers was evident.

Student presentations ranged from the role of the Jewish religious minority in controlling women's rights The effort to secure equal rights for women and to remove gender discrimination from laws, institutions, and behavioral patterns.

The women's rights movement began in the nineteenth century with the demand by some women reformers for the right to vote, known as suffrage, and
 to abortion and reproductive freedom to a dramatic presentation of a woman seeking an abortion through the National Health Service. One group had a panel discussion that addressed the social pressures to reproduce, the stigma of choosing not to, and the role of the state in influencing women to have several children. They talked about the tenuous nature of their national survival, their fears about death through war, and the resultant responsibilities placed on them as women. The women wanted to support their country and their people, but they did not know how to reconcile the national imperative to procreate pro·cre·ate
v.
1. To beget and conceive offspring; to reproduce.

2. To produce or create; originate.



pro
 with their personal desires to experience what else life had to offer. They spoke of their visibility as procreators, their diminished recognition in other roles, and the specific ways their lives were being directly affected by war. They resented that women's issues were considered by mainstream society as less important than the war effort and wondered how things would be different if peace were achieved with their neighbors.

The final assignment provided students with an opportunity to work with the theoretical framework provided by relational cultural theory. This theory became the intellectual background for dealing with the role of relationships within difficult situations. They were asked to address the realities of their sociocultural context, and to examine the impact of relationships within this context by responding to an existing relationship between an Israeli Palestinian and an Israeli Jewish woman, and to do so in the context of gender, its impact on daily life, and the potential for social change. The assignment was as follows:
   Read the article by Isis Nuhair,
   "Women and Militarization in
   Israel, Forgotten Letters in the
   Midst of Conflict," in Waller &
   Rycenga, Eds. (2001) Frontline
   Feminisms, New York: Routledge,
   which addresses the occupation
   and the military nature of the society
   through a series of letters
   between an Israeli Palestinian and
   an Israeli Jewish woman. Write letters
   to both women, addressing
   feelings, issues and questions that
   surfaced from the reading.
   Describe the relationship between
   the two women; and comment on
   the concepts of connection, resistance
   and empowerment as they
   apply to the women's narratives.


This assignment provided students with an opportunity to apply feminist theory to their reality and to the struggles of women in militarized societies in general.

In this article, Isis Nuhair, a Palestinian Israeli woman, describes her communication with a Jewish Israeli friend, Hilla. The original exchange of letters was part of an assignment in a course Isis was taking at Clark University Clark University, at Worcester, Mass.; coeducational; chartered 1887, opened as a graduate school 1889. It was the second graduate school to be formed in the United States. Its undergraduate college (est. 1902) was integrated with the university in 1920.  in Worcester, Massachusetts. The assignment was to interview and analyze the impact of militarization mil·i·ta·rize  
tr.v. mil·i·ta·rized, mil·i·ta·riz·ing, mil·i·ta·riz·es
1. To equip or train for war.

2. To imbue with militarism.

3. To adopt for use by or in the military.
 on a woman's life as reflected in a correspondence between the two women. In one letter, Isis asks Hilla: "Could one isolate themselves from the process of militarization? Is it possible for a fish to live without water? I consider my life to be militarized and this militarization is part of my memory and identity" (116). Hilla notes that she came to realize that the militarization process is continuous, persistent. It starts at an early age, and is defined by the construction and interpretation of daily and national events (115).

The students' papers about this correspondence revealed a range of thinking on subjects including their relationship to the military, their national identity, their responsibilities to the state, and to family and relationships. Several students wrote Hilla and Isis joint letters. Many expressed envy about Isis and Hilla's relationship. They wished they had a Palestinian woman in their lives with whom they could talk about the ongoing struggle, and they commended Isis and Hilla for their willingness to talk honestly with each other. This correspondence evoked strong emotional responses. They referenced deaths of loved ones loved ones nplseres mpl queridos

loved ones nplproches mpl et amis chers

loved ones love npl
, the closeness of the violence, and the impact of the war on their roles as mothers, caretakers, and women.

One of the students, unsurprisingly, due to our shaky beginning as a class, began her letter to Isis with the following:
   ... To tell you the truth, I was not
   interested in reading your
   exchange of letters with Hilla; I
   was even a little angry at the lecturer
   for burdening us with the
   task of writing letters to you both.
   After reading the letters, I thought
   to myself that this foreigner, from
   over there (America) was playing
   an academic game at the expense
   of those of us living a difficult,
   painful reality; suffering from terrorist
   attacks and bearing the burden,
   while, she from her ivory
   tower in America is forging an academic
   career from us children.... I
   must say that I was incredibly
   shaken up when I started to read
   your exchange of letters and I
   thank both of you and our lecturer
   for allowing me to encounter so
   many terms, dilemmas and issues.


Another student wrote about giving birth:
   First Memory: "A delivery room
   nurse enters the room and says to
   me, 'mazel toy, congratulations,
   another soldier for the IDF (Israeli
   Defense Force) has been born....' I
   burst into tears." She goes on to
   recount her second memory: "I
   accompany my son to the induction
   center. The whole family is
   present. We all hug him, as if to
   say, watch out for yourself ... be
   strong ... we love you ... I remember
   the nurse ... and I burst into
   tears."


The student wrote that words did not have much meaning for her anymore; she no longer had any interest in who was right or wrong. She expressed the fatigue that is common to those under the constant stress of violence. This fatigue often affects the ability to think critically, let alone advocate for new social, political, and economic paradigms.

In another letter to Isis, one student told of her youthful adventures with the Arab girls in the village near her kibbutz kibbutz: see collective farm.
kibbutz

Israeli communal settlement in which all wealth is held in common and profits are reinvested in the settlement. The first kibbutz was founded in Palestine in 1909; most have since been agricultural.
, not far from Nazareth where Isis was born. She wrote about how different it is now that the companionship she enjoyed as a youth is no longer possible; the hostility, the suspicion, and the electric fence around the kibbutz represented a microcosm of Israel. She wondered when she became aware of being part of an occupying nation, and asked: "Why do I continue my routine life as if it is a negligible matter?" She drew the analogy between her lack of awareness about the occupation and her lack of consciousness about her personal sexual awareness, societal gender polarization, and glorification glo·ri·fy  
tr.v. glo·ri·fied, glo·ri·fy·ing, glo·ri·fies
1. To give glory, honor, or high praise to; exalt.

2.
 of the military.

Hilla's decision not to do military service was a major focus for the students. One woman wrote to Hilla that she respected her decision but did not agree with her choices. This student claimed that when she was younger, she believed that the army was necessary for the survival of the state and acted on that obligation, as Hilla should have. However, she added, today she sees things differently. She no longer sees the army as a necessary defense force but as a tool to occupy and dominate the Palestinian people, and yet she still thought that Hilla should have fulfilled her military obligation. Another woman accused Hilla of placing her burden on others. Since Hilla did not go into the army, she reasoned, others had to take up her share of the responsibility. Many students saw Hilla's resistance to military conscription conscription, compulsory enrollment of personnel for service in the armed forces. Obligatory service in the armed forces has existed since ancient times in many cultures, including the samurai in Japan, warriors in the Aztec Empire, citizen militiamen in ancient  as an act of self-hatred and an act of war against the state. One student told her that there was a "wide river between them," and that she felt rage and sadness about Hilla's decision to resist military service. Another student wrote that Hilla's actions raised confusion for her about the separation of the state, the society, and the army in Israel. For this woman, army service was a way to contribute to and be an integral part of Israeli society.

By not entering the army, Hilla crossed a boundary unacceptable to most of the students. Letters berated Hilla for not being a Zionist, for not participating in the defense of her country, and for betraying Israel. One woman suggested that since Hilla didn't serve in the army, she had lost the right to criticize Israeli politics. This situation demonstrates that when individuals resist dominant cultural paradigms, their actions cause others grave emotional discomfort. Actions like Hilla's refusing to do military service create a disturbance in how citizens are interconnected. A significant bond is no longer there.

Did Hilla cross the boundaries of gender that made her position more reprehensible rep·re·hen·si·ble  
adj.
Deserving rebuke or censure; blameworthy. See Synonyms at blameworthy.



[Middle English, from Old French, from Late Latin repreh
? She was saying no to the military, no to nationalism, no to masculine authority. Isis, on the other hand, was saying yes to Palestinian pride, nationalism, and resistance. Even though her affirmation of the Palestinian struggle ultimately is in conflict with Israeli national interest, students affirmed her position but marginalized Hilla's. Hilla's posture brought to the surface their personal conflicts, anger, losses of loved ones, and fears, while Isis's did not. Did their reaction to Hilla reflect the marginalization mar·gin·al·ize  
tr.v. mar·gin·al·ized, mar·gin·al·iz·ing, mar·gin·al·iz·es
To relegate or confine to a lower or outer limit or edge, as of social standing.
 of women's resistance to war within Israel? Their indignation directed towards Hilla as a refuser seemed connected to this interrelated in·ter·re·late  
tr. & intr.v. in·ter·re·lat·ed, in·ter·re·lat·ing, in·ter·re·lates
To place in or come into mutual relationship.



in
 troika of national icons: state, society, and military. Since Israel's army is a people's army, opting out of the military is opting out of society's responsibilities and privileges.

Within such exacting collective imperatives, the personal ends up conflicting with the political. Many women shared painful accounts of losing husbands, fathers, brothers, and other loved ones in the ongoing war. They expressed their fears about there being no end in sight. One student reflected that everyone in the conflict is a "prisoner of war PRISONER OF WAR. One who has been captured while fighting under the banner of some state. He is a prisoner, although never confined in a prison.
     2. In modern times, prisoners are treated with more humanity than formerly; the individual captor has now no
."

Further, many of the letters extended empathy to Isis. They understood her nationalism, her political identity, and her experience as a conquered minority living under Israeli occupation. She behaved in a way that they admired, respected, and understood. They saw her as strong, though politically misguided. Hilla, on the other hand, challenged them beyond where they were willing to go.

Students struggled with the assignment. Most seemed to respect the relationship between the two women, and some envied their ability to speak openly and honestly about the occupation and its direct impact on their lives. The assignment made visible the gendered nature of relationships within the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, and helped students think about it in the context of cultural arrangements of social and political power. Although the course addressed history, psychological historiography, and feminist multicultural perspectives, its most enduring contribution was its focus on the role women play in the survival of a nation.

As I reflect back on this experience, I recognize that I started the course outside the cultural boundaries that determined what was permissible. I needed to be more alert to what was necessary to build empathy within this setting. I recognize that feeling understood, nurtured, and respected is basic to creating a positive learning environment. It is not that I didn't already know this, but I had to learn it again from within another cultural reality. In many ways the course provided the students a "laboratory" in which to examine how gender and the needs of the state affected their everyday lives. In some ways it also provided me with a "laboratory" in which to explore ways of teaching that extend the boundaries of what is permissible.

Further, teaching in the state of Israel a cultural blend of theocracy theocracy

Government by divine guidance or by officials who are regarded as divinely guided. In many theocracies, government leaders are members of the clergy, and the state's legal system is based on religious law. Theocratic rule was typical of early civilizations.
 and secularism sec·u·lar·ism  
n.
1. Religious skepticism or indifference.

2. The view that religious considerations should be excluded from civil affairs or public education.
 in a perpetual state of war can offer American educators insight into the changing dynamics within American educational institutions as well. It brings to mind questions such as: What is the impact of religious fundamentalism in a security obsessed ob·sess  
v. ob·sessed, ob·sess·ing, ob·sess·es

v.tr.
To preoccupy the mind of excessively.

v.intr.
 state? How does a glorified and privileged military affect society? Does legislation like the Patriot Act in the United States polarize po·lar·ize  
v. po·lar·ized, po·lar·iz·ing, po·lar·iz·es

v.tr.
1. To induce polarization in; impart polarity to.

2. To cause to concentrate about two conflicting or contrasting positions.
 and determine the discourse regarding war? Will the debate between those who support or oppose the war in Iraq be silenced? What role would a universal draft play in post 9/11 United States? How is fear employed in the silencing of dissent and critical analysis? These questions have and will continue to face educators in a growing fear-based and retaliatory environment.

Americans are collectively circling their psychological wagons in response to a perpetual war against terrorism. Though this response is understandable, it also invites new paradigms for teaching within this ongoing struggle. Israel models the results of making military priorities paramount and living with their social and political consequences. As a result, it is caught in a cycle of continuing violence. The United States may soon find itself in a similar predicament. Such developments make it urgent for us educators to foster in our students a critical thinking that cuts through accepted norms, freeing itself to re-envision possibilities for a changing social and national consciousness.

WORKS CITED

Armstrong, M, dir. The Burning Times {Motion Picture} U.K. Direct Cinema, Ltd., 1990.

Buhle, M. Feminism and its Discontents. New York New York, state, United States
New York, Middle Atlantic state of the United States. It is bordered by Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, and the Atlantic Ocean (E), New Jersey and Pennsylvania (S), Lakes Erie and Ontario and the Canadian province of
: Harvard University Press The Harvard University Press is a publishing house, a division of Harvard University, that is highly respected in academic publishing. It was established on January 13, 1913. In 2005, it published 220 new titles. , 1998.

Gilligan, C. et al, (Eds.) Women, Girls and Psychotherapy. New York: Haworth Press, 1991.

Jordan, J. & L. Harding, L. "New Developments in Relational-Cultural Theory." Rethinking Mental Health and Disorder, Feminist Perspectives. Ed. Ballou. M. & L. Brown, L. New York: Guilford Press, 2002. 48-70.

Lips, H. A New Psychology of Women. Boston: McGraw Hill, 2003. 1-34, 117-151, 356-457.

Nusair, I. "Women and Militarization in Israel." Frontline Feminisms, Women, War, and Resistance. Ed. Waller, M. & J. Rycenga. New York: Routledge, 2001. 113-127.

Remmenick, L. "Childless in the Land of Imperative Motherhood: Stigma and Coping Among Infertile in·fer·tile
adj.
Not capable of initiating, sustaining, or supporting reproduction.


infertile,
adj unable to produce offspring.
 Israeli Women." Sex Roles: A Journal of Research (Dec. 2000).

Said, E. "Orientalism." The Edward Said Reader. Ed. Bayoumi, M. & A. Rubin, A. New York: Vintage Books, 2000. 63-113.

Sered, S. What Makes Women Sick? Maternity, Modesty and Militarism Militarism
See also Soldiering.

Adrastus

leader of the Seven against Thebes. [Gk. Myth.: Iliad]

Siegfried

killed many enemies; led many troops to victory. [Ger. Lit. Nibelungenlied]
 in Israeli Society. Hanover, N.H.: University Press of New England The University Press of New England (or UPNE), founded in 1970, is a university press that is supported by Brandeis University, Dartmouth College (where it is located), the University of New Hampshire, Northeastern University, Tufts University and the University of Vermont. , 2000.

Stone, M. Ancient Mirrors of Womenhood. Boston: Beacon Press, 1979.

Zerbe, K. The Body Betrayed. Washington, D.C.: American Psychiatric Press, 1993. 51-76.
COPYRIGHT 2005 Center for Critical Education, Inc.
No portion of this article can be reproduced without the express written permission from the copyright holder.
Copyright 2005, Gale Group. All rights reserved. Gale Group is a Thomson Corporation Company.

 Reader Opinion

Title:

Comment:



 

Article Details
Printer friendly Cite/link Email Feedback
Author:Roffman, Eleanor
Publication:Radical Teacher
Geographic Code:7ISRA
Date:Sep 22, 2005
Words:5401
Previous Article:The stone and the pen: Palestinian education during the 1987 intifada (1).
Next Article:Looking to the future: investing in our youth as a form of effective resistance (1).
Topics:



Related Articles
ARABS-ISRAEL - May 1 - An Israeli and 6 Palestinians Killed.(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - June 21 - Powell Sees Some Steps Towards Peace.(Colin Powell)(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - June 27 - PA Memo.(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - Sept. 20 - Israeli Woman Killed Amid Violence; PA Security Detain Suspects.(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - Sept. 30 - Two Palestinians Killed.(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - May 8 - Hamas Leader Killed In Gaza Helicopter Attack.(Brief Article)
ARABS-ISRAEL - July 25 - Palestinian Boy Killed.
ARABS-ISRAEL - Nov. 19 - Plan Could Ease Palestinian Hardships.
ARABS-ISRAEL - Feb 9 -Israel To Readmit Palestinian Workers.
Israel vs. Hezbollah: what was their month-long war all about--and what does it mean for the Middle East and for America's role in the...

Terms of use | Copyright © 2009 Farlex, Inc. | Feedback | For webmasters | Submit articles